Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

an honest question about Christianity

who's talking here?

eterry2 1
planemom 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 11
Work in Progress 11
Dorothy Parker 2
itstxdaddy 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Texan65 2
Butterbean 1
You can call me Michelle 2
jacobson 16
AMDG 12
Wicked 2
Elsa 1
SSG Army Wife 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I've heard so many different criteria for being a Christian- the only one that everyone agrees with is believing in salvation thru Christ- I frankly can't imagine how a person can lack compassion and empathy, and still call themselves Christian- bible quotes are used to support their stance, and mine- please give me your feedback, hopefully in a nice way- 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

the only one that everyone agrees with is believing in salvation thru Christ

I don't agree with that. That is only part of it. You continue to forget that a Christian believes Him to be their Lord also.

"For so an entrance shall be ministered unto you abundantly into the everlasting kingdom of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ." - 2 Peter 1:11 

planemom --- 12 years ago -

People are people. Just believing in salvation doesn't change them overnight. Most of us would rather look for the speck of dust in our neighbors eye rather than the plank in our eye. It's easier to be self righteous than to admit we are flawed. Even those of us who admit we are flawed have a hard time changing. As long as I'm not as bad as so and so I'm doing okay.

That's all I have to say about that. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

so you sort of believe that good works are part of you're journey? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

that's what I think- 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

criteria for being a Christian

A heart felt, and deep desire
to know Jesus,
to love Jesus,
and to follow Jesus. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

even when I was an agnostic, I've always been generous, and I've always had empathy-many have told me that has nothing to do with anything- 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

Tat, a few things:

1. Christians sin. We will often fail to have compassion and empathy, because this side of heaven, the flesh is still weak. We are called to study the Word, pray, and seek to have a Christ-like mind, indwelled by the Holy Spirit, so that we are CAPABLE of having compassion and empathy. Some is easy, like compassion for a child. Compassion for our enemies who are openly hostile and threatening is much more difficult.

2. Disagreeing on a message board, or even fighting, isn't necessarily a sign of a lack of compassion or empathy. It's probably more a sign that the person is struggling with self-control which is also a sin (um, that would be me. My mouth, or this case, fingers, will fly off in a retort before I have a chance to really process and think about how best to respond. That's just lack of self-control, and a daily struggle for me!) Compassion and empathy look like the good Samaritan. He helped the guy who was beaten, paid his expenses, and took care of him despite their political/religious differences.

It's hard to see someone's true empathy and compassion on a message board where we are debating the abstract. It shows when people are personally involved in situations, and are taking care of each other. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

good answer- I'm not really talking about remarks on KU, it's a question about faith- 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

Oh, I'm sorry, I misunderstood the intent of the question.

If the person is truly not showing signs of compassion and empathy, that could be a sign that the person is not a Christian. Those are two really big fruits of the faith!

But be careful when you determine that. What the world today describes as empathy and compassion is not necessarily biblical. Often, it is described as agreeing with everyone or accepting anything that people want to do. That was not at all what Jesus was like. Jesus was radical and ticked people off wherever he went. He was not liked then, and he probably would not be liked by many now. But he saw people as broken, and in desperate need of a Savior, and he spoke to those desperate people, taught them about himself, told them to repent and follow him. And he raised up followers to continue his work unceasingly and unfailingly until he returned.

And that is our model for compassion and empathy. And it's a TOUGH model. We all fail miserably, hence the need for a Savior! It turns out that WE are the pathetic wretches we read about in the scripture that he came to save. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

so you sort of believe that good works are part of you're journey?

There is no "journey" to become a Christian, and there is definitely no "works" involved.

Any "good works" produced by a Christian are the result of submitting to the Spirit that God places within the Christian when they are born again.

People who are not Christian can do works that would be judged as "good" by the world, but aren't really recognized by God as "good". 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I've learned that the the Jewish holiday next week is about being repentant about sinning against your fellow man, and promising to do better- God writes about you in the book of life, for the next year- (I think-someone please correct me if I got any of that wrong-) giving begrudgingly doesn't count, it must be with a glad heart- Work, is that part of it? 

itstxdaddy --- 12 years ago -

Mark 16:16
16 Whoever believes and is baptized will be saved, but whoever does not believe will be condemned. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

I've learned that the the Jewish holiday next week is about being repentant about sinning against your fellow man, and promising to do better- God writes about you in the book of life, for the next year-

That isn't Christianity. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

is anything in the OT pertinent, anymore? 

itstxdaddy --- 12 years ago -

is anything in the OT pertinent, anymore?

yes 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

We are supposed to give with a cheerful heart, Tat, because God gives to us freely and willingly, out of love. Because we love him, we have to love who he loves, and that is our fellow human beings.

But the Bible is also clear that it isn't about our works. Our works, even our BEST works, even if we go live in a Leper colony and save orphans from burning buildings. . .are nothing compared to God's righteousness. The Bible actually refers to the good that we manage to do as filthy rags (MENSTRUAL RAGS in the original) before a Holy God. We cannot earn our way to God. We are too broken, and even our good is often from selfish motives.

So we cling to Jesus, our Savior, the ONLY good human being EVER. The only one who can stand before God. And he covers us, through his sacrifice, that we may appear as He does, blameless, before God.

And the good that we do, the selfless giving, the charity, the feeding of the hungry and giving to the poor, and all of that, is simply following his example. We do it because he did it. It was important to Him, and therefore, it is important to his followers.

We do it in recognition of our own brokenness, and try to show others that there is hope for their brokenness, and it is in Jesus alone. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

People who are not Christian can do works that would be judged as "good" by the world, but aren't really recognized by God as "good".




We don't care what YOUR God thinks of our good deeds. We live in the here and now and care what those living people around us think. And in some situations, we only care what we think. I don't need God to tell me to be good. I just am. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

I have little faith in the "christian" idea. I have great faith in doing good works.

The idea that there is some sort of subsidiary to God just doesn't make sense.

I'll take the good works Jew, Hindu, Muslim, or other spiritual designation along with Christian. Doesn't make much sense to hate, regardless of the spiritual association. ` 

itstxdaddy --- 12 years ago -

I have little faith in the "christian" idea.

then why are you responding on a thread specifically asking about Christianity? 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

We don't care what YOUR God thinks of our good deeds.

You should. What He thinks is what actually matters. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

Jacobson. I'm ok with you believing.

Are you ok with me not? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

please don't turn this in to an argument- I'm having trouble understanding the things I've mentioned as being unimportant, and I'd really like it explained to me in a way I can understand- how could good works, done from a loving heart, not count? 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

And Tat, the Old Testament law still matters, but this is how:

We have a tendency to think of ourselves as good, because we compare ourselves to other humans, who are also fallen. We tend to think of Hitler, serial killers, and Nero as bad, and normal people who aren't dictators or homicidal maniacs as good.

But God thinks otherwise. He gave us the Law, which is way more than just the 10 Commandments, to show us how far we fall short of His perfection. Then the Pharisees, in an attempt to properly interpret and apply the law, added TO the law and then patted themselves on the backs for how much closer they followed their own additions than the other Jews and gentiles. And you know what, some of them probably did follow the law better than the rest of us. But God wasn't impressed.

Then Jesus said, (and I paraphrase) "Yeah, you think that law stuff is difficult? HA! You ain't got nothing! Not only is it wrong to kill somebody, but it's wrong to even THINK bad about them!!! You think it is wrong to commit adultery, but it's wrong to even THINK about person you aren't married to. You have no hope of pleasing God. You can't do it!"

"So I will do it for you. And then I'll take the punishment that YOU deserve for being wretched, so that you can be with me." 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

 

SSG Army Wife --- 12 years ago -

even the devil believes in Jesus Christ. There's more to it than just believing that Jesus is Lord 

SSG Army Wife --- 12 years ago -

But the underlining question that you asked. No Jacobson does not act like a Christian on here 

SSG Army Wife --- 12 years ago -

Nor does John Lynch for that matter since they are the same person. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

even the devil believes in Jesus Christ. There's more to it than just believing that Jesus is Lord

That is absolute nonsense. Satan knows who Jesus is, but doesn't believe Him to be his Lord.

You are also ridiculously trying to misstate what I said. There IS more to it than Jesus just being our Lord. You left out the other part of Lord AND Savior, which I even quoted Scripture to make that point.

And the fact that Satan and his demons know who Jesus is the exact reason why you have to also believe that Jesus is your Lord in order to be a Christian.

No Jacobson does not act like a Christian on here

It probably appears that way to you, because based upon your previous post, you apparently don't understand what it is to be a Christian.

Nor does John Lynch for that matter since they are the same person.

Since you've been wrong on everything else, you might as well be wrong on that also. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

Puppy Breathe, that wasn't the question- aside from some of the things he's posted, my question had nothing to do with him- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I understand a lot better from what Work said- although I still don't get why walking the walk isn't important, other than Work said it was- is she the only one that thinks that? 

Elsa --- 12 years ago -


Any "good works" produced by a Christian are the result of submitting to the Spirit that God places within the Christian when they are born again.


this 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Well, I guess this is better than a dishonest question about Christianity. ..lol. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

although I still don't get why walking the walk isn't important

That phrase, "walking the walk", is just another "religious" standard in an attempt to be acceptable to God. The true concept is misunderstood by most people.

Submitting to the Spirit that God places within the Christian will allow the Spirit to walk the walk, not the Christian. Obedience to God is the actual "walking the walk".

Also, I don't see where WIP said "walking the walk" was important. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

TAT - As you probably know, "faith alone" or "faith and works" is, and has been a major difference between protestant based beliefs, and Catholics. I have no intention of continuing an argument that is 500 or so years old, but just to state the position, Catholics do not believe in sole fide, nor do we believe in once saved, always saved. We believe what you do matters. We believe what you fail to do matters. We should never say we are saved, we hope for salvation upon God's judgment of our lives. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

^^^I agree with AMDG's version. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Catholics do not believe in sole fide, nor do we believe in once saved, always saved.

Although God tells in Scripture that it is so.

We believe what you do matters. We believe what you fail to do matters.

Although God says in Scripture that it doesn't matter in terms of our salvation.

We should never say we are saved

Although Scripture says "are saved", not "hope to be saved".

^^^I agree with AMDG's version.

More proof that AMDG is not being Scriptural in "his version". 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Tat, you're right. People who have truly had their heart changed by God, ie, salvation, live by that affect God's spirit has on their life. It changes you bc His spirit comes to dwell within you, hence the change from His presence.

Since the whole premise of Christianity is that God is love, you should look at what love is as in a characteristic of behavior and what those traits ARE. They are kindness and compassion, selflessness, the ability to bear things that hurt when it's for the good of others, sympathy and empathy that move you to act on the behalf of others.

No one is perfect and Christians aren't either but they should be driven by love the majority of their time and in their actions.

It is a willingness to love others, with joy, bc that's what God did for us. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Love isn't the whole premise of Christianity. God is Love, but He is also Righteous and Just. Those qualities can't be left out of the equation. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

The works are not a means to salvation. Christ alone is the means to salvation. The works are just the evidence that the Holy Spirit lives within you.

If I do good works, it is not ME that does them, it is the Holy Spirit within me. That is what is pleasing to God. He works through me to bless others. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground