Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should we tax the AIG bonuses?

who's talking here?

marthas attic 1
JDB2 1
smartypants 10
randyjet 16
Texas Girl 1
txwareagle 1
Pepper 2
NoNameNoLastName 7
donottreadonme 1
ghostpost 1
david 2
justforfun 4
~sassy~ 6
rEVOLution 2
Perfection 14
brian* 2
Nightstorm 3
31415927 1
Warren Peace 1
TakeTheGlovesOff 1
Ogre1 20
RCSKI 1
barefoot and pregnant 1
genxer 2
moltobella 3
Harmony 1
BarbWire 1
zombie slayer 1
burbchick 1
sadiesmom 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should we tax the AIG bonuses?

The House passed legislation taxing away 90% of the lavish bonuses given to AIG executives; Senate republicans don't seem to like the idea. Do you think taxing away 90% of those $165MM is fair? Why?

Yes Vote
 
 57.3% (47)
No Vote
 
 42.7% (35)
NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

The House passed legislation taxing away 90% of the lavish bonuses given to AIG executives; Senate republicans don't seem to like the idea. Do you think taxing away 90% of those $165MM is fair? 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

No, thats like me giving you $1000 to help you pay bills and then taking 90% of it away just because you stopped and bought lunch for a $1. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Huh? 

david --- 17 years ago -

My worry is that the bill will be abused the same way bush did with the patriot act 

Pepper --- 17 years ago -

Don't misunderstand, I don't approve of the bonus' these people were paid, however; they should not be taxed anymore than you, or me, would be taxed if received; which is typically 38%. Taxing them more would be setting a dangerous precedent. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

They are being punished for following through with their contracts. Its ridiculous. You dont give someone something and then take it away just because you don't feel like they are spending it they way they should. They aren't going out and blowing it (this time anyways). They are simply doing something that was set up way before any bailout was awarded. If they had chosen to not follow through with their obligations they would be deep in lawsuits right now. Just seems they are being setup to be the scapegoats. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

From my perspective, if those folks had a spec of moral values, they would have returned their bonuses. Also, we didn't "give" AIG anything, they borrowed our money for a very specific purpose - lift the company from the hole those very same executives dug. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

From my perspective, if those folks had a spec of moral values, they would have returned their bonuses. I totally agree with this. But like I said, AIG was following through with contracts. What would make way more sense is to stop the bonuses and have AIG use the money in a different way, not to take it away completely. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

Why should people receive retention bonuses for driving their company into the ground on someone else's dime? As long as they are not in jail, they're getting off easy. What precedent would be set? That companies getting help from taxpayers after making poor business decisions would be expected to answer to the people that bailed them out? That's exactly what needs to happen. Nothing dangerous about that. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Don't misunderstand, I don't approve of the bonus' these people were paid, however; they should not be taxed anymore than you, or me, would be taxed if received; which is typically 38%. Taxing them more would be setting a dangerous precedent. Very well said Pep. Their contract stated bonus, the contract did not state performance based. They are owed the money pure and simple. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

They are owed the money pure and simple How much would they have gotten if AIG went bankrupt? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I totally agree with this. But like I said, AIG was following through with contracts. I hope that you feel the same way about the auto workers contracts too then. They had real legal contracts, AND THEY actually DID A GOOD JOB and did what they were paid to do. UNLIKE the guys who got the bonuses! The crooks who took the bonuses did NOT do their job. They not only FAILED to do their job, but they then turned around and used blackmail to get paid. There is NO possible legal remedy that they could use to prevail in any court. AIG should have said simply SUE US if you don't like it and GOODBYE! Or an even better idea, would be to transfer all of them to a new division of the company, slough if off, and bankrupt it. Then have them sue the bankrupt company to try and get paid. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

AIG should have said simply SUE US if you don't like it Exactly. Ever try to collect anything from a bankrupt company? It's not worth the effort. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Their contract stated bonus, the contract did not state performance based. They are owed the money pure and simple. ANY contract is performance based by the way. You cannot force somebody to pay you for no work or reason. If you hire somebody to do a job and they do not do it, you cannot be forced to pay for it NO MATTER WHAT a slick contract may say! THAT is why we have malpractice insurance. When you have any medical procedure, you sign a RELEASE that absolves the doctor of liability. Even with THAT release, they do NOT have protection against bad work. They DO have protection against normal risks and complications. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

NO, the idiots in Washington should have addressed the issue before hand. If we allow Congress to do this to them, we're next. Besides, my guess is it won't hold water in court. 

TakeTheGlovesOff --- 17 years ago -

I say tax the idiots in the government at 110% who voted for this plan in the first place. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

If we allow Congress to do this to them, we're next. Well, under President Eisenhower, the tax rate for the wealthy was 91%. Are YOU paying that much now? That is simply DUMB and it only applies to those who got bonuses from companies who got huge bailouts from US. It was the guy YOU voted for who did that too. THAT is WHO allowed this to happen. Those contracts were signed BEFORE Obama took office and took responsibility for the country. Had he known that they existed and would trigger such a big payout, I am sure that he would have taken some action to make sure that the bonuses were not paid. I cannot fault him for not knowing everything that goes on in his administration. He did NOT, UNLIKE BUSH did about Al Qeada, get a memo from his Sec. of Treasury, stating that these bonuses were to be paid. IF he had gotten such a memo,THEN he would be responsible. 

Pepper --- 17 years ago -

What precedent would be set? The precedent is, if Congress were (edited to say, "allowed) to do this to them then they could do it to you and me should they see fit. And that is what I see as a dangerous precedent. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

How much would they have gotten if AIG went bankrupt? We should have seen. When a company is unsuccessfull that is a ramification of that action. It is unfortunate but some companies must fail. Those employees have college degrees, using your logic from the "its ok to tax the fortunate so the unfortunate can go to college" they will be fine since college degree required jobs must be plentiful. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

ANY contract is performance based by the way. You cannot force somebody to pay you for no work or reason. If you hire somebody to do a job and they do not do it, you cannot be forced to pay for it NO MATTER WHAT a slick contract may say! Really? Have you looked at pro sports contracts? They are guaranteed regardless of ability to play. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Oh wait, pro basketball contracts are governed by the pro players union so that must make them ok... 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

We should have seen. When a company is unsuccessfull that is a ramification of that action. It is unfortunate but some companies must fail. Those employees have college degrees, using your logic from the "its ok to tax the fortunate so the unfortunate can go to college" they will be fine since college degree required jobs must be plentiful. The fortunate shouldn't ever have to support the less fortunate. If they want to fine but they shouldn't ever be forced to support anyone but their own family. If you want to tax people to death, guess what, those people will find a way to either hide their money or move into a lower tax bracket. 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

No. These taxes are punitive in nature, which is not legal, as it currently stands. Taxing them b/c everyone failed to notice it when addressing the bailout funds is the congress just trying to go back and fix a mistake. They should just admit their mistake and move on. I don't agree with the bonuses being paid but a contract is a contract and they were already in place. No one in congress tried to force the unions to rework their contracts when the automakers received bailout funds. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

using your logic from the "its ok to tax the fortunate so the unfortunate can go to college" they will be fine since college degree required jobs must be plentiful. Right. It's the taxpayer's money, not theirs. They'll manage quite well without it. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Right. It's the taxpayer's money, not theirs. They'll manage quite well without it. So where will the money come from if no one is working to generate taxes? 

david --- 17 years ago -

Smarty you are right it is taxpayer $$ but when taxes are raised that is when the issue starts 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Earned income is taxpayers money? So you are suggesting that there should be a level of income that everyone should have. No one should be above, no one below, is that correct? So you are willing to take from star athletes, movie stars, singers, entertainers to pay for this? Just how many of those positions do you think will remain here if they are paid the same as the 3rd assistant producer? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

They are guaranteed regardless of ability to play. Those contracts have signing bonuses which ARE paid up front. They also have performance clauses and injury ones which kick in if they are injured. That is PART of doing the job, being injured, and as part of the contract and thus they are paid on that basis. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Right. It's the taxpayer's money, not theirs. They'll manage quite well without it. So where will the money come from if no one is working to generate taxes? Don't confuse people. No one has thought that far ahead. Everyone thinks the very wealthy will willing give up their hard earned money but guess again. It's their money, not yours or mine. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

The precedent is, if Congress were (edited to say, "allowed) to do this to them then they could do it to you and me should they see fit. In what instance? I didn't speculate with, say, all my neighbors money, lose it, and then say they owed me a bonus. That would be really asking for trouble lol 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

No. These taxes are punitive in nature, which is not legal, as it currently stands I see that you have no idea that under Eisenhower the top rate was 91%. It was legal then, and it sure as hell is legal now. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

Earned income is taxpayers money No, the bailout money is taxpayer's money. The bonuses were paid from the bailout money, as far as I know. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

No, the bailout money is taxpayer's money. The bonuses were paid from the bailout money, as far as I know. True. AIG made bad business decisions (donating $106,000 to Dodd and $101,000 to Obama among them), why shouldn't those individuals and companies be forced to give back money as well? AIG perhaps could not need the bailout if that were done. The bailout went to cover business expenses, for Citibank that now includes over $3Million to renovate offices........... we do not manage those companies nor do we know the contractual obligations they have - if we trust them enough to give them the money, then we have to trust them enough to manage it. If we don't don't trust them to manage it, let them fail and don't bail them out. 

burbchick --- 17 years ago -

Retention bonuses are paid to employees so they will not leave the firm. They are considered invaluable employees. It is owed to them if they stay. Period. Plus, a tax directed at such a narrow group would not be legal. Find the idiots who are responsible for setting this deal up and act accordingly. And, quit getting all upset over things that are not really that important. 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

I see that you have no idea that under Eisenhower the top rate was 91%. It was legal then, and it sure as hell is legal now. When Eisenhower was President, the top tax rate on income over $400,000 stood at 91 percent. That was for an income bracket. You cannot single out a specific group of people and make them pay a higher tax rate just to punish them. Generally speaking, when these types of cases have been brought before a court, punitive taxes were not upheld. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

If Charlie Rangel would pay his taxes, if Tim Geithner would pay his, if Gov Richardson would pay his........... well you get the point LOL 

Nightstorm --- 17 years ago -

Taxing them more would be setting a dangerous precedent. Paying them bonuses for accomplishing sh1t is is a more dangerous precendent. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

if we trust them enough to give them the money, then we have to trust them enough to manage it. Now there's a key sentence. "We" don't trust them. At least I don't, not after what has happened. Not without regulations. I don't feel we had any choice, and that's why they got the money. It was either give them the money, or possibly go back to the barter system because if AIG went down, every bank in the world would follow, going down like dominoes. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

So where will the money come from if no one is working to generate taxes? That's what the stimulus is supposed to do, jump start the economy. Keynesian theory. 

Nightstorm --- 17 years ago -

NO, the idiots in Washington should have addressed the issue before hand. If we allow Congress to do this to them, we're next. Besides, my guess is it won't hold water in court. NO, the idiots in Washington shouldn't have had to get involved. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground