Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

DISCIPLINE question? what should I do.

who's talking here?

outermaga 8
GCan 2
Fiona 1
planemom 2
Sandyr9111 2
AuthorMan 1
Joybell 3
Mygirl01 2
Fin and Feather 1
sweetpea* 7
picasso1 2
Unichic™ 1
POTUS 3
JusticeForAll 2
Ogre1 2
ladyjane 1
RedMulch 2
Pollys Crackers 1
jhjlhar 1
luv2massage 1
oy with the poodles already 1
KWnewbie 1
Dr Aborto 2
YoMomma 19
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
jewels4ever 5
LiveFreeOrDie 1
ForestMama 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

YoMomma --- 16 years ago -

OK my dd who is 5 said something she shouldn't have. She is in Big Trouble. When we get home I told her she will be in her room for the rest of the night. (which btw will punish me because she will cry and wine for the rest of the night and I will have to hear it) Anyway my problem is she has a dance class tonight that I already paid for. Do I make her skip it and just eat the money or let her go THEN punish her when she gets home? 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

I would punish her and not have her go to dance class. You are already eating the money. She's 5, what is she gonna learn in one dance class the would really make any difference?

What did she say? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

At her age you need immediate discipline. It's very hard for young kids to associate punishment with the crime when they happen hours apart.

Tobasco sauce or lemon juice come in handy when kids get mouthy. Put a little on their finger and make them suck on it. Make sure they wash their hands well afterwards. 

sweetpea* --- 16 years ago -

I would start the punishment when you get home and skip the class otherwise you are teaching her that the punishment can be altered or waived depending on the surrounding circumstances.

Can you contact the place where you paid for the dance class and change to another class? This way you are not out of the money.

But I would definitely enforce the punishment as you first told her that you would. 

oy with the poodles already --- 16 years ago -

Eat the money and start the punishment immediately. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

You should honestly explain that the reason you are letting her go to this dance class is purely based on economics and getting what you paid for. Show her a bill for the classes. Maybe mention that since physical activity is healthy, it also factors into the decision to ultimately do what's best for her-- Which is make her go to the class and then uncork the biggest bottle of whoop @$$ ever seen when she gets back 

YoMomma --- 16 years ago -

What did she say?

id rather not say LOL 

sweetpea* --- 16 years ago -

I would not tell her that you are changing the class if you decide to go that route. You also said that you told her that she would get her punishment when you got home. In the meantime, are you treating her as if she isn't in trouble? How are you disciplining her until you get home? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Since you have already told her what her punishment will be you need to stick with it.

The whole money issue is why missing class because you're in trouble is reserved for the most severe problems in our house. When she is older, make her do extra work around the house to pay you back the money you spent on the class she was too disobedient to attend.

None of these are my ideas. I've borrowed them from friends. 

YoMomma --- 16 years ago -

Can you contact the place where you paid for the dance class and change to another class? This way you are not out of the money.

yes I can. I will do that.

Tobasco sauce or lemon juice come in handy when kids get mouthy. Put a little on their finger and make them suck on it. Make sure they wash their hands well afterwards.

It would have to be Tobasco she loves lemons. I am scared it might kill her though I saw something on the similar on the news. 

sweetpea* --- 16 years ago -

(which btw will punish me because she will cry and wine for the rest of the night and I will have to hear it)

Pardon my harsh words but act like an adult, if you want to get your point across that she did something that she shouldn't have, then so what if she whines and cries the rest of the night. She must have learned that the whining and crying works and she might get out of a punishment. 

YoMomma --- 16 years ago -

I know it needs to be done but this child of mine IS ALWAYS IN TROUBLE. And my other child is soo good and gets to do more things because of it. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

Come on, what did she say? Did she say the C-Bomb, N-Bomb or F-Bomb? 

YoMomma --- 16 years ago -

Pardon my harsh words but act like an adult, if you want to get your point across that she did something that she shouldn't have, then so what if she whines and cries the rest of the night. She must have learned that the whining and crying works and she might get out of a punishment.


Your right I am not saying I am not going to punish her. I know I will have to deal with the crying I was just saying... 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

Tobasco sauce or lemon juice come in handy when kids get mouthy. Put a little on their finger and make them suck on it. Make sure they wash their hands well afterwards.

Lady, are you for real in the year 2010? 

Fiona --- 16 years ago -

I would think that punishment to the room for the rest of the night was harsh if she for instance said a bad word. Especially if she said it and did not know it was a bad word. But then you already said it so you really can't go back on it now. 

YoMomma --- 16 years ago -

I would think that punishment to the room for the rest of the night was harsh if she for instance said a bad word. Especially if she said it and did not know it was a bad word. But then you already said it so you really can't go back on it now.

she KNOWS it was bad what she said before she said it. We have gone over this before. She just chose to do it anyway. 

sweetpea* --- 16 years ago -

if this child is always in trouble then it might be to get attention.

If I may offer some advice (since I was the one in my family that was always in trouble), please do not tell her that the other child is so good, etc. That only causes resentment. I would say just discipline the child as her behavior warrants. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Tobasco sauce or lemon juice

Neither would have worked on me, I'd have seen that as reward :-) I'd have probably asked for some tomato juice and vodka.

Even at 5 y.o.

Anyway, punishment is ineffective unless performed quickly. If you take her to dance class she'll learn that you don't really mean it. 

YoMomma --- 16 years ago -

If I may offer some advice (since I was the one in my family that was always in trouble), please do not tell her that the other child is so good, etc. That only causes resentment. I would say just discipline the child as her behavior warrants.


Oh no I would NEVER. I know she is a very active and needs lots of attention kind of child. And I give it I never knew I had this much patience until her. My heart breaks for her because she is always in trouble. I read and try all kinds of things to help her. And some of it works some doesn't. 

sweetpea* --- 16 years ago -

Neither would have worked on me, I'd have seen that as reward :-) I'd have probably asked for some tomato juice and vodka.

Even at 5 y.o.

I would have liked to have seen you at 5 yrs. old. LOL 

YoMomma --- 16 years ago -

If I may offer some advice (since I was the one in my family that was always in trouble), please do not tell her that the other child is so good, etc. That only causes resentment. I would say just discipline the child as her behavior warrants.


Oh no I would NEVER. I know she is a very active and needs lots of attention kind of child. And I give it I never knew I had this much patience until her. My heart breaks for her because she is always in trouble. I read and try all kinds of things to help her. And some of it works some doesn't. 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

When my daugther was considerably smaller she said a cuss word. I took her over to the sink put a dab of Dawn on my finger and raked it around her teeth. I told her if she ever said those kind of words again she would have more in her mouth. She did know not to say those kind of words but she chose to use them towards me anyways.

I didn't have to punish her any further. She understood and to this day she still hasn't said another cuss word.. that I know of. 

YoMomma --- 16 years ago -

hmmm dawn soap?? That is a different route. I may really try that. Spankings and time outs DO NOT SEEM TO WORK. 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

Basically to answer your question.. If this was a first offense I think once you got your point across that what she said wasn't going to fly then yes I would have taken her to her dance class. If it wasn't the first time it happened and she keeps pushing the boundaries then I would say no she shouldn't go. 

sweetpea* --- 16 years ago -

then YoMomma, you are on the right track. I wish kids came with manuals on how to raise them, don't you? Thankfully, mine are just about grown up and I get complimented on what nice young people they have become. 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

hmmm dawn soap?? That is a different route. I may really try that. Spankings and time outs DO NOT SEEM TO WORK.

Yeah just a dab across the teeth. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

lol i have no business posting in this thread 

jewels4ever --- 16 years ago -

damn, she is five! my goodness chill out!!!!! and some of your suggestions sound like child abuse!

i suggest some rest relaxation and wine for mamma... and if she still cant chill out a valium. give the kid a break. one curse word! wait till she's 16! 

sweetpea* --- 16 years ago -

YoMomma, if time outs and spankings don't work, have you tried to have her do chores that are age appropriate? Such as picking up her and her siblings toys for the day, or something along that line? 

ForestMama --- 16 years ago -

Soap in the mouth always works wonders. If you have a fresh bar of soap, something that would taste really nasty, stick it in her mouth and tell her she has to keep it there for one full minute. She might gag, cry, sputter, etc., but the point will be made. 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

damn, she is five! my goodness chill out!!!!! and some of your suggestions sound like child abuse!

i suggest some rest relaxation and wine for mamma... and if she still cant chill out a valium. give the kid a break. one curse word! wait till she's 16!




Nope you have to nip the small problems in the bud when they are small. They only grow up and get to be bigger problems as time goes by.

I have a 16 year old. I am certain he cusses but I have never once heard it and I expect it to stay that way. 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

damn, she is five! my goodness chill out!!!!! and some of your suggestions sound like child abuse!

i suggest some rest relaxation and wine for mamma... and if she still cant chill out a valium. give the kid a break. one curse word! wait till she's 16!


If she doesn't discipline her now, cursing at age 16 will be the LEAST of her problems. 

KWnewbie --- 16 years ago -

Im for the soap in the mouth. My youngest had a bad habit of saying crap she had no business saying. After a few times of using soap she wont say the bad word out loud. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

damn, she is five! my goodness chill out!!!!! and some of your suggestions sound like child abuse!

i suggest some rest relaxation and wine for mamma... and if she still cant chill out a valium. give the kid a break. one curse word! wait till she's 16!



Nope you have to nip the small problems in the bud when they are small. They only grow up and get to be bigger problems as time goes by.

I have a 16 year old. I am certain he cusses but I have never once heard it and I expect it to stay that way.


Ditto

Mine got a teaspoon of Dawn Antibacterial about 5ish and she hasnt ever said another cuss word that Ive heard and Id do it again if she said it now at almost 14. I will NOT have a nasty foul mouthed child in my house! Id up the dose to several tablespoons today though. 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

I did the Tabasco in the mouth stuff when my oldest was 5. He's always been very verbally advanced to our detriment. He told my father that I had "tortured" him with the hot sauce. My dad chewed me out for messing with his grandson but more than that, he was concerned that my son would tell his friends or teachers. A few weeks after that, there was an incident in another state where a mom was reported to child protective services for disciplining her kid with Tabasco sauce.

For the original poster...I'd follow through with what you told your daughter. In the long term, losing a few bucks is nothing compared to sending your kid a message that you're willing to stick to your guns. 

jewels4ever --- 16 years ago -

A few weeks after that, there was an incident in another state where a mom was reported to child protective services for disciplining her kid with Tabasco sauce.

see ! 

Fin and Feather --- 16 years ago -

Key word here is she is 5, a 4 hour punishment will do no good, an 30 min-hr punishment that was handled well will be far more productive. This way she will see full circle of punishment, trouble, and moving on. Again just my $.02 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

A few weeks after that, there was an incident in another state where a mom was reported to child protective services for disciplining her kid with Tabasco sauce.

Just because someone got "reported" doesn't mean anything. You can "report" someone for spanking a child, too...but it's still legal.

I wear my dd's behind OUT. If necessary, that it. 

Pollys Crackers --- 16 years ago -

Your right I am not saying I am not going to punish her. I know I will have to deal with the crying I was just saying...

I always heard "you continue to cry and whine, I'll give you something to cry and whine about", and I said the same thing to my kids. If she pitches a fit and causes a great disruption for you in the evening, then tack on further punishment - take away a toy, a fun things, etc. Don't allow that kind of verbal manipulation to take place. This is one of those things that you can't afford to give in for if you do, it will grow into something bigger next time.

Good going for taking your stand about bad words. I wish more parents would do the same. It is outlandish how I hear children sass their parents which is a huge dose of disrespect for the parents. They then end up speaking to teachers, etc., the same way.

Parenting is difficult and not for the faint at heart. You will be rewarded for it though. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground