Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Continental found guilty - fined a bunch...

who's talking here?

randyjet 7
traveller 2
hollyedw 1
JustMeBeingMe 2
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Nick 2
zapper007 3
AsExpected 2
RedMulch 1
SighFiGurl 1
LiveFreeOrDie 2
Puss In Boots 1
Ares 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

zapper007 --- 15 years ago -

December 6, 2010, 12:42 pm EST
PONTOISE, France (AP) -- Continental Airlines and one of its mechanics were convicted of manslaughter Monday by a French court, which ruled that debris from a Continental plane caused the crash of an Air France Concorde jet that killed 113 people a decade ago.

The panel of judges fined Continental euro 202,000 ($268,000) and John Taylor, its mechanic living in the United States, euro 2,000 ($2,650). Taylor also was given a 15-month suspended prison sentence. Both said they will appeal.

Continental Airlines Inc.'s lawyer, Olivier Metzner, criticized the Pontoise court outside Paris for what he called a "patriotic" decision -- blaming an American company while acquitting French officials accused of ignoring design flaws in the elegant Concorde, a jet that could fly at twice the speed of sound and was the pride of European aviation.

All other defendants in the case -- including three former French officials and Taylor's now-retired supervisor Stanley Ford -- were acquitted.

The judges also ordered nearly euro2 million ($2.7 million) to be paid in damages to Air France, families of some victims and other civil parties in the case. Air France, which wasn't accused of any wrongdoing, will receive euro1.08 million ($1.43 million) of those damages for the negative effect the case has had on its reputation.

Continental was ordered to pay the bulk of the damages, with a fraction of the burden falling to Airbus parent company EADS.

The presiding judge confirmed investigators' long-held belief that titanium debris dropped by a Continental DC-10 onto the runway at Charles de Gaulle airport before the supersonic jet took off on July 25, 2000, was to blame. Investigators said the debris gashed the Concorde's tire, propelling bits of rubber into the fuel tanks and sparking a fire.

The plane then slammed into a nearby hotel, killing all 109 people aboard and four others on the ground. Most of the victims were Germans heading to a cruise in the Caribbean.

The crash marked the beginning of the end for the Concorde, which was a commercial dud despite its glamor, and which was retired in 2003 by its only two carriers, Air France and British Airways.

Ronald Schmid, a lawyer who has represented several families of the German victims, said he was "skeptical" about the ruling.

"It bothers me that none of those responsible for Air France were sitting in the docks," he told The Associated Press by phone from Frankfurt.

While France's aviation authority concluded the crash could not have been foreseen, judicial investigators said the Concorde's fuel tanks lacked sufficient protection from shock and said officials had known about the problem for more than 20 years.

The court ruled, however, that though French officials had missed opportunities to improve the Concorde over the years, they could "be accused of no serious misconduct."

The court said Taylor -- a Danish citizen with permanent U.S. residence -- should not have used titanium, a harder metal than usual, to build a piece for the DC-10 that is known as a wear strip. He was accused of improperly installing the wear strip, which fell onto the runway.

In a telephone interview from his home in Montgomery, Texas, on Monday, Taylor said, "I don't think I did the work" installing the wear strip.

He also said the case has "destroyed my life."

"I've been nothing but wronged since this started," said Taylor, who marked 20 years of employment with Continental in August. He said the case has prevented him from gaining citizenship in the United States, where he has lived since age 3.

Continental defense lawyer Metzner, who argued that a fire broke out on the Concorde even before it reached the runway debris, said the ruling "protects only the interests of France.

"This has strayed far from truth, law and justice," he said. "This has privileged purely national interests."

Continental spokesman Nick Britton also said in a statement that the airline disagrees with the "absurd finding" against it and Taylor.

"Portraying the metal strip as the cause of the accident -- and Continental and one of its employees as the sole guilty parties -- shows the determination of the French authorities to shift attention and blame away from Air France," he said, noting that Air France was state-run at the time.

Continental faces no other court or other government action over the Concorde crash.

Roland Rappaport, a lawyer for the family of Concorde pilot Christian Marty and a pilots union, said the verdict was "incomprehensible" and asked why blame was heaped on Continental mechanics when French officials were aware of weaknesses on the Concorde around two decades before the crash.

"This trial made clear that the Concorde, this superb plane, suffered from severe technical insufficiencies, problems with the fuel tanks that were known since '79," he said.

The fine ordered for Continental surpassed the euro175,000 ($231,000) fine sought by a state prosecutor, who had requested 18-month suspended prison sentences for both Taylor and Ford.

The prosecution also had requested a two-year suspended sentence for Henri Perrier, former head of the Concorde program at former plane maker Aerospatiale. It argued for the acquittal of Aerospatiale engineer Jacques Herubel and Claude Frantzen, former chief of France's civil aviation authority.

Though both Aerospatiale employees were cleared of manslaughter charges, the court ruled that European defense giant and Airbus parent company EADS, which absorbed Aerospatiale, did bear some civil responsibility, which is why the French branch of the company was ordered to pay a share of damages.

Parties including Air France and Continental compensated the families of most victims years ago, so financial claims were not the trial's focus -- the main goal was to assign responsibility.

Continental is now part of Chicago-based United Continental Holdings Inc., which was formed in October as the holding company owner of United and Continental airlines, which will eventually be combined into a single airline.

In France, unlike in many other countries, plane crashes routinely lead to trials to assign criminal responsibility. It is common for cases to drag on for years.

Last year, France's highest court finally confirmed the acquittal of all those originally accused of responsibility in an Air Inter crash that killed 87 people in 1992 -- or 17 years earlier.

Kirsten Grieshaber in Berlin and Diana Heidgerd in Dallas, Texas, contributed to this report. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

The French........ what a bunch of funny people. 

zapper007 --- 15 years ago -

The French........ what a bunch of funny people.

For a brief moment, I bet Continental thought it was funny, also...lol 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

The French........ what a bunch of funny people.

Yeah, they should have KNOWN that when you take off behind Continental aircraft you will probably run into airplane parts they leave on the runway. 

traveller --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, they should have KNOWN that when you take off behind Continental aircraft you will probably run into airplane parts they leave on the runway.

Spoken like the true ignorant person you are rj. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Spoken like the true ignorant person you are rj.

Well when I was working at United at SFO, I rmember that SFO tower got pissed off at a Continental 727 for leaving parts on their runway. Then we cannot forget about Continental Express coming apart in midair over Eagle Lake TX when the left leading edge of the horizontal stab came off because all the screws had been removed from it the night before during maintenance. At least all those folks died instantly. There were a couple of other instances of Continental parts coming off which I cannot remember all the particulars.

I DO remember that when Lorenzo was in charge, and had Eastern Airlines, his maintenance cheif got prison time for falsifying documents. I also know of a mechanic who left Continental because he refused to pencil whip inspections.

I was entertained by Continental when I was going to A&P school at Rice at Hobby. WE were out on break when there was a huge explosion from the hangar near us. WE thought that was a bit unusual, so we later found out their method of inflating tires. They put the tire in the cage, turned the air compressor on, when the tire pressure was more than enough, the safety valve on the compressor would lift, make a noise, and they would shut it off and reduce pressure in the tire. Unfortunately, this time the relief valve did NOT relieve, and instead the tire exploded. It destroyed the cage, a number of tool boxes, blew out a big chunck of metal from the sides of the hangar, and did NOT kill or injure anybody. I guess they should know all about exploding tires given their experience at it. 

traveller --- 15 years ago -

It is ludicrous to compare the CO of Frank Lorenzo to the CO of today, but if it makes you feel better go right ahead. CO's maintenance records and procedures are probably the best in the business right now. Perhaps you should check maintance records from the past 15 years. 

hollyedw --- 15 years ago -

ditto traveller 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

If I were Continental, I'd send them a reply letter in German. See if the get it. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

It is ludicrous to compare the CO of Frank Lorenzo to the CO of today, but if it makes you feel better go right ahead. CO's maintenance records and procedures are probably the best in the business right now. Perhaps you should check maintance records from the past 15 years. 

This is exactly why the FAA looks at Continental's maintenance program for other airlines to model after.. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

OK, so a question...
Is there still a dispute as to whether or not debris on the runway caused this accident? Or is the dispute about whether Continental's plane dropped the debris?

If the accident happened here, our courts and investigators would have investigated and come to their own conclusions. As the French have done.

Is anyone here suggesting that the French have made up the evidence or am I missing something here?

These are not questions meant to stir....just curious as to why everyone is up in arms about this. And yes, I have read the article. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

Is there still a dispute as to whether or not debris on the runway caused this accident?

There was question as to if the tire had already blown when it hit the piece of metal. Not sure if that was substantiated or not.

Or is the dispute about whether Continental's plane dropped the debris?

Don't think that is in dispute anymore..


The British and the French knew this was a problem with their wing tanks, the Brits put in baffles to prevent this from happening but the French refused. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

Glad i bought my ticket for Christmas before this happened........ 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

It is ludicrous to compare the CO of Frank Lorenzo to the CO of today, but if it makes you feel better go right ahead. CO's maintenance records and procedures are probably the best in the business right now. Perhaps you should check maintance records from the past 15 years.

http://www.dailymarkets.com/releases/2010/05/13/faa-proposes-325000-civil-penalty-against-continental-airlines-update/ 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

Rut roh. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Perhaps you should check maintance records from the past 15 years.

While there is no question that Continental is a FAR better airline than under Lorenzo and is a perfectly safe airline which I would not hesitate to fly on, I had to respond in a facetious way to the remark that the French were being unfair to Continental.

The FAA conducted a safety review after the Eagle Lake crash and found little wrong and even complimented Express on its maintenance. This was surreal as an inspection. The maintenace was great, but the airplane crashed because of bad maintenance. As far as paperwork goes, that may well have been true because all the FAA checked was the paperwork. The NTSB denounced not only Continental Express, but the FAA as well because of the poor job they did in monitoring them.

It is even more disturbing since Continental is not owning up to its clear role in the crash. THAT does NOT send a good signal that they are taking their maintenance practices seriously enough. It is impossible to design an aircraft to meet ALL contingencies and still have it fly. I cannot fault Air France for not foreseeing that a metal strip would cause a crash. It should NOT have been there at ALL. The tires on the Concorde could have been better and the fuel tanks were armoured after the crash. It should not have been necessary to do either if other airlines would keep their airplane parts where they belong, ON THE AIRCRAFT!

Since I have been out of the airline business and the maintenance end for years, I cannot speak to the present state of it there. I only hope that Continental will follow the lead of United in maintenance because United has always had the best in the business. At least that was true when I worked there. United can learn a LOT from Continental on the rest of the business since United is abysmal in all of those areas. When I worked at United, we had to get additional security clearances because we worked on so many planes from heads of state from many countries. THAT is how you know your maintenance is not only good, but GREAT. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

For the life of me, I cannot figure out why the mechanic would use a titanium strip for a wear strip. That sort of goes against the whole idea of a wear strip since titianium is so hard and tough. You WANT a wear strip to WEAR which it the whole purpose of it.

I also cannot recall if there is any titanium on the thrust reversers in the DC-10 which would make it a bit more understandable. I would be interested in finding out about that. 

Nick --- 15 years ago -

The concord was designed with sloppy tolerances in the wings , it was notorious for leaking fuel as it sat on the tarmac . The life of an A&P mechanic can defenitly suck at times . This mech said he doesnt think he installed the wear strip , somebody signed the log book for it 

AsExpected --- 15 years ago -

Without pulling out the book, my brain tells me that commercial aircraft are supposed to be able to take off on one engine.
So if there is a fire in one engine, why not shut it down, continue the take off, and circle to land?
Or was the fire in the fuel tank?
Or does AF follow different regulations being an international carrier?
But then how are they allowed into the US if they dont meet our flight standards?

As long as we have AP's/ AI's here I thought I'd ask for clarification... 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

The concord was designed with sloppy tolerances in the wings , it was notorious for leaking fuel as it sat on the tarmac

It was supposed to leak fuel like the SR-71 which was so leaky that fuel poured out of it. They took off with only enough fuel to meet up with a tanker to get fuel in the air. Then they would go supersonic, heat up the plane and the leaks would stop. Unfortunately, the plane I fly has leaks as a normal part of its operation. There is a leak test which allows a certain number of drops per minute and it is still OK. This plane is NOT supersonic or even close to it. Having leaky fuel tanks is not necessarily something that makes an aircraft unairworthy.

There is NO question that normal fuel leaks did NOT cause the crash. That would not cause the massive fire that is observed on the left wing.

I am very disturbed by the allegation that the mechanic who signed off on the repair says he did not do it. While it would not surprise me, it goes to the heart of Continental maintenance practices. I hope and think that defense was presented in the court and was found not credible if the poor guy had his own lawyer. If he relied on Continental's he is screwed. 

Nick --- 15 years ago -

A E , yes A/C are designed to be able to take off on one engine , the fire came from what the french are saying damage to the wing caused by the debris on the run way . A.F. has to follow FAA rules and regs and like you said ANY aircraft coming to the U.S. has to follow our rules .The euro standards are just as high if not higher than U.S. . The aircraft mech over there are engineers and have to obtain a 4 year degree to work on them . As far as the mech that said he didn't work on the cont. A/C there is a log book that has someones signature on it , if he wasn't the one that made the repair he shouldn't have any worries . Something led them to him and if he pencil whipped it then he gets what he deserves 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

So if there is a fire in one engine, why not shut it down, continue the take off, and circle to land?

The fire was not in the engine and the crew did not know that they had a problem until the tower told them about the big fire on their wing. They then got a fire warning on #2 engine and they shut it down. The fire then burned through the wing and caused #1 engine to lose power too. They tried to get the gear up and it would not retract. So they were dead with two engines out, gear still out, and decreasing control because of the fire and slowing airspeed. I am sure that the crew would have tried to find a field to crash in, but lost control because the fly by wire system was degraded or went out completely. I hate fly by wire control systems if they have no mechanical back up or should at least have one control system that is all mechanical. I initially did not want to fly the EMB-170 until I found out that the ailerons were still totally mechanical. At least I would have a fighting chance if the fly by wire and computers decided to go out. 

AsExpected --- 15 years ago -

Dig it.
Thanks guys.
Havent really been able to keep up on all of it, obviously. 

zapper007 --- 15 years ago -

Interesting posts - thanks for updating the non-airline types... 

JustMeBeingMe --- 15 years ago -

without going in to the "mechanical" details of the whole situation, my issue lies with the airport itself. with the concord already known for it's "problems" (for lack of a better word) that a FOD check was required on the runways before every concord takeoff...
i still have yet to see why any liabilities haven't been taken there....was the co mx at fault? perhaps, but there is a system in place to avoid such problems that the concord had....anyone know? 

JustMeBeingMe --- 15 years ago -

...i guess question being how, IF the required FOD check was done, how one would be able to miss that "piece of metal"
??
is continental (that mechanic) being the fall-guy in the big picture? 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

concord already known for it's "problems" (for lack of a better word) that a FOD check was required on the runways before every concord takeoff...

The Concorde did not have problems above and beyond that of most aircraft. ANY airplane hitting FOD will have problems, some more than others. There are NOT supposed to even BE FOD and there are NO requirements to my knowledge that aircraft have to be able to hit FOD on the runway and safely continue.

FOD checks are conducted at intervals and do NOT take place after every takeoff. The sad thing is that if it had been aluminum, it probably would not have caused the tire to rupture since it would have bent very easily and not caused as much tire damage.

The fault is 90% with Continental, and about 10% with the aircraft designers. They designed the airplane within the rules and regs at the time. Air France did all that they could do and followed all of the rules. Continental did NOT. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground