Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Nearly Half of U.S. Lives in Household Receiving Government Benefit

who's talking here?

smartypants 3
planemom 1
ukchristine 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
david 2
oopsy 1
rEVOLution 1
Perfection 6
justcat 1
voice of reason 1
Frio 1
Dr Aborto 1
LiveFreeOrDie 1
Dorothy Parker 3
crazypinetrees 2
gardeniagirl07 2
giannasmommy 1
NativeTexan 1
justforfun1 3
LitlJay 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Wow that's a lot

0

Families were more dependent on government programs than ever last year.

Nearly half, 48.5%, of the population lived in a household that received some type of government benefit in the first quarter of 2010, according to Census data. Those numbers have risen since the middle of the recession when 44.4% lived households receiving benefits in the third quarter of 2008.

The share of people relying on government benefits has reached a historic high, in large part from the deep recession and meager recovery, but also because of the expansion of government programs over the years. (See a timeline on the history of government benefits programs here.)

Means-tested programs, designed to help the needy, accounted for the largest share of recipients last year. Some 34.2% of Americans lived in a household that received benefits such as food stamps, subsidized housing, cash welfare or Medicaid (the federal-state health care program for the poor).

Another 14.5% lived in homes where someone was on Medicare (the health care program for the elderly). Nearly 16% lived in households receiving Social Security.

High unemployment and increased reliance on government programs has also shrunk the nation’s share of taxpayers. Some 46.4% of households will pay no federal income tax this year, according to the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center. That’s up from 39.9% in 2007, the year the recession began.

Most of those households will still be hit by payroll taxes. Just 18.1% of households pay neither payroll nor federal income taxes and they are predominantly the nation’s elderly and poorest families.

The tandem rise in government-benefits recipients and fall in taxpayers has been cause for alarm among some policymakers and presidential hopefuls.

Benefits programs have come under closer scrutiny as policymakers attempt to tame the federal government’s budget deficit. President Barack Obama and members of Congress considered changes to Social Security and Medicare as part of a grand bargain (that ultimately fell apart) to raise the debt ceiling earlier this year. Cuts to such programs could emerge again from the so-called “super committee,” tasked with releasing a plan to rein in the deficit.

Republican presidential hopefuls, meanwhile, have latched onto the fact that nearly half of households pay no federal income tax, saying too many Americans aren’t paying their fair share.

UPDATE: Nearly half of the population lives in a household that has at least one member who receives some kind of government benefit. An earlier headline incorrectly suggested that half of American households receive some government benefit. Due to differences in household size that isn’t the case. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -


High unemployment and increased reliance on government programs has also shrunk the nation’s share of taxpayers. Some 46.4% of households will pay no federal income tax this year, according to the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center. That’s up from 39.9% in 2007, the year the recession began.



yikes 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

Socialism is great till you run out of rich people.. 

justforfun1 --- 15 years ago -

Socialism is great till you run out of rich people..


Try telling the ones with the entitlement mindset that tax payers are the ones who are supporting them. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Where is their pride.

I have more respect for the illegals who are here picking crops, washing cars, cleaning houses than I do for those who don't. 

oopsy --- 15 years ago -

I live in one. Dh is a cancer patient and we were forced by our private disability insurance to apply for SS Disability. He received it in 1 week due to the severity of his cancer. After 18 months on SSD, Medicare automatically kicks in. We pay for Medicare, but also pay for private insurance at extremely high premiums. Dh is an Air Force veteran who probably contracted his cancer from high dose radiation in him mission. The VA turned down any claim to that and hearing loss.

Also, note, that many households that receive assistance are military families. Unfortunately, the large number of deployments leave a single parent at home to maintain the home and finances. Many of our enlisted service members have to get assistance to buy food. That is a travesty!!!!! 

justforfun1 --- 15 years ago -

Our servicemen should be taken care of no matter what. It's the ones here that have never done anything except expect the government to take care of them. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

I wonder what the percentage would be if they took out those receiving benefits from Social Security, which is not a tax but an insurance program.

Considering that people live longer, it's perfectly logical that the % would reflect increases. Too bad we don't have a graph that's not skewed. 

justforfun1 --- 15 years ago -

I wonder what the percentage would be if they took out those receiving benefits from Social Security, which is not a tax but an insurance program.



Social Security is a benefit that old people pay into their whole life and draw such a small percentage back that it's pitiful. These people have put that money in there and have every right to take it back out. 

justcat --- 15 years ago -

And my 24 yo SD, living with her Mom, owns nothing, has a dead beat dad of an ex husband who can't even pay the measly 400 dollars a month for child support. She works at the day care her son attends and is finishing her degree in education...
Can. Not. Get. Aid. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

These people have put that money in there and have every right to take it back out.

I agree. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

How many of them are getting more than they put in?

How many draw out without putting any in?

Remember, it was designed to SUPPLEMENT retirement. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

These people have put that money in there and have every right to take it back out.

Which is why it's ridiculous that they include the 16% of the population that are on S.S. in that 48.5%.


Where is their pride.

I think that people that are on S.S. can be on that and have their pride completely intact. What about you Chunk? You have anybody in your house on assistance? Disability perhaps?

(sorry this is Randle) 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

No one pays FICA expecting to get it back some day in food stamps or welfare checks, but they DO pay for their entire lives into SS with the expectation that they will get it back when they retire or if they become disabled.

SS is not an entitlement, a handout, or even an investment. It is money paid in with the expectation that it will be paid back. Educators, police officers, firefighters, and other public employees who have public pensions are being RIPPED OFF when they are denied their SS benefits at retirement because they have a gov't pension (as both of my parents were).

SS is not free benefits and should not be included in that chart. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

SS is not free benefits and should not be included in that chart.

But it makes the chart look more scary! That's the point. Then people can turn around and say oh my god that is so shocking. It helps them justify their politics to themselves, even when they have to believe lies to do so. 

giannasmommy --- 15 years ago -

I am asking because I am not sure of the answer, but isnt ssi also given to children when their parents pass on early in life? AnHow many of them are getting more than they put in?

How many draw out without putting any in?

Remember, it was designed to SUPPLEMENT retirement.


And this is so true. Pull out a check stub see how much you pay in. Multply that by 52 or 26 and then by 40. Then take the amt that you will receive in ssi when you retire, multiply that by in some cases 30 years. Which is the greater number? Ssi, is a supplement, its wont be there because more and more people are living longer and cost of living continues to go up. Its a harsh reality but the truth. 

david --- 15 years ago -

That's why I don't understand why people don't think ss as a ponzi scheme it works the exact same way with the end result being the same... No money to pay benefits... 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

I do not understand why
Perry was vilified for calling it a ponzi scheme. 

david --- 15 years ago -

Exactly uk the working class pay the Retiree benefits when that generation retires they receive the benefits (less % than the previous generation) their kids and grand kids pay for the benefits they retire receive benefits (at a even lower % than the original benefits... Till finally the benefits stop.... The definition of a ponzi scheme. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Dh is an Air Force veteran

You are not the folks being discussed in this conversation. There is NEVER any excuse for our Veterans paying for health care services. This is one reason it disgusts me when our government says things like "Support our Troops" when they know full well that they themselves have left so many Veterans wounded and paying for their own health care.

It was Obama after all who tried to force current Troops to pay for their own health care.

Many of our Veterans today did not volunteer for service and they absolutely should never pay a single dime for health care. Even those who did volunteer deserve the same.

Perry was vilified for calling it a ponzi scheme.

One reason he was vilified is not because he said it, but rather where he learned the idea from. Some of Perry's views that he claims are is own are in fact Ron Paul's views. Several of the candidates have taken his views and used them as their own platform because they know his views are becoming more popular.

The other reason he was vilified is because people are shocked to hear that we are being ripped off, they don't want to accept the reality that our government is not really here to help us.

Just like with welfare, welfare is not a support for most, for some it is but for most it's doing nothing more than keeping them at the level in society that they are at and for many that is in poverty. 

gardeniagirl07 --- 15 years ago -

I'm on SSDI and hubby draws SS because he is retired. It's the people who refuse to work but are capable of it and live off of gov't programs that irritate us. There is no crime in people being poor but being lazy is inexcusable. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Bingo. Well said gardeniagirl07 

gardeniagirl07 --- 15 years ago -

Thanks CH. You brought up an excellent topic! :) 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Nearly half, 48.5%, of the population lived in a household that received some type of government benefit in the first quarter of 2010, according to Census data.

What is a "Government Benefit"? Is it MediCare? Social Security? How about injured military? I don't think we should look at the 48% as poor, lottery scratching dead beats. A lot of you are pointing fingers yet you're one of the 48%. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Thanks it is a very difficult and uncomfortable subject. No one wants to appear heartless however we have to be able to say enough is enough and really look at what we are spending. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I'm on SSDI


Playing Devil's advocate, why are you on it?

Lots of people are accused of being on it fraudulently, I've seen posts on KU about this very thing. (Same with welfare, section 8, etc etc) but, unless you know the person, you have no idea whether or not there's a legitimate need.

Would you like being accused of being "lazy" and just choosing not to work? Now granted, I don't know you, so, it may be obvious why you're on disability and never questioned. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

A lot of you are pointing fingers yet you're one of the 48%. 


Isn't it ironic? There have been people on KU, ON WELFARE, but they were never told to get rid of their internet and stop being so lazy, etc.

I guess it's easier to point fingers and just ASSume those "other people" are the abusers.... 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

I think that people that are on S.S. can be on that and have their pride completely intact. What about you Chunk? You have anybody in your house on assistance? Disability perhaps?

Chunky never answered this. 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

What is a "Government Benefit"? Is it MediCare? Social Security? How about injured military? I don't think we should look at the 48% as poor, lottery scratching dead beats. A lot of you are pointing fingers yet you're one of the 48%.

Uh no...ill point fingers and i dont qualify for that 48%. I got WIC as a single mom for about 2 years, I ve received UE for 2 months many years ago but no other benefits. My husband and I both work and pay a buttload in taxes every year and get nothing back because we only have 1 child as opposed to 3, 4 or 5.

This govt benefits to me means Section 8 housing, medicaid for adults who can work and dont, food stamps for those who continue to breed knowing they cannot feed or house or insure their kids. 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

Isn't it ironic? There have been people on KU, ON WELFARE, but they were never told to get rid of their internet and stop being so lazy, etc.

No i know some on here who have gotten benefits but didnt need too. Capable of working and wouldnt. No excuse for that. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

i don't know what you all expect when 1% of the people are earning majority of the money. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

i don't know what you all expect when 1% of the people are earning majority of the money.

Such envy. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

Another 14.5% lived in homes where someone was on Medicare (the health care program for the elderly). Nearly 16% lived in households receiving Social Security.

Since the majority of people who receive these benefits paid into them, they aren't on the dole. What bothers me about medicare/medicaid is the government accepts a 10% fraud rate. How much money could be save if the government went after the fraudulent claims in medicare/medicaid the same way the IRS goes after tax cheats? 

NativeTexan --- 15 years ago -

Also, note, that many households that receive assistance are military families.

About 10% of the U.S. population are veterans and I agree that they are underpaid and under supported. I don't mind helping them to thank them for their service. What about the other 38%? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground