Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

HOPE the "HOLLOWAYS" & Attorney collect FROM "KELLER WILLIAMS" the $850K NOW w/o appeals

who's talking here?

auntmarsa 1
Banjos and Squealing Pigs 2
workingmommiex2 2
Tipsyhic 5
LoveMyDoggies 1
Dorothy Parker 1
Gazer 2
Nightshade 8
snowprincess 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Gazer --- 14 years ago -

Posted: Tuesday, November 29, 2011 5:16 pm

By STEFANIE THOMAS | 0 comments

A Harris County jury recently found realty powerhouse Keller Williams Northeast liable for the 2009 fraudulent sale of a termite-infested home in the Trailwood subdivision of Kingwood.

In mid-November, Judge Alexandra Smoots-Hogan entered a judgment of approximately $850,000 in total in favor of area residents Shawn and Stephanie Holloway. According to court records, the jury decided unanimously that Keller Williams was guilty of misleading and deceiving the Holloways in the purchase of their home, knowingly engaged in unconscionable actions and committed statutory fraud against the couple.

Adam W. Green, who represented the Holloways during the civil proceedings for more than two years, said he is pleased with the outcome of the trial.

“Every single cause of action we had against Keller Williams, we prevailed on. And it was unanimous,” Green said. “All 12 of them agreed that Keller Williams was liable for fraud, statutory fraud, breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, and violations of the DTPA, which is our consumer protection act.”

The Holloways filed civil action against Keller Williams in July 2009, less than two months after they moved into their new home in the 1300 block of Trailwood Village.

“After closing on the home on or about May 6, 2009, the Holloways hired a contractor to perform certain repairs and upgrades,” the plaintiffs stated in their petition to the court. “On May 23, during the course of this work, it was discovered the home suffered from massive and insidious termite damage. One of the many indicators leading to the contractor’s discovery occurred when one of his workers pressed on a wall and it moved four to five inches. In other locations, wood crumpled into dust when handled. Further investigation revealed termite damage so extensive that the home is unfit for human habitation.”

Green said the Holloways were forced to move from their new home almost as soon as they had moved in and stayed with relatives, and later in an apartment instead, while still paying mortgage on a house they couldn’t live in.

“They had bought that house to start a family, and then they had to put all those plans on hold because they didn’t know if they were going to make it,” Green said. “By the time it came to trial, 27 months later, the right result was achieved. But it’s just ridiculous that they had to go through all this.”
FAILED POLICY

Green said a serious conflict of interests resulted when Keller Williams allowed its agents to break the firm’s policy that prohibited a seller, who also is an agent for Keller Williams, to represent him- or herself. In the Holloway’s case, Green said, the seller was a Keller Williams agent, representing herself, although the paperwork showed another agent’s name who, as it turned out during trial, was merely a figurehead who in reality performed no function during the transaction whatsoever. The buyers’ agent was also a Keller Williams agent.

“This is one of the most recognized realty firms in the country. These are people who should have known better and probably did know better,” Green said. “The policy looks really good on paper, but nobody is actually following it.”

When the Holloway’s first deal on another house fell through, court records indicate the couple’s own agent suggested to take a look at his colleague’s home for sale. The Holloway’s liked it and, not without pressure from the agents, decided to buy.

“My clients were told there were four or five other people lined up to buy that house, and they’d have to hurry and make a full price offer,” Green said. “It turned out in trial there was no one. None of that was true.”

Trial records show that the home had a history of termite problems. The real estate agent who purchased the home in 2002 reportedly was aware of the problems but failed to disclose them to the Holloways. A real estate inspector, referred to the Holloways by their own agent, was initially also named in the lawsuit for allegedly deliberately overlooking the termite infestation. That aspect of the suit was later dropped when the parties reached an agreement, according to Green. The seller of the home also managed to extricate herself from the proceedings.

“The most galling thing is, what were those people thinking? Keller Williams had a file on this house in their possession the entire time, and that file would have shown that the seller’s disclosure that my clients got from the seller herself, was a lie,” Green said. “Keller Williams never went and pulled that file until they found out they were going to be sued. I’m thinking my client would have loved to have that information before they made the largest investment in their life. ”

According to Harris County Appraisal District records, the home was valued at more than $198,000 when the Holloway’s purchased it in 2009. Since then, the home’s value has dwindled to $33,000 in 2011.

The jury awarded the couple more than $315,000 in damages, along with pre- and post-judgment interest on that sum, as well as attorneys’ fees totaling about $524,000.

“More than anything, the Holloways want to make sure this doesn’t happen to anyone else,” Green said. “They’re smart people, so if it can happen to them, it can happen to anybody.”

Attorney Mark Stein, representative for Keller Williams, declined to comment for this report, only to say that his client plans on appealing the decision. 

LoveMyDoggies --- 14 years ago -

Hallelujah!!! 

Gazer --- 14 years ago -

What did the INSPECTOR pay to the HOLLAWAYS to get out of the LAWSUIT?

and what did the SELLER DO or PAY to "extricate herself" ? whatever that
means,,,

*******

"A real estate inspector, referred to the Holloways by their own agent, was initially also named in the lawsuit for allegedly deliberately overlooking the termite infestation. That aspect of the suit was later dropped when the parties reached an agreement, according to Green. The seller of the home also managed to extricate herself from the proceedings." 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

Shouldn't the seller be the one held responsible for the majority of it? It seems like she was the one who started the whole thing. 

workingmommiex2 --- 14 years ago -

It could of ended along time ago with E&O insurance, by all the parties, but they chose to gambled on a jury
Sorry that some agents from KW will suffer the fall out by those in the lawsuit.
JMO 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Who was their agent and are they still an active agent now? 

auntmarsa --- 14 years ago -

Who was their agent and are they still an active agent now?

Jeremy Williams 

Tipsyhic --- 14 years ago -

Sorry that some agents from KW will suffer the fall out by those in the lawsuit.
JMO

You would have thought that the smart move would have been to settle out of court or they should have bought the house back out right. They could have rented the house out for 5 years and then taken the loss. JMO 

workingmommiex2 --- 14 years ago -

Im sure there is alot of Monday Night Quarterbacking going on! 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

and what did the SELLER DO or PAY to "extricate herself" ? whatever that
means,,,

*******

"A real estate inspector, referred to the Holloways by their own agent, was initially also named in the lawsuit for allegedly deliberately overlooking the termite infestation. That aspect of the suit was later dropped when the parties reached an agreement, according to Green. The seller of the home also managed to extricate herself from the proceedings."



The seller/agent shouldn't have had to do anything to extricate herself.

Plaintiff's atty, Green, apparently doesn't know how RE firms operate. The agent who 'lists' for the seller/agent is always a figurehead. Not just at KW.

The reporter also doesn't know how RE operates. The agent is never sued personally. It is always the broker and their E&O insurance. She didn't manage to extricate herself. She is never personally liable.

This comment by the attorney is just plain stupid. KWNE would not know it was a lie just because they have a copy of the disclosure in their file.
“The most galling thing is, what were those people thinking? Keller Williams had a file on this house in their possession the entire time, and that file would have shown that the seller’s disclosure that my clients got from the seller herself, was a lie,” Green said. “Keller Williams never went and pulled that file until they found out they were going to be sued. I’m thinking my client would have loved to have that information before they made the largest investment in their life. ”

Typical idiocy/unfairness in today's society with the attorney getting $524k of the settlement. It operates just like our dysfunctional plutocracy. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

Who was their agent and are they still an active agent now?

Jeremy Williams



Jeremy is beyond a nice guy. I bet he had no idea Jennifer was lying about her home's condition. I doubt she told a soul.

No agent in their right mind would bring their buyers to a home in that condition if they were aware of it.

Jeremy also would not have known if there were really 4-5 other offers in the works. The buyer's agent can only go on what the seller's agent tells them.

I doubt Jennifer will ever practice RE again. Btw, she has left the area. 

Tipsyhic --- 14 years ago -

I think the judgement came from 12 people that new the facts. I am sure it was not in the best interest for KW to make inspectors to pay money to be on their inspectors list. It should have been an open market with the best inspectors on the list not the bottom of the barrel inspectors that had to pay to get on this list. Seems to be that greed was the basis of this case and the best interest of the client was thrown to the side. I think RESPA should get involved with this case. Was it disclosed to the buyers that these inspectors had to pay money to get on this list??? 

Banjos and Squealing Pigs --- 14 years ago -

I think broker fees are too high. The 3% or whatever the final fee was should have been enough for any agent to do their damned job. The job of the agent is to represent the party that signs them up. This is a prime example why buyers should bring in an unrelated agent to the sellers agent. This was a snow job from the onset and KWNE got what they deserved. This should be a wake up call to all real estate agents to stand up and do the right thing when they take on a client.

I remember back 10 years ago when everyone wanted to be a part time RE agent. Big money lure, nothing really to do but drive people around and print out listings for them. Easiest work on the planet. At some point many of these fly by night agents forgot that they're supposed to be a protector of interests for their clients.

Frankly, I think there about twice as many "agents" in this area than there needs to be. That's what happens.

Shame on the KWNE broker that allowed this to happen without better oversight in his/her own agency. I'd have a house cleaning of agents and a major sit down with those left so as to try and save face and that office.

This is all enough that I would never use KWNE ever for buying or selling my home.

This, frankly, comes down to greed and perhaps some laziness. Much more of the former then the latter. 

Tipsyhic --- 14 years ago -

Shame on the KWNE broker that allowed this to happen without better oversight in his/her own agency. I'd have a house cleaning of agents and a major sit down with those left so as to try and save face and that office.
Personally I think they all forgot about their CODE of ETHICS. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

I am sure it was not in the best interest for KW to make inspectors to pay money to be on their inspectors list.

It should have been an open market with the best inspectors on the list not the bottom of the barrel inspectors that had to pay to get on this list.




Where did you get this info from? It's completely untrue.

I don't think you know how it works. An agent can recommend whomever they want but KW requires the agent to recommend *more than one* to their buyers with the buyer making the final decision. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

I think broker fees are too high.


That's because you have no idea how much work an agent actually does and how many hours go into each sale. Not to mention all the work that is done that generates zero commission..... especially in today's environment.


The job of the agent is to represent the party that signs them up.

There is no evidence at all that Jeremy didn't represent his buyer. Absolutely *none.* You are assuming he had knowledge of what Jennifer was hiding and I know he did not.

As for KWNE, I don't know how you expect them to know that Jennifer, the seller/agent, was unscrupulous. When someone is lying and hiding facts, how the heck is anyone else supposed to know that??

As for the inspector, he probably got off the hook because it is not his job to uncover termites. He is a mechanical/structural inspector. It is up to the buyer to hire a termite inspector and all are advised to do so by KWNE. Matter of fact, I believe they even have the buyers sign a form stating that they were advised to do so.

I've never seen an inspector walk around the house pressing on all walls to make sure they don't move. Never ever. It's not in their scope. They've got too many other things to focus on.

When was the last time you looked at an inspection report? Please lead me to the section that states "touch all walls."


This is a prime example why buyers should bring in an unrelated agent to the sellers agent.


No, it isn't. Agents are unrelated. Irrelevant that they work for the same broker. I would bet my bottom dollar that Jeremy had absolutely no idea what Jennifer was hiding. Many of the agents working for the same broker don't even know each other. Do you have any idea how many agents KWNE has? Do you realize that most of them are rarely even in the KW office because they work from home?? Obviously not.

Other brokers....like Realty Associates, for example....have thousands of agents who never go into the office at all because of the way its structured so they really don't even know each other. So please....stop making accusations and allegations about things when you don't have the slightest idea how they operate.


This was a snow job from the onset and KWNE got what they deserved.

A snowjob only by the seller/agent. You are completely out of line and unfair by pointing fingers at KW. One bad agent doesn't spoil the whole agency. People like you do.


This should be a wake up call to all real estate agents to stand up and do the right thing when they take on a client.

Give it up already. One bad agent out of 200. That's 99.5% that *are* ethical.

Oh, and no, I'm not a KWNE agent.


I remember back 10 years ago when everyone wanted to be a part time RE agent. Big money lure, nothing really to do but drive people around and print out listings for them. Easiest work on the planet. At some point many of these fly by night agents forgot that they're supposed to be a protector of interests for their clients.


Now I know you're an idiot talking out your butt. You are completely clueless as to the amount of work an agent puts in. That is painfully obvious. Big money lure? LMFAO. You also obviously have no idea how much it COSTS to be an agent. No idea whatsoever.

Also, neither of them are fly-by-night agents so again you speak of which you know not. Jeremy has been an agent for going on 15 years and he is now an assistant team leader at another KW brokerage. And Jennifer was also an agent for years. She was even featured on an HGTV show.


Frankly, I think there about twice as many "agents" in this area than there needs to be. That's what happens.


And what, pray tell, do you base this conclusion on?

How many agents are in this area? How have you determined how many are actually needed?


Shame on the KWNE broker that allowed this to happen without better oversight in his/her own agency. I'd have a house cleaning of agents and a major sit down with those left so as to try and save face and that office.

You are a true idiot. How in the world is *anyone* supposed to know that the seller was lying? Huh?

Clean house? Based on what???


This is all enough that I would never use KWNE ever for buying or selling my home.

Oh. Now I get it. You work for or actually are another broker in the area trying to smear KWNE as much as you can.

People like you make me sick.

KWNE has sold thousands upon thousands of homes in this area. One crappy deal. Woopee. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

On 2nd thought, if you were a broker you wouldn't have made so many completely ignorant comments about what goes into buying and selling a home, the related agents' costs, etc. 

Banjos and Squealing Pigs --- 14 years ago -

Hey bud, it's all about what people perceive. Obviously, there was fraud in the transaction otherwise a jury wouldn't have ruled the way they did.

So you're saying that a broker doesn't screen agents before they let them work under them? You'll never make me believe that other agents, including the broker perhaps don't do everything above board. There is always that one deal that they can slip in and make a home run on or get out from under an investment property that they find out wasn't such a good deal afterwards.

I wonder what the history of the house was. Was it the sellers family residence or was it an investment property? That will shed some light.

I'm not saying all agents are bad. I'm just saying that I think for a great many, customer service is a lost art and if they can't close a lead with a picky client, they lose interest in continuing.

And stop with the name calling. It's beneath you. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

So you're saying that a broker doesn't screen agents before they let them work under them? You'll never make me believe that other agents, including the broker perhaps don't do everything above board. There is always that one deal that they can slip in and make a home run on or get out from under an investment property that they find out wasn't such a good deal afterwards.


I believe that most people in the world are good. The same percentage of schnooks and sheisters holds true for RE agents as it does in any other profession.

You get the point.

What do you mean by "screen" an agent exactly?

"We think we know the ones we love but anyone can keep secrets."


I wonder what the history of the house was. Was it the sellers family residence or was it an investment property? That will shed some light.


You made all those comments above and you don't even know all the facts of the case? Add to that the fact that your knowledge of the real estate world is also lacking. That was exactly what had me outraged earlier.

You bad-mouthed a whole business full of agents that depend on their jobs to survive just because of one unscrupulous agent. You inflict harm on a local community business.


I'm not saying all agents are bad. I'm just saying that I think for a great many, customer service is a lost art and if they can't close a lead with a picky client, they lose interest in continuing.


You are completely generalizing here. Again. And that stinks. "For a great many"? Exactly how many have you worked with that you can make these sweeping generalizations?

Are you the picky client?

Every agent should have their limits with how much time they want to invest in any particular client. Those that are ridiculously picky can be a no-win situation. Some people are totally unreasonable. Those you have to cut loose. It's a business and a business decision. 

Tipsyhic --- 14 years ago -

Where did you get this info from? It's completely untrue.
Duh:: NO Duh: If you must pay for an advertisement in a KW publication in order to get on a KW inspectors list then it is basically the same as paying to be on the list.Like I said it was all about GREED and not putting the interest of the buyer above all else. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

If you must pay for an advertisement in a KW publication in order to get on a KW inspectors list


Where did you get that info from?

They don't charge to get on their list. They charge for the ad. Big deal. They aren't forced to buy an ad. 

Tipsyhic --- 14 years ago -

They charge for the ad.
They must pay for the ad. to get of the list. Everyone knows that. Flat out greed. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

They must pay for the ad. to get of the list. Everyone knows that. Flat out greed.


Well, no, they don't have to buy an ad to get on any list. Each agent has their own list of preferred vendors/contractors anyway and they can each recommend whoever the heck they want.

Besides, advertisement isn't greed. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground