Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Education official - teachers know whats best for kids, not parents.

who's talking here?

planemom 2
hummer 1
Perfection 4
justcat 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
B12Fan 1
Work in Progress 1
LiveFreeOrDie 3
Good Ole USA 1
Dorothy Parker 5
One Nation Under God 2
ZUULisBACK 1
Lets Be Fair 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

This is your government in action

Debbie Squires, education official at the Michigan Elementary and Middle School Principals Association (MEMSPA), has sparked some controversy after telling the House Education Committee in a hearing for a new school choice package, that teachers know better than parents what's best for their children, MLive.com reports.

Squires elicited a shocked response from Education Committee Chair Thomas McMillin after testifying on the parent's role in school operations.

"[Educators] are the people who know best about how to serve children, that's not necessarily true of an individual resident," Squires said. "I'm not saying they don't want the best for their children, but they may not know what actually is best from an education standpoint."

McMillin responds, "Wow, parents don't know what's best for their child..."

Afterward, MLive's Dave Murray approached McMillin and got this comment:

"I'm surprised I didn't lose it when she said that," McMillin told Murray. "They think they know what's better for children than their own parents, and that's what I find upsetting."

According to the report, however, several readers disagreed with McMillin, including one under the username Johnny0000.

"Yes, people who are trained professionals at something tend to know more about it than those that don't. When my child has an issue that involves education I don't ask MYSELF, I get input from her TEACHERS."

The charter-school bill discussed would effectively lift the state's cap on charter schools, including virtual ones, without creating quality safety guards. Michigan currently has 225 charter schools, and their performance is currently "mixed" both in the state and nationally.

An extensive report on cyber education by the New York Times notes many educators believe that virtual schools to be important in situations like teenage mothers, but that it may not be optimal for elementary schoolers. In the report, deputy superintendent of Memphis city schools Irving Hamer Jr. told the paper that children have a lot to be gained by attending a traditional school.

"The early development of children requires lots of interaction with other children for purposes of socialization, developing collaboration and teamwork, and self-definition,” Irving Hamer Jr., deputy superintendent of Memphis city schools, told the Times.

The votes on the Michigan cyber charter school issue is expected to come in the committee's next meeting, but some educators have asked lawmakers to prevent the opening of more of such school until data is available to determine if the schools are effective. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

So now teachers know more than parents Let's just let government have full control. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

"I'm not saying they don't want the best for their children, but they may not know what actually is best from an education standpoint."


I agree with her...there are many homeschooling parents out there who have NO BUSINESS teaching anyone.

Teachers are educated, they're trained to teach...parents are parents, and teaching academics may not be their forte, much like taking your child to a doctor for medical care or to a dentist for dental care.

Teachers are trained to teach...and many have a calling for it as well. I understand the point this woman is trying to make. Seems a lot of people didn't listen to what she actually said...sad. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

An individual teacher might have a better idea but teachers are not allowed to do what they want. They have to follow what the school district dictates whether or not it's best for the child. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

They have to follow what the school district dictates whether or not it's best for the child. 


that's true.

Still, I think a trained teacher is better at educating a child than an average parent. 

justcat --- 14 years ago -

When it comes to education, over all..yes, I think they know best. That's why they go to school, and why we pay taxes to pay their salaries...
Do the parents have a say? Some, not really. Curriculum's are presented and passed without much parental choice.
We are our childs advocate, and it is up to us to see that their best interest is served. When school districts go astray..parents can and do step in. But having parents micromanage
every thing educators do is counter productive. 

One Nation Under God --- 14 years ago -

You are responsible for your child. Yes, getting input from as many sources is important in making your decision, but ultimately, you know your child better than anyone else, and you will always have your child's best interest at heart. When parents decide to homeschool, it is not usually just for academic reasons. Many other factors usually play into that decision. When I homeschooled my oldest child for a year, it was a hard decision for me, but I knew that ultimately it was the best choice for him at that time. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

0 

B12Fan --- 14 years ago -

Meh I think this goes both ways.

It should just say that parents that - well do parenting are better.

But many many parents really suck at doing that job. In that case I would lean for the teachers having a step up. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

The topic being discussed in the article is school choice; whether or not more charter schools should be allowed to open. In that context the quote is quite frightening. To me the speaker is saying, I'm not intelligent enough to determine whether or not a school can educate my child. It is also the standard line to oppose any type of change in the current bureaucratic education system. 

ZUULisBACK --- 14 years ago -

There are some parents that are too stupid to educate their children. Visit the Porter Walmart for a display of numerous examples. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

So since teachers are best and so if a teacher is a perv.............


I mean they do know best right? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

So since teachers are best and so if a teacher is a perv.............


I mean they do know best right?



Why would your mind go here? 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

I agree with her...there are many homeschooling parents out there who have NO BUSINESS teaching anyone.

Teachers are educated, they're trained to teach...parents are parents, and teaching academics may not be their forte,





Yes because the public school system has done so much for us.. :/

0 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Yes because the public school system has done so much for us.. :/


I shudder to think where we'd be if everyone homeschooled their children.

Public education has many opportunities for kids and parents. It's successful for most families and the colleges are pumping out graduates left and right who started with a public education.

I guess you consider our colleges to be mediocre as well? Where do you plan to send your kids to school? Europe? 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

I guess you consider our colleges to be mediocre as well?

Where exactly do you see that I said that??

We were talking about the public school system. Not private university's.


I shudder to think where we'd be if everyone homeschooled their children.

It's definitely not for everyone, the easy way would be to put them on the bus. Home schooling takes complete dedication and lots of sacrifice. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

I think she was talking about education. I had wonderful parents and was raised in a loving home, but they would have not been good at meeting all of my education needs. I think most teachers do a really good job. A really good teacher understands that they are only a portion of the child's educational process and therefore work with the parents to make sure the child's needs are being met. 

hummer --- 14 years ago -

Home schooling is perfect for some students and families.
Education unfortunately has a big problem dealing with all the needs.
I don't think it is an easy task.

I also shudder if all students were home schooled.

There are some students where school is their only constant. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

We were talking about the public school system. Not private university's.


Who said anything about "private" universities? And, who do you think goes to college in this country? Just the spoiled rich kids with expensive prep school backgrounds?

Let's be real. MOST of the college students were educated in our public school system....if it's such an utter failure, that certainly wouldn't be the case.

It's definitely not for everyone, the easy way would be to put them on the bus. Home schooling takes complete dedication and lots of sacrifice.

Yeah, there's no sacrifice involved...most people pull their kids out for religious or political reasons...because they don't want their children "tainted" by the gentiles...lol.

Homeschooling is not a superior way to educate children unless the parents are highly educated and dedicated to exposing their children to all sorts of ideas and people, in order to make them well-rounded. It's not just academics that you're learning in public school...it's learning about diversity, adversity, dealing with different personality types and learning social cues that only dealing with the public can teach you. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Yeah, there's no sacrifice involved...

So for the many family's who give up a second income many of which is a professional income. Yea.. no sacrifice there..


Homeschooling is not a superior way to educate children unless the parents are highly educated and dedicated to exposing their children to all sorts of ideas and people, in order to make them well-rounded.


That's why the home schooled have higher GPA's, higher high school graduation rates and higher Collage graduation rates. With higher scores all along the way.

Because it's less superior. :/ 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

That's why the home schooled have higher GPA's, higher high school graduation rates and higher Collage graduation rates. With higher scores all along the way.

Because it's less superior. :/



Don't buy it...show me some actual statistics on that, please..and from a credible source, not a pro-homeschooling website. Thanks. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

You are as educated as your reading, and your research. It doesn't really matter WHERE you accomplish it, but it has to be done.

Public school has an accountability system--kind of. It's pretty lousy actually.

I think that some of the homeschool programs have higher standards than some of the public schools I've taught in. 

Good Ole USA --- 14 years ago -

There are some very dedicated homeschool parents and unfortunately, some that say they homeschool. Regardless of where kids are educated, they need structure, socialization, and hands on other than a computer. I didn't take offense to what she said. It could have been said differently, and I think she meant teachers follow guidelines and are specialists. Some of the comments had me rollin :) 

One Nation Under God --- 14 years ago -

Just as their are bad teachers in the school system (and your child could be in their class), their are also bad parents who choose to homeschool and don't do a good job. My brother and sister in law have 4 girls. They have homeschooled all four of their kids. They have done an absolutely incredible job! They are 4 intelligent, witty, athletic, outgoing and well rounded girls. My sister in law gave up her career to stay home and homeschool all of them. Yes, they struggle at times financially as a result, and it definitely was a SACRIFICE, but they believe that they have made the best choice for their children. I am very proud of all four of my nieces. Having said that...there are bad parents out there. But, last I checked, this is a free country, and if they want to homeschool their children, they have that right. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

The difference is that you have to go through training and earn a degree to be a teacher. You don't have to do anything to homeschool. It takes people who are willing to study, research, and set aside the time and a dedicated space for homeschool. Also, children need to be provided opportunities for socialization with peers. There are some excellent people who have done this and their children have excelled. There are others who think it will be easy to homeschool. The child essentially watches TV and plays during the day. They eventually bring the child back to the public school and the school has to give the child extra support to try to help them catch up. Your tax dollars at work! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground