Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Wood Flooring vs Wood-Look Tile

who's talking here?

Melanie 4
QueenCassie 2
ukchristine 1
Rubicon 1
ExLady In Blue 1
tinman 1
TexasOma 2
BoxerMama 1
Work in Progress 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
TinktheSprite 3
Kgsriverdude 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

I was sold on wood flooring which we will be doing within a year or so. But today I saw the wood-look tile. I was impressed!! Now I am torn again. Anyone have wood-look tile floor?? 

Kgsriverdude --- 14 years ago -

I am a ceramic tile contractor and I have laid several of the newer porcelain plank tiles. They look great,have no upkeep like the wood floors, don't have to worry about water leak issues. Interceramic Tile and Hutcherson Tile have some great looking tiles in this style that come in 24",36", and 39" lengths. They are now making them more random in texture and shading so they don't look so cookie cutter 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

What is the cost comparison? Say on a 15 X 15 room? 

Kgsriverdude --- 14 years ago -

The material runs anywhere from $3.50-$7.00 per square foot. 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

Kgsriverdude....

What do you do about grout lines?

Is it installed like tongue and groove flooring except over a mortar bed? 

QueenCassie --- 14 years ago -

I so want the wood-look tile! Much more durable than wood flooring, easier to upkeep. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I LOVE the look of wood. But some of the tiles they have now are really good looking. And wood is no where as durable, scratches, dings, fades and other things.

I'm surprised the tiles are that expensive, up to 7.00 a sq. foot? Hmmm.

I think if one plans on staying in their home long term and making it their own, good to do the tile. BUT for resale, or short term, the tiles wouldn't be as desireable. JMHO. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -



The material runs anywhere from $3.50-$7.00 per square foot.



Tinman asked:
What do you do about grout lines?

Is it installed like tongue and groove flooring except over a mortar bed?



OK - calculating out the material costs at the $7.00/sf it doesn't look too bad. Does that material cost include the mastic and grout?

What is the installation cost. Again, I'm basing on a 15 X 15 room. I'm trying to figure a very rough estimate to see if I even want to go that direction & my actual room is way bigger than that....but this is something I have been mulling over for a while now. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

The material runs anywhere from $3.50-$7.00 per square foot.

The only thing about that is you can do wood laminates which are also highly durable, for less than that.

And we put in some beautiful real wood in the formal dining room for not much more than 7.00. It's real wood, a floating floor, easy as heck to install. But again real wood. If you put it in yourself, you can save a ton. 

Melanie --- 14 years ago -

0undefined

Wood or tile? 

Melanie --- 14 years ago -

0undefined

Tile or wood? 

Melanie --- 14 years ago -

0undefined 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

Thanks, I forgot all about Hutcherson. I will need to start investigating this better. I like the varied lengths idea. If I was impressed with the 2 tile styles at Lowe's I can't imagine what I will be like when I see other choices. Wow.

Here's a shot I took from Lowe's. I thought the grout lines were sort of wide and the wrong color but that is easily remedied. With pets, tile is the way to go. One puke or pee accident that you delay in finding on real wood and you could have trouble on your hands! This might be very doable for us!

0 

ukchristine --- 14 years ago -

I have heard from a couple of realtors that buyers are turned off by the "fake"....even though for practical purposes it's more sensible...especially if you have kids or animals. ARe there any realtors or people on here looking to buy who could comment........ (especially a high end home where one expect certain materials.) 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

I am no moving. I am going to die in this house! So I don't care about resale. We care more about our own comfort and what works for us in our own home at this point. Besides, when you buy a resale home nothing like this is permanent. Most everything is changeable in a home right down to taking down walls. 

Melanie --- 14 years ago -

All of my pics were tile. Pretty cool I think. 

BoxerMama --- 14 years ago -

I found some wood look tile at Competition Flooring on N Shepherd. Don't know the price but reviews were very good. I think that is what we need with 3 dogs running thru the house. 

Rubicon --- 14 years ago -

The tile does look nice, but I prefer the feel of wood. 

Kgsriverdude --- 14 years ago -

An average installation cost would run in the $2.50/ sf. range. The floor would need to be checked out for evenness given the long lengths of the planks. This is no different from wood floors needing to also be very even. Also figure on another .50-.75 cents per square foot for grout and Thinset. I recumbent a better quality latex modified Thinset since most of these newer plank tiles are porcelain and require a setting material to handle the imperviousness of this material.

The tiles are not tongue and groove, they are a regular straight edge like all other tiles. In the installations that I have done, I have used a 1/8" grout joint being careful to select a grout that blends in well. You could use a 1/16" joint but you would have to switch over to a non sanded grout.

The price ranges reflect the same price ranges that one would find with wood floors. Also. No type of wood floor regardless of quality will withstand pet accidents, leaking toilets or sinks, or floods like tile. 

QueenCassie --- 14 years ago -

Mel, I love the 2nd & 3rd pics! 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

It's beautiful! And it would totally work for my house, but the cost is pretty high. ..

We actually have the unique situation of having to get rid of ALL the carpet, even in the bedrooms. It's going to cost us! And we haven't figured out what to replace it with.

We have two rough and tumble boys that would destroy hardwood, so we need something tough, but not too "cold" or "hard" for bedrooms. It's difficult to figure out, ideas? 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

WIP, have you considered doing tile in the general areas of your home and carpet in the bedrooms? We installed some beautiful tile on our main floor, except for the dining room, and have never regretted it. I am actually contemplating (wood) tile in the TV room and halls in the upstairs, too, although I have been warned about "resale value", but like 8675309, I am going to die in this house so my heirs can figure out what to do about tile on the 2nd floor. :-) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground