Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should arrest records be held against job applicants?

who's talking here?

planemom 1
lizandmike 1
Joybell 2
Donkey Hodie 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Red Heifer 2
captureit11 1
SleightOfHand 4
Perfection 3
AngieKaye 2
LBHTX 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
sweetscreaminmonkey 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 3
BCSKW 6
Storm Jane 4
Bornanraisedkw 1
Circlesmile 1
crazypinetrees 1
freebyrdII 1
Lady Long Legs 1
4leafclover 1
SmoochieAndTheBean 1
Odin 15
Lets Be Fair 1
Loveday 1
kwgraniteguy 4
daslang 1
KingOfSomewhereHot 1
tredanis 5
kespethdude 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should arrest records be held against job applicants?

With TSA being caught not screening their employees it raises a good question. With many unemployed and many of those with some infractions in their past should we still expect employers to screen employees and applicants?

Yes - all records as an adult Vote
 
 79.5% (58)
Yes - but only within 5 years from application Vote
 
 4.1% (3)
No - what happened in the past doesn't predict the future Vote
 
 16.4% (12)
Perfection --- 14 years ago -

With TSA being caught not screening their employees it raises a good question.


With many unemployed and many of those with some infractions in their past should we still expect employers to screen employees and applicants? 

lizandmike --- 14 years ago -

It would depend on the job. People who have made bad choices still need to be able to work. Trash service, lawn crew, and such; it shouldn't be a big deal. Positions working with the public, especially children, should definitely be checked. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I think it depends on what the crime is. Factory jobs where the don't come in contact with the public would be better options in my opinion. Lawn service and trash service still puts them around children and if their crime is theft or breaking and entering allows them to essentially scope out new targets. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

that's a good question.. I immediately thought it should depend on the crime, but you wouldn't know the crime until you checked- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

It's obviously going to depend on the interviewer-how he perceives the crime- 

Bornanraisedkw --- 14 years ago -

Not arrests only charges with convictions 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

are charges w/o convictions shown to the public? 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

are charges w/o convictions shown to the public?


Yes they are all arrest are public with or without convictions. I feel if someone has an arrest history it should be questioned. I know I wouldn't want a convicted felon working for me unless they had shown rehabilitation. If someone lies on an application and later found they are a felon I surely would have them arrested for lieing on an application. 

KingOfSomewhereHot --- 14 years ago -

Absolutely an employer should be able to request such records from an applicant. It doesn't mean they won't hire them... But an employer can make that decision based on the record.

Yes, decisions you make (even when you are young and dumb) can have consequences that follow you for the rest of your life. Kids and young adults need to be made aware of this! 

Circlesmile --- 14 years ago -

I knew a guy that would brag about what he did. I no longer talk to him. Rehab for some lifestyle for others. 

SmoochieAndTheBean --- 14 years ago -

I can't answer the poll b/c my choice isn't up there. It depends on the job!

A teacher should be an extremely morally upstanding citizen with no record or very minimal. I expect a thorough background check on teachers, doctors, police, tax preparers...basically any public service job.

The chick that is ringing me up at Kroger...I don't care. Unless she was convicted in a string of murders, go on a ring me up. 

daslang --- 14 years ago -

I voted yes but it is very black and white with the poll...Even though someone may have a record they should still be able to redeem themselves as well but if it were a government job I think not on the hiring. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

Your poll only mentions arrest, not convictions. If they've only been arrested and not convicted it shouldn't be held against them. 

Donkey Hodie --- 14 years ago -

I'm wondering which Democrat has just been found to have had a minor arrest when s/he was 19 or so. That's the reason Chunky puts up these kind of polls. 

Loveday --- 14 years ago -

This discussion reminds me of the article posted about the Splendora kids found living in a bus. The mother is a convicted felon (embezzlement) with a bachelor's degree in accounting - who is now studying for a master's in education. Accounting and education don't seem like reasonable goals for her future... 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

I think if that woman of the Splendora kids didn't hide what she did and the company she is hiring with knows about it then they can take extra security measures to protect the company. I honestly think all needs to be based on character. If they person doesn't lie about their "convictions" then there shouldn't be anything held against them. I thought it was against the law if that person disclosed their past honestly. Felons have to make a living too. Dont want them to become worse felons by commiting crimes just to get groceries on the table. 

kwgraniteguy --- 14 years ago -

Your poll only mentions arrest, not convictions. If they've only been arrested and not convicted it shouldn't be held against them.

This can be quit tramatic for someone who has never even had a speeding ticket. Some years ago DW, before she was DW, was arresested on a class A drug feloney. The detective was negligent in his investigation. Long story short they wanted "jane Marie Doe" and they picked up "Jane Mary Doe",same age same basic description. They got "marie" prior to trial.
She almost lost a job for not disclosing her arrest, but being young not realizing the difference between arrested and convicted. It took letters from the arresting officer and DA to save her job,and I am sure once disclosing without an opportunity to explain has cost more than 1 interview.
It will also land you on the Inmate lock up web page with your mug shot, at least until you can afford to pay to have it exspunged. And good luck finding a lawyer that will go up against the city for damages. I am still out $400.00 dollars in bail.
So even as a small biz owner I am somewhat torn on this issue. 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

Allowing non convictions / false arrests to harm a person in employment or in any other way goes against the very idea of "innocent until proven guilty". 

kwgraniteguy --- 14 years ago -

"innocent until proven guilty".

Agreed, but employers are not bound by that, only the legal system. And of course the media, lol. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

I'm wondering which Democrat has just been found to have had a minor arrest when s/he was 19 or so. That's the reason Chunky puts up these kind of polls.

LOL. This failed. 

crazypinetrees --- 14 years ago -

It would depend on the person and the situation and how much time they had served. I would REALLY have to know all of the details first and it would depend on the type of job they are applying for. 

kwgraniteguy --- 14 years ago -

I would rather see on an application "have you been arrested and convicted" vs "have you been arrested". I am certain there would be bias against the applicant that marked yes opposed to the one that marked no. 

captureit11 --- 14 years ago -

i worked at the airport...the background check is actually a VERY LONG process. up to 2-3 weeks just for everything to come back. 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

I would rather see on an application "have you been arrested and convicted" vs "have you been arrested". I am certain there would be bias against the applicant that marked yes opposed to the one that marked no.


Yes, there is a bias. Many employers won't even bother to find out if the arrest was false or not.

I've never been arrested, but I can guarantee you that if I had been and even had been completely cleared... I would not have had the jobs I've had.

It is discriminatory and perhaps even in an EEOC type fashion. Certain demographic groups are more likely to get profiled or arrested on "suspicion". 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

Your poll only mentions arrest, not convictions. If they've only been arrested and not convicted it shouldn't be held against them.


Agreed, although even that is shades of grey. Why they were not convicted can vary from a completely wrong arrest right through an acquittal based on a technicality. I guess the point is that a prospective employer should not treat an arrest as being equal to actual guilt, but we know how that works out. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

I realize this is off topic, but I am more troubled by drug testing and other information that a prospective employer can require as a condition of a job when it is not particularly relevant to the job. 

4leafclover --- 14 years ago -

There is no doubt that in an area like Houston where there is a vast industrial/ petroleum based job market. Your clients will require your employees to have a clean background inorder to gain access and perform work. Even managers who visit these facilities for meetings must pass background clearence to get in. 

SleightOfHand --- 14 years ago -

You should try mandatory polygraphs to maintain your job if your integrity is in question. 

Storm Jane --- 14 years ago -

I am very upset with the people on here advocating this type of punishment after the fact is unjust and very typical of people who have never been in the system or had a loved one in the system.
If you did your time and paid for your crime then who are we to say that you must continue to be punished when you get out. With more and more people being incarcerated or arrested for petty crimes we soon will have no one left to work but the illegals you hate so much.
As long as your crime is not one that involves children then it is non of my business, felons have families and want to say out of jail but close minded hypocrites that stop them from finding viable work only exacerbate the problem by denying them the chance to change thus forcing them to go back to a life of crime to take care of their families. Oh and all you people that think they should work on the lawn crews disgust me, Micheal Vick got his job back and so did Martha and you have no problem with her or him so keep your judgment to a minimum remember Jesus didn't hang out with socialites or the rich. 

tredanis --- 14 years ago -

Micheal Vick got his job back

Poor example.

Vick is allowed to play football but he cannot own a dog. 

SleightOfHand --- 14 years ago -

"If you did your time and paid for your crime then who are we to say that you must continue to be punished when you get out. With more and more people being incarcerated or arrested for petty crimes we soon will have no one left to work but the illegals you hate so much. "
_____________
Employers have the right to hire whom ever they want. They are responsible to their other employees, customers, stock holders etc that their safety and investment is secured from potential criminals. Don't do the crime if you cannot deal with the consequences. 

tredanis --- 14 years ago -

felons have families and want to say out of jail but close minded hypocrites that stop them from finding viable work only exacerbate the problem by denying them the chance to change thus forcing them to go back to a life of crime to take care of their families.

Oh, that's rich! Criminals are the victims and honest, hard-working citizens are the oppressors!!

GMAFB 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

Don't do the crime if you cannot deal with the consequences.

But what about those that are incorrectly arrested?

Should they have to suffer a life time of bias even though they have done nothing wrong?

I know that it is legally allowed for employers to do that, I just don't think it's just and moral. We have laws against all sorts of unjust discrimination, interesting that this is allowed as well.

And the key issue for me is this: People who can't get jobs because of a bias may become desperate...leading to crime. Same for those that should have been arrested. Hard to break the cycle if they can't find legal employment.

I figure there should be a time limit on how long a record remains out there. If they stay out of trouble for 3 years, let them be considered redeemed. (not for all crimes though... the obvious should never go off record) 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

As an employer you are responsible for your employees so yeah they have that right.

A grocery clerk has access to credit card numbers, checking account information and so on, is that a good job for someone convicted of burglary, identity theft, or another crime involving lying?

A person who has a past of beating someone up, would an employer feel comfortable with them in the public or even with other employees who might aggrevate them? Doesn't the employer have an obligation to protect other employees from those situations?

Someone drives drunk, as an employer is that a decision you think was good? If the employee shows poor decision making skills isn't that something that you should know? 

Storm Jane --- 14 years ago -

Did you know that taking a pen from work is a class c misdemeanor if the value of the property is under $1500,
A person who commits harassment, for example, commits a Class B misdemeanor.

Sex crimes constituting misdemeanors under Texas law include bigamy, homosexual conduct, incest, indecent exposure, and public lewdness i.e peeing in public all of which you must register with the state as a sex offender
If you post date a check in the state of Texas its fraud,
If you defend yourself by fighting back and are arrested its called mutual combat
if you take a proscribed drug and drive with your child in the care its a felony.
Don't tell me your completely innocent because chances are your not and just because you dont think its wrong doesn't mean its not illegal.The only difference between a criminal and you is, you haven't been caught yet. People that live in glass housed shouldn't throw stones and just because Mr.Vick can't own a dog doesn't mean he can't make a living.
Public records are not court records I have a girl in my outreach who was arrested for stabbing her husband, he was beating her with a brick when she got away and ran to the kitchen she scratched him with the knife, he called the cops after she had locked her and her kids in a bathroom when they showed up they didnt care what he had done she didnt call so she when to jail with a broken jaw and 7 fractured ribs and she got the Assault with a Deadly Weapon arrest , Employers don't get that side of the story and they dont ask but you know what that's fine she can get welfare just not a job. And trust me she would rather have a job. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Yes 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

There but for the grace of God, go I 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

I have to admit that I'm actually curious how John Lynch stands on this one.

What say you? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

so she when to jail with a broken jaw and 7 fractured ribs and she got the Assault with a Deadly Weapon arrest


Something is fishy here. If that really happened then those who arrested her need to go to jail themselves. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

felons have families and want to say out of jail


56% of violent felons are repeat offenders and 61% of all felons are repeat offenders. Why because they can't find jobs? Really? Did they have a job when they committed their first offense? What waws their job history to begin with? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground