Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Job Interview Question..

who's talking here?

ToidBoid 1
Jen 1
planemom 1
wayward1 1
Perfection 2
quiettype 4
CraftyKWChic 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
Dr Aborto 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 4
esquala 1
IbarraFam222 1
TinktheSprite 1
4leafclover 2
SmoochieAndTheBean 1
PeopleRPeople 4
LillyDivine 1
Joker 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

So, I have been looking for a part time job. I have gotten tons of response from my resume. My question in: I have gone on 3 interviews where the person has asked if I have children and what ages they are. The second I tell that person, the interview has shifted and I know I won't get the job. I didn't think they were allowed to ask about children? 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

I think they can ask you that. I'm thinking they are trying to vibe the type of person you are. I usually get the, "tell me about yourself".

So what was the answer that scared them away? 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

I always answer I have one child that is in school. From that point on, it goes downhill. 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

Boy howdy, would they be scared off if I mentioned all her therapies and medical problems. That's why I want part time and weekends. I just think its funny, I mention child and it's like I have the plague :) 

quiettype --- 14 years ago -

I'm in HR for over 20 years. They absolutly cannot ask that question. You might politely respond with a question asking them why they are asking? State perhaps the better question is to state the time requirements of the position and is there any reason why you would not be able to meet that committment 100% of the time? This is the appropriate way to ask the question from a legal standpoint. Heck, I have just as many employees miss work due to their own circumstances, elderly parents, etc. and probably more so than from kid issues. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

They absolutly cannot ask that question.

Why not? 

quiettype --- 14 years ago -

Discriminatory based on family status. EEOC would have a field day with those folks.

The appropriate way to ask about anything that might be considered protected status under Title VII and other associated federal and state laws is to simply state the job requirements (a job description is best) and ask if there is any reason the person will be unable to perform any of the job requirements. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Lie. Tell them you hate children because they are sooooo needy. lmao.

That's sneaky tho, and causes an unlevel playing field between candidates when they start considering people for reasons other than why they are or are not qualified to perform on the job....BOO. 

Jen --- 14 years ago -

Nope they can not ask you that! And if they are not a family kid friendly place, I wouldn't work there! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Nope they can not ask you that!


Yeah but they have their ways...like they can't ask someone's age either but they ask you what year you graduated from college...lol. 

IbarraFam222 --- 14 years ago -

I would think of some smart response to that question like is that part of the job requirement? I didn't add that job and my accomplishments to my resume. Ask if they have children. Once they start asking personal questions get personal right back. They'll either get more comfortable with you or change the subject. I've been able to turn having children to a plus instead of a negative at interviews. Good luck!! 

4leafclover --- 14 years ago -

I interview people all the time and I ask that question. It has nothing to do with discrimination but how responsible are you. If saying you have a child deters you from getting the job you are applying for, that says a lot about the interviewer. Not sure that is the best place for you to be anyway. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

All they can ask is if there is any reason you can't work the scheduled hours.

They can't ask about kids 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -


Just checked, and apparently it is not legal. Well, that piece of info doesn't get sent out to interviewers because they do it ALL THE TIME.



I have had 5 job interviews. Four of them asked me if I had children. One of the four didn't seem to mind-the other three I could tell wouldn't hire me b/c of it. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

You might politely respond with a question asking them why they are asking? State perhaps the better question is to state the time requirements of the position and is there any reason why you would not be able to meet that committment 100% of the time? This is the appropriate way to ask the question from a legal standpoint.



Well that response is sure to seal the job offer for you. lol


We also ask people to tell us more about themselves. Yes we do it to find out if they are married, have kids, what their hobbies are and how responsible they are. We do not ask so that we can exclude people, we choose people based on experience, personality, and most importantly length of time they stayed with former employers.

We don't hire job hoppers. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Even if you offer the information about kids an interviewer cannot follow up on the information. 

4leafclover --- 14 years ago -

I have had 5 job interviews. Four of them asked me if I had children. One of the four didn't seem to mind-the other three I could tell wouldn't hire me b/c of it.

The illegal thing is if they use that as a reason to not hire you. You could very well ask the interviewer "what significance does having children have on this position". If they cannot answer you then simply move on the the next question. 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

It is a hard time getting a job out there right now. Which job candidate would take a potential employer to court over that and risk not getting a job. People need the job. Potential employers are running amuck doing whatever they want because they can get away with it. Good luck, HandmaidsTale,. 

ToidBoid --- 14 years ago -

Yeah but they have their ways...like they can't ask someone's age either but they ask you what year you graduated from college. . .

I always say "my senior year". . . 

LillyDivine --- 14 years ago -

My boss always tells me to ask the age when they turn in their app bc its only illegal for him to ask, not me... 

CraftyKWChic --- 14 years ago -

I'm in HR and we train all of our interviewers on the dos and don'ts.

It is absolutely illegal to ask anything that doesn't effect the interviewees ability to do the job (i.e. children, marital status, age, gender, race, national origin, ect.). It doesn't matter who you are (if you're going to be a supervisor or a peer). If you are asking question to make a hiring decision or report back to someone who is then you cannot ask questions that can be discriminatory.

Just because you "think" it's alright doesn't make it legal. TheHandmaidsTale - you can file a claim against these companies with the EEOC. 

Joker --- 14 years ago -

(i.e. children, marital status, age, gender, race, national origin, ect.)

Welcome the politically correct fantasy world. All those reasons affect a persons ability to work.

Children: If a Dad it's fine but if a Mom then she is always taking off to handle kids, not to mention the months of leave required for a birth -it sets the female behind a male up to a year...

Marital status: If male it's not an issue but females carry a lot of baggage. Single females use the office to find the next Mr Right. How many of you dated or married someone in your office? Were you the office tramp?

Age: Young people work harder than old people. Old people are set in their ways while the young are eager to learn. Old people have a lot of medical problems and raise insurance premiums for the entire company, not to mention the meds they require to function at work...

Gender: Women are weaker and have their special needs. Do you really want a chick that barely meets the adjusted minimum strength requirements to be a fireman, policeman, soldier? Females don't have nuts so stop trying to act like men. Mother Nature will reveal your strength...

Race: This is a hard one depending on the job. Outdoor work you want a certain people, sports have a preferred race, electronics need tiny iSlave types, 3 guesses who the banks want counting money...

National Origin: Could have a lot of special holiday requests, stink up the office microwaving ethnic meals, talk with a funny accent, problems with the INS...

This is why you can't pick the right person for a job - you must compromise and settle on the lesser candidate or face a lawsuit. American business has been on a decline since adopting PC rules, rules that are against the laws of nature. Businesses like Apple that work with the laws of nature (islave factories) are succeeding. No wonder all businesses are moving overseas - they are not running from Americans, they are running from PC lawyers... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

[i](i.e. children, marital status, age, gender, race, national origin, ect.)

Welcome the politically correct fantasy world. All those reasons affect a persons ability to work.

Children: If a Dad it's fine but if a Mom then she is always taking off to handle kids, not to mention the months of leave required for a birth -it sets the female behind a male up to a year...

Marital status: If male it's not an issue but females carry a lot of baggage. Single females use the office to find the next Mr Right. How many of you dated or married someone in your office? Were you the office tramp?

Age: Young people work harder than old people. Old people are set in their ways while the young are eager to learn. Old people have a lot of medical problems and raise insurance premiums for the entire company, not to mention the meds they require to function at work...

Gender: Women are weaker and have their special needs. Do you really want a chick that barely meets the adjusted minimum strength requirements to be a fireman, policeman, soldier? Females don't have nuts so stop trying to act like men. Mother Nature will reveal your strength...

Race: This is a hard one depending on the job. Outdoor work you want a certain people, sports have a preferred race, electronics need tiny iSlave types, 3 guesses who the banks want counting money...

National Origin: Could have a lot of special holiday requests, stink up the office microwaving ethnic meals, talk with a funny accent, problems with the INS...

This is why you can't pick the right person for a job - you must compromise and settle on the lesser candidate or face a lawsuit. American business has been on a decline since adopting PC rules, rules that are against the laws of nature. Businesses like Apple that work with the laws of nature (islave factories) are succeeding. No wonder all businesses are moving overseas - they are not running from Americans, they are running from PC lawyers...




Thanks for my morning entertainment. Just lmao.

Good to know you got it all figured out!! 

esquala --- 14 years ago -

stink up the office microwaving ethnic meals

Hahahahahhaa!! 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

Marital status: If male it's not an issue but females carry a lot of baggage. Single females use the office to find the next Mr Right. How many of you dated or married someone in your office? Were you the office tramp? yuck never dated someone i work with when i was single .. they were either married or yucky..


the age one soooo not true.. the young ones at my job or jobs in the past come in talking about where they partied or what new reality show they saw etc.. the older ones come in early, stay late and work their tushes off.. :) 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

the age one soooo not true.. the young ones at my job or jobs in the past come in talking about where they partied or what new reality show they saw etc.. the older ones come in early, stay late and work their tushes off.. :)


Yep, I agree but they are ususally at their peak earning years and thus cost more...and there's lots who aren't as experienced but will work for much less, money rules. As usual. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

why not just say that it's the reason you are looking for part-time work? I would tell them that I'm very responsible and dependable-(I know it's illegal, but that won't get you hired) 

SmoochieAndTheBean --- 14 years ago -

They "can't" ask, but really they can do whatever they want.

Answer them confidently, and just say that you have a ____ year old but have arrangements already in place for anytime she is ill or whatever.

Otherwise, if 4 out of 5 places are asking and you aren't answering, you could be looking for a looooong time. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

exactly, Smooch... 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

My boss always tells me to ask the age when they turn in their app bc its only illegal for him to ask, not me... 


We don't ask age we get a copy of their drivers license. 

quiettype --- 14 years ago -

Yeah but they have their ways...like they can't ask someone's age either but they ask you what year you graduated from college...lol.

That question will not give away your age because there are many, many people who do not got straight to college and/or graduate in 4/5 years.

My boss always tells me to ask the age when they turn in their app bc its only illegal for him to ask, not me...


We don't ask age we get a copy of their drivers license.


Hate to say it but your boss is a fool, and so are you because now you both can get in trouble. The DL should not be asked for until AFTER an offer has been extended and then only if you need it for legit position requirement.

There are a LOT of small business out there who don't have a clue (or don't care) what they are doing is not appropriate...until they have to pay out thousands (or tens or hundreds of) when that one person pursues actions against them. And the amount and type of information the EEOC asks for when there has been a charge made against your company...oy, there is no way a small business tracks it or even has a clue to do so. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

I know several people who have recently started new jobs. Their biggest issue is the employer either lied or avoided answering questions pertinent to the job during their interviews. Two people would not have taken the job if the employer had been truthful. Both asked specific questions regarding the hours they would be expected to work and their work duties. Don't employers know they gain nothing by doing this. One is looking for a new job and the other is very frustrated because the employer doesn't understand the mess that was left for her to clean up. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Hate to say it but your boss is a fool, and so are you because now you both can get in trouble. The DL should not be asked for until AFTER an offer has been extended and then only if you need it for legit position requirement.


All people who work for us are required to be able to drive a company vehicle if needed. If they cannot be insured they cannot be hired. No fools here. 

quiettype --- 14 years ago -

planemom you are so right about that. I too have found myself in those shoes. Unfortunately even when you do get the right answers up front something can change at the company in an instant and then you are stuck trying to adapt just to keep your job. There are no guarantees and the business climate is just very fluid. That is part of the reason small business ask those questions they shouldn't because they are trying to find people who are flexible enough to deal with the ever changing business needs. Heck my previous employer wan't all that small and I had 5 different bosses in just over 3 years before I got layed off. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground