Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Boehner has a tough job.

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 3
ExLady In Blue 1
RiteWingKing 5
Warren Peace 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
james osterberg 1
Clovis 1
justforfun1 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

In House of Representatives, an Arithmetic Problem
By NATE SILVER

Markets were down sharply on Friday after Speaker John A. Boehner’s tax plan failed to reach a vote in the House on Thursday evening. No Democrats were prepared to support the bill, and Mr. Boehner told reporters that his plan also lacked sufficient votes among Republicans.

A variety of smart political observers have suggested that the markets are misreading the situation. Instead, they say, the failure of Mr. Boehner’s bill makes a deal to avert the so-called fiscal cliff more likely because it has now become clear that any deal will need to rely upon the support of at least some Democrats, which could ease passage through the Democratic-controlled Senate.

Perhaps this is correct. Mr. Boehner has said that the White House and Senator Harry Reid, the majority leader, will now have to take the lead in negotiations.The chance that a fiscal deal will be secured on terms that Democrats find favorable may have increased.

But the chance that there will not be a deal at all may also have increased, or at least not one before protracted negotiations that could harm the economy. The difficulty is in finding any winning coalition of votes in the House of Representatives.

In the diagram below, I’ve charted the major coalitions in the incoming 113th Congress, which will convene on Jan. 3. The new House of Representatives will have 233 Republicans and 200 Democrats. Two seats remain vacant, which means that 217 of 433 votes will be required to pass a bill.

Of the 233 Republicans, 51 will be members of the Tea Party Caucus, give or take a few depending on which first-term members of Congress join the coalition. The other 182 are what I will call Establishment Republicans.

As Keith T. Poole of the Voteview blog points out, the Tea Party Caucus wasn’t solely responsible for Mr. Boehner’s failure to pass his bill. A significant number of Tea Party Caucus members were thought to support his plan, while some of the opposition came from representatives who do not formally associate themselves with the Tea Party.

Nonetheless, it seems clear that Mr. Boehner lacks the confidence of roughly three dozen Republican members of the House, and possibly more. Erick Erickson, of the blog RedState, identified 34 Republicans who he said opposed Mr. Boehner’s bill and another 12 whom he identified as being on the fence.

Say that Mr. Boehner cannot count on the support of 34 of his Republicans when it comes to passing major fiscal policy legislation. That means he would need to identify 18 Democrats who would vote along with the Republicans who remained with him.

Here’s the problem: it might be hard to round up those 18 Democrats.

The reason is that most of the Democrats who remain in the House are quite liberal.

In fact, the once-powerful Blue Dog Caucus, a coalition of moderate Democrats, will have only 14 members in the new Congress. The centrist Democrats who once filled its ranks fared very poorly in the 2010 midterm elections, while others retired or were harmed by redistricting or by primary battles. Although Republicans have moved more to the right than Democrats have moved to the left in recent years, according to measures like those developed by Mr. Poole, the attrition in the Democratic Party has nevertheless contributed to moving the two parties even further apart.

What that means is that if Mr. Boehner has a significant number of Republican defections, as he did on Thursday night, he will need to win the support of at least some liberal Democrats. And a bill that wins the support of some liberal Democrats will be an even harder sell to Mr. Boehner’s Republicans. For each vote that he picks up from the left, he could risk losing another from his right flank.

Perhaps cooler heads will prevail in these negotiations. But a majority of the incoming House – 237 of 433 members – will be either Tea Party Republicans or liberal Democrats, leaving only 196 members who are either Establishment Republicans or Blue Dog Democrats and who might form a functional center-right coalition.

Moreover, the House is likely to engage in repeated battles over fiscal policy during the next two years: not just the over the fiscal cliff, but also over the debt ceiling, annual budgeting plans and whatever stabilization measures might be proposed in the event of another economic downturn.

If Mr. Boehner is having as much trouble whipping votes as he did on Thursday night, reducing the pool from which he might be able to draw together a compromise, this arithmetic problem could turn out to be intractable at some point. 

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

will be either Tea Party Republicans or liberal Democrats, leaving only 196 members who are either Establishment Republicans or Blue Dog Democrats and who might form a functional center-right coalition.


Stop gerrymandering...We need more moderates. 

james osterberg --- 13 years ago -

The chickens have come home to roost for the weeper of the house.

He built the coop with the chuckle heads so now he can shovel it. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

Markets were down sharply on Friday after Speaker John A. Boehner’s tax plan failed to reach a vote in the House on Thursday evening. No Democrats were prepared to support the bill, and Mr. Boehner told reporters that his plan also lacked sufficient votes among Republicans.

Boehner's tax plan? Didn't Boehner simply put forth Nancy Pelosi's bill from May and called it Plan B?

If so, why aren't we saying that it was Pelosi's bill which failed to get any Democratic support? This article suggests that there were Republicans supporting it. Why not report on whether or not the total votes would have resulted in the bill's passage if only the Democrats had supported Pelosi's bill?

This makes a good case that both sides want the fiscal cliff to happen so they can blame the other side. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

LOL......... When you bring in facts like that, Warren............. it always seems to silence those voices from the left. 

justforfun1 --- 13 years ago -

Why is it Boehner’s tax plan is a problem? It is Pelosi's plan that wouldn't pass so it looks as though Obama and the dems are in deep trouble. 

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

This makes a good case that both sides want the fiscal cliff to happen so they can blame the other side.

They are attempting to shield themselves from blame. Pin the vlame on the other party. You see this all the time when the Senate/House pass bills that have no chance of making it. Really wasting taxpayer money.

The Republicans are losing the war of public perception. They may give the Dems a monopoly of power in less than two years. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

They may give the Dems a monopoly of power in less than two years.

This would only make things worse. Look at the mess we're in from the last time they had a monopoly. 

justforfun1 --- 13 years ago -

They may give the Dems a monopoly of power in less than two years.

This would only make things worse. Look at the mess we're in from the last time they had a monopoly.




Heaven forbid that people don't come to their senses by then. If not who cares what happens to this country if the dems keep control, this country is done for? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Full control of the govt for 2 years.

What did it get us?

A takeover of healthcare the majority of people didn't want.

Debt that continues to rise.

No budget out of the Senate for well over 1000 days?

But somehow, all of this is the fault of the Republicans. 

justforfun1 --- 13 years ago -

Obama continues to maintain that he be given unilateral authority to raise the debt ceiling. 

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

No budget out of the Senate for well over 1000 days?

Do you think that the average American considers that?

Or that their paycheck was reduced because the Republicans were defending tax cuts for the rich.

Fair or not perception is going to hurt the Republican brand. We haven't even discussed the NRA. 

Clovis --- 13 years ago -

Here's something that Boehner can cry about:

"House Speaker John Boehner has now unseated his Democratic predecessor Nancy Pelosi as the least-liked major congressional leader, a title Pelosi has held for several years.

A new Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey finds that 51% of Likely U.S. Voters now view Boehner unfavorably, while 50% feel that way about Pelosi. Just 31% have a favorable opinion of the Ohio congressman, compared to 37% who look favorably on the San Francisco Democrat."

http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/mood_of_america/congressional_favorability_ratings

LOL! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

both sides have plenty of blame-last year, the Tea party refused to take any deal that Obama put out- Obama offered concessions that infuriated his base-now, Boehner is offering to take his concessions, but he won't take it-both sides need to get kicked out- I'm sick of their games at our expense- 

ExLady In Blue --- 13 years ago -

And, Clovis, while I am impressed that you made a point without a picture or political cartoon, do you think the MEDIA spin on things has anything to do with those numbers? 

justforfun1 --- 13 years ago -

Reid on the Fiscal Cliff: “We’re Not Going to Do Anything”

Friday, December 21, 2012
2012-12-20t173812z_1_cbre8bj1czr00_rtroptp_3_usa-fiscal-senate

Raise your hand if you’re the least bit surprised. Harry Reid’s Senate has perfected the art of doing nothing; from not passing budgets to not taking up President Obama’s various proposals. They also do quite a bit of not debating or voting on legislation — due to a record number of Republican filibusters, triggered by Reid’s historic abuse of shutting down the amendment process. So with America on the precipice of devastating across-the-board tax hikes, Harry Reid is promising to do precisely nothing unless President Obama gets everything he wants. Two quotes from today’s press conference:

(1) “We are not taking up anything they are working on over [in the House].”

(2) “We are not going to do anything.”

Senate Republicans have culled a list of choice quotes from Reid over the last three weeks, demanding that the House act to protect the middle class while “compromising” on rates for the “richest of the rich” 

justforfun1 --- 13 years ago -

Senate Republicans have culled a list of choice quotes from Reid over the last three weeks, demanding that the House act to protect the middle class while “compromising” on rates for the “richest of the rich”



SEN. HARRY REID (D-NV): "We are willing to compromise, but we also will not consign the middle class to higher tax bills while millionaires and billionaires avoid all the pain." (Sen. Reid, Congressional Record, S.7364, 12/4/12)

REID: "…waiting for them to do something that will help the middle class. … All the president is asking - all we're asking is take care of the middle class and do something about the richest of the rich." (Sen. Reid, Press Conference, 12/13/12)

REID: "Generally during a negotiation, each side brings an offer or demand to the table. That is how it has always worked. Then the two sides sit down and find middle ground. It is not always easy and it is rarely fun. True compromise means no one gets everything they want, but unless both sides come to the negotiating table with an offer, you can't even begin the negotiation. In fact, unless both sides come to the table with an offer, there is no negotiation."


Reid conveniently disregards the fact that the House has already voted to avert the roster of economic ruin that is the fiscal cliff, including the maintenance of all current tax rates for the middle class. Nevertheless, with Democrats refusing to budget, House Republicans are gearing up to vote on Speaker John Boehner's "Plan B," which would permanently extend more than 99 percent of all current tax rates, but would allow Democrats to raise taxes on families on businesses making more than $1 million per year. The GOP opposes this outcome, but they're willing to put it on the table in the interests of avoiding the cliff. Reid prattles about "millionaires and billionaires" and "the richest of the rich" in the quotes above, all of which are plucked from earlier this month. "Plan B" offers the majority leader's party the chance to finally stick it to the very people he describes. As we explored yesterday, the $1 million compromise threshold has been touted by the likes of Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer in the not-so-distant past. It can't be dismissed as "radical." Indeed, the proposal is rather controversial on the Right: Americans for Tax Reform has given it a clean bill of health, Freedomworks signaled tentative support for the idea before reversing their position, and both the Club for Growth and Heritage Action remain staunchly opposed. As Katie reported earlier, Boehner and Cantor are expressing confidence that they have the votes to pass "Plan B" later this evening. We'll see if they receive any Democratic tallies, as Pelosi is expected to whip her caucus hard against voting her own previous proposal (which she now boasts was a "ploy" all along).

If Boehner does muster enough support to pass the plan, Republicans' next move will be telling. If everyone sticks around and lingers in town, it will signal that Boehner is hoping to use the vote as an eleventh-hour leverage power play to influence behind-the-scenes negotiations with Obama. I continue to worry that any resulting "bargain" would be no such thing for conservatives, and I'm dubious about the wisdom of whipping GOP members for an on-the-record vote to allow tax hikes simply as a bargaining chip. On the other hand, if the GOP caucus passes "Plan B," then heads home for the holidays, they're playing some real hard ball. It would suggest that the Boehner/Obama talks are stuck in the mud, and that Republicans are finished with negotiating against themselves. I would strongly prefer the latter scenario, the success of which would depend on Republican messaging. Gulp. They would have to make it crystal clear that they have offered plan after plan, incorporating ideas that Obama himself has backed in the recent past, but to no avail. They would have to flood the zone with the (accurate) talking point that Republicans have compromised twice in Plan B. First, by permitting Democrats to hike tax rates on millionaires, which Republicans have fought for economic reasons. Second, by keeping $1.2 trillion in sequestration cuts intact, including major cuts to the US military. Conservatives detest these defense cuts, which were originally suggested by the White House during last summer's debt debate. The House has voted to offset those reductions, but the Senate has refused to act, and Obama threatened a veto. So all of those bipartisan cuts remain in place. Republicans should say that they are not happy with the compromise by any stretch of the imagination, but Democrats left them no choice. They acted to prevent 99 percent of taxpayers from seeing a significant tax hike on January 1. They acted to avoid the cliff. They acted in a way that gave up some key Republican demands. "Your move, Democrats -- we're finished." Would Obama have the cajones to follow through on his latest veto threat? He may very well be bluffing. Will Republicans call him on it? 

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

He forgot to mention Senate Bill 3412. It is sitting in the House. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground