Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

no HOF for Biggio......

who's talking here?

txwareagle 3
wayward1 1
hummer 1
Perfection 3
tinman 3
Gigix4 1
itstxdaddy 5
freebyrdII 1
Mayberry 1
Weekend chore guy 3
BuiltinTX70 6
lmillie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

discuss. 

freebyrdII --- 13 years ago -

No HOF for anyone.....,., 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

not worthy of 1st ballot but will get in eventually.

unlike bagwell, bonds, clemens, et al. 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

Until Don Mattingly makes it in, I'll refuse to acknowledge that organization's existence. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Mattingly?

You probably think Phil Simms belongs in Canton also.

Donny Baseball has a very uphill battle because he played a power hitting position during a time when the Yankees sucked.

Mattingly barely had over 1000 rbi's and didn't even hit 250 home runs.

He did have over 2000 hits, but that's hardly worthy of admission on it's own.

He only had five years with over 100 rbi's.

Again....first basemen are never going to be judged on fielding accomplishments. This is a power hitting position just like 3rd base or right field.

The last contemporary of Mattingly's to get in was Eddie Murray.

He had 3255 hits, over 500 homeruns and over 1900 rbi's and it took him forever to get in. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

Never understood first ballot.....what is Biggio going to do next year that he hasn't already accomplished in his playing career. To me, you're either good enough to be a HOF'er, or not.

Baseball writers association leaves much to be desired. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Bagwell had 8 years with over 100 rbi's and 2 more with over 95.

Bagwell also had 8 seasons with over 30 home runs and two seasons where he went 30/30.

He is getting caught up in the steroids thing and it's really hard not to think of him in that light. I mean, he is a shadow of his former self today and did consort for an awful lot of years with Cammy and some of the other juicers.

I can actually understand the hesitation with Baggy....but Biggio....gimme a break. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

there are some bbwa writers that simply refuse to vote for guys on the 1st ballot...while i do find it odd...biggio was no henderson, ripken, ruth, cobb, wagner, etc...so maybe there is some method to the madness. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

Until Don Mattingly makes it in, I'll refuse to acknowledge that organization's existence.

wow. i'd love to hear this argument...other than being yakeefan of course...lol. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

I hear ya Daddy, but as I said, you're either a HOF or you're not.

My issue is, time passes, and guys get in that really shouldn't......you lose perspective.

To me, when you think HOF'er, there shouldn't be a pause where you need to think about it. 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

I heard an interview with Biggio last night and Biggio said it wouldn't bother him if he didn't make it into the HoF and that his life would go on.
While that's true, it has to sting a little for him. I, for one, believe he does belong in the HoF. He was a well rounded, hard working baseball player that deserves that honor. 

lmillie --- 13 years ago -

Being an Astros fan (do or die) since I was a little kid, I grew up watching Craig Biggio play and play his heart out the entire time he was on the field. Three years ago, my youngest son was diagnosed with cancer and became involved with the Sunshine Kids in which we had the priveledge of meeting and getting to know Mr. Biggio. He was a class act on the field and is one off the field as well. It is a shame that because of the stunts of some of the other players regarding using steroids he does not receive an award he very much deserves. I hope the voters wise up next year. 

Mayberry --- 13 years ago -

Robbed! Simply robbed! 

hummer --- 13 years ago -

I think the steroid thing has got to be affecting votes. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

So using the argument that you are either a HOFer or not. It would appear Biggio is not.

The Hall should be for those who clearly were standouts not just reward longevity and above average play. 

txwareagle --- 13 years ago -

above average...

Since 1900 he is one of only three players with 3,000 hits, 200 homers and at least 200 steals. The other 2 were first ballot HOF

he is one of only seven to have 3,000 hits and 400 steals;

And he played 20 years in the majors, all of them with Houston, making him one of seven players to play a whole career of at least 2,800 games all in one city. The other 6 were first ballot HOF

And his work withing our community has been significant. The Hall needs more players like Biggio in it. 

txwareagle --- 13 years ago -

and much of his baseball career was played in the very offensive un-friendly Astrodome, on some awful teams. 

Weekend chore guy --- 13 years ago -

Yes, Craig is obviously a great guy and his community work significant. The HOF is supposed to be for the best players of all time, period. If you even break it down by generation, Craig was a good player, not great. I am and was a huge fan of Craig's but we should not let our admiration of him inflate how good he was. Mind you, I've always used Craig as a role model to my sons in how the game should be played and how you conduct yourself. Modern day Hall of Fame players are guys like George Brett, Nolan Ryan, Greg Maddux, Ken Griffey Jr, Barry Larkin, the guys who were the absolute best at their position and/or great hitters for a long time. It needs to be for the best, not for longevity stats, or the steroid users like Bonds and Sosa or marginally great players. I respect Carig Biggio as much as any fan or Houstonian. He just did not consistently maintain greatness. 

Weekend chore guy --- 13 years ago -

Here is what keeps Craig out:

Modern day non-steroid player comparison:

Ken Grffey Jr.- .284 battng average but with 630 home runs.

Barry Larkin-best defensively plus .295 batting average.

Chipper Jones- great switch hitter power and average, career .301 hitter.

Biggio- career .281 batting average, too many down years hitting 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

All he hit was singles. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

All he hit was singles.

laughable. he is 5th ALL TIME in doubles.

biggio will get in, he just does not deserve first ballot status. his name does not belong with those guys. 

Weekend chore guy --- 13 years ago -

itstx,

there you go, you said it "his name does not belong with those guys" , hate that for Craig but it's true 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Ryne Sandberg, the player Biggio is most closely compared to, had to wait three years in order to get in.

If it wasn't for Sandberg, Biggio would have won a dozen gold gloves for 2nd base.

Here is a side by side analysis of their offensive stats.

Biggio .281 ba, 668 doubles, 291 hr, 1175 rbi, 414 sb.

Sandberg .285 ba, 403 doubles, 282 hr, 1061 rbi, 344 sb.

The other stats that biggio has that makes him a better offensive player than Sanberg are skewed due to his longevity. So, in an attempt to keep that argument at bay, I've left them off.

I agree with TXdaddy...he'll get in, but he'll have to wait his turn just like Alomar and Sandberg had to.

BTW...just to shed some light on how arbitrary the BBWA voters are, the widely held explanation of why Alomar wasn't a first ballot entry was because of the spitting incident on the umpire, John Hirschbeck.

Really? I find that incident to be utterly classless and stupid, but I would have still voted him into the hall, first ballot, every day and twice on Sunday. 

txwareagle --- 13 years ago -

Had biggio played 2nd Base, at Wrigley he would have creamed Sandberg's numbers. Many of his Astrodome doubles would have been caught in the wind and ended up on the street.

Thats whats stupid about baseball HOF. Its all about the magical numbers, and how to compare, but the dimensions of each ball park are different. This dramatically effects the numbers, which we use to compare "Great" agains "Almost Great" 

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

The man has 3,000 hits....

Perfection, your analysis is way off base. Just singles? Above average play? Check the stats. Also, longevity is part of baseball (and any sport really).

A333 - why would you compare Biggio to Griffy and Chipper....two totally different types of players?

He will be in the HOF. 3K hits guarantees that. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

Tinman - great post about Biggio and Sandberg...... 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

So he just as to wait his time. No biggie.

You were the one who said he is either a HOFer or not, and per the voters, he is NOT.

Now as the voters change due to new ones added and old ones passing, that may change, but in this vote, he failed to impress. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

Had biggio played 2nd Base, at Wrigley he would have creamed Sandberg's numbers.

silly. no need to demean sandburg in order to make your case for biggio.

Many of his Astrodome doubles would have been caught in the wind and ended up on the street.

by the same token many of his doubles in the spacious astrodome would have been knocked down by the wind and caught at wrigley. the wind didn't always blow out ya know. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

Now as the voters change due to new ones added and old ones passing, that may change, but in this vote, he failed to impress.

You don't get it. The same guys who didn't vote for him this year, will in subsequent years.

Perhaps my arguement makes more sense to you now?? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground