Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

OK.......

who's talking here?

ukchristine 2
Donkey Hodie 12
Perfection 5
voice of reason 1
tinman 12
Gigix4 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
sheddy 2
MissPris 1
Prolix Raconteur 2
a4480796uu 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

tinman --- 13 years ago -

So...I get an email from the HR department in Dallas. They tell me that they will be in town for two days to go over our insurance options and to explain the effect the ACA will have on our coverages and what the options are.

Our open enrollment period begins Nov. 1 and runs through the middle of December.

I'm figuring that if HR has to make a special road trip from Dallas to Houston just so they can 'splain things...this isn't going to go very well.


So....here's the dealio. I want to know from those that care to opine, predict or just plain old guess, just how they think my benefits are going to be affected. Right now, my coverage is very basic. 2k deductible per person and 4k for the family. No real coverage until the deductible is met. Well care checkups, mammograms, and the usual well care stuff is free and covered. I pay 250 per month to cover Mrs. Tinman, Daughter of Timan (in college) and good old Tinman himself.

Blue Cross Blue Shield is the provider.

So...what's the new coverage gonna be and will it be better, worst, the same?

How about costs?

I will be very forthcoming when the news is given and if do better than I am now, I will admit it. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Are you in a group plan? 

Prolix Raconteur --- 13 years ago -

VOR can post a cartoon to ease your pain 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Perfection --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments

Are you in a group plan?


Yes....my company has over 2000 employees. About 1/3 are union and have coverage through their CBA.


edit to add....I mean..the company I work for...not my company...lol.



ericb --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments

VOR can post a cartoon to ease your pain



Now I don't care who you are...that's funny. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

$250 per month for Blue Cross Blue Shield is a pretty good deal, even with your high deductible. Even if it goes up, you're still getting a good deal. If it doubles, you're probably about average. Count your blessings. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Donkey Hodie --- 38 sec ago - quote - hide comments

$250 per month for Blue Cross Blue Shield is a pretty good deal, even with your high deductible. Even if it goes up, you're still getting a good deal. If it doubles, you're probably about average. Count your blessings.



Yeah...that's what I'm afraid of. I like the coverage for the price. I'm afraid there is going to be a material change in benefits and prices and none of it is going to be to my advantage.

Good to see you on here man!! 

Prolix Raconteur --- 13 years ago -

watch for a huge increase in deductible...that's what happened to us and we're on BX/BC...other than that most aspects remained relatively static...so yeah, pay more, get less... 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

ericb --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments

watch for a huge increase in deductible...that's what happened to us and we're on BX/BC...other than that most aspects remained relatively static...so yeah, pay more, get less...



Yeah....I've decided that no matter how much higher my deductible is, I will not drop it. I refuse to get on the ACA database. That's for life.

The ACA needs all of the healthy, young people it can get on there so those premiums will help off set the ones that have the pre existing conditions. For the most part, I like the idea of insurance for those with pre existing conditions, but I don't like it being forced on everyone just so it can be paid for like that. The young don't realize just how institutionalized this is going to be in five years. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

I like the idea of insurance for those with pre existing conditions, but I don't like it being forced on everyone just so it can be paid for like that.

But the only way insurance coverage for pre-existing conditions will work is if everyone gets insurance. Otherwise nobody would pay for it unttil they need it, and then they would be able to buy it since they couldn't be denied as a pre-existing condition.

If car insurance worked that way, nobody would buy until they get in a wreck. Then they'd call up and buy it on the phone before they called the police if they got in an accident, and the insurance company would have to take them as a customer.

You can't have it both ways. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

But the only way insurance coverage for pre-existing conditions will work is if everyone gets insurance. Otherwise nobody would pay for it unttil they need it, and then they would be able to buy it since they couldn't be denied as a pre-existing condition.

And if it were actually a viable business model, the insurance companies would have already done it.

Instead, the government is now in charge and that always gives me a warm and fuzzy. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

That is my complaint about Obamacare. People who have paid for years in case they got sick, are suddenly suckers. My daughter has Blue Cross. She was paying, I think, $122 a month with at $3,500 deductible. It did go up $20 a couple of months ago. It sound like you are getting a good deal one the family plan. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

And if it were actually a viable business model, the insurance companies would have already done it.

I think we have a fundamental difference of opinion on the purpose of governments and how they interact with markets. If left to their own devices, insurance companies could deny coverage for all kinds of reasons. Governments, through laws and things like ACA, have started to make insurance companies play a little more fairly with customers. I think enforcing fairness on the market is exactly what governments should do. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

That is my complaint about Obamacare. People who have paid for years in case they got sick, are suddenly suckers.

I'm sorry that you consider responsible people to be suckers. It should be the other way around - we should consider people who never bought insurance to be freeloaders.

In fact, when it all settles down and straightens out, responsible people will end up paying less, in the long run, (if you count taxes paying for the uninsured,) as there will be a larger pool of people paying for insurance now. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I think we have a fundamental difference of opinion on the purpose of governments and how they interact with markets.

That ain't no b.s....lol.

But it's cool. I prefer that the govt stay out as much as possible. There is a very fine line between government intervention/control and socialism and the slope is pretty darn slick.

There's no doubt that the present system is broken. I, for one, do not believe that the ACA is the answer, but I guess I'll have to wait to see if I'm right or not. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

So far someone I know who has the BEST coverage there is, only a
250.00 deductible and full coverage after that, has been informed their out of network coverage now will require a 3000.00 deductible instead of the 250.00 that is required in network. This is Humana.

It could be a change in deductibles, co-pays, or out of pocket limits is my guess. 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

VOR can post a cartoon to ease your pain


watcha lookin for.
i aim to please! 

ukchristine --- 13 years ago -

If left to their own devices, insurance companies could deny coverage for all kinds of reasons. Governments, through laws and things like ACA, have started to make insurance companies play a little more fairly with customers. I think enforcing fairness on the market is exactly what governments should do.

In Utopia YES.....but did the Govt and people really think the insurance companies were going to suck up the extra cost and not respond by charging their customers more?

In fact, when it all settles down and straightens out, responsible people will end up paying less, in the long run, (if you count taxes paying for the uninsured,) as there will be a larger pool of people paying for insurance now.
In fact, when it all settles down and straightens out, responsible people will end up paying less, in the long run, (if you count taxes paying for the uninsured,) as there will be a larger pool of people paying for insurance now.

In fact, when it all settles down and straightens out, responsible people will end up paying less, in the long run, (if you count taxes paying for the uninsured,) as there will be a larger pool of people paying for insurance now.

So when that happens (less people at emergency room etc as they now have insurance) TAXES will go DOWN???? 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

My former employer outsourced the administration of retiree medical coverage to Extend Health. They assist in coordinating benefits with medicare. A lot of major companies have done the same thing.

When I retired, the former employer paid a portion of my premiums directly to the insurance company then we paid the rest. We had no choice of what insurance company and we had $350=/- deductible. In my case, I was only paying $101 a month for both medical and drugs.

Today I had my enrollment conference with Extend Health to get all signed up for 2014. They offered 7 different companies for medigap or medicare advantage and probably 14 different prescription plans. Of course there were various plan options depending on what I wanted for deductibles and co-pays.

I was able to actually pick my preferred insurance company and select a plan that company offered.

Both plans will cost me $229 a month, and my former employer has set up an account, with $1.1k, for us to assist in paying the premiums or copays. The plan I selected has "0" deductible, "0" copay. For drugs, I'll have "0" deductible with co-pays somewhere around $3 for a 30 day script and around $6-7 copay for a 90 day script.

Again, this is a supplemental to medicare. I'm happy with the plan. I guess growing old does have a few good days! 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

but did the Govt and people really think the insurance companies were going to suck up the extra cost and not respond by charging their customers more?

That's why they are requiring everyone get insurance. And yes, if everyone has insurance, costs will eventually go down, since right now healthy people aren't paying into the system and sick people without insurance are getting very expensive emergency room care that taxpayers are paying for. If everyone has insurance, overall, over time, aggregate costs will go down, as everyone will be responsible for paying their share. I don't understand why you Ayn Randian types are not for this plan. It's anti-freeloader. Oh, I forgot, Rand herself was a hypocrite freeloader even when she was espousing the opposite. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Actually that is not considered an hdhp (high deductible health plan).

The pricing you quote I assume since it is so low is after the employer pays the majority of it.

I would expect there to be added some hdhps to choose from and perhaps the option to have an hsa (healthcare spending account) to cover the deductible. As an option that is typically a good way to go.

BCBS is offering a number of their plans that are on the exchange to employers, your employer may have added some of those options to your menu.

Good luck! 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

This is Humana.

Humana is the only carrier offering the platinum plan in the market. 

ukchristine --- 13 years ago -

How many people have the luxury of former employers paying the bulk of the premiums? Partly the reason for the need for an overhaul of the health care system was because people without jobs had no reasonably priced access to health because they did not have access to group insurance. Cobra is a joke. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

How many people have the luxury of former employers paying the bulk of the premiums? Partly the reason for the need for an overhaul of the health care system was because people without jobs had no reasonably priced access to health because they did not have access to group insurance. Cobra is a joke.

You guys are ridiculous. You rail on the ACA for everything it does, and then in the next breath turn around and insist we do everything that the ACA does. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Donkey Hodie, when employers got involved in the health insurance business we all suffered.

By employers, and the largest employer is the government, creating these "group plans" it priced the individuals out of insurance.

If employers, including the government, were out of the insurance business then everyone would be on the same level playing field on pricing and the insurance companies could offer fair market pricing to everyone. Right now they have to offer discounts to these employers (group rates) and then can't offer that same pricing to individuals.

The ACA does nothing to address this and in fact encourages it by the use of taxpayer paid subsidies and even more subsidies to federal workers so they can get not the silver plan (what they recommend for everyone else) but the gold plan which is far more expensive. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

If employers, including the government, were out of the insurance business then everyone would be on the same level playing field on pricing and the insurance companies could offer fair market pricing to everyone.


Nope. If the government got out of the insurance business, then insurance companies would only offer affordable insurance to the safe bets, and we'd have even more people without insurance. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Nope. If the government got out of the insurance business, then insurance companies would only offer affordable insurance to the safe bets, and we'd have even more people without insurance.

In my opinion, that's not entirely factual.

Look at auto insurance. I know the only thing in common here is that they are both insurance, but, there is no government interference and the masses can afford it. Free market forces the companies who want to be in that business to price competitively. Also, some companies, such as Allstate and Farmers actually operate the auto insurance arm of their businesses as a loss leader in order to sell life, annuities and other low risk, high profit vehicles. Once you have an auto policy, it's much easier for an agent to sell the more profitable lines.

Sort of like selling a steak cheap and marking up potatoes, cheese, and sour cream.

If the government regulated the hospitals instead of the insurance, they would find that the cost of health would drop and with that, the cost of insurance. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

One of the reasons we need government regulation and "interference" with healthcare and insurance instead of leaving it completely up to "the market" is that healthcare is an inelastic demand. Someone is not going to decide to wait a year to have that heart attack because they can't afford it this year. Someone is not going to all of the sudden decide to have that appendectomy right now because the price fell 10%. Unlike many other markets, the price of healthcare has very little effect on the demand for it. If you're having a heart attack, if able, you're going to the hospital ASAP, regardless of whether your co-pay is $20 or $100, or if your deductible is $100 or $1,000. The demand for lifesaving healthcare services is almost completely independent of it's price. The insurance companies know this, and that's why they get away with charging what they do. That is exactly why we need reform and government involvement. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I agree with part of what you type. The part of your post about the inelastic nature of health care demand is very true.

So is the inelastic nature of automobile crashes.

But, because of the cost of insurance, the cost of accidents is a lot less. This lessening of cost is driven by the insurance companies not agreeing to overpay for services of the body shops.

If the government regulated the cost of health care, and not the cost of insurance, the cost of insurance would drop due to the drop in the cost of health. That drop in health insurance cost would then make it more affordable.

Once that happens, then you can make it mandatory like auto insurance is now. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

The government has no business in the insurance business. Their computer enrollment fiasco should prove that in spades! 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Sheddy

Clearly..the govt needs to regulate some part of the health care industry.

The gov't regulates the stock market, oil industry, utilities, and drugs.

Without government intervention in those industries, I shudder to think what kind of world we would live in. Don't believe me? Think Goldman Sachs and 2008.

Nuff said.

But...to regulate insurance and not the hospitals is like treating a tumor with ben gay. Go after the stuff that costs alot and the vehicles in place to help pay for those high costs will become cheaper to own.

It's classic supply and demand. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

If your current plan doesn't offer the minimum requirements set forth by Obamacare, then you will be bumped to a plan that meets legal requirements. With a company that large, it's odd that they offer plans that wouldn't already meet those minimums but I would guess if they are sending someone to explain things, you are currently under-insured and will have to move to a plan that offers the legal minimum.

We just got a letter saying that all of the plans that our company offers already exceed Obamacare minimum requirements and open enrollment will proceed as usual. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

I posted this 17 days ago, but it seems few people watched it.

 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Uh...that's exactly what I am saying.

Couldn't have said it any better. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

One of the problems, and if you watched to the end of the video he said it as well, is that "the problem" is that that are many problems, and they all contribute to "the problem".

One of the problems that the video didn't address, and one I see on KU every day, is that people want a magic pill, or one quick and easy solution to everything. People are reluctant to work on one problem, or one aspect of the problem, if it won't solve everything. They also think that if one part of the solution doesn't address and fix everything, then it shouldn't be done at all. Complex and large problems require complex and large solutions. There is not one single thing we can do that will fix everything. We need to do many different things to fix many different problems. But too many people don't want to bother with multifaceted complex solutions because they want something simple and easy that will fix everything at once, and they want every single detail to mesh 100% with their fringe political beliefs. That's not going to happen, ever, for anyone or any problem. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

One of the problems that the video didn't address, and one I see on KU every day, is that people want a magic pill, or one quick and easy solution to everything.


You have hit the nail on the head, but you've missed the point. The point, in this case, is that the ACA does attempt to solve the entire problem with one solution and you are right...that won't work. It won't work because, in my opinion, the problem has been misidentified.

It also won't work because too many people are being forced to do something they do not want to do. You cannot force people to do things they don't want and expect there to be complete accord.

Our society isn't built for that. So, instead of forcing the people, the govt should force the corporations. That is how it is done in literally every other facet of our economy except for health care.

One of the biggest sectors in our GDP is health care and instead of regulating the companies, the government decides to give them free reign and regulate the citizens instead.

Now...I'm not totally against that, but I am totally against it being totally against the citizenry and giving the hospitals a free pass.

Your little video said it best. We pay 10, 15, 20 times as much for products and services in the health care industry than the rest of the world. Cut those costs and the insurance companies will cut their costs.

Easy. 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

Tinman, I think you have nailed it. If you have ever really looked at a detailed statement of charges for hospital care, it is just ridiculous! At one stay, I was given Tylenol for pain, just plain ol' Tylenol ... at $12 a pop! And those "cute" little slippers that you can buy at the Dollar Store - $18 a pair. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

You have hit the nail on the head, but you've missed the point. The point, in this case, is that the ACA does attempt to solve the entire problem with one solution and you are right.

I don't think the ACA is trying to solve the entire problem, it would be single payer and a whole lot more if it were.

Yes, the ACA is not going to fix everything, but it will fix several large parts of the problem. But because it doesn't fix everything, the simpletons criticize it, which is ridiculous for many reasons. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

Cut those costs and the insurance companies will cut their costs.

I'm not sure this would naturally follow without some kind of collective bargaining or some kind of regulatory oversight. 

a4480796uu --- 13 years ago -

People can't even sign up for ObamaCare. Even a simpleton can see that this is a disaster. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -


I'm not sure this would naturally follow without some kind of collective bargaining or some kind of regulatory oversight.


I agree and that's been the thrust of my entire take. Every other major component of our economy has federal regulation, but not the overall health care system. Banking, drugs, money, you name it and the fed has rules that govern everything from pricing to oversight.

But not health care.

So..without preaching, I'm not sure what the iron clad, sure fire solution is. All I know, in my opinion, is what the solution isn't. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground