Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The hardest decision you might have to make...would you?

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
Perfection 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
JohnLynch 1
Dr Aborto 1
winjer 1
In AbsentiaW 1
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
sheddy 1
Mayberry 2
Nurse Ratched 1
Emperor of Kingwood 3
housewife1 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Tim Bowers loved the outdoors. Hunting gave him the quiet time during which he could reflect on a busy life that included a new wife, a successful business and a baby on the way.

The Indiana man was enjoying that time while hunting for deer Saturday when he fell 16 feet from a tree and suffered a severe spinal injury that paralyzed him from the shoulders down. Doctors thought he might never breathe on his own again.

Confronted with that prognosis, Bowers' family made an unusual request of doctors at Fort Wayne's Lutheran Hospital: Could Bowers be brought out of sedation and told of his condition so he could decide for himself whether he wanted to live or die?

The doctors said yes, and Bowers made his choice.

"We just asked him, 'Do you want this?' And he shook his head emphatically no," his sister, Jenny Shultz, said of her brother, who was also often found hunting, camping or helping his father on his northeastern Indiana farm.

Courts have long upheld the right of patients to refuse life support. The American Medical Association says competent adults can craft directives stating if or when they want such systems withdrawn or withheld should injuries or illness leave them unable to make those decisions.

But it's rare after a devastating injury that a patient would get to make such a decision for himself. The heart-wrenching call to remove life support is more often left to surrogates who must speak for those patients. Even when a patient has outlined his wishes for end-of-life care, the decision can tear families apart.

Shultz, of Las Vegas, has seen it happen in her job. But her medical training also meant she understood the severity of her 32-year-old brother's injuries. His C3, C4 and C5 vertebrae were crushed. Though his brain was not injured, his body was irreparably broken. Surgery could fuse the vertebrae, but that would only allow Bowers to sit up. He would never walk or hold his baby. He might live the rest of his life in a rehabilitation hospital, relying on a machine to help him breathe. He'd never return to those outdoor activities that gave him such peace.

Shultz said her brother — the youngest of four siblings — wanted to talk but couldn't because the ventilator tube was still in place. She told him that if the tube was removed, they weren't sure how long he would live. But when she asked if he wanted the tube reinserted if he was struggling, he shook his head no.

Doctors asked Bowers the same questions and got the same responses. The tube came out Sunday.

The last five hours of Tim Bowers' life were spent with family and friends, about 75 of whom gathered in the hospital waiting room. They prayed and sang songs.

Through it all, Shultz said, her brother never wavered in his decision to die.

"I just remember him saying so many times that he loved us all and that he lived a great life," she said. "At one point he was saying, 'I'm ready. I'm ready.'"

Medical ethicists say it's rare for patients to decide on the spot to be removed from life support, especially so soon after an injury. But standard medical ethics practice is to grant more autonomy to patients, and courts have upheld their rights to decide on end-of-life care.

Patients often change their minds after they've had time to meet with spiritual advisers and family, said Art Caplan, director of the medical ethics program at New York University's Langone Medical Center in New York City.

Dr. Paul Helft, director of the Charles Warren Fairbanks Center for Medical Ethics in Indianapolis, said cases in which the patient makes the decision usually involve a debilitating illness such as Lou Gehrig's disease, which compromises the patient's body but leaves the mind intact.

Helft said patients have been legally and ethically permitted to make their own decisions on life support for several decades, due in part to court cases and the evolution of the practice of medicine, which places more emphasis on patients' rights.

"We give patients autonomy to make all kinds of decisions about themselves," he said. "We've recognized that it's important that patients have the right to self-determination."

Shultz said her family had an idea what her brother would want because he had previously talked with his wife, Abbey, whom he married Aug. 3, about never wanting to spend his life in a wheelchair.

She knows that not everyone would make the same call. But she's thankful her brother was able to make his own decision.

"No outcome was ever going to be the one that we really want, but I felt that he did it on his terms in the end," she said.

___ 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I don't know if he should have been asked so soon after his injury....but, allowing him to decide was the absolute right thing to do.

I feel so sorry for his new wife and the child that will never know him. :( 

Mayberry --- 13 years ago -

Advance Directive .... Case and point.... 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

I don't know if he should have made the decision so soon, but I know many who would never want to live that way. I often wonder what kind of life Charles Krauthammer would have had without his injuries. He might be practicing in some town and never have done the things he has accomplished. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I know that most of us look at that situation and say I wouldn't want to live that way, but that comes from a stand point of health and well being. That is a very different perspective when you look at a deficit situation from the point of wholeness.

I know a paraplegic and he does indeed want to live, even with all the pain and disability he lives with daily. He can see his wife and kid, eat and even drive. But his life is not like ours on obviously since we can move freely about.

It's different WHEN you are actually in that situation. The will to live is very compelling when you actually might die.

I think the man in the story above was totally overwhelmed at the early stage of his trauma. I can't imagine giving up seeing my family unless death was imminent anyway or I was in tremendous constant pain. How can you pass on seeing and being with your kids?

To each his own tho, nobody else should decide but emotions are known to move us in the wrong direction sometimes. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Thats right. The right to die the way you want and not to live in a way you dont is the most basic of human rights. 

Nurse Ratched --- 13 years ago -

I firmly believe that people who are terminally ill and suffering should be given the option of euthanasia. I also believe that people absolutely have the right to refuse medical treatment,so long as they are clear on the possible outcomes and are willing to take responsibility for those outcomes.

I think this situation was very sad, but it sounds like he was clear on his wishes. That being said, I agree with the posters who question the fact the decision was presented that soon after the accident. Like Sifi said, I think I would want to live to get a chance to see my children grow up. I'm sure at the time he felt like he would just be a burden on his wife and child, but I wonder if he would have felt differently in the future. 

Mayberry --- 13 years ago -

ADVANCE DIRECTIVE.....that's why you make those decisions BEFORE you need to....your wishes-without emotional stressors.... 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

i would do everything possible to live...life is a gift from God...my life would be in God's hands 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Yes to the advance directive and make sure more than one person knows about it. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

This was entirely the wrong thread for me to read right now. I'm crying into my dinner. What a horribly sad situation. I'm not sure what I would do.

Oy. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

No one is sure what they would do until faced with their own mortality. People say that they know, but they really have no clue. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Ok weird question time.

Would the insurance company now see this as suicide since he voluntarily gave up life?

If so how would that impact any accidental death payout? 

Dr Aborto --- 13 years ago -

His C3, C4 and C5 vertebrae were crushed.

UGH. As long as the vertebrae was not severed, there was still a chance of recovery. It happened to this Moto dude. 

housewife1 --- 13 years ago -

Would the insurance company now see this as suicide since he voluntarily gave up life?

I don't see this as suicide. He was breathing on his own. He didn't do anything to himself to cause his own death.

i would do everything possible to live...life is a gift from God...my life would be in God's hands

We don't know what he was going through, maybe his spirit was ready...you just don't know what God's will is...God allowed him to live for 5 hours before it was time to go. 

winjer --- 13 years ago -

I saw this story and in my opinion this was sad to hear. Even in a wheelchair you can live a good life. The decision to leave his child with never even given a chance to know him was very short sighted. Yes, an accident like this is life changing but it isn't life ending. This guy should have waited to give it a chance.

I know this from direct personal experience. In 1988 my 5th cervical vertebrae was crushed so bad that they had to take bone from my hips to reform a new one. My accident was "complete" meaning it will never heal, slivers of bone sliced my spinal column. This was due to a bicycle accident and I dove 15ft into concrete (I was a BMX vert stunt guy, think X-Games on the big ramps. I knew what I did was very dangerous and everyday was a risk.)

I never once felt like I wanted to just give up. I pushed my self hard to make the most of the situation. I have been in a wheelchair for 25yrs now and have lead a very fulfilling life. I have traveled all over this country and most recently traveled to Toronto, Montreal, and New York city. Going back to Montreal/New York this spring as well as a cruise to the Bahamas.

I have a very good career working in 3d software development, building software tools for film / tv / and games. If you have been to the movies, watched tv, or played any major game titles you have seen my work. After my accident I moved out of my parents house in less than a year and moved into Section 8 government housing 200 miles away to go to college and living off of SSDI, these programs gave me the assistance I needed to literally start my life over. During school I learned everything I could about computers and started my own company in 1994 doing internet development and computer graphics. I did so well that I choose running my business over finishing school. I have worked for the world's leading 3d animation tool company for the past 14 years. In addition to my work I have a very happy personal life and an amazing woman in my life, plus an awesome dog.

Anyway, long way to get to my point but I feel that this guy really didn't think this though and wasn't given the chance too. When you first get to the hospital after a spinal cord injury and hooked up to all the machines you are also pumped full of heavy drugs such as morphine. I know for the first two months in ICU I was in no state to make any serious cognitive decisions. Once getting past ICU and into rehab I did everything I could to get through and get on with my life. I was only 19 then my accident occurred.

I do fully support a persons right to choose their on fate in this situation and this was his right. I just wish he had not given up thinking that his life was over.

I'm not just "in a wheelchair", I suffered a very severe injury with no hope of ever recovering. My situation is that I only have partial use of my arms and no hand control, in fact I have typed this entire message one key at a time with a "Mouth Stick" yet I live a really good life and literally started with zero financial resources. Being in a wheelchair is not the end of the world.

I don't consider myself to be blessed, lucky, brave or anything else others say to try and make me feel better. I just never felt pity on myself and had no intention of just giving up. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

advanced directive means it's made before the situation even occurs-you don't know, then either, how you'd feel after an accident- this man was a quadraplegic- unable to breathe, probably, on his own- winjer, you're an unusual man,and kudos to you- I wouldn't want to be put on a breathing machine- my dh is a`paraplegic, and in pain all the time- if he'd known what his future held, he never would have allowed the doctors to keep him alive- 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground