Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Check out this "STAND YOUR GROUND story.

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 2
Polly Ester 2
Warren Peace 3
I_won't_tell 2
*LOL* 2
Work in Progress 1
fcabanski 1
FabFive 3
Emperor of Kingwood 7
Slider152 8
Butterbean 1
mutton 1
AMDG 5
Wicked 6
Eclipse 2
Alaska Again 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

http://wonkette.com/569554/murder-is-illegal-even-in-montana







This is bazaar. Sorry, can't figure out how to link. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Despite the overall snarky tone of the very biased article, its clearly murder in my view. But the overall tone reduces the seriousness of the article. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Bait and murder.

Stupidly written article. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Agreed. Who ever wrote that article has no credibility. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

CLearly the author of this tripe is clueless on stand your ground and the Castle Doctrin. 

FabFive --- 11 years ago -

Bizarre. The other Bazaar is a market. Just sayin'. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

LOL @ Fabfive. 

FabFive --- 11 years ago -

As a lover of words I just couldn't pass it up. Not trying to attack but it's my OCD or something LOL 

Alaska Again --- 11 years ago -

So if I leave my garage door open and sit my purse on the trunk of the car while I am taking my groceries in the house, then it is okay for someone to enter the garage and take my purse? 

Polly Ester --- 11 years ago -

0 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

Alaska... Yes, you are correct. And if you drive a nice "enticing" car and are being car-jacked... Don't try and defend yourself, that wouldn't be fair to the car-jacker if you did.
I'm sure there are some sex offenders out there "enticed" by someone's child too. Don't defend your child with force though... I mean you obviously tried to "entice" someone who had no right whatsoever to invade your personal space.
Also, I have power tools I'm my garage and surveillance cameras all over the place, does this mean I'm in a perpetual state of planning entrapment or pre-meditated anything if I leave my garage door open for any length of time? 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

You know... I don't condone killing of any kind, only self-defense. I'm no cop, boxer, ex-special forces, or martial-arts expert. So, if it comes to defense of myself or anyone I care about... I won't hold back and I won't give them a fair fight. I will decisively stop the attack with the full force of whatever I can bring to bear. And for the unfortunate person who should pick me for a victim, they'll find I have a lot of force to deal with... As does my wife.
That being said... I need to read this in a few other places before making my decision, but I will say that the one guy chose to go into an open garage (knowing he was trespassing) and looked around for something to steal. His choices led him into that situation. Several of my neighbors leave their garage doors open all the time. I've never once considered going in their garage for any reason.
Why? You may ask... Because I'm not a criminal.
And for those of you who say he was unarmed... Within 1/2 a second of being in my garage, you could be holding anything from a crow-bar, tire-iron, chainsaw, steel pipe, chain, 2x4, hatchet, machete (not to mention what you may already have under your shirt). These are all weapons and I can't afford to try and figure out what degree of criminal you are... Are you just a thief, or do you intend to do me harm? No time for that... If you're there, you intend to do me harm... Period!
And I don't even want to imagine what happens to my wife if I'm incapacitated. So once again, once you step foot in my garage uninvited, you should consider yourself 1/2 a heartbeat away from a seriously dangerous situation.
The easy way to prevent situations like this... It's very simple. Don't go into someone's home uninvited, and don't take something that doesn't belong to you.
There... Problem solved. 

*LOL* --- 11 years ago -

slider, from what I can tell, the home owner wasn't in fear for his life, he was setting up an entrapment to catch someone on his property and shoot them.

I don't think stand your ground was intended for people to set up situations and scenarios where they can just pop people off of this earth like they were duck hunting, including people that steal.

Yes, the teen was wrong for trespassing. We don't know what his intentions were. There was no indications that I can tell that he took anything. Of course, maybe he was going to. But that still doesn't explain the homeowner admittedly waiting and watching and then shooting. That isn't self defense or responsible gun ownership.

Obviously, it is a very poorly written article with an obvious bias. Both the home owner and the trespasser made very bad choices. I do not believe the teenager was a saint in this situation but that doesn't mean he should have been gunned down.

And yes, if someone stole my purse out my garage I would be mad as hell. Would I want to kill someone over it? No.

If I put a $100 on my front porch, would I be justified in shooting and killing the first person who was tempted enough to pick it up? I hope not. Because I believe there is a place for the castle doctrine in our laws. I just don't think this is an example of it. 

Alaska Again --- 11 years ago -

There is something to be learned from this. Don't go into someone's home or garage to steal something. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

It was definitely a snarky article and I should have posted something a bit more credible. Here is one.


http://www.usnews.com/news/us/articles/2014/12/17/montana-man-convicted-in-exchange-students-death 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

Bizarre. The other Bazaar is a market. Just sayin'.


LOL, thanks. My spelling sucks :) 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

Two points:

Point 1:
I'm still saying that if you're in my home or garage without being invited... I'll always automatically assume two things:
1. That you are armed.
2. That you are there to harm me or my family.
I will take self defense measures if I catch you in there.
Obviously children would be the exception here because they are generally not a threat, and because they may not know that they should not be there (someone obviously very young and not physically capable of inflicting serious damage... In other words, a 17 year old can easily inflict harm).

Point 2:
Criminal cases work on precedent and case-law.
There has now been a precedent set that at least partially states that this man used surveillance to catch someone in the act and that he enticed the person onto his property with one of his possessions.

What does this mean to you and I?
I sometimes leave my garage door open and you can sometimes see power-tools and other valuable items inside my garage.
If I happen to leave my garage door open, a thief walks in and grabs say... a saw, and I open the door and catch him in the act, at which point I defend myself (as stated in Point 1 above), and this is all caught on camera...
Now there is case-law that can possibly be used in an attempt to prosecute me.
Based on this precedent, the prosecutor will say that I left the garage door open on purpose, used a valuable tool to entice or lure someone to trespass and steal from me and then shot them for doing so.
Because of this precedent, the burden now lies on my shoulders to explain how this is not true and how I was the victim who was both trespassed against and stolen from. And that this was not pre-meditated.
The prosecutor will point back to this case and say here's how this was ruled on in the this prior case. That will have a negative impact on my defense. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

Slider152. The guy in question was telling neighbors that he was going to shoot some kids....and shot him three times in the torso and then blew his head off. If this same thing happened in Texas, the person shooting would walk free. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

If I understand correctly he had been robbed recently so set up to see if would happen again while he lay in wait? 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

1. If you live at the house... How exactly do you "lie in wait"? You can never be more than 100' away while you're home. He said a motion detector tipped him off that there was movement. How many people have an alarm??? I know I do, and guess what? It alerts me to movement which I will respond to at night while carrying a weapon.

2. How exactly do you "set a trap for someone" by enticing them using YOUR own possession within the perimeter of YOUR own house. The fact that the door was partially open makes no difference... You should always be able to reasonably expect all of your belongings to still be there the next morning even if you leave your garage door open and the light on. The fact that we can't do this speaks more to the accelerating moral-decay of our society than anything else.
If he's convicted based on this situation, then no one should ever be held accountable for rape or sexual assault to a child as long as they state that they were "enticed" by their victim.
Of course the sex offender should burn in hell for their actions, but my point is that enticement is not an excuse criminal behavior (or the consequences of that criminal act you're committing).


3. Who hasn't said after something like "I'm gonna kill these guys/kids if I find them" in the heat of the moment? I know I did right after i realized my house had been robbed. I would never had followed through with it though...
I can't tell you how many times my dad said he was going to kill me when I would get in trouble as a teenager...
If they convicted him based on this statement, then without a doubt... Michael Brown's dad needs to be convicted of inciting a riot and destruction of property after yelling out to burn Ferguson down. He doesn't get to say it was in the heat of the moment, if this guy can't also say that.

4. The three shots to the torso and one to the head... I can't find that anywhere on this story. I saw that a witness heard 4 shots and that there was a slight pause between shots 3 and 4.
And listen... Gunshot wounds and impacts aren't like in the movies. People don't fly backwards when hit with even a 12ga shot slug. Think Newton's 3rd law (for every action, there is an equal, and opposite reaction). If a shotgun shell produced enough power to blow someone 10ft backwards, I couldn't possibly hold onto that gun when it was fired. I actually know a guy who was shot with a 9mm while riding a bicycle and didn't even know it until he got home and noticed the hole in his leg. My point is that one shot almost never has enough power to stop an attack in-progress. Most gun-owners understand this. I would not fire only one shot to stop an attack. I can easily see myself shooting multiple shots to deal with a threat before pausing to reassess the situation. I can shoot pretty quick I bet I could land 4shots from my semi-auto shotgun within the same timeframe it would take a person to fall to the floor.
What I would NOT do though is fire several shots, then walk up to the incapacitated guy and shoot him again... So IF that's what he did, then I agree... That would be murder... And he should be charged.
But that's the only thing I would agree on based on reading this story on 4-5 different sites.
Points 1&2 above is what frightens me about this case. This could be said of any one of us on this board.
My neighbor's garage door was open until almost 10 tonight. I guess he was lying in wait and his ladder inside the garage (that I could see from inside my house) I guess was an enticement.
Maybe I should call the cops on my neighbor to make sure the criminals are protected from him. 

fcabanski --- 11 years ago -

"So if I leave my garage door open and sit my purse on the trunk of the car while I am taking my groceries in the house, then it is okay for someone to enter the garage and take my purse? "

That's not what happened in this case. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

I think the difference in this case, and a lawful application of the castle doctrine is intent. It is very difficult to write mal intent into or out of a law like this, but the legal process is pretty good at finding it in a case by case basis.

I can't find the general good in allowing relatively untrained civilians to willfully and knowingly plan and entice someone into a situation where their goal is to kill them. 

I_won't_tell --- 11 years ago -

Consequences happen. Plan accordingly.

He took the risk and was provided the consequences of his actions.

He made a bad decision.

He was not forced into the garage.

He committed suicide.


. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Won't tell - that is pretty black and white world you live in. I am not sure I know of anyone who has lived their life without making a bad choice or two. I am pretty sure none of us would like to judged by our worse moments. Very sure we shouldn't be killed for them.

Your logic, just taken a half of step further, is throw out the progressive punishment system, and just have the cops execute at every arrest, if they are pretty sure the perp is guilty. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

?If this same thing happened in Texas, the person shooting would walk free.?

BS. We all know you hate Texas and Texans. The case would've gone to the grandjury. Why do you live here if you hate us so much? 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

The justice system worked the way it was supposed to. It drew a distinction between specific intent to murder and the type of self defense castle doctrine intends to provide.

The guy in this case was clearly a murderer. He now has a conviction that properly labels him for life. 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

If this same thing happened in Texas, the person shooting would walk free.

I don't think you read the facts of this case very closely. Do you have this belief because you're aware of a similar case where the circumstances led to no conviction for the shooter? If so, link it. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -


The justice system worked the way it was supposed to. It drew a distinction between specific intent to murder and the type of self defense castle doctrine intends to provide.

The guy in this case was clearly a murderer. He now has a conviction that properly labels him for life.


Obviously warren I agree. What continues to amaze me about issued like this on this site is, my neighbors, folks walking around Kroger with me, at the light on Kingwood drive in front of me, and on the treadmill next to me at the club, could see this any other way.

It just always amazes me, how differently such otherwise homogeneous folks can view an event like this. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

It just always amazes me, how differently such otherwise homogeneous folks can view an event like this.?

True enough. With regard to the OP, their intent was another Texas bashing thread. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

BS. We all know you hate Texas and Texans. The case would've gone to the grandjury. Why do you live here if you hate us so much?


Bob, I don't hate Texas or Texans. You don't know
me. But, the truth is, and I have read many posts on here regarding issues like stand your ground, the whole Michael Brown situation and most mentality here steers towards, shoot now, ask questions later. And it is not just Texas. Montana is probably a more screwed up state than Texas when it comes to the whole gun mentality. I think this man thought he was going to get away with this because of the George Zimmerman case. This guy was of that same mentality. Both of these men should not have been gun owners. This is the reason there should be gun control.

The bottom line here, this man did wrong, and the right verdict was handed down. The people of Missoula MT saw past the stand your ground law and realized this guy was a nut case on a mission. His wife played a part in it as well and I hope she is put away also.


One last point. George Zimmerman went after Trayvon Martin, followed him....and admitted to others that he was following him...and still got off...and those of you that think he is innocent, should probably also think the guy in MT is innocent as well. There is really no difference in the way both of these crimes were committed. 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

If you think Zimmerman's effort to call 911 before violence took place demonstrates the same motive as the premeditated murder that this Montana guy did (who did not call police), you need some refresher training in Basic Reasoning 101.

No difference? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

But, the truth is, and I have read many posts on here regarding issues like stand your ground, the whole Michael Brown situation and most mentality here steers towards, shoot now, ask questions later.?

You really have no idea what stand your ground or castle doctrin laws really mean or are applied. Further, you seem to ignore evidence in both the Zimmerman and Brown cases that in both cases a jury saw. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

This is the reason there should be gun control.?

There are plenty of gun laws and rules in place. Neither the Brown or Zimmerman case or the one in that terrible article referenced any gun laws being broken. 

FabFive --- 11 years ago -

Except the constitution clearly says the right to bear arms. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Except the constitution clearly says the right to bear arms.?

Which the SCOTUS have reaffirmed on more than one instance that its an individual right. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

So. . .the case was handled exactly as it should have been, and you think it is a reason for MORE laws? On what premise??? 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

So were new facts released??? In the several articles I read about this, the facts were sparse and the assumptions were high.

The facts as I found them:
He did say he wanted to kill the kids who were continuously robbing him.
He was alerted via motion detector to an intruder in his house (garage).
He shot a trespasser in his house (garage) 4 times (as HEARD (not seen) by a witness).
Any other FACTS (not conjecture)?
Anyone see him execute the guy (as insinuated earlier by a KU poster?

The conjecture:
He baited the guy, not sure how they proved that.
He was lying in wait. Again not sure how they proved this was the case when the guy lives there.
He executed the guy. Remember, no eye-witnesses.

If he was convicted on the proof we're aware of... It's too vague (not beyond a shadow of a doubt) for a murder conviction.
That's what concerns me...

If they convicted based on a savvy attorney and conjecture... I'll never be okay with that.
Maybe there's more to this than we know.
But until I see more PROOF, I'm not convinced he's not just guilty of self-defense, stupid statements, and a bad attitude.
You guys can guess if you want, but need to see the facts.
I promise though that you'd want me on the jury if you found yourself on trial after shooting someone in your house or garage.
If you're truly guilty, then you should be convicted, if you have to add things to the facts in order to complete a timeline of events (conjecture), I start getting suspicious. 

Eclipse --- 11 years ago -

 

Eclipse --- 11 years ago -

Sorry, but the link got messed up ... let me try again.

The Castle Doctrine 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground