Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

'But' Nothing: Why the Right to Build a Mosque Trumps the "Heckler's Veto"

who's talking here?

Fiona 1
smartypants 4
traveller 2
ukchristine 7
wayward1 2
SoupIsGoodFood 1
justforfun 5
jmbtx78 1
JusticeForAll 9
oneyedman 1
Squareduck 1
evolved 1
Train1972 3
Ogre2 10
Bringit 2
~ MARY C ~ 5
Pops 3
Puss In Boots 2
funguy74 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

by Mark Green

Many of those opposed to the proposed Islamic cultural center (and mosque within) say they're all for religious freedom -- and then comes the "but." But not Islam. But not there. But not if it offends 9/11 families.

"But" is un-American.

The entire point of the First Amendment's protections of freedom of speech, assembly and religion is that these rights can't be restricted based on their substance. Of course there are "time, place and manner" restrictions on speech and prayer -- so people are not entitled to talk at 120 decibels in a residential neighborhood no matter their religion or views. Zoning laws can prohibit incompatible or dangerous activities, like a liquor store near a school. And obviously government can punish the bad conduct of anyone claiming to act in the name of a religion or group: For example, would-be Times Square bomber Faisal Shahzad or anyone conspiring with him.

What we cannot do, however, is condition speech or religion based on its content. That's the bedrock of the First Amendment.

Going further, courts have ruled against what's called the "heckler's veto." Whether a speaker is, say, for or against birthright citizenship, an audience member cannot shout him or her down; otherwise, speech would be contingent on the whim of any mob or critic. So, as painful as it was, our laws permitted Nazis to march though a community of Holocaust survivors near Skokie, Illinois in 1978.

Which brings us back to "but."

The opponents of the Park51 project claim this is not about rights -- it's about the difference between "right and wrong."

However, no group or momentary majority can be allowed to veto another's right, as Judge Vaughn Walker ruled in the protracted battle over same-sex marriage in California. If the proposed Islamic center is effectively shouted down because it's unpopular or the murderous acts of a few are attributed to an entire religion, then why can't community sentiment stop any religion with some members who've done awful things? "But" is the exception that swallows the first amendment's rule.

Nor can there be a "compromise" because of 9/11. Having been a city-wide official on that calamitous day, I am sensitive to the sensibilities of victims' families; they are sincere and upset. But while buildings fell that morning, our system of constitutional law did not. In America, legal questions are decided by juries or judges, not aggrieved parties.

But -- there's that word again -- what about "hallowed ground"? Beyond the unarguable reality that the proposed center is north and out of sight of Ground Zero, even that sacred site now has a huge, new commercial building being erected on its footprint. The city could have tried to make the whole area a cemetery to commemorate that day and those deaths. But by rebuilding, Mayor Bloomberg -- and the city as a whole -- instead properly chose to focus on the future of lower Manhattan, not its past.

Frustrated that the law and the facts are not on their side, many prominent conservatives are now resorting to absurd analogies and hysterical assertions. Islam and this planned mosque, however, are not comparable to Nazis, Pearl Harbor, Saudi Arabia, Carmelite nuns at Auschwitz, or liquor stores near schools. When Fox's Glenn Beck declares that after "you've killed 3000 people, you're going to now build your mosque?", Dick Morris concludes that it will be "a command center for terrorism", and Sean Hannity nightly attempts to "Sherrod" the Imam behind it with similar out-of-context attacks, they're all just assuming that those behind the mosque are terrorists. Any serious evidence? None of them has yet to explain why Bush 41's State Department (and now Obama's) chose to send Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf to Arab countries because, as a New York Times profile last Sunday documented, his entire life has been as a bridge-building moderate Muslim between East and West.

(That eloquent accelerant, columnist Charles Krauthammer, on Friday finally blamed, of course, "liberals" for playing the bigotry card. It's a verbal gimmick to blame the mirror for reflecting reality --if it's intolerant to point out intolerance, then civil rights workers in the '60s were apparently the racists.)

Here's the deal -- because of the values of the very first amendment, Fox News and Islam should both be allowed to say and pray as they wish without getting permission from offended dissenters. Curiously, they're alike in that both have about three million American followers as well as lots of angry critics.

Those who have been saying but-not-this-religion now have to be called out for their Muslim McCarthyism. Once again, demagogues and fear-mongers - Newt Gingrich, Sarah Palin, Peter King, Rudy Giuliani, George Pataki, Rick Lazio, Rush Limbaugh, Beck, Hannity, O'Reilly, Krauthammer, et. al. -- are using guilt-by-association, innuendo, sophistry and sheer lies.

Now as anti-Muslim protests spread around the country far beyond the location of 9/11, two Republicans especially stand out with the potential to shift the axis of debate. With the credibility to have a Nixon-to-China moment.

One is Rupert Murdoch. He has the editorial choice of allowing Fox's slanderous attacks to continue or establishing a more fair and balanced approach that could help calm the hysteria. The other is George W. Bush, who as the President attacking two Muslim nations made clear that America was fighting al Qaeda, not all of Islam. This is the perfect moment for them to speak out and remind everyone why the new World Trade building at Ground Zero will be exactly 1776 feet tall.
 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

One is Rupert Murdoch. He has the editorial choice of allowing Fox's slanderous attacks to continue or establishing a more fair and balanced approach that could help calm the hysteria. The other is George W. Bush, who as the President attacking two Muslim nations made clear that America was fighting al Qaeda, not all of Islam. This is the perfect moment for them to speak out and remind everyone why the new World Trade building at Ground Zero will be exactly 1776 feet tall.

For most of the opposition it's not even about our country anymore on any issue. It's about a President they HATE.

That's all! 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

No conservative or neo-conservative will speak out against this because they're all afraid of being labeled false prophets by the Tea Partiers.

Murdoch doesn't care because his goal isn't to run a good news organization, his goal is to sell advertising. Fox does that in spades. And for all the Fox apologists out there.. the OTHER "news" agencies are simply advert seller's too, but they're not mentioned in the main article, so I don't care about them.

What NEEDS to happen is the agencies need to stop focusing on the protesters and start focusing on the supporters. We need to make the protesters the "but" portion of the story. Supporters not necessarily of the community center itself, but of our civil rights in general. ALL civil rights, not just the ones people like at the moment.

But supporters aren't as exciting as protesters. So that ain't happening any time soon. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Fear and hysteria = ratings. Do you think they would now back pedal against that cash cow? Not too mention, as far as Bush is concerned, I don't think he wants any attention brought on himself since a lot of what's going on, is directly connected to him and his "us vs them" tactics for 8 years.

I don't know how the political climate in this country will ever come back to a unified level, but hopefully one day, it will... 

jmbtx78 --- 16 years ago -

What NEEDS to happen is the agencies need to stop focusing on the protesters and start focusing on the supporters. We need to make the protesters the "but" portion of the story.

I know it's the new American way to cater to the minority in an issue, but it would take a really special effort to try and portray 70% of Americans as the "but" portion of the story. 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

I have a hard time calling people who don't know and support their constitution, Americans. A real hard time.

These faux-patriots (or Faux (fox)-Patriots) know only the lies and half-truths fed them by their preachers on Fox and talk radio.

And it's one thing to express an opinion, it's another to try to suppress another's liberty. Especially when it is done out ignorance and fear.

I think that's the thing that bothers me the most. Fear. Americans have become so d@mned fearful that they can't see straight. Where's the adventurous spirit? Where's the toughness of character? I see these people and that's the only thing I can think... What are you so afraid of? 

traveller --- 16 years ago -

Americans have become so d@mned fearful that they can't see straight. Where's the adventurous spirit?

When you have to worry about suicide bombers and at least one arabic country whose sole purpose is to destroy us and Israel. We have a president who scrares the hell out of me and alt opf people and you ask what are people are afraid of?? 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

When you have to worry about suicide bombers

Hogwash, Traveler, pure unadulterated hogwash. There have always been dangers out there. It's only recently that Americans have been acting like beat dogs running around with their tails between their legs. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

When you have to worry about suicide bombers a


Look what happened in Oklahoma City! Look at what happened at Columbine. Look at what happened at the Trolley Square Mall in Utah, or Virginia Tech...

Crazies are everywhere and have always been here. They come in all colors, ages, creeds. 

funguy74 --- 16 years ago -

Don't forget about the D.C. Sniper. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

I was just about to add him, Funguy!

The Unabomber, Son of Sam, The Manson Family, Richard Ramirez, Ted Bundy, Ed Gein...

The list of crazies/killers is a mile long. We shouldn't outlaw everything they were associated with because of fear. 

ukchristine --- 16 years ago -

I do think there is an overreaction whipped up by the press. It's easy when they have a known target to build upon that fear which increases viewership. The random acts of terror can't be predicted so nobody can be fearful in advance. Only after do people think fearfully for a while....but there's nothing tangible to wrap your head around.

I hear American tourism to Mexico is down but up from other parts of the world. could it be we are nearer to the problems and hear so much about the bad stuff...which made us either sensible....or paranoid...depending on your point 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

I don't live a life based on fear.

I thought the major objection to the mosque was not fear based but respect based...as in, it would be disrespectful to those that lost their lives 9/11 to have a mosque so close to where they died. 

ukchristine --- 16 years ago -

Individual crazy/evil people versus organized terrorism


apples versus oranges 

funguy74 --- 16 years ago -

JFA you can add John Wayne Gacy to that list. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

.as in, it would be disrespectful to those that lost their lives 9/11 to have a mosque so close to where they died. 

except that it was radical Muslims that did this, not the average Muslim. That's the problem. Everyone is acting like being Muslim = terrorist. This mosque isn't even on the grounds where the towers stood, it's blocks away amongst restaurants, porn shops, strip clubs...if they want to put a cultural center there, it seems to me it would improve that area, not make it worse! 

funguy74 --- 16 years ago -

Great point JFA! Muslim doesn't equal terrorist. It's the people who like to spread fear that lump them together. 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

.as in, it would be disrespectful to those that lost their lives 9/11 to have a mosque so close to where they died.

Can you show me where it says that in the Constitution? Just curious.

Hallowed Ground = Porn Shops, restaurants and strip clubs... THAT's My kind of religion! 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Individual crazy/evil people versus organized terrorism


apples versus oranges 


random acts of violence are just that...

So to hate all Muslims because of the acts of a few...seems wrong, imo.

I think Ogre made a point one time regarding the scandal with Catholic Priests and churches near schools...should we shun/hate/fear Catholics because of what's gone on in their church and in MANY cases, covered up? 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

Can you show me where it says that in the Constitution? Just curious

I didn't say it was constitutional, I just considered it a personal objection by those that were making the protest. 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

0.00003% of all Muslims world wide are associated with terrorism. (that number is MUCH smaller within the U.S.)

4% of all Catholic priests in the U.S. have been accused of child molestation.

Who's scarier again? 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

I don't believe for one moment that the US is as consumed with hate and fear as funguy and JFA try to portray it.

People are not that stupid. I don't know ANYONE that lives a fear or hate based life. 

Bringit --- 16 years ago -

I am with you on that Mary!! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

0.00003% of all Muslims world wide are associated with terrorism. (that number is MUCH smaller within the U.S.)

Are you serious? Someone actually counted?

I'd love to see the report on this. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

I don't believe for one moment that the US is as consumed with hate and fear as funguy and JFA try to portray it.

Not the US, the GOP...there's a difference.

The GOP and Fox News are trying their hardest to keep fear in the hearts of their followers because fear = votes and ratings. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

Most of the people I know are Conservatives.....I repeat, I don't know ANYONE who lives a hate or fear based life.

Maybe you are the one living with the hate and the fear! 

Fiona --- 16 years ago -

I think it is disrespectful, but too funny about the percentage of muslims that are associated with terrorism. Oh I bet they were chomping at the bit to get recognized in that survey. lol 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Most of the people I know are Conservatives.....I repeat, I don't know ANYONE who lives a hate or fear based life.

Maybe you are the one living with the hate and the fear! 


LOL! sure I do...

When I start making thread after thread after thread about how horrible our country is, how horrible illegals are and how they're ruining everything, how horrible Muslims are and so insensitive to Americans, how horrible conservatives or democrats are, etc etc etc...THEN you can tell me I live my life with hate and fear.

I don't fear/hate the government, I don't think they're out to get me. I don't fear/hate someone based on our differences or my lack of understanding of their culture or religion. AND I certainly don't blame the actions of a few onto the masses who subscribe to the same ideology, whatever that might be. 

Squareduck --- 16 years ago -

The GOP and Fox News are trying their hardest to keep fear in the hearts of their followers because fear = votes and ratings.

I think you were dropped on your head when you were a child.... 

ukchristine --- 16 years ago -

So...they mailed (or phoned) a survey to a randon number of Muslims....and one of the questions was

"Are you a terrorist?....check off YES or NO"

Easy. 

ukchristine --- 16 years ago -

I don't fear/hate the government

Logicaly why would you since you agree with their policies. 

ukchristine --- 16 years ago -

Most of the people I know are Conservatives.....I repeat, I don't know ANYONE who lives a hate or fear based life.

but I suspect a lot of the people you know Mary FEAR the outcome of some of the present Government's policies....and HATE what they are currently doing. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

THEN you can tell me I live my life with hate and fear.

You're wrong about that. I can say it again now, tomorrow or anytime I want to.

You see, you are always quick to use the "hate and fear" words....christians remain true to their belief because of fear..........Gee, I don't know any Christians like that......

You are always quick to say conservatives hate obama and illegals and poor people,,,and we are racist also. Nope!

YOU are the one always talking about hate and fear, not the conservatives.

It just seems that fear and hate are part of your lifestle. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

As usual the dems are all for destroying this country. It's a kinda run of the mill mentality. Lets condemn the Americans and side with anyone who isn't. What happened to Americans banning together? Are those days over? I am not for anyone who wishes to build without any respect for our people. Plain and simple, I side with the people in New York. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

At the cost of disregarding the very document that founded our nation??? 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

I don't fear/hate the government

Logicaly why would you since you agree with their policies.


I've never feared or hated our government under any administration. I didn't like Bush, true, but I didn't fear him or feel he was ruining the country. I didn't do everything in my power to discredit him or rally around hate campaigns against him.

I will say I think the way he ran things so partisan, has greatly contributed to the divide we're seeing today... 

Bringit --- 16 years ago -

HATE what they are currently doing. 

Yep, I hate his policies, his lies, his multiple vacations, all while I sit at my little kitchen table and wonder how I am going to feed my family and pay my bills this week. Yes, you are right UK..... 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

At the cost of disregarding the very document that founded our nation??? 


this falls on deaf ears... 

ukchristine --- 16 years ago -

I think the great divide really got going after the "hanging chad" election of 2000...that's when MoveOn.org really took off. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

What happened to Americans banning together?

Is this a Freudian slip?.....

:) 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground