Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

She called off her wedding.

who's talking here?

*Annie* 2
wayward1 1
MoveIt 4
Tylers Journey 2
Shortnsassy 1
Laurabeth 3
Yosamitesa 4
quiettype 2
SueRDH 1
ladyjane 1
OH SNAP 2
Dr Aborto 2
Q The Rain in 5 4 3 2 1
pants 1
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Puss In Boots 1
Mabs 1
itstxdaddy 5
cat person 1
Nature Girl 2
kapoocheeno 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

Should she return the shower gifts?

Personally, I want her to keep my gift. I hate that the couple is going through this (I don't know the cause, but I know it must hurt) and I don't have a problem with her keeping my gift.

What do you think? 

*Annie* --- 15 years ago -

Should she return the shower gifts?


That would be appropriate. When she makes contact with you to make the return, you can then tell her to keep the item that you still want her to have it. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

Returning the gifts would be the classy thing to do. I think many people may feel the same way you do, but at least it leaves the decision up to them. 

Shortnsassy --- 15 years ago -

Returning the gifts would be the classy thing to do. I think many people may feel the same way you do, but at least it leaves the decision up to them.

Agreed! 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

Really? But why make her go through all of that? She already has to admit that her wedding is called off. I dunno. I guess I am just really sad for her. :( 

Nature Girl --- 15 years ago -

no wedding, no gifts.

she needs to make the attempt to return them and then it's up to the gifter to either let her keep it or accept the return. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

Really? But why make her go through all of that? She already has to admit that her wedding is called off.

I feel the same way about engagement rings, even if the groom is the one who called off the wedding. 

*Annie* --- 15 years ago -

I feel the same way about engagement rings, even if the groom is the one who called off the wedding.


Technically, the ring is a contract. If he broke the contract, she may keep the ring. If she broke it, the ring should be returned. If an heirloom piece, I would hope that it would be returned to be kept in the family. 

Nature Girl --- 15 years ago -

Technically, the ring is a contract. If he broke the contract, she may keep the ring. If she broke it, the ring should be returned. If an heirloom piece, I would hope that it would be returned to be kept in the family. 

Agreed. However, there are some cases where it still warrants she keep it, except in the case of heirloom. That should always be returned to the family no matter what. 

cat person --- 15 years ago -

Agreed. However, there are some cases where it still warrants she keep it, except in the case of heirloom. That should always be returned to the family no matter what.

Agree on both 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

The gifts should be returned. People can decide whether or not to allow her to keep them based on the scenario, but it is the only classy thing to do. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Better they brake up now than after they sign paperwork and pop out a couple kids. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Technically, the ring is a contract. If he broke the contract, she may keep the ring. If she broke it, the ring should be returned. If an heirloom piece, I would hope that it would be returned to be kept in the family. 

Absolutely and in some cases she should return the ring even if he is the one who broke it off. Personally I feel if a guy spends 5,000 and up on a ring and the wedding is called off the ring should be returned. That is the classy thing to do, to do otherwise is to want to financially punish him for calling it off.

Very sad indeed, I can imagine a lot of money is wasted that will not be recouped as well on rentals, the dress, catering and such. Sad but better to call it off now than do make a bigger mistake and get married if it doesn't have a chance. 

ladyjane --- 15 years ago -

If you want to spare her the extra burden of contacting you about the gift, maybe you could call or send a sweet note telling her how sorry you are and that it would mean a lot to you if she would keep the gift you sent - then maybe ask if she needs help with anything? (Like, maybe, composing a letter for people who sent gifts and asking how/where they would like them returned.....)

Or if you are close to any family members - maybe her mom - maybe you could help that person get the process moving. I know I would have felt like just going underground, and I probably would not have been able to marshall the forces to get any of the unpleasantries taken care of. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Very sad indeed, I can imagine a lot of money is wasted that will not be recouped as well on rentals, the dress, catering and such.

My sister-in-law was getting married in Vegas. She called it off a week before. Family members from CA, AZ, NV and us in TX had tickets to fly there for it. Father-in-law was pissed because if she would have called it off a week earlier, he would have just lost the deposit on the wedding, instead he had to pay for the whole thing.

She's lucky it was was in Vegas because everyone was still happy to fly in and have fun. We all danced, ate and had wedding cake without a wedding :P 

Yosamitesa --- 15 years ago -

Etiquette states that if a wedding is called off that the gifts are to be returned, unless the giver insists on either him or her to keep the gift. Typically the family and wedding party help with the returning of gifts. If you want her to keep the gift then you need to make an attempt to contact her directly and express your love to her and that you want her to keep your gift. However, don't be surprised if she wants to return it anyways due to the nature and reasoning behind the gift.

As for the wedding ring, in the state of Texas the ring goes back to the party that purchased the ring no matter what. Sorry, but that is the law. If he bought it and ended the engagement, he gets the ring back, however if she purchased the ring, then she keeps it.

Hugs and good thoughts go out to her during this hard adn emotional time. 

quiettype --- 15 years ago -

Of course you are all assuming she would want any reminder of the canceled event around. It might be she wants to return to gifts so she doesn't have to look at them and be reminded. 

SueRDH --- 15 years ago -

Ok, so what if the gift has been opened and used? I know if someone gave me a gift I wouldn't just store it away in a closet - I would use it. 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

were the gifts specifically for the bride?

i thought a wedding shower consisted of gifts for THEM.

does HE get to keep any of them?

no doubt, i don't care what you think or say...the ring should ALWAYS be returned. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

As for the wedding ring, in the state of Texas the ring goes back to the party that purchased the ring no matter what. Sorry, but that is the law. If he bought it and ended the engagement, he gets the ring back, however if she purchased the ring, then she keeps it.


I think thats the way it should be. A lot of times people buy the ring on credit and are paying on it for years. Can you imagine getting married and your husband is still paying on a ring from someone else. lol 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

No wedding. No gifts. 

Yosamitesa --- 15 years ago -

Ok, so what if the gift has been opened and used? I know if someone gave me a gift I wouldn't just store it away in a closet - I would use it.

True, a lot of people are doing this, again with etiquette, the wedding gifts should not be used until the wedding is finished. That is what my dh and I did when we got married 4 years ago. We piled everything up in the corner and the day after our wedding, we started pulling everything out of the boxes and putting away. :) 

MoveIt --- 15 years ago -

No wedding...no gifts. They should be returned with a polite note. 

Tylers Journey --- 15 years ago -

No wedding no gifts. I even gave back my wedding rings when I got divorced because I left when I found him cheating. 

MoveIt --- 15 years ago -

Well...I kept the ring when I found him cheating..He broke the vows, it was my ring. Had I called off the engagement/wedding, I would return the rings. 

Tylers Journey --- 15 years ago -

Well...I kept the ring when I found him cheating..He broke the vows, it was my ring.

I am know if I called him and asked for them back he would give them to me. We make better friend then husband and wife. I thank the mistress (Angela) all the time for doing what she did because if she didn't come into my life I wouldn't have what I have now. 

MoveIt --- 15 years ago -

I am know if I called him and asked for them back he would give them to me. We make better friend then husband and wife. I thank the mistress (Angela) all the time for doing what she did because if she didn't come into my life I wouldn't have what I have now.

If those going thru it could just see that life goes on, and gets better when you LET GO of the crap! 

quiettype --- 15 years ago -

Well...I kept the ring when I found him cheating

Me too, the whole wedding set. I have 3 nice rings now made from the set :) 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

He broke the vows, it was my ring. Had I called off the engagement/wedding, I would return the rings.

so you caught him cheating before the wedding? what vows did he break? 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

so you caught him cheating before the wedding? what vows did he break?

Nice one sir. It's because of good arguments like this that Casey Anthony is a free woman. 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

Nice one sir. It's because of good arguments like this that Casey Anthony is a free woman.

lol. uh, what? 

pants --- 15 years ago -

what vows did he break?

The vow of silence. 

Laurabeth --- 15 years ago -

He broke the vows, it was my ring. Had I called off the engagement/wedding, I would return the rings.

so you caught him cheating before the wedding? what vows did he break?



No, TXD, I think she meant that she DID catch him cheating so she kept the ring.......but then continues and explains that IF she had been the cause of the separation, then she would have given the ring back whether she was engaged or married.

I think you just misunderstood her comment. 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

He broke the vows, it was my ring.

I think you just misunderstood her comment.

it appears to me that she is saying that since he broke the vows, it is her ring. maybe not. either way, i don't agree. you give the ring back. 

Laurabeth --- 15 years ago -

it appears to me that she is saying that since he broke the vows, it is her ring. maybe not. either way, i don't agree. you give the ring back.


Yes, he broke the vows, but I was responding to the other part of your post as well.....

so you caught him cheating before the wedding?


They were married when she caught him, so yes, he did break their vows.....


Personally, I wouldn't want the ring either, I left mine on the kitchen counter the day I found out my husband cheated.....and walked out.

But I can understand if someone would want to keep it, either for sentimental or financial reasons. 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

Ugh... what about group gifts of gift cards? It's so complicated. So sad! :( 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

They need to send the gifts back, PLUS postage reimbursement.

;)


(not really, wink, wink) 

MoveIt --- 15 years ago -

vows would indicate that we were married... just to clarify. I was responding to Tylersjourney saying she gave the ring back after they divorced. Sorry for any confusion. 

Laurabeth --- 15 years ago -

What about contacting each gift giver, thank them for their gift and ask if they would prefer for their gift to be returned or donated to a charity such as Goodwill.......

Could make something good come of it afterall.... 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

vows would indicate that we were married... just to clarify. I was responding to Tylersjourney saying she gave the ring back after they divorced. Sorry for any confusion.

no worries moveit. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground