Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Sad the young girl died, but it is the parents responsibility to protect them, not a beverage

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
Jen 1
Fiona 4
sunshine1881 1
MonzaRacer 1
hummer 1
elle 1
Perfection 3
Lillabeth 4
jtcitrus 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 7
Tipsyhic 1
Work in Progress 2
Good Ole USA 1
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 5
Its Mygirl01 5
txsassy 2
FluffyPenguin 1
Lets Be Fair 2
Edgar Po Wong 1
Friday 1
RockstarSuperNova 2
witchywoman 1
AAAAAHHHHHHH 1
Haterage 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Cheapens her death by suing to make money

Sorry but it is a parents responsibility to know what their kids are consuming and educate them on what is harmful.

If the child chooses to over indulge then that is not the blame of the product, it is the blame of the parents for not raising a child who follows rules.

This action only cheapens her death and makes it seem the parents are out to profit from their loss. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

She drank two drinks and died. I can't believe that those drinks are that high in caffeine! That's pretty horrible.

I HATE those energy drinks. Very sad. 

RockstarSuperNova --- 14 years ago -

She had a heart condition. If she had drank enough coffee it could have happened.

My 14-year-old son gets so ticked at me that I won't let him drink these. This is why. That much caffeine is not good for you. Period. Especially in someone that young.

I can't imagine drink two monsters -- 24 oz one's too. I'm a caffeine addict and if I drink one I'm good. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

She had a heart condition. If she had drank enough coffee it could have happened.

Oh. . .see, that's pertinent information that I missed when reading the article. That does kind of change things, doesn't it?

But I still hate those energy drinks. 

Lillabeth --- 14 years ago -

5 people have died. She is just the youngest at 14.

She drank two in 24-48 hours.

I think they taste nasty.

I agree it our responsibility as parents to not buy that crap for our kids. But it's not illegal. They can buy it, heck the schools have energy drinks they can buy. We can only monitor so much with our kids.

One of her causes of death I heard from watching the news, was caffeine poisoning. Didn't even know there was such a thing.

I personally think the parents should sue as there are no caution labels. There are a lot of "unknowns" pertaining to those drinks.

I wouldn't be surprised if there were even more deaths linked to these energy drinks. It seems adults and kids drink them like water. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

If we put caution labels on everything - then even Nerf balls will need them.

We cannot protect everyone from everything.

The parents knew she had a heart condition but failed to educate her enough that she understood the consequences of her choices.

That's on the parents, not on the company. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

my dh couldn't stay awake without them-they should put a warning label on them, and probably will, now- I'm usually against lawsuits, though, unless it's flagrant malpractice- I understand the parents are angry, but that child could've gone to Starbucks, and ordered several espressos.. 

Edgar Po Wong --- 14 years ago -

YOLO? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

The whole thing is so sad, just awful.

I don't think a warning label is a bad idea. If your kid has a heart condition, she should have been well schooled on the danger of caffeine for her particular condition. I just don't get how she did not know she shouldn't have that stuff. If your kid as an allergy to peanuts, they should know to avoid peanuts like the plague...I think the parents dropped the ball in that the girl didn't seem to even know better??

I have never had one of these drinks. But if there's that much caffeine, it should boldly be described as such on the label. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

they taste awful-I don't find them more stimulating than Starbuck's coffee, though..probably less- 

Its Mygirl01 --- 14 years ago -

She had a heart condition. If she had drank enough coffee it could have happened.

I have to agree, my dd was just diagnosed a heart condition and even though she doesn't drink caffinated drinks regularly we have already been telling her how dangerous they can be for someone with her condition and she is old enough at only 10 to know it can really cause her harm. If the family knew she had a genetic heart condition, then a 14 year old should have known to avoid caffeine. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

So, how much caffeine is in one of those drinks? Is there more b/c the drings are large or is it purely high in caffeine??

I get palpitations fromm too much caffeine. I drink the half caff coffee and tolerate it just fine with a 50% reduction. And I drink decaff iced tea. It's not that hard to moniter what you consume.

I just wonder how much was in a bottle of that stuff...it's nuts they have to make it so high in caffeine..ugh. 

Haterage --- 14 years ago -

The amount of caffeine should be written clearly on the label.

The parents and girl share the blame as they knew she had a condition and that she she avoid caffeine.

If the law requires more than 50% of the blame as the rule I would say it is well known that Monster and others are energy drinks and where that energy comes from. Monster wins lawsuit. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Holy cow, a 16 oz can has 160mg of caffeine...and she drank 2 24oz. cans?? OMG, no wonder. that's like injecting speed, yikes.

It kinda makes me mad that they can even make those drinks that high in caffeine. Some? OK, but that's truly excessive, truly. Well, why not encourage more caffeine addiction? OY.

Moderation is a lost art. 

Its Mygirl01 --- 14 years ago -

Monster Drink Label

The 24 ounce says it has 80 MG of caffeine per serving, and it is supposed to be THREE servings, so she had 480MG of Caffeine!

Starbuck Caffeine Amounts

An expresso at Starbucks has 75MG of Caffeine 

AAAAAHHHHHHH --- 14 years ago -

Red Bull is better anyways. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

An expresso at Starbucks has 75MG of Caffeine


That's a lot too, but expresso is higher in caffeine than a regular coffee, right?? But, yeah, it's nuts. Plus when you get a Starbucks, you get ONE. Those drinks are multiple servinds in one, which sort of encourages drinking more than one serving. NOT good, at all. 

Its Mygirl01 --- 14 years ago -

Plus when you get a Starbucks, you get ONE. Those drinks are multiple servinds in one, which sort of encourages drinking more than one serving

Yeah you don't usually drink 24 ounces of Expresso at once and yes expresso is typically higher in caffeine than regular coffee 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

3 large espressos are the same- 8 oz each)not that hard to do,in the same period of time- 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

3 large espressos are the same- 8 oz each)not that hard to do,in the same period of time-


OMG, that's a lot!! I can't imagine drinking that much. I like my coffee strong, but espresso is like drinking mud, LOL!! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

when it's mixed with milk, flavors and ice, it doesn't taste like mud-I always doctor mine- 

Fiona --- 14 years ago -

I absolutely agree with their lawsuit. That mess should be regulated and labeled. It shocks me to see parents give their children energy drinks before games they say it just helps them to get a extra boast and play better. They probably have no clue that it could kill their children. This lawsuit may save many lives. I would go so far as to say you should have to be 21 to purchase it. Large quantities of caffeine is pretty much equivalent to speed. 

Haterage --- 14 years ago -

Someone needs to sue the parents on the girls behalf. 

Fiona --- 14 years ago -

The girl is 14 yrs old the drinks are not illegal. I am sure she knew that she shouldn't drink them but she did anyway. The drinks should not contain dangerous amount of caffeine Period. It is amazing that people would say it is the parents fault at 14 they can not watch her every move. 

RockstarSuperNova --- 14 years ago -

It is amazing that people would say it is the parents fault at 14 they can not watch her every move.

It's more the parents' fault than it is Monster's fault.

Teach your children.

Let them know the dangers. 

Haterage --- 14 years ago -

It is amazing that people would say it is the parents fault at 14 they can not watch her every move. 


It not called an energy drink without a reason. They should have educated her more to the dangers for her personally. Instead they want someone else to blame. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

So everyone appears to be A OK with a drink that can KILL you with 2 cans of it?

160MG of caffeine can kill you?

Just asked a cardiac patient and that's news to him. 

Jen --- 14 years ago -

I posted this on Facebook just the other day...my teenage son has a heart condition and we see a Cardio at TCH. NOOOOOOOOOO to enrgy drinks, PERIOD! I also had a friend who says he drank only one, and went in to Tachycardia. The ambulance had to give him adenisine to stop his heart, to start it back,. it was racing at 250 beats a minute I think he said. And that is my sons problem, a fast heart rate.

I do believe just one drink could be fatal...especially with an unknown heart condition you might have??? 

Haterage --- 14 years ago -

Warning to anyone who doesn't already know this. Energy drinks have crap in them to stimulate your heart and metabolism. Thats why they are called energy drinks. 

FluffyPenguin --- 14 years ago -

I would go so far as to say you should have to be 21 to purchase it

lol

You could get the same amount of caffeine from drinking a lot of Starbucks(it tastes better too!). Starbucks also has double shot drinks, AND energy drinks. Heck, you could get the same amount of caffeine from sodas if you drank enough, not to mention the massive amount of sugar in sodas and that could cause you to go into a coma! While we're at it, let's regulate chocolate because it too has caffeine in it! Or perhaps we should regulate COFFEE BEANS!

You cannot regulate everything. The world does not work that way. Do I feel for the parents? Not really. If they knowingly let their child drink something that is known(common sense people!) to cause altered heart-rate it's their own fault for not being more cautious.

Why is it the fault of that company for their obvious lack of parenting skills?

It IS the parents fault. Sorry, but even if you cannot monitor your children 24/7 does not negate your parental responsibilities. You cannot blame them for what this child did. They did not force her to drink them. She did it all on her own. Her parents should have taken her aside and did what every parent should do, talk with them about the effects of alcohol,caffeine and medications. Hell, my 6 year knows that Monsters are high in caffeine and he's not aloud to touch them. 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

80 MG of caffeine per serving

I dont' think that includes the guarana. which IS caffeine once you digest it.

and if it wasn't the lo-carb or sugar free, then that's a lot of sugar too. (granted less per serving than chocolate milk) but still a lot of sugar on top of whatever other crap she was eating. 

Fiona --- 14 years ago -

lol

You could get the same amount of caffeine from drinking a lot of Starbucks(it tastes better too!). Starbucks also has double shot drinks, AND energy drinks. Heck, you could get the same amount of caffeine from sodas if you drank enough, not to mention the massive amount of sugar in sodas and that could cause you to go into a coma! While we're at it, let's regulate chocolate because it too has caffeine in it! Or perhaps we should regulate COFFEE BEANS!

You cannot regulate everything. The world does not work that way. Do I feel for the parents? Not really. If they knowingly let their child drink something that is known(common sense people!) to cause altered heart-rate it's their own fault for not being more cautious.

Why is it the fault of that company for their obvious lack of parenting skills?

It IS the parents fault. Sorry, but even if you cannot monitor your children 24/7 does not negate your parental responsibilities. You cannot blame them for what this child did. They did not force her to drink them. She did it all on her own. Her parents should have taken her aside and did what every parent should do, talk with them about the effects of alcohol,caffeine and medications. Hell, my 6 year knows that Monsters are high in caffeine and he's not aloud to touch them. 



Anyway your OPINION is different than mine so be it. The only part of your opinion that gets to me is you do not feel for the parents. WOW 

Fiona --- 14 years ago -

After so many deaths linked to the drink yes it should become a health concern. The only way to start that process is for people to start standing up and filing lawsuits. They are making money hand over fist while endangering lives. But then again if people would stop purchasing this garbage it would go away. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

hmm...it equates to suing Smith & Wesson,because a child found a gun and shot himself with it-those drinks serve a purpose-as far as making money, that's what a capitalist country does-put a warning on the cans, and after that, it's on you- 

Its Mygirl01 --- 14 years ago -

I absolutely agree with their lawsuit. That mess should be regulated and labeled

It already has a warning on the label, it says on the can that it is not for use by children or by people with caffeine sensitivity!

She was a child with a heart condition, she took the risk and it had the worst possible outcome, but how is that the companies fault? 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

While it's true than en excess of coffee could do the same thing, coffee isn't marketed to teenagers and the amount of coffee you'd need to so the same damage, is also a factor, imo.

These energy drinks are aimed at teens and young adults. If five deaths have occurred because of them, I think a change in marketing and a warning label isn't an overreaction.

Many people have undiagnosed heart conditions that may not think twice about slammimg these drinks. I think the company needs to market their product more responsibly. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

I see groups of teenagers at Starbucks! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

It has been 5 deaths. Is that really excessive and prove blame on the product. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I think a lawsuit is a little over the top, though..nothing wrong with more responsible advertising, but suing them? 

sunshine1881 --- 14 years ago -

It has been 5 deaths. Is that really excessive and prove blame on the product.

Not at all, really, especially considering how many of these drinks are sold. I'm sure that many people probably choke on cough drops.

Stuff happens. We don't live in a bubble. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground