Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What the bible says about disciplining your child

who's talking here?

ghostpost 1
Polly Ester 2
AngieKaye 1
JohnLynch 7
mom2dx 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 12
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 6
waterfall 14
Four Pinocchios 5
JAMS 7
witchywoman 1
Smoochie and The Bean 3
ThisLady 11
Frashley26 9
UR fake conservatives and moro 1
iloveyou246 12

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

iloveyou246 --- 13 years ago -

Question: "How should Christians discipline their children? What does the Bible say?"

Answer: How to best discipline children can be difficult task to learn, but it is crucially important. Some claim that physical discipline (corporal punishment) such as spanking is the only method the Bible supports. Others insist that “time-outs” and other punishments that do not involve physical discipline are far more effective. What does the Bible say? The Bible teaches that physical discipline is appropriate, beneficial, and necessary.

Do not misunderstand—we are by no means advocating child abuse. A child should never be disciplined physically to the extent that it causes actual physical damage. According to the Bible, though, the appropriate and restrained physical discipline of children is a good thing and contributes to the well-being and correct upbringing of the child.

Many Scriptures do in fact promote physical discipline. “Don't fail to correct your children. They won't die if you spank them. Physical discipline may well save them from death” (Proverbs 23:13-14; see also 13:24; 22:15; 20:30). The Bible strongly stresses the importance of discipline; it is something we must all have in order to be productive people, and it is much more easily learned when we are young. Children who are not disciplined often grow up rebellious, have no respect for authority, and as a result find it difficult to willingly obey and follow God. God Himself uses discipline to correct us and lead us down the right path and to encourage repentance for our wrong actions (Psalm 94:12; Proverbs 1:7; 6:23; 12:1; 13:1; 15:5; Isaiah 38:16; Hebrews 12:9).

In order to apply discipline correctly and according to biblical principles, parents must be familiar with the scriptural advice regarding discipline. The book of Proverbs contains plentiful wisdom regarding the rearing of children, such as, “The rod of correction imparts wisdom, but a child left to himself disgraces his mother” (Proverbs 29:15). This verse outlines the consequences of not disciplining a child—the parents are disgraced. Of course, discipline must have as its goal the good of the child and must never be used to justify the abuse and mistreatment of children. Never should it be used to vent anger or frustration.

Discipline is used to correct and train people to go in the right way. “No discipline seems pleasant at the time, but painful. Later on, however, it produces a harvest of righteousness and peace for those who have been trained by it” (Hebrews 12:11). God's discipline is loving, as should it be between parent and child. Physical discipline should never be used to cause lasting physical harm or pain. Physical punishment should always be followed immediately by comforting the child with assurance that he/she is loved. These moments are the perfect time to teach a child that God disciplines us because He loves us and that, as parents, we do the same for our children.

Can other forms of discipline, such as “time-outs,” be used instead of physical discipline? Some parents find that their children do not respond well to physical discipline. Some parents find that “time-outs,” grounding, and/or taking something away from the children is more effective in encouraging behavioral change. If that is indeed the case, by all means, a parent should employ the methods that best produce the needed behavioral change. While the Bible undeniably advocates physical discipline, the Bible is more concerned with the goal of building godly character than it is in the precise method used to produce that goal.

Making this issue even more difficult is the fact that governments are beginning to classify all manner of physical discipline as child abuse. Many parents do not spank their children for fear of being reported to the government and risk having their children taken away. What should parents do if a government has made physical discipline of children illegal? According to Romans 13:1-7, parents should submit to the government. A government should never contradict God’s Word, and physical discipline is, biblically speaking, in the best interest of children. However, keeping children in families in which they will at least receive some discipline is far better than losing children to the “care” of the government.

In Ephesians 6:4, fathers are told not to exasperate their children. Instead, they are to bring them up in God’s ways. Raising a child in the “training and instruction of the Lord” includes restrained, corrective, and, yes, loving physical discipline.

Read more: http://www.gotquestions.org/disciplining-children.html#ixzz2WVspLbxk 

Frashley26 --- 13 years ago -

Agreed. 

ghostpost --- 13 years ago -

I know many faithful and devoted Christians that do not use physical punishment to discipline their children. Their children are well disciplined and loving and respectful.

While, I do not believe that physical punishment is child abuse (unless it is taken to the extreme), I also do not believe that spanking or not spanking is a religious issue. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

I also do not believe that spanking or not spanking is a religious issue.

if you love God...it's not...it's an obedience to God issue...and being obedient to God isn't a religious issue 

Smoochie and The Bean --- 13 years ago -

I don't think God is angry with me for not spanking the children He gave me, provided I am consistent with disciplining them and make them know right from wrong and that they have consequences for their actions.

I rather go straight to God with my questions then to trust the word of man who may or may not fully grasp the issue in its entirety. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

if you love God...it's not...it's an obedience to God issue...


So you're saying if you don't spank, you are violating God's word?

This spare the rod, spoil the child thing is like almost all the other issues in the Bible where interpretations differ. I read that the "rod" was not even meaning anything physical, the rod referred to an expectation of behavior, a bar to be set in the area of setting expectations and limits. So, set no expectations or limits, spoil the child. THAT makes sense to me.

I never struck the kids. I might have threatened a spanking but It never went beyond that.

We got spanked as kids if you were really bad, and my mom pinched you too. lol 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

I don't think God is angry with me for not spanking the children He gave me

i don't see where anybody...myself included...said that...are you trying to put words in my mouth?

I rather go straight to God with my questions then to trust the word of man who may or may not fully grasp the issue in its entirety. 

then why don't you do it?...going to the Bible IS going directly to God...and read what the Bible actually says...not what you think it says

fyi...i fully grasp the issue in its entirety...you won't until you go to the Bible and study the issue

This spare the rod, spoil the child thing is like almost all the other issues in the Bible where interpretations differ.

nope...it isn't...the Bible is very clear...and no interpretation is needed...in fact God tells us that no "private interpretation" is needed...every time the word "interpretation" is used to justify man's meanings...it is just someone trying to liberalize the Bible

when people try and make God fit their mold of what they think He should be or do...then they are rejecting God through disobedience

I read that the "rod" was not even meaning anything physical, the rod referred to an expectation of behavior, a bar to be set in the area of setting expectations and limits

well...whoever wrote that is writing something that is contrary to what the Bible says...therefore they are wrong...it is just liberal hogwash

stick with the Bible...not the liberal man written hogwash 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

John, no matter WHAT you say, it is not true that that verse is speaking specifically to hitting/spanking your kid.

Here's yet another "interpretation."

Beth McDonald
Proverbs 13:24
He who spares his rod hates his son, but he who loves him disciplines diligently and punishes him early.



I looked up as many commentaries and opinions as I could regarding this passage and I thought I was going to get sick. This little piece of scripture written by King Solomon is the justification for parents to spank their children with a stick, or "rod" as they now call it, from the age of 15 months to apparently forever. There are child psychologists, teachers, moms, pastors, doctors, and entire institutions who condone disciplining children by hitting them. Focus on the Family's James Dobson officially states that the Bible, being the unerring Word of God, tells parents to spank, smack, or hit, their children as young as 18 months. James Dobson says "If the child cries for more than five minutes, I would offer him more of what caused the original tears." So, the fundamentalist Christian view point is that to not hit your kids is mamby- pamby liberalism and hitting them is straight up Biblical. You are either a weak parent who interprets the Bible any old way you want, or you are an enlightened follower of God's teachings. In fact, these people go so far as to correlate the lack of "corporal punishment" (euphemisms are always invented when the true word is unacceptable) with the escalation of drugs, crime and violence in the world today. If we just hit them when they were toddlers, they would be nice girls and boys instead of gansta's and hoochies.

THE ROD WAS A SHEPHERD'S ROD
Not that complicated. His father, David, WAS A SHEPHERD!!!! The guy knew what a freaking rod was, it's not a metaphor taken out of context. The Hebrew word used in the text is shevet or shebet (#7626) which means "rod" and is the same word used one of the most comforting Psalms of the Bible, Psalm 23:4 "your rod and your staff comfort me". Here we go again, people who are wounded from their own childhoods, refusing to see their parents with a clear eye, are interpreting clear Biblical instruction in a manner that supports their own upbringing. And these people have huge influence on Christians who buy their books, go to their conferences, listen to their tapes and send them money. A rod is not a hickory switch, wooden paddle, yardstick, wooden spoon, talking stick or, in a pinch, an open hand on "bare buttocks". All of these methods are recommended by many, many so called Christian leaders today. They say a hand should only be used if nothing else is available because a hand should be used for loving and the rod for disciplining. Ok...right. Like a stick isn't attached to a hand that's using it to whip the kid. "Oh, that stick is hitting me by itself! I'm so glad my mommy or daddy isn't the one hurting me!"

Jesus said: "I am the Good Shepherd and I know my sheep, and I am known by my own." There are good shepherds and there are bad shepherds. Some would probably beat their sheep with their staff, that doesn't mean that's what it's for. A shepherd's sheep are very valuable to him, they're valuable to the entire community. James Dobson's child rearing notions are not only archaic and dangerous, they're psychologically ridiculous not to mention Biblically inaccurate. "I am the good shepherd"...does the Lord correct James Dobson by slapping him, humiliating him, scaring him or intimidating him? Would you love Jesus if He hit you with a stick when you made a mistake? No. You would hate him. Or hate yourself for doing something so bad that it caused our Savior to hit you.

A GOOD SHEPHERD USES A ROD TO:
Separate: He uses it to separate wounded sheep from the rest of the flock. At night, when the flock enters the fold, they pass under the shepherd's rod, which is held slightly above their backs. They enter the fold single file in the same order every time. When he gently touches a sheep's back, that sheep knows to leave the line and come to the shepherd so it's wounds can be dressed and attended to.

Guide: A shepherd will gently guide his sheep where he wants them to go by sort of "nudging" them with his rod. He does this if the sheep is wandering off on it's own, distracted or off in it's own little world. Sheep are vulnerable when they're away from the security of their flock. He'll also give a little warning tap to any bully sheep who won't allow the young, older or wounded sheep to eat where the best grass might be. A shepherd knows which one of his sheep are likely to bully or wander and he anticipates their behavior. If he's moving his flock from one pasture to another, he can't afford to let any of his sheep get out of line.

Protect: A shepherd's rod can knock a predator off it's feet before it knows what hit him. The sheep trust the shepherd to look after them, they know that he is watching out for their safety so they don't need to be so anxious. A rod is used to hit the enemy, not the lambs! The enemy of the flock quake when the shepherd starts coming at them with the mighty rod, not the sheep in his care.

Hold back from danger: Sheep are not stupid, they just don't have a very good sense of smell. They wouldn't know bad grass from good, they'll eat dirt if the shepherd doesn't lead them to green pastures. Sometimes a shepherd will have to hold the staff out in front of a sheep that is determined to go where it shouldn't, where it's dangerous. The sheep don't have to know where not to go, the shepherd does.

I think it's pretty obvious that Solomon was not saying that if you don't hit your kids with a stick, they'll grow up to be drug dealers and thieves. He is saying that if you do not attend to your children's wounds, protect them from the enemy, or hold them back when they're about to do something hideously stupid, you're going to end up with a child who doesn't know how to care for themselves and doesn't feel loved. Also, he's saying that to predators, your sheep are prey and if you don't take a stick to anyone who tries to hurt your babies, good luck. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

John, no matter WHAT you say, it is not true that that verse is speaking specifically to hitting/spanking your kid.

the problem for you is...there is no "spare the rod, spoil the child" verse

and this woman's "blog" entry is contradictory to what the Bible says...especially to the Scripture passage she quoted

I looked up as many commentaries and opinions as I could regarding this passage and I thought I was going to get sick.

she didn't like what she read...too fundamentalist...so she made up her own explanation...typical liberal undertaking

He is saying that if you do not attend to your children's wounds, protect them from the enemy, or hold them back when they're about to do something hideously stupid, you're going to end up with a child who doesn't know how to care for themselves and doesn't feel loved.

that is definitely NOT what God was saying in that Scripture passage 

UR fake conservatives and moro --- 13 years ago -

There goes author man talking about his rod again. 

ThisLady --- 13 years ago -

Ugh, please! If I have to read another statement saying "Spare the rod spoil the child," I might blow a gasket! My ex and I used to fight about 2 things...One^^ THAT statement, 2 the day I stated I would one day come home and desire a glass of wine at dinner or just in general. Oh lawdy lawd did all H-E-double hockey sticks break loose!

I always had a very tender heart for children and initially felt it unnecessary to spank at any means. I had a strong belief that sternly hitting a child may lead to their belief that hitting is acceptable as the one they love most and look up to are showing them that behavior. That feeling increased upon becoming aware of my son's autistic tendencies. I had an overwhelming thought to protect his every feeling (ones he was actually able to show and more so the ones he couldn't express) and scared me to think of how drastically hitting even in a mild form could increase his frustrations and inhibit future feelings to manifest through anger. I have a strong belief that he (his father) had finally come to that same understanding shortly later...

I will say that since then I have had two more children and one of those two sometimes needs that sense of discipline beyond guidance of words alone. All I have to do is threaten the naughty spoon and she goes right into tip top shape. Yes, I had to break my original beliefs of spanking is unnecessary a couple times with her... But for the most part, most children at a reasonable age can reason without physical discipline. As long as it's done without the presence of anger from the parent. Never discipline from anger!

Get to know your child well and what works for them, each personality is different and will respond differently. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

I just would like to see people controlling their brats at the stores. I am so embarrassed for them to have kids totally out of control. Let me know how the time out thing works for that. Mine would of gotten a pop on the bootey, embarrassed by it and it would never happen again.

I thank GOD everyday I have great boys. Never hardly had to punish them. 

Frashley26 --- 13 years ago -

.. Do You Have To Comment On Every Post I Comment On? Lol You Sound Really Bitter About Your Ex's. Good Thing My Husband Found Someone Who Doesnt Like To Drink And Has The Same Beliefs. He Told Me He Prayed For Someone Like Me .. Its Been Like 10 Yrs And Your Still Dwelling On Him And His Words. You See That He Is Doing Great Financially Now And that He Is Happy. Let It Go And Move On. Good God. 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

OMG Ashely, STFU.

She's sharing her story and opinion. It isn't about you!! You have got to be the most immature, selfish, self centered brat in the world. Maybe YOU should have been spanked more.

If anyone needs to let it go, it's you. 

Frashley26 --- 13 years ago -

What Is The Point In Drinking Anyway? Its Gross And Dehydrates You. Glad My Husband And I Think Alike. I Wouldnt Be Compatible With A Drinker. 

Frashley26 --- 13 years ago -

Yes It Is Bc I Wrote Spare The Rod And Spoil The Child Twice Today. 

Frashley26 --- 13 years ago -

And I Also Wrote On This Post First. And On My June Bug Post And Another Post About A House Alarm And The Flies Post. She Watches My Every Word On Here And Comes By My House Leaving Notes On The Front Door For My Husband 

Frashley26 --- 13 years ago -

My Husband Spanks Me ;) Bow Chicka bow Wow 

mom2dx --- 13 years ago -

What's Wrong with Kids Today

"Before you go and criticize the younger generation, just remember who raised them." - Unknown

We've all heard the complaints. Today's children are more disrespectful, undisciplined, and have a greater sense of entitlement than ever before. But do they? Alfie Kohn talks about this in his article Spoiled Rotten: A Timeless Complaint. He notes that "Parents today, we're informed, either can’t or won’t set limits for their children. Instead of disciplining them, they coddle and dote and bend over backward to shield them from frustration and protect their self-esteem. The result is that we’re raising a generation of undisciplined narcissists who expect everything to go their way, and it won’t be pretty -- for them or for our society -- when their sense of entitlement finally crashes into the unforgiving real world."

Sound familiar?

He goes on to give 3 examples from authors stating the same concerns, published in 1962, 1944, and 1911, respectively.

"The revelation that people were saying almost exactly the same things a century ago ought to make us stop talking in mid-sentence and sit down – hard. In fact, the more carefully we look at the cranky-wistful conventional wisdom about how children are raised, the less there is to be said in its favor." - Alfie Kohn

I've heard it over and over again. Kids need more discipline! Parents today are too soft! Well, depending on where you look for statistics, anywhere between 65% to 90% of American parents are spanking their kids. Here are some statistics I found:

- 68 percent of American parents think spanking is not only good but essential to child rearing;

- 90 percent of parents spank their toddlers at least three times a week; two-thirds spank them once a day;

- One in four parents begin to spank when their child is 6 months old, 50 percent when their child is 12 months old;

I'd say it's pretty clear that a lack of discipline is not "what's wrong with kids today." So what is wrong with kids today? Could it be that the only thing wrong with them is our perspective of them? Perhaps so.

But I have another theory.

I believe the problem is not a lack of discipline, but a lack of connection. For decades upon decades, we have raised children with fear (Do you want a spanking?), punishment (You're grounded for a week!), shame (You're such a naughty little girl), and coercion (If you don't pick up your toys, I'm throwing them in a trash bag!). We've become so wrapped up in "raising them right" that we've forgotten how to love them right. We've bought into the so-called experts advice of not spoiling them with too much attention, letting them cry it out, and not sparing the rod, and we've pushed aside our own instincts. Thus, parents have drawn a line between themselves and their children that dare not be crossed. "I'm your parent, not your friend!" This has been so ingrained throughout the generations that many don't even question it. (I'm questioning it, are you?) Naturally, we love our children. We give them hugs and praise, conditionally. We buy them the latest gadgets. But are we connected?

For too long, children have been seen and not heard.

It's time to hear them.

For too long, we've raised our children using fear tactics.

It's time to use love tactics.


A century's worth of complaints is more than enough evidence that we're doing something wrong. Depression and mental health issues are a major problem because adults have to put so much into healing their childhood wounds, and some never do heal.

Let's stop wounding them. Instead of punishing, teach. Instead of hitting, hug. Instead of isolating, get close. Instead of coercion, cooperate. Instead of conditional love, love unconditionally. Let's build strong relationships with our children, set good examples for them, and allow them to feel all of their emotions. Let's say "I'm right here with you" instead of "Go to your room!" Let's say "I hear how upset you are" instead of "Quit your crying." It's time to change the way we raise our children.

"There is no single effort more radical in its potential for saving the world than a transformation in the way we raise our children." - Marianne Williamson

Learn about what positive parenting really is. Learn how to set loving limits. Learn how to elicit cooperation through relationship. Learn how to break the cycle of fear, and begin a new cycle of love and connectedness.

If we do this, I guarantee our story will be different a generation from now. Imagine where we could be in a century... 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Whyx3, are you freaking stalking me?

I was here first. You're all up in my bizness!

You're so jealous of me!!!!!!!!! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Whyx3, are you freaking stalking me?

I was here first. You're all up in my bizness!

You're so jealous of me!!!!!!!!! 




You caught me. I think you had more kids than me just because your jealous and wanted to one up me.

Have you been driving by my house?

I know you got a cell phone just because you knew I had one.

Get a life!!!! 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

You caught me. I think you had more kids than me just because your jealous and wanted to one up me.

Have you been driving by my house?

I know you got a cell phone just because you knew I had one.

Get a life!!!! 


lol! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

And Comes By My House Leaving Notes On The Front Door For My Husband 


that was me..... 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

How would you know I was driving by your house?! OMG, are you looking out your window?! I knew it!!

And please, you're so jealous because I still have my clear pager I bought at that old flea market off 610 in 1993.

I'm going for a swim. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I never look to the bible for discipline tips. We've come a long way in 2013 years! 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

We've come a long way in 2013 years!

Some of us have. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Some of us have. 


some not so much 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I'm going for a swim. 



OMG you got a pool, you are just trying to steal my life. 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

OMG you got a pool, you are just trying to steal my life. 

I don't think she is really going swimming. I think she is going to go drive by your house. :) 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I think she is going to go drive by your house. :) 


Again? Well she better not because I am naked and she will get arrested for that. I'm calling CPS!! My husband is the best and he loves me and I'm awesome. 

witchywoman --- 13 years ago -

JohnLynch --- 2 hours ago - quote - hide comments
I also do not believe that spanking or not spanking is a religious issue.

if you love God...it's not...it's an obedience to God issue...and being obedient to God isn't a religious issue




So one must have to hit their children or you're disobedient to YOUR God?

Now I think I've heard it all. 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

Again? Well she better not because I am naked and she will get arrested for that. I'm calling CPS!! My husband is the best and he loves me and I'm awesome.

And everything is just sunshine and rainbows and unicorns!!!!!!!!! LOL! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

And everything is just sunshine and rainbows and unicorns!!!!!!!!! LOL! 


Sounds like you do understand our love..he prayed for me.... 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

Sounds like you do understand our love..he prayed for me.... 

And live happily ever after without any hidden insecurities... 

Smoochie and The Bean --- 13 years ago -

Would you stone your wife to death if she cheated on you? 

ThisLady --- 13 years ago -

Comes By My House Leaving Notes On The Front Door For My Husband 


Yupp, darn right I did. I was concerned that a caring father like him never showed up to pick up his son for father's day weekend. And since he has a (*edited by me*) wife that won't allow him to keep open lines of communication for purposes of his son's well being, I had no other way of communicating with him and was worried about randomly receiving law enforcement at my home for interference with parent custody.

Go ahead Ashley post the picture of the letter I wrote and posted on your front door, while you were on your five mile run, and after I passed your husband on my way to your home. Post it, I know you took a pic of it, show KU what a compassionate lunatic I am! And then I even give you permission to post the pic of me stalking you at the gym. The one that is obvious I had been working out on the stairmaster for at least 15 minutes and was about to get off but not before you jumped up on the one in front of me and took a picture of me behind you, trying to make it look like I was following you and giving you evil glares even though in the pic it's obvious I'm not even looking up. (total run on sentence).. Let's let KU be the judge since you insist on going on with your antics....? 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

KU made it's ruling a long time ago. No one is buying into Ashley's perfect little fairy tale life. And no one needs to see any more personal info posted. I think you have shown that you are the adult ThisLady. This little girl needs a reality check. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I have told you both, ThisLady and KUAshley87 that airing all your personal info on here is unwise. You both continue to attack each other and ruin threads with all your personal junk.

STOP now or you both are going to the cooler. 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

STOP now or you both are going to the cooler. 

But Ashley is running out of alt ID names to change to. :) 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

advice
book club
charity
children


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground