Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should Andrea Yates be allowed out on trips?

who's talking here?

Polly Ester 1
Perfection 3
Just Ray 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
JohnLynch 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 10
SwimSwim 4
Dorothy Parker 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 8
Its Mygirl01 1
sheddy 1
PokerFace 1
freebyrdll 1
JAMS 1
MissPris 1
Butterbean 3
mutton 5
Sweet Cherub 2
The Master 3
MalevolentWitchesClub 1
Wicked 1
Brooklyn5 4
Chef Justin 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

link title 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

Yes. 

Its Mygirl01 --- 12 years ago -

Yes 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

No.
Arts and crafts? What crap. I have to pass her children every time I visit my mom's grave.

I bet they'd like to go on a picnic. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I posted this too before it saw you beat me to it!

I'm conflicted, truly. It's obvious she is desperately mentally I'll. Murderers shouldn't have many privileges or comforts IMO. But she's really sick. I guess if I was going to be completely logical, I would have to say she should get whatever freedoms are routine and normal for patients like this. I assume she is better and they want to socialize her since she only has Parnam and his wife and one friend as visitors.

If she was physically sick and this treatment would benefit her in some way, it would be done. Is mental illness any different? Should it be? 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

It is hard to even want to think about. She has committed the one act that is truly hard to wrap one's head around, let alone then try to feel any sympathy for her. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I don't know....

What type of mental illness causes someone to drown their 5 children, but with medication and supervision, makes it ok to attend church and picnics? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

It is hard to even want to think about. She has committed the one act that is truly hard to wrap one's head around, let alone then try to feel any sympathy for her.




I think you're right. Child killers/molesters make me experience HATE. Something that's very, very difficult otherwise.

But that logical side of me thinks there is a prejudice about how we feel about mental illness. I know we don't know nearly all there is to know but when it comes to being sick physically, we have all kinds of sympathy. Mental illness, not so much. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Very true Saga. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

What type of mental illness causes someone to drown their 5 children, but with medication and supervision, makes it ok to attend church and picnics?





But don't you have to be deranged to do that in the way it happened for her? It wasn't a crime of passion or a premeditated hate killing. She was actually being treated for depression, postpartum, and her genius husband was warned she should not be giving birth again.. So imo, the mental problems escalated with another birth and more and more responsibility and less and less lucidity...when you have issues like that, it seems to me the people closest to her have a responsibility to stay on top of things but they can't do it. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

I always felt her husband should be in jail. 

PokerFace --- 12 years ago -

She should still have to be accountable and serve out her time. I understand she was experiencing a psychotic break, but given the severity of her crime, her life should be over. No perks. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

But don't you have to be deranged to do that in the way it happened for her? It wasn't a crime of passion or a premeditated hate killing. She was actually being treated for depression, postpartum, and her genius husband was warned she should not be giving birth again.. So imo, the mental problems escalated with another birth and more and more responsibility and less and less lucidity...when you have issues like that, it seems to me the people closest to her have a responsibility to stay on top of things but they can't do it.


But I still don't WANT to feel any sympathy for her. Sad to say but very true. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

why is she any different that a woman who has had multiple abortions? 

Chef Justin --- 12 years ago -

No. Those children can not go on outings because she KILLED them. 

MalevolentWitchesClub --- 12 years ago -

let her rot in person then in hell 

SwimSwim --- 12 years ago -

No perks..no picnics, not outings...nothing.

She killed those babies and she knew what she was doing. Yes, I realize she is mentally ill, but she still had the presence of mind to wait until her husband left for work and before her mother in law came to help her out for the day. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Agree wholeheartedly with Sheddy.

At the time, the husband was shunted aside. The pressures put on this poor woman were enormous. I thought and think that she exhibited all the symptoms and characteristics of a battered woman.

IMO, the husband bears the main responsibility for this tragedy. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

I thought and think that she exhibited all the symptoms and characteristics of a battered woman.

IMO, the husband bears the main responsibility for this tragedy.


lol...it always has to be the husband's fault

there was never any assertion that she was a "battered" woman 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

The fact she had to chase her oldest son around to catch him so she could kill him, shows planning, imo.

Sick or not, she killed 5 kids by her own hand, one right after the other...and now she's all better and wants to go to picnics??? Hell no.

Does Son of Sam get to go to picnics? He's schizophrenic too. 

freebyrdll --- 12 years ago -

No, no and HELL TO NO! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Anyone who murders is mentally ill. Should they all be allowed picnics?

Those murders were premeditated. She had attempted it before, her husband knew it too. They should have fried. Both of them. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Anyone who murders is mentally ill. Should they all be allowed picnics





But that's not true. Most killings are people with no mental issues previously. They are criminals. Drug dealers, whatever. You have passion/rage killings too, none of that means you're mentally unbalanced. Or truly have mental illness.

And the vast majority of people WITH mental illness don't kill people either. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

And the vast majority of people WITH mental illness don't kill people either.

You hit the nail on the head for me right there! That is why I have a hard time with any sympathy. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

yes, she should- 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

This is a tragedy that she will never make right. I am sure she has so many regrets and grieves the loss of her children every day. She experienced post partum psychosis. Psychosis is as real as diabetes. We all have a clear grasp on the concept of diabetes, but many of us don't want to grasp the fact that the brain can do odd things. I work with the mentally ill. Their delusions and hallucinations are real to them. That is their reality while they are in that moment. It takes a lot of time and medication to get them back to their reality. It is not easy. It is sad that people have judged a person who was so ill at the time. This is just tragic. There are no words when thinking of 5 little children dying like they did. But do realize, once the psychotic episode was over and she was stabilized, her nightmare began. She has to live with that. That is her punishment. 

Just Ray --- 12 years ago -

What is said is that this individual is still above ground. She should be wormfood by now. Mental illness my butt. She killed 5 babies. Plant this b*tch. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

But that's not true. Most killings are people with no mental issues previously. They are criminals. Drug dealers, whatever. You have passion/rage killings too, none of that means you're mentally unbalanced. Or truly have mental illness.

And the vast majority of people WITH mental illness don't kill people either.



I disagree. Anyone who kills another person with intent is mentally ill. Just because some people with mental illness don't doesn't mean those that do are not mentally ill. Different type of mental illness, sure whatever. That does not mean they should get away with it or in my opinion that they shouldn't be put to death for it. No reason to be ugly to them about it. You just tell them your sorry that they have this problem but they have to go night night now. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I disagree. Anyone who kills another person with intent is mentally ill. Just because some people with mental illness don't doesn't mean those that do are not mentally ill. Different type of mental illness, sure whatever. That does not mean they should get away with it or in my opinion that they shouldn't be put to death for it. No reason to be ugly to them about it. You just tell them your sorry that they have this problem but they have to go night night now.


"Nigh night now"...... That's funny!

On a more serious note, it appears that we need to truly define mental illness. There is a list of emotional/mental diseases that require real treatment, counseling, medications, etc. to achieve a state of normalcy and balance. I feel that is different than rage or passion killings. People can snap and go overboard in moments of weakness who have otherwise led normal lives. Andrea Yates WAS indeed diagnosed with a mental disorder and was being treated. To me, that's different than that chick in the South somewhere, Susan Smith, who drowned her kids bc the latest BF didn't like kids. Was she a whacko? yes, but that does t mean she wasn't functioning in society relatively normally previously. Andrea Yates suffered from a brain disorder.

And, IMO, some people are sane acting/functioning as they can be, like Ted Bundy, but he liked killing people as well. He was evil, not insane IMO. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

And, IMO, some people are sane acting/functioning as they can be, like Ted Bundy, but he liked killing people as well. He was evil, not insane IMO.


He just had a bit of something missing, it is called humanity. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

He just had a bit of something missing, it is called humanity.



I think you mean no heart. People can be pretty normal functioning and be cold as ice to everyone but themselves. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

I am sure she has so many regrets and grieves the loss of her children every day.


I agree that she was obviously mentally ill, but I don't know that she has recovered to the point of realizing the depth of what she did. If so, I don't think she would even want to go on picnics or see other people..her heart would be so sick at what her own hands did to her precious children that she would just wither up.

It is a shame she didn't just take her own life and spare the children.


I don't have much heart for her ex husband either. He knew she wasn't emotionally strong and had postpartum depression but did not limit their family size. Having to homeschool and be isolated was not in her best interest or the children's either. But of course, he is not the one that pushed those precious little faces into the water. 

Brooklyn5 --- 12 years ago -

I hardly believe that all murderers are mentally ill.
What about all the murders that are committed so that people can collect insurance benefits? Those cases are usually done by highly calculating, greedy, heartless scum.

Picnics aside, I'm wondering how Andrea Yates can even live with herself. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

So you guys think calculated premeditated murders that are fun for the person commiting the crime are done by normal functioning brains? Interesting.

And yes I think Susan Smith was mentally ill too or she would not have been able to drive her kids into a lake and pretend that someone else did it. Normal people don't do that. 

SwimSwim --- 12 years ago -

So you guys think calculated premeditated murders that are fun for the person commiting the crime are done by normal functioning brains? Interesting.

And yes I think Susan Smith was mentally ill too or she would not have been able to drive her kids into a lake and pretend that someone else did it. Normal people don't do that.



I think sometimes people are just pure evil. Not mentally ill, just evil and I think Susan Smith is just that. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Do you think evil people might be mentally ill? 

SwimSwim --- 12 years ago -

Do you think evil people might be mentally ill?



No, I really don't...evil exists in this world. Thing is, its hard for most of us to wrap our minds around that kind of evil. I think that's why we want to call it mental illness so we can at least try to understand that kind of evil.

Does that make any sense at all? 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Does that make any sense at all?

No. 

SwimSwim --- 12 years ago -

Does that make any sense at all?

No.


Fair enough! LOL! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

TheUglyTruth --- 10 min ago - quote - hide comments
Do you think evil people might be mentally ill?




I think some are and most are not. There are far too many murderers in regular jails then and not in institutions like where Andrea Yates is. By your definition that all murderers are insane/ mentally ill, there is a real problem because the vast majority of convicted murderers are in general population type prisons and not mental hospitals. These folks are all examined by psychiatrists and mental health professionals and few are ever truly judged to be the criminally insane.

Sometimes people can do really evil things and not have a mental disorder, the free choice and lack of judgment or impulse control issues damns a lot of people.

Andrea Yates truly had a mental psychotic break. She was under the care of a doc and on medications. Most murderers are not, before and after their crimes. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground