Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What Americans thought of Jewish refugees on the eve of World War II

who's talking here?

SleightOfHand 1
FANCY PANTS 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Judas 1
a889324uu 5
Slider152 15
jacobson 1
AMDG 4
alldayredux 3
fuzz81 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Judas --- 11 years ago -

What Americans thought of Jewish refugees on the eve of World War II

0


Look familiar?! 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

Hmm...Wonder why???

0

0

0 

SleightOfHand --- 11 years ago -

That and German spies were already trying to sabotage our factories and other sensitive national security interests. the costal cities had mandatory blackouts at night so the German ships couldn't see the coast line 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

Obama hasn't exactly stepped up since we've let in less than 1000 which is shameful.

We can repeat the bigotry and fear of the past or let these poor people in. It's an easy decision for the unbelieving people of humanity but not so much for the people of Christ. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

right, because there was a group of Jewish terrorists blowing up everyone. not. 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

Exactly, even though you're clueless to the fact you just agreed with me. We didn't let the Jews in until much too late due to many factors mostly made up.

Just like today. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

20% unemployment with no end in sight... WW2 brought us out of that recession. We had no work and needed no additional mouths to feed...
Plus... at the time we were trying to stay neutral and didn't want to be seen as sympathetic to any side at all.
Wasn't about anything but pure self-preservation at that time.

Today it's about being cautious about welcoming with open arms a group of people who openly defy our way of life and values. Doing this blindly is just foolish. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

20% unemployment with no end in sight... WW2 brought us out of that recession. We had no work and needed no additional mouths to feed...
Plus... at the time we were trying to stay neutral and didn't want to be seen as sympathetic to any side at all.
Wasn't about anything but pure self-preservation at that time.


Slider, granting that all of that is 100% true, in hindsight, did it make it morally "right" to not allow them?? Is any of this a sound moral reason, or a rational, for a non-moral reason.

That is a question, I really don't have an answer yet myself what is the right answer today. I am conflicted, I feel it is a moral obligation of nations to offer asylum to people fleeing tyranny and violence. I also feel that nations have a moral obligation to protect their citizens. I do not know enough about how these refugees are or will be vetted to know if it allows the first "good" and addresses the second "good". 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

I don't know... if you have only 3000 calories worth of food for your children, you have 3 children who require a minimum of 1000 calories/day to keep them healthy... do you take in 3 more children and feed them all 500 calories/day? Are you actually helping them at that point? What do you do when they all become malnourished?
Sometimes the right thing to do is heart-breaking.
So basically... you can save 3 or starve 6... and that is your only choice. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

I don't know... if you have only 3000 calories worth of food for your children, you have 3 children who require a minimum of 1000 calories/day to keep them healthy... do you take in 3 more children and feed them all 500 calories/day? Are you actually helping them at that point? What do you do when they all become malnourished?
Sometimes the right thing to do is heart-breaking.


Not sure I could grant true a premise that says for each Jewish refugee we would have directly taken food away from a starving American - even during the depression.

But no doubt they would have placed additional hardship, during a time when as a nation we could not take any additional hardship.

But with 20 - 20 hindsight IMO we should have taken the hardship, no matter how harsh - rather than allow what was happening to the Jews in Europe. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

And you know... I don't think we actually knew the extent of the atrocities until near the war's end. We knew about some things, but if memory serves me... we didn't know about things like the death camps at the time. Mainly... in 1938 it looked like they were being discriminated against, but not killed off by the millions.

And in my family history, I have relatives who were kicked out the house in their early teens (12 in the case of my great-grandfather) in the mid-late 1930's because the family could no longer feed them. The story goes that the choice was to feed 4 people well enough to keep them healthy, or feed 7 people and malnourish the young children.
People were dying in the community because they weren't healthy enough (due to malnutrition) to fight off even the common cold in some cases.
Times were hard then. Harder than we can ever imagine. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

I have relatives who were kicked out the house in their early teens (12 in the case of my great-grandfather)

Somebody fed him, or you wouldn't be here today. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

yea Slider - I do not think we knew the extent of the atrocities.

I am not arguing that what they did was wrong, with what they knew. Not trying to cast any moral judgment on their actions.

But I am interested in thinking if they did know, what we now know, would they - or us - make the same choice.

The moral question I am after, that I admittedly do not have an answer for, is -

What is the level of hardship or danger or fear, that supersedes the moral obligation to help those fleeing tyranny and violence. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

I have relatives who were kicked out the house in their early teens (12 in the case of my great-grandfather)

Somebody fed him, or you wouldn't be here today.


He was very resourceful and posed as a 16 year-old and found a job driving a logging truck. He was very lucky to get that job and sent most of his money back home.
He had one brother who starved to death and one who joined the army.

But the luck and determination of one person, doesn't paint an accurate picture of how hard times were then. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

What is the level of hardship or danger or fear, that supersedes the moral obligation to help those fleeing tyranny and violence.?

and that is the question... it's the right question and it's a good question.
Some would argue that this should never be the question due to the morality you're talking about, but the fact is that economic/financial health, unemployment rates, unchecked numbers of refugees (remember we're still fielding 10's of thousands of "refugees" from south of the border also), unchecked spending, rising healthcare costs, rising food costs, an appalling inability to support our own indigent people... That all plays into the sliding scale of viability to sustain an increased population. When we're doing well... I say let them come (but keep a close eye on those who openly defy our values), but I don't believe we're doing well enough for that right now. So until our veterans get the care they deserve and fought for, and until we can take care of our own starving people... I don't think that morally we should take on any more.
We have a moral obligation to our own citizens as well. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -


We have a moral obligation to our own citizens as well.?


How liberal of you ;) 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

Liberal...? I don't remember saying give them handouts for doing nothing at all...
Hence the "care that they fought for" remark about veterans from earlier.
Provide jobs, training, a time-limit on welfare things like that... Things that won't drown us all in debt in the long run.
That's the conservative approach. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

That's the conservative approach

Really? Who are you fooling? To me, it looks more like send them up creek without a paddle. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

I'm sorry... Who just declined to pipeline that would have created a number of jobs???
That sent thousands of people up the proverbial creek without a paddle during a time when the oil industry desperately needs jobs. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

so slider my point on the hindsight, is this:

If there are give or take 1.8M Christian Syrians living in immediate danger of death. Would you continue to stand by your reasons above if we later learn that 100 were killed ? 1,000 were killed, 10,000 - 100,000 were killed ?

I think the US today can financially assimilate thousands, maybe tens of thousands of refugees, many of which will rely on private charity. I do not see these numbers impacting our ability to fix the problems you highlight above any more than now.

The question to me is can we vett them well enough to not significantly increase the danger of terrorist attack.

If zero is the only acceptable number, than we will never get there, but I don't think we need to get to zero. We need to get to not significantly increases. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 11 years ago -

If there is an attack here as a result will those advocating for this take responsibility for those deaths? 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

To me, it looks more like send them up creek without a paddle.

That's because you have been deceived by liberal propaganda. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

So the first part of your statement is asking if my religious convictions somehow change my mind on the morality question.
The answer is no because while realize you don't share the opinion I do (and I can respect that), my decision was based on my opinion that with our current economic policies, we're already saturated with both indigent citizens and "refugees from the south". I'm not even sure we can yet assess the impact of the flood of people from the south yet.
It would break my heart, but I personally would have to say no.
Now the other part of your statement is about security, if we were more sound economically and I felt we could bring them in properly, then I agree 100% but I would also expect us to vett everyone regardless of religion.
But I would definitely keep a serious eye on people from some flash-point countries.
It's what we used to do with asylum-seekers from the USSR. The FBI kept a close eye on them for quite some time after they arrived. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

To me, it looks more like send them up creek without a paddle.

That's because you have been deceived by liberal propaganda.?


Oh, I guess you missed Romneys 47% speech. Luckily for him that number is down to 40% now. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

If there is an attack here as a result will those advocating for this take responsibility for those deaths?

Sure, when gun nuts take responsibility for children being mowed down in elementary schools and in movie theaters. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

Come on now... Statistics without peer-reviewed (and triplicate-signed documents) publications???

Would you accept that retort without proof from anyone else fuzzy? 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

France is accepting Syrian refugees.

and

Why isn't KU afraid of THESE terrorists? 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Why isn't KU afraid of THESE terrorists??

Don't rain on the xenophobe parade!!!!! Those are misguided youth, whom we should coddle 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

France IS trying to close it's borders. That actually began just before the attack.

And I am afraid of the white supremacists. I'm glad they were caught. They deserve no mercy.

But there's a difference between dealing with our citizens who are terrorists (that pesky constitution again), and inviting in other people's terrorists.

I say we sent those guys to fight ISIS... Put them on the front lines. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Don't rain on the xenophobe parade!!!!! Those are misguided youth, whom we should coddle

They are all too stupid to even grasp it.

We have homegrown terrorists right here in our backyards, slaughtering our children as they learn their ABCs, and these boobs are worried about refugees fleeing death and destruction.
This is absolutely what ISIS wants - shun the refugees - guess where they will then go?

If you can't beat 'em, join 'em.

It's more difficult to be a refugee than oh, say, a visitor - it would make more sense for foreign terrorists to come over as a visitor than an actual refugee.

Americans can be so dim. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

Jack Nicholson - go sell crazy somewhere else... We're all full up here.

That's how I feel about our issues here. We already have enough of our own problems to invite more in. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

They are only terrorists when the republicans decide to call them that. Now if there were transgenders or gays attacking people..... That would be like Fox News terror headline bolded, italic, double underlined flashing kind of terror 

FANCY PANTS --- 11 years ago -

Were the Jews trying to kill us in 1939? No! We have more reason to keep the Syrian refugees out of the US because most are not women and children. Most are young, strong men without family ties to any of the other refugees. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

France IS trying to close it's borders.

France is still committed to accepting refugees

But there's a difference between dealing with our citizens who are terrorists (that pesky constitution again), and inviting in other people's terrorists.

Ah, yes, that pesky Constitution, which allows in REFUGEES.
Refugees DO. NOT. EQUAL. terrorists.

We are not inviting terrorists in. Stop repeating that ridiculous lie.

I say we sent those guys to fight ISIS... Put them on the front lines.

American terrorists, AKA white supremacists?
I can agree with that. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Americans can be so dim.?

LOL, America didn't acquire the global term of "dumb americans" for nothing 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

We have more reason to keep the Syrian refugees out of the US because most are not women and children. Most are young, strong men without family ties to any of the other refugees.

That's a lie. Stop repeating it. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

International and federal law allow asylum, but I don't think the constitution specifies it.
The constitution protects the citizens, not foreigners beyond international law.

And while I know asylum-seekers are not all terrorists (my wife was an asylum-seeker from eastern-Europe in the 80's), stopping the flow of refugees would likely have prevented at least one Paris attacker (with a "Syrian Refugee" passport from shooting up Paris.

No refugees = no terrorists posing as refugees. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 11 years ago -

If there is an attack here as a result will those advocating to take these people in take responsibility for those deaths? 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

If there is an attack here as a result will those advocating to take these people in take responsibility for those deaths?

Sure. Vote me off the school board 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

We have more reason to keep the Syrian refugees out of the US because most are not women and children. Most are young, strong men without family ties to any of the other refugees.

That's a lie. Stop repeating it.


None of that actually matters... A female blew herself up this morning in France.

They are only terrorists when the republicans decide to call them that. Now if there were transgenders or gays attacking people..... That would be like Fox News terror headline bolded, italic, double underlined flashing kind of terror?

They are terrorists when they decide to use violence against other people because they share different beliefs or opinions.
No group, race or religion is immune from producing terrorists. So if transgenders or gays decide to start shooting people up who disagree with them... then yes, they are terrorists.
Right now though... the vast majority of terrorist attack comes from one particular demographic...
To ignore this is simply foolish.

I can tell you that I for one would feel much better about the refugees coming in if they were more willing in general to assimilate to our culture/way of life. Of course most do... but others don't. We need some type of recourse once we realize this to quickly deal with the radicalization issue.
Until they become citizens... they are guests here... nothing more. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground