Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The "Truth" Behind Math Investigations - Petition

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
GCan 11
Denise C 17
Fiona 1
Lilteapot 1
cmi 1
Fallon 1
Fancy 16
planemom 3
FishinKim 1
coach'sgirl 2
momofthreeatascosita 4
qpc 2
Zionist NightOwl 8
Bellarue 1
Mabbers 1
$AshleyThePrincess$ 1
txmama 2
2girlygirls 1
AudreyO 1
ghostpost 6
Astro King 2
reh6110 1
~sassy~ 1
SleightOfHand 1
rEVOLution 5
OH SNAP! 1
Mommyto3kiddos 1
Hope 2
Allimama 1
Squareduck 1
KU OldTimer 1
ohmygoodness 4
iheartboxers 3
N.S. Sherlock 2
~*~ 1
my2boyskw 11
smarterthanu 8
it'sme 1
lucysmom 2
aggie75790 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Start googling math invetigations. This is what our students are being taught and it is useless. Look at this petition I found. I say let's investigate further and start our petition to HISD. In the meantime, we need to email our discontent with this "new math" to the person in charge of this. November 2, 2008 Update: Well over 1350 PW County citizens have petitioned PWCS and the PW School Board for choice in our schools; the right to an appropriate mathematics education for our children - not a remedial program based on fringe ideology with a record of failure across the nation. PWCS continues to force "Investigations Math" on all children. Spring 2008 math test scores showed a precipitous drop in performance for "Investigations Math" 3d graders while 4th and 5th grade scores under traditional math continued to excel. To date, the Board and the PWCS administration refuses to allow instruction using traditional math texts and methods as primary materials in K-4 classrooms. As an oversight body elected to represent PWCS parents, the School Board has yet to act and hold the PWCS administration accountable for a text selection process that appears to have skirted state law, PWCS Policy, and Regulations. Please join us in our charge to teach math right in PWCS! -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- To: Prince William County School Board and Superintendent of Schools In 2006, PWCS mandated countywide implementation of a controversial “reform math” program known as TERC “Investigations in Number, Data, and Space”. This mandate makes “Investigations” the only allowable K-5 core elementary math instruction program in PWCS. Instead of teacher-led instruction for math mastery using quality traditional texts and materials, “reformist” programs like "Investigations" abandon proven approaches to the teaching of fundamentals and instead promote “self-discovery” of math concepts by children. Renowned mathematicians, university professors, engineers, scientists, parents and individuals who use, advance, and rely upon mathematics in their careers and daily lives have condemned programs like TERC “Investigations” which abandon teaching of proven math fundamentals to elementary school children. Of all the elementary school math programs listed by the Virginia Department of Education (VDOE), “Investigations” least adequately supports the Virginia mathematics Standards of Learning (SOLs) and is excluded by VDOE for Grade 5 due to its inadequacy. “Investigations” has an ongoing record of failure across the United States. Math experts from Harvard and Stanford University assess such “reformist” math programs as falling short of giving students the essential mathematics skills to reason accurately, and regard “Investigations” as especially deficient – resulting in children falling roughly two years behind where they should be by the end of fifth grade (as referenced through the website: http://www.pwcteachmathright.com). DOCUMENTED DEFICIENCIES OF “Investigations”: • DOES NOT teach proven standard, simple efficient and effective methods of solving mathematics problems. • DOES NOT promote mastery of basic arithmetic facts. • DOES NOT teach mastery of multiplication tables. • DOES NOT teach simple long division. • DOES NOT provide sufficient practice for children to master math concepts and applications. • DOES overemphasize the use of calculators. • DOES rely on “group think” and “discovery” by children vice individual mastery through teacher instruction and quality materials. • DOES progress at a remedial pace. The overwhelming majority of Prince William County elementary school students were excelling in traditional mathematics prior to implementation of “Investigations.” This is evidenced by PWCS annual average grade 3 and 5 SOL scores for the last several years and the nearly 50\% of all PWCS elementary school students who, in the last two years running, scored high enough in annual SOL testing to qualify for advanced/extended mathematics programs in middle school (http://www.doe.virginia.gov). PWCS abandoned a successful, proven traditional approach to math education and replaced it with “Investigations.” PWCS continues to invest tax dollars in an experiment on the county’s elementary school children. Given the nationwide failures of “Investigations” and programs like it, we are not willing to allow PWCS to gamble with our children’s mathematics educational future. For the benefit of our children, our school district, and our community, we, the undersigned parents and citizens of Prince William County, Virginia, hereby formally request PWCS remove “Investigations” from PWCS core elementary mathematics instruction. We specifically request that PWCS: • Stop adoption and/or further implementation of “Investigations” beyond the current 2007-2008 school year. • Remove "Investigations" as the core PWCS elementary math program no later than the start of the 2008-2009 school year. • Allow PWCS parents to “opt out” of “Investigations” immediately and be provided with an appropriate traditional mathematics education for their children – in every PWCS elementary school – using either the legacy PWCS traditional core mathematics courseware or any of the top four recommended traditional elementary math text/materials series approved by VDOE (Harcourt Math, Houghton Mifflin Math, Scott-Foresman Addison Wesley Mathematics, or Saxon Math). • Offer immediate summer remediation for students whose parents assess their children have not received sufficient and appropriate grade level instruction in basic math facts and standard arithmetic algorithms under “Investigations” so PWCS children have an opportunity to "catch back up" in math to where they would have been under a sound traditional math program.  

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

I'm in. 

whatchamacallit --- 18 years ago -

There was another thread about this today, did you see it? 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

I say let's investigate further and start our petition to HISD. In the meantime, we need to email our discontent with this "new math" to the person in charge of this. I'm in. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

That's why I want to know if Humble ISD chose this math or if it was chosen by the state. 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

I went to Math night tonite. Not one single teacher agrees with it. It was not chosen by the State. It was chosen by HISD. There was another thread about this today, did you see it? That one went off all different directions. This one is to start a petition. 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Rev, I will email the person that created the above petition to get his permission to use his verbage but changed of course to HISD. In the meantime, contact person in administration is: Wendy Gustafson Coordinator, Math wendy.gustafson@humble.k12.tx.us 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

would someone else like to join me and rev on writing a peition up? 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

I will gladly sign this, and I'll make sure the petition gets around our school! I hate this "new" math. The kids are being done a disservice with this crap. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

I will sign this. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

I will gladly sign this, and I'll make sure the petition gets around our school! I hate this "new" math. The kids are being done a disservice with this crap. Ditto!!! 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

They are not teaching concepts and basic memorization first. You're so on the mark. By 3rd grade, I already memorized my multiplication table but seems like my kid's still working on addition/subtraction. He knows some of his multiplication but that's because he's learning at home. 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

I was a victim of "new math" years ago. I transferred to a gifted and talented program in 5th grade and they were teaching CSMP. It seems very, very similar to what's being discussed here: Link to wiki about CSMP You have got to check the link. I remember wondering what in the world a "mini computer" was and being treated like it was just soooooooo obvious and that if I couldn't get it, I obviously didn't deserve to be there. It was AWFUL! I went from learning basic fundamentals of math to some weird "logic" crap that made absolutely no sense to me. The other students had been doing it a couple of years already, but I was treated like a complete idiot because I just couldn't understand it. Because of it, I didn't learn fractions, decimals, and other basic math concepts until I took remedial math in community college. I just barely managed to scrape by in middle school and high school math classes because of it. I can vouch from personal experience that these methods DO NOT WORK. I can't believe they're even bringing this stuff back around after over 20 years. By the way, be very wary of putting your kid in any gifted and talented program. I stayed in special schools for gifted and talented kids until my freshman year, and they do nothing but turn your kids into guinea pigs for crackpot programs like these. We had to learn to "channel our energy" in art class, and my English teacher was always talking about her stupid new age crystals. The kicker is that this was a public school, just a magnet. 

coach'sgirl --- 18 years ago -

I am in on whatever it takes to get rid of the program. What do we do and where do we start? I think I am going to start by sending the video and above paragraph to my son's Principal and Wendy Gustafson. 

AudreyO --- 18 years ago -

I'll sign it even if I'm in NCISD. Are they doing this fuzzy math too? Anyone know? 

N.S. Sherlock --- 18 years ago -

I was at dinner last night with a co-worker and his wife who is an elementary teacher in the district. She said that there is so much wrong with this approach for several reasons. She said that the district has "math consultants" on the payroll who are basically former teachers (another place where our tax money could be saved) that come to their campuses and tell them how they should teaching this stuff. She said the teachers are not happy about it but are not in a position to go against the consultants because the district has a paid a lot for the training, materials and of course, the salaries of these math consultants. Not to mention, she said not only do the teachers not buy into this method of teaching, she said it hard to teach something so new to the teachers themselves. I felt her frustration as she said kids are still counting on their fingers and do not have basic concepts of their facts or multiplication tables. She said that maybe for some students it is a good approach, but in the meantime, other kids are going though the grades without a strong foundation in fundamental math. it was obvious she would like to chuck the whole thing..but again, she said these math consultants are preaching that this is the way to teach it and the district isn't going to back down. 

coach'sgirl --- 18 years ago -

The more I read about all this the more angry I am getting!!! 

FishinKim --- 18 years ago -

I'm in! 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

Not to mention, she said not only do the teachers not buy into this method of teaching, she said it hard to teach something so new to the teachers themselves. That's the impression that my son's teacher gave me. That she's learning about this new method at the same time she's trying to teach it to the students. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I think I am going to start by sending the video and above paragraph to my son's Principal and Wendy Gustafson. I just sent it to our teacher also. I would like to hear how she feels about it. I'll definitely sign the petition. 

KU OldTimer --- 18 years ago -

Tell me where to sign and I will sign it! 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Ok, I'm going to take all your guys comments and testomonials (if that's ok) so I can start writing up the petition. I could not find ONE teacher that approves of this crap. Even the teacher's own children are struggling to understand it. 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Ok, first step. I emailed the writer of the above petition to ask his permission to use it here. Next step. A teacher friend of mine is checking with State to see how many school districts are using this method. HISD is claiming 95%. Step 3. Anyone have connections with the Observer so we can bring this to John Q. Public's attention? 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I'm going to take all your guys comments and testomonials (if that's ok) so Feel free. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Maybe even invite someone from the Observer to view the KU threads about it. 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Maybe even invite someone from the Observer to view the KU threads about it. Good idea Fancy. Shall we start forwarding this link to them? 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Does anyone have a good contact at the Observer? 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

Matt Huisman at Observer handles HISD related stuff. He can be reached at mhuisman@hcnonline.com 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Thanks GCan. So what do you need from us Denise? Take the lead on this project. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

More info on Math Investigations. Math Investigations 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

ok...I just emailed Channel 2 so I will copy that email and mail Matt. Thanks Gcan! I have also already emailed the original writer and need to find out when Humble started this new crap..I mean Math. I will ask today when I go to school. Have to do on the sly though because teacher's are worried they will loose their job if they talk about it. 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Can someone contact our State Region office thru TEA and find out what we can do to address this with them as they oversee the school districts? 

Fiona --- 18 years ago -

I will sign, the new math is so confusing my dd who is good at math cannot get all this grouping and cluster mess but she can tell you the answer and get it marked wrong because she can't write out all the other mess. 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Next step. Does anyone want to write a letter addressing this to the Houston Chronicle. I can but maybe someone else would like to? 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Ok, need input from College Professors. Anyone want to help there? 

~*~ --- 18 years ago -

The "Truth" Behind Math Investigations - Petition Am I the only one that saw this as The "Truth" Behind Meth Investigations - Petition 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

Interesting article I ran across---I don't know if this is referencing the math program Humble uses, but it sounds a lot like it. According to an analysis of recent math textbook selections, Texas school districts have overwhelmingly rejected the latest fad in math instruction. Sometimes called "fuzzy math," "whole math," and "new new math," textbooks based on this pedagogical approach received only 4% of the textbook orders for second grade math, 2% for fifth grade math, and 5.6% for seventh grade math. Ironically, those promoting this approach refer to it as "standards-based math." This rejection is particularly significant given the fact that this instructional approach was heavily promoted throughout the state by the Texas Statewide Systemic Initiative (SSI), with funding from the National Science Foundation, operated by the Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin -- both publicly funded by tax dollars. "We are happy to see this educational fad bite the Texas dust. Fuzzy math has been shown to hurt children academically, especially disadvantaged and minority students. Thanks to discerning textbook committees in our school districts, parents can breathe a sigh of relief," commented J. C. Bowman, TPPF Director of Research. Parents should watch for signs that their children are enrolled in "standards-based" math programs when students: Direct their own learning; work in groups to teach one another; construct their own math language, facts, and computations; are not taught or required to memorize facts or formulas; are taught to use calculators as the first and primary form of computation; and, are taught that deriving correct solutions lacks importance. TPPF, along with two other organizations Mathematically Correct and Education Connection of Texas released an analysis earlier this year to provide parents and school officials the information needed to make informed selections of elementary and middle school math textbooks. The analysis was sent to all school districts and local school board members throughout Texas and encouraged use of a "classical" instructional approach characterized by curricula that is taught directly, systematically, and incrementally in small structured and guided steps that progress from basic to more complex learning; instruction focused on specific academic content (not process or outcomes); repetition, practice, and memorization used used to derive automaticity; and students receive immediate feedback and correction. The "fuzzy math" textbooks that were unsuccessfully promoted by the Statewide Systemic Initiative and Charles A. Dana Center were: (second grade books) Everyday Mathematics published by Everyday Learning Corporation; and Investigations in Number, Data and Space published by Addison Wesley Longman; (fifth grade books) Everyday Mathematics; and Investigations in Number, Data and Space; (seventh grade books) Math Thematics published by McDougal Littell; and Connected Mathematics published by Addison Wesley Longman. 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin WOW! Can someone contact this place and find out if this is indeed the same math HISD is teaching? Come on folks, Fancy and I can't do it all. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

What textbook curriculum does HISD use now for its elementary schools? Is it the Investigations in Number, Data and Space? 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

I'll sign. Irregardless of what the district's ultimate decision is, I think they need to know how parents and teachers feel. My only problem with today's education is that they're catering to the kids. It really doesn't take much to pass a class these days. Believe me. Oldest ds is fixing to graduate, and I don't know how in the hell he's pulled it off. (I'll keep my mouth shut on that one though.) :D 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground