Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

5 Freedoms You'd Lose in Health Care Reform

who's talking here?

marthas attic 7
randyjet 3
qpc 1
AuthorMan 3
momof2girls 1
david 1
justforfun 2
~sassy~ 2
rEVOLution 1
Perfection 2
fishlady 1
Wilstar77 1
zapper007 2
genxer 1
wordman777 1
james osterberg 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

If you read the fine print in the Congressional plans, you'll find that a lot of cherished aspects of the current system would disappear. In promoting his health-care agenda, President Obama has repeatedly reassured Americans that they can keep their existing health plans -- and that the benefits and access they prize will be enhanced through reform. A close reading of the two main bills, one backed by Democrats in the House and the other issued by Sen. Edward Kennedy's Health committee, contradict the President's assurances. To be sure, it isn't easy to comb through their 2,000 pages of tortured legal language. But page by page, the bills reveal a web of restrictions, fines, and mandates that would radically change your health-care coverage. If you prize choosing your own cardiologist or urologist under your company's Preferred Provider Organization plan (PPO), if your employer rewards your non-smoking, healthy lifestyle with reduced premiums, if you love the bargain Health Savings Account (HSA) that insures you just for the essentials, or if you simply take comfort in the freedom to spend your own money for a policy that covers the newest drugs and diagnostic tests -- you may be shocked to learn that you could lose all of those good things under the rules proposed in the two bills that herald a health-care revolution. In short, the Obama platform would mandate extremely full, expensive, and highly subsidized coverage -- including a lot of benefits people would never pay for with their own money -- but deliver it through a highly restrictive, HMO-style plan that will determine what care and tests you can and can't have. It's a revolution, all right, but in the wrong direction. Let's explore the five freedoms that Americans would lose under Obamacare: 1. Freedom to choose what's in your plan The bills in both houses require that Americans purchase insurance through "qualified" plans offered by health-care "exchanges" that would be set up in each state. The rub is that the plans can't really compete based on what they offer. The reason: The federal government will impose a minimum list of benefits that each plan is required to offer. Today, many states require these "standard benefits packages" -- and they're a major cause for the rise in health-care costs. Every group, from chiropractors to alcohol-abuse counselors, do lobbying to get included. Connecticut, for example, requires reimbursement for hair transplants, hearing aids, and in vitro fertilization. The Senate bill would require coverage for prescription drugs, mental-health benefits, and substance-abuse services. It also requires policies to insure "children" until the age of 26. That's just the starting list. The bills would allow the Department of Health and Human Services to add to the list of required benefits, based on recommendations from a committee of experts. Americans, therefore, wouldn't even know what's in their plans and what they're required to pay for, directly or indirectly, until after the bills become law. 2. Freedom to be rewarded for healthy living, or pay your real costs As with the previous example, the Obama plan enshrines into federal law one of the worst features of state legislation: community rating. Eleven states, ranging from New York to Oregon, have some form of community rating. In its purest form, community rating requires that all patients pay the same rates for their level of coverage regardless of their age or medical condition. Americans with pre-existing conditions need subsidies under any plan, but community rating is a dubious way to bring fairness to health care. The reason is twofold: First, it forces young people, who typically have lower incomes than older workers, to pay far more than their actual cost, and gives older workers, who can afford to pay more, a big discount. The state laws gouging the young are a major reason so many of them have joined the ranks of uninsured. Under the Senate plan, insurers would be barred from charging any more than twice as much for one patient vs. any other patient with the same coverage. So if a 20-year-old who costs just $800 a year to insure is forced to pay $2,500, a 62-year-old who costs $7,500 would pay no more than $5,000. Second, the bills would ban insurers from charging differing premiums based on the health of their customers. Again, that's understandable for folks with diabetes or cancer. But the bills would bar rewarding people who pursue a healthy lifestyle of exercise or a cholesterol-conscious diet. That's hardly a formula for lower costs. It's as if car insurers had to charge the same rates to safe drivers as to chronic speeders with a history of accidents. 3. Freedom to choose high-deductible coverage The bills threaten to eliminate the one part of the market truly driven by consumers spending their own money. That's what makes a market, and health care needs more of it, not less. Hundreds of companies now offer Health Savings Accounts to about 5 million employees. Those workers deposit tax-free money in the accounts and get a matching contribution from their employer. They can use the funds to buy a high-deductible plan -- say for major medical costs over $12,000. Preventive care is reimbursed, but patients pay all other routine doctor visits and tests with their own money from the HSA account. As a result, HSA users are far more cost-conscious than customers who are reimbursed for the majority of their care. The bills seriously endanger the trend toward consumer-driven care in general. By requiring minimum packages, they would prevent patients from choosing stripped-down plans that cover only major medical expenses. "The government could set extremely low deductibles that would eliminate HSAs," says John Goodman of the National Center for Policy Analysis, a free-market research group. "And they could do it after the bills are passed." 4. Freedom to keep your existing plan This is the freedom that the President keeps emphasizing. Yet the bills appear to say otherwise. It's worth diving into the weeds -- the territory where most pundits and politicians don't seem to have ventured. The legislation divides the insured into two main groups, and those two groups are treated differently with respect to their current plans. The first are employees covered by the Employee Retirement Security Act of 1974. ERISA regulates companies that are self-insured, meaning they pay claims out of their cash flow, and don't have real insurance. Those are the GEs and Time Warners and most other big companies. The House bill states that employees covered by ERISA plans are "grandfathered." Under ERISA, the plans can do pretty much what they want -- they're exempt from standard packages and community rating and can reward employees for healthy lifestyles even in restrictive states. But read on. The bill gives ERISA employers a five-year grace period when they can keep offering plans free from the restrictions of the "qualified" policies offered on the exchanges. But after five years, they would have to offer only approved plans, with the myriad rules we've already discussed. So for Americans in large corporations, "keeping your own plan" has a strict deadline. In five years, like it or not, you'll get dumped into the exchange. As we'll see, it could happen a lot earlier. The outlook is worse for the second group. It encompasses employees who aren't under ERISA but get actual insurance either on their own or through small businesses. After the legislation passes, all insurers that offer a wide range of plans to these employees will be forced to offer only "qualified" plans to new customers, via the exchanges. The employees who got their coverage before the law goes into effect can keep their plans, but once again, there's a catch. If the plan changes in any way -- by altering co-pays, deductibles, or even switching coverage for this or that drug -- the employee must drop out and shop through the exchange. Since these plans generally change their policies every year, it's likely that millions of employees will lose their plans in 12 months. 5. Freedom to choose your doctors The Senate bill requires that Americans buying through the exchanges -- and as we've seen, that will soon be most Americans -- must get their care through something called "medical home." Medical home is similar to an HMO. You're assigned a primary care doctor, and the doctor controls your access to specialists. The primary care physicians will decide which services, like MRIs and other diagnostic scans, are best for you, and will decide when you really need to see a cardiologists or orthopedists. Under the proposals, the gatekeepers would theoretically guide patients to tests and treatments that have proved most cost-effective. The danger is that doctors will be financially rewarded for denying care, as were HMO physicians more than a decade ago. It was consumer outrage over despotic gatekeepers that made the HMOs so unpopular, and killed what was billed as the solution to America's health-care cost explosion. The bills do not specifically rule out fee-for-service plans as options to be offered through the exchanges. But remember, those plans -- if they exist -- would be barred from charging sick or elderly patients more than young and healthy ones. So patients would be inclined to game the system, staying in the HMO while they're healthy and switching to fee-for-service when they become seriously ill. "That would kill fee-for-service in a hurry," says Goodman. In reality, the flexible, employer-based plans that now dominate the landscape, and that Americans so cherish, could disappear far faster than the 5 year "grace period" that's barely being discussed. Companies would have the option of paying an 8% payroll tax into a fund that pays for coverage for Americans who aren't covered by their employers. It won't happen right away -- large companies must wait a couple of years before they opt out. But it will happen, since it's likely that the tax will rise a lot more slowly than corporate health-care costs, especially since they'll be lobbying Washington to keep the tax under control in the righteous name of job creation. The best solution is to move to a let-freedom-ring regime of high deductibles, no community rating, no standard benefits, and cross-state shopping for bargains (another market-based reform that's strictly taboo in the bills). I'll propose my own solution in another piece soon on Fortune.com. For now, we suffer with a flawed health-care system, but we still have our Five Freedoms. Call them the Five Endangered Freedoms.  

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

We aren't going to lose anything. We are going to get everything we want, no waiting and total control over our healthcare. Yup, that's right. I'm dreaming LOL 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

lol chunk. This health care plan is gonna be a whole lotta nuthin' for a whole lotta somethin'....you just wait! 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

We need to expand medicaid for those who can't afford care....at least medicaid is a good plan. Sh*t, poor folk on medicaid get gastric by pass and lap band.....my insurance doesn't even cover that for me! Expand what we know, leave this crap alone! 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

This country is headed in the wrong direction at a rapid speed. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

1. Freedom to choose what's in your plan I have NEVER had that choice in all my years of being insured. 2. Freedom to be rewarded for healthy living, or pay your real costs That is freedom to make others who are old, sick, or overweight,or don't run five miles a day, to be without insurance. 3. Freedom to choose high-deductible coverage That is a miniscule part of the population and I have never had that either. Since these plans generally change their policies every year, Good reason for the plans to NOT change every year, don't you think? Even better it will force more competition among companies. You ARE in favor of competition aren't you? 5. Freedom to choose your doctors I guess you haven't been insured in any health plan that I have had. That is the SAME feature in 90% of plans that I know of where you have the same kind of freedom that this plan offers. Right now you have NO freedom to choose doctors, unless you can pay for it yourself. In which case, you will still be able to do whatever you want. When I had health insurance I HAD to see my primary care doctor to get to see ANY other specialist. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

or pay your real costs If you get ill with ANY insurance, YOU NEVER pay the REAL costs! If you come down with cancer, the amount of money you paid in premiums will NEVER cover what will be paid out in your care. That is the whole point of insurance. To have a large enough pool of premium payers so that when one gets ill and needs the care, the rest pay for that care through THEIR premiums. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

randyjet, I am really sorry you are this bitter. Must be hard never being happy. 

qpc --- 17 years ago -

Right now you have NO freedom to choose doctors, unless you can pay for it yourself. The insurance that we have, we have the option of seeing a specialist whenever we want without prior referal from a primary care doctor. We pay a $35 copay instead of a $20 one. For MY family, this is extremely important. Two of my sons have hemophilia, where their blood does not clot. We are free to see the hematologist whenever we need to without the involvement of a primary care physician (who knows self-admittedly VERY little about hemophilia). Sometimes, when my sons have a potentially very serious injury, such as a head injury, they need to see the hematologist quickly. Right now, I can call the hematology clinic and be seen immediately. I hate to think of the day when we have to wait for business hours of the PCP and physically go see him before we can see the hematologist. Waiting can sometimes mean serious consequenses. Even when it is bleeding into the joint and not life threatening, quick treatment means the difference between a normal future or one of severe physical disability as the blood disinegrates the joints. I watched my dad go through the debilitating process of this disease and it is not fun. The treatments are far superior now, but only if we have access to them. The hematology clinic sees us much faster than the ER too, which even at TX Children's, doesn't always know how to appropriately treat their condition. Needless to say, loss of doctor choice and the already Obama-admitted rationing that will take place scares me for the future of my sons' health. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Right now you have NO freedom to choose doctors, unless you can pay for it yourself. The insurance that we have, we have the option of seeing a specialist whenever we want without prior referal from a primary care doctor. We pay a $35 copay instead of a $20 one. That is how ours is too. We don't have to ask our primary care doctor because we choose who we want. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

We are free to see the hematologist whenever we need to without the involvement of a primary care physician I assume your hematologist is in the group of approved doctors. In your case, when I had health insurance, I would not have to pay any more to go directly to the specialist for an on going condition. I didn't even have to go to my PCP when my knee went. I just called my insurer and told them what I needed, and they approved going direct. I had to use the doctors on the list though. It STILL took over two months before I could get it taken care of at Kingwood. You are lucky you live in a place like Houston and have health insurance. If you didn't, you would be SOL. 

david --- 17 years ago -

your forgot the most important freedom to attain healthcare when your elderly, did a bypass sorry your 65, i cant believe this one tbing doesnt worry randy, he will be in the same boat as he is now complaining and bitter, then he will jump ship to the right becaue they offer a better health care option 

genxer --- 17 years ago -

Right now you have NO freedom to choose doctors, unless you can pay for it yourself. I choose what ever doctor i want Picked the PPO and have never had one problem and pay $50 extra a month. We are just heading off a cliff I told my Tea party group they needed to call Cornyn's office today. He was on the list of on the fence. I am so sick of this i gave them a real big chewing out that he even landed on this list. Same for poe's office after i got an email polling me on what i think about health care. I"m on your email list what do you think i think about health care...the lady thought that was very funny 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

From the other thread: Yup, and Congressman Conyers stated today that the health proposal is 2,000 pages that no one can read in two days and would need two lawyers to help out. Joke butt libs make me ill. This crap is not going to happen. We are finally standing up to the lunacy of a non-qualified rookie America hater and his unproud to be American wife. The dems tried to push this piece of crap by the American people. The budget office turned a light on their phony numbers and scared the hell out of people. More are getting mad. o's favorable below 50% and falling. Hey obomination, leave my country alone. Health care needs a tune-up, not radical brain surgery. Idiot. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

Our healthcare plan offers us everything we need. We do not need a referal, we go to who we want. WE make those decisions not the government. 

zapper007 --- 17 years ago -

This another bullsh*t blog post. Wake up KUers. Use your brains and not your mouths to spresd this crap... Read the DRAFT bills before beleiving any of these bloggers!!!!!!! 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

This another bullsh*t blog post. Wake up KUers. Use your brains and not your mouths to spresd this crap... Read the DRAFT bills before beleiving any of these bloggers!!!!!!! Why don't you read it and stop living in lala land! 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

Also this information was not from "some blogger" it was from Fortune 500.. 

zapper007 --- 17 years ago -

Why don't you read it and stop living in lala land! I have read it. Have you - oh yea!!! 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

This another bullsh*t blog post. You heard that on KOS, Huffington Post or read it in the new york times, huh? 

wordman777 --- 17 years ago -

you would have the right to wait 6 months for a doctor appointment, longer for surgery. you would be denied many life saving treatments. the older you are the less likely you are to be treated at all and when all else fails , you would have the right to die young without proper healthcare...p.s.- ya still have to pay your taxes........ 

momof2girls --- 17 years ago -

when are people going to see we are LOSING rights rather than gaining anything under this plan? 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

As long as we all keep fighting about instead of sending these threads to our Non Representing Representatives, they will just pass the bill and think they were doing the right thing since no one spoke out against it. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

If you read the fine print in the Congressional plans, DID YOU READ IT ? NO,All you did was paste an article. So now it's gospel according to Martha 

fishlady --- 17 years ago -

I read this yesterday on yahoo news and it was quoted as being from fortune 500..... Right now I have a choice to choose what doctor with my co pay, I also have a health care spending account I can pay for medical expenses out of. I like my right to choose 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

So now it's gospel according to Martha Not according to me, but I think its of value, if you do not wish to believe it, just stick your head back in the sand. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

link title 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

At least we elephants know when to be concerned. You jackasses might want to heed the warning signs. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

At least we elephants know when to be concerned. You jackasses might want to heed the warning signs. lol.. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground