Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Who will Texas' Medicaid cuts hurt? All of us

who's talking here?

Empty Nest 2
smartypants 5
planemom 1
ukchristine 1
Perfection 8
Cookin' Queen 1
Nightstorm 1
jmbtx78 2
PS 2
ladyjane 3
evolved 1
james osterberg 1
Gigix4 2
SighFiGurl 2
Biggie Smalls 1
Bornanraisedkw 4
Clovis 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

"...The proposal to cut reimbursements paid to Medicaid providers by 10 percent is pure pound-foolishness. And its horrifying long-term costs will hit us all.

For most of us, Medicaid seems far from our everyday lives; we think of it as a program that covers people who've been poor, or will be poor, all their lives.

But actually, Medicaid generally winds up helping people who spend most of their days in the middle class. According to the Texas Hospital Association, 50 percent - half! - of all the babies delivered in Texas are billed to the program. And according to the AARP, Medicaid covers two-thirds of the elderly in nursing homes.

"The older you get, the more likely you are to be poor," Bob Jackson, AARP Texas state director, explained to us recently. "And nursing home care is expensive. People who've been good middle-class taxpayers all their lives, who never expected to be poor, end up on Medicaid."

The 10 percent cuts would be plenty awful if they only meant that those babies and grandmas would receive 10 percent less of the medical care they need: 10 percent fewer vaccinations, 10 percent less help avoiding bedsores. But the actual effects would be even more painful — and more widespread.

Texas already runs one of the leanest Medicaid reimbursement programs - one so lean that it doesn't cover the actual cost of treating Medicaid patients. Doctors already lose money on those patients; many simply can't afford to accept them. And further cuts could mean that far more would have to stop accepting Medicaid.

The upshot? If pregnant women can't find a doctor who'll see them, they're likely to skip prenatal care — and thus, more likely to suffer serious problems with their pregnancies or give birth to a premature baby. Those intensive-care outcomes aren't just tragic; they're far more expensive than prevention. And we taxpayers will end up paying for them.

Even babies and mothers-to-be lucky enough to have insurance would be affected. Medicaid cuts, the hospital association says, would cause some OB/GYN wards to close entirely. Those closures would hit rural places hardest, leaving towns without a hospital ready to deliver babies. One likely closing in the Panhandle, for instance, would mean that a woman could go into labor more than a hundred miles from a maternity ward.

The cutbacks would hit the elderly just as cruelly — and with equally little in likely cost savings. Consider Medicaid's Primary Home Care program, which pays for an attendant to do the stuff that allows a fragile person to continue living at home: help with things like shopping, tracking medicines or bathing.

Cutting the Medicaid reimbursement makes it likely that agencies wouldn't be able to pay those home health care workers even minimum wage, the AARP points out; and since it's illegal to pay less, agencies would have to stop providing the service. Without home help, a semi-self-sufficient senior would likely be propelled into a nursing home — which would cost Medicaid three times as much.

Of course, that's assuming that a nursing home could be found. Slashed reimbursements, the AARP says, means that many long-term care facilities would also stop accepting Medicaid patients. The elderly who outlive their assets - the blind, the Alzheimer's-addled, the wheelchair-bound — would be left to shift for themselves.

Texas can't afford to treat its babies and its elderly so badly. It's time to tap that rainy-day fund. Spending those pennies will save us pounds. And lives."

http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/editorial/7410555.html

Like it or not, we are all connected. When a group of people are left out in the cold, all of us will feel it. 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

Sad ... just so sad.
I bit the bullet last year and bought into a long term care insurance policy. It was thru a company AARP recognizes as reliable and dependable.
Yeah, it costs a little but fortunately, the premiums are tax deductable.
I would advise anybody that can possibly afford it, to look into it and of course, the younger you, the less expensive it is. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

So what do you propose to do to balance the budget? 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

I don't know Chunky but it makes my head swim when I think about those that abuse the system. What concerns me the most are those that rely on the system for extended periods to support them and don't bother to go out to try to get a job ... any job to become self-supporting. It's not just the illegals doing that.
I hear the ad on tv nearly every day about some woman that was denied ss disability ss benefits because she has a knot on her wrist and can't work so she hires this bigtime tv lawyer. I call BS - there are jobs she can do but why should she if the "system" will support her?
Okay - off my soapbox. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

There are also lawsuits that require certain services be provided to specific groups at a greater percentage and benefit level than to other groups. To pay for these lawsuit benefits services to the vast majority of recipients has to occur.

Is it fair, nope but the parties that brought the lawsuits didn't care about fair. They simply wanted what they wanted and didn't care who had to pay it.

Medicaid has a limited pool of money and with two lawsuits taking a preponderance of the funds it leaves less for all others to share.

But don't worry the plaintiffs attorneys made sure they got their money from the State. 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

This may not be the answer, but the Texas "Rainy Day" fund could help fill in some gaps. The comptroller estimates the fund will have $9.4 billion available for the 2012-13 budget.

However, Perry doesn't want to touch this:

"...The Texas Constitution says money from the fund can be spent to “prevent or eliminate a temporary cash deficiency in general revenue.” With the state facing a budget shortfall estimated somewhere between $15 billion and $27 billion, some say if it ain't raining now, it ain't ever going to.

But Gov. Rick Perry has said repeatedly he doesn't want to use the fund, and the initial budgets filed by the House and Senate leave it untouched.

Those opposed to drawing from the fund now make a couple of arguments. One is that nobody knows for sure how long this economic downturn will last. If the fund is sucked dry, there will be nothing left if things get worse or if the economy doesn’t recover quickly enough. Another argument is that drawing too deeply from the fund could hurt Texas’ bond rating.

But Horacio Aldrete-Sanchez, a credit analyst with Standard & Poor's, says using the Rainy Day Fund will not necessarily hurt Texas’ relatively strong bond rating as long as the state adopts measures “that over the long term would put the state in a position where it can eventually restore the fund balance or at least not resort to the use of the Rainy Day Fund.”

Using the fund to help balance the budget requires a two-thirds vote from lawmakers. The fund can also be tapped in the middle of the biennial budget if the comptroller says a sudden budget deficit has developed. That would require a three-fifths vote from lawmakers.

Bottom line: Tapping the fund — or not — is a political decision."

http://www.texastribune.org/texas-taxes/rainy-day-fund/texplainer-what-is-texass-rainy-day-fund-for/ 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

So sad. As always...who do they line up first.... The young and the old. Those without voices and defenseless. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

The proposal to cut reimbursements paid to Medicaid providers by 10 percent is pure pound-foolishness.

Without home help, a semi-self-sufficient senior would likely be propelled into a nursing home — which would cost Medicaid three times as much.

Supreme stupidity! but I'm sure private charity will pick up the slack...NOT. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

The cuts are to all departments not just Medicaid. Most, if not all, were greater cuts so to they did this to kids and old first is blatantly wrong 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Actually cuts to nursing homes are cut more than the cuts to home care. But don't let facts interiupt your rant. 

PS --- 15 years ago -

Can't wait to see what RandyJet has to say about this. 

james osterberg --- 15 years ago -

Maybe this issue should be directed to Mr.Puberty. Seems like he said he was gonna do things the right way. Is anybody contacting this guy to hold him accountable? He has an email and a telephone. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

Is he on here? 

jmbtx78 --- 15 years ago -

Keep in mind here:

Medicare patients COST doctors more money than they receive. This is true of many (most) government run programs. The inefficiency and reimbursement rates are already bad as the article mentioned.

Secondly...the further and further Medicare goes into the red, the less and less likely ANYONE is to receive ANYTHING at all from the program because it's bankrupt. (kind of like social security).

People need to stop living the fantasy that the private sector needs to lose money to accommodate our government's out of control spending habits and total mismanagement of its programs. Take a look at clovis' post about the rainy day fund. The utter suggestion that money should be saved instead of spent is classified as "a political decision". Heaven forbid anyone try to save money. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

Aren't medicare and Medicaid different? 

jmbtx78 --- 15 years ago -

Aren't medicare and Medicaid different?

Gah...yes they are, and I typed the wrong one. Sorry.... 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

Lol u was confusing me... 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

People need to stop living the fantasy that the private sector needs to lose money to accommodate our government's out of control spending habits and total mismanagement of its programs.

Medicare patients COST doctors more money than they receive

It's not out of control spending when the medical care costs MORE than what is reimbursed. It what country is it out of control spending for invalids to get a wheelchair and attendent care? Maybe we should just do what they do in India and put them on a palette on the street corner to beg, alone. Then when the person has a seizure or needs to go to the bathroom they are on their own. We could take pictures so Joel Osteen could run them on a TV begathon. Adopt this grandma! Only $35 a month keeps her in diapers!

Go America! Balance that budget at ALL costs. Pffftt. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

So how much attendant care should be paid for and how much should the family provide? 

Cookin' Queen --- 15 years ago -

I was talking with a lady from Canada. She said that her mother is in a very nice government home and it only costs $300 a month. Also she didn't have to sell her paid for home and use the funds for care before the government paid for home. They keep the home for when they visit up there. She also said that her mom gets great care. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

Maybe if we weren't so hasty to jump into wars all over the globe we would have a budget like Canada's. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

So how much attendant care should be paid for and how much should the family provide?

The "family" can't go to work if they are home taking care of someone who needs round the clock supervision, help getting to doctor's appointments, bathing, not to mention some semblance of companionship once in awhile. A potential tax payer could probably afford to hire some help, but when you box the person in because they have to chose between a career and dumping a family member in a nursing home, you are cutting off your nose to spite your face. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

So everyone else should sacrifice.

Ok makes sense 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

It's not a sacrifice. We do not go around throwing people away by institutionalizing them, denying them care, and writing them off.. We stand up for what is important, the people who are most vulnerable. We sure do like all our advances in medicine that make it possible for people to live longer with medical conditions. Well, along with that goes some personal accountability, on the part of the citizens of the nation that prides itself on being the best. 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

So everyone else should sacrifice.

Yes. For our ideals. Some don't share the integrity of sacrifice and if that works for you so be it.

It's not a sacrifice. We do not go around throwing people away by institutionalizing them, denying them care, and writing them off.. We stand up for what is important, the people who are most vulnerable. We sure do like all our advances in medicine that make it possible for people to live longer with medical conditions. Well, along with that goes some personal accountability, on the part of the citizens of the nation that prides itself on being the best.

Some people do throw people away Smarty. Mostly it's the personal responsibility crowd who have no clue what that credo truly means. 

Nightstorm --- 15 years ago -

ChunkyHeifer --- 1 hours ago - quote - hide comments
So everyone else should sacrifice.

Ok makes sense




No. Wouldn't want to make you sacrifice for anyone but yourself.

If a sick person has no family or if their family needs to work a real job, we should kick the sick to the curb. F@#k 'em. As long as no one infringes on your (large) bubble. 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

The "family" can't go to work if they are home taking care of someone who needs round the clock supervision, help getting to doctor's appointments, bathing, not to mention some semblance of companionship once in awhile. A potential tax payer could probably afford to hire some help, but when you box the person in because they have to chose between a career and dumping a family member in a nursing home, you are cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Amen.


So everyone else should sacrifice.

It is a part of living in a civilized society. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

What should be cut? So far everything that has been mentioned has people saying we can't cut it. Well guess what? The government is broke. It doesn't have enough money to pay it's bills. Because elected officials have borrowed from Peter to pay Paul for years we now have to make painful choices. Even items considered necessities will be cut. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

And obviously many of you did not read the fact that nursing homes are being cut more than home care therefore institutionalizing people won't happen.

I do so enjoy watching people ignore facts and reality.

Yes there are cuts shared by all as there should be. Families will be asked to do more as they are able within the law. That will be the case with all of the cuts not just this one. But to think there won't be changes well that is simply unrealistic.

Personally I would like to see some areas left uncut but that wouldn't be fair. And isn't fairness for all at the expense of a few what we are all about? 

ladyjane --- 15 years ago -

[i]It's not out of control spending when the medical care costs MORE than what is reimbursed.

Medical costs are a factor, true, one of which is that all medical costs rise in order to carry the burden of the government's out of control spending. We can't continue to provide the level of services we have to the amount of people we have without taking a hatchet to this ponderous system.

People who work for the government can tell you, it's rare to have any incentives for efficiency. When I worked in a government job awhile ago, my supervisor told me to slow down, as I was going to raise the expectations for the department : (. Eliminating duplications of services, streamlining processes? Nope, we don't want government employees to lose their jobs.

People who provide services for Medicaid or Medicare can tell you how hard it is to get a real person to answer a question, how befuddled the billing process is, and the cost to them of hiring people to track down claims, sort through denials, and keep up with the daunting list of regulations (which, if you don't observe, will get one thrown in jail).

And the process for determining who's eligible? Heartbreaking to think of all the truly disabled people who can't get services when there are others scamming the system with no oversight. Get a "capitalist" approach going, imho, and clear the way for those who really need it. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

If they would just investigate and crack down on the waste, abuse, and fraud they could re-visit this. But the whole system is like a runaway train, taking on a life of it's own without restraint.

People should take one very important thing in to account. DO NOT depend on gov't programs for your security. Save money til you are blue in the face, then save some more. 

Biggie Smalls --- 15 years ago -

ChunkyHeifer --- 2 hours ago - quote - hide comments
I do so enjoy watching people ignore facts and reality.


You do that on a regular basis!!!!! 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Well said SighFiGurl. If the economic issues we have been facing have taught us anything it should be the importance of saving for the unexpected. 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

Maybe we should just do what they do in India and put them on a palette on the street corner to beg, alone.


Some people go through life have all the latest and greatest of things....cars, homes, vacations, gadgets.........they live a consumerism based life. They do not save for their future. Some people go through life modestly and SAVE often going without nicer things. In a civilized society we don’t want elderly people to be in that position ...of course not. But what is fair and reasonable? We all get old and some end up in horrible situations. Maybe the new health care bill should have a mandate that long term care insurance MUST be purchased. Clearly if some people cannot/will not purchase health insurance and end up costing everybody else that's not going to happen. So in the end everybody pays...in a civilized society. 

ladyjane --- 15 years ago -

No, I don't think the government should mandate that people get long-term health insurance. I'm glad we have provisions made for those who cannot handle overwhelming situations - like the parents of one or more severely disabled children who will need care their whole lives, or for people who are so severely disabled they cannot work. But right now, we're providing a full trough for all kinds of people who abuse the system - and they're often the savvy ones who know how to "work it," but the really needy ones so often get turned down. 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

If they would just investigate and crack down on the waste, abuse, and fraud they could re-visit this. But the whole system is like a runaway train, taking on a life of it's own without restraint.

The rate of fraud is about 3-10% so it isn't quite a runaway train. Fraud is also taken very seriously. There are professionals who investigate fraud (I have a friend who does this) and there are numerous toll free numbers so citizens can report fraud and it will be investigated.

That means that 90-97% are people with legitimate needs.

There is fraud in everything, from government programs to corporations, but you can't just eliminate them them all because of it. 

PS --- 15 years ago -

Medicare and Medicaid Scams Cost Taxpayers over $60 Billion a Year

So Pops, you're saying $60 Billion is chump change? Yes, let's turn a blind eye on all the thieving scumbags and lying blood suckers because it's the easy thing to do, so typical. 

ladyjane --- 15 years ago -

The rate of fraud is about 3-10% so it isn't quite a runaway train.

Where did you get that information? If that's true, those numbers must just reflect the numbers they do anything about. I can't even count how many late teens to mid-twenties single mothers I know of who live with their rich parents and receive full benefits, including food stamps, a monthly check, free medical, etc. They continue to "date" or have the daddy also live with the parents (and, of course, he appears completely off the hook), while they piddle around with keeping one class going in a junior college so they can have more benefits. I knew of a young woman who used to drop her kids off at Head Start driving a Mercedes.

And lots of times the parents don't really want the mama to marry the deadbeat dad because the gravy train will stop. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

[i]The rate of fraud is about 3-10% so it isn't quite a runaway train. Fraud is also taken very seriously. There are professionals who investigate fraud (I have a friend who does this) and there are numerous toll free numbers so citizens can report fraud and it will be investigated.

3-10%? According to government statistics I bet. Do we really expect them to be totally forth coming in telling the truth so they can be castigated before the whole country? The truth is they have lost control of Medicaid. There is NO WAY it isn't a runaway train. I bet if you targeted just one local office and studied the activity there, the abuse is rampant. There are entire generations of families abusing the system, and it's like part of the culture. Any time a "service" like this which is government run gets this big, you have big problems. I'm all for helping someone truly in need but when you make it this easy to get "free" stuff indefinitely, the loop holes and manipulation, and those willing to navigate them is astounding. And indeed becomes an industry of fraud all it's own. 

Empty Nest --- 15 years ago -

But right now, we're providing a full trough for all kinds of people who abuse the system - and they're often the savvy ones who know how to "work it," but the really needy ones so often get turned down.

So true! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground