Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Supreme Court Upholds Arizona Law Penalizing Businesses For Hiring Illegal Immigrants

who's talking here?

randyjet 3
Evan Carroll 1
wayward1 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
justforfun 2
voice of reason 1
twisty 1
evolved 1
james osterberg 1
Dr Aborto 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 8
Butterfly Kisses 2
Puss In Boots 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

WASHINGTON -- The Supreme Court has sustained Arizona's law that penalizes businesses for hiring workers who are in the United States illegally, rejecting arguments that states have no role in immigration matters.

By a 5-3 vote, the court said Thursday that federal immigration law gives states the authority to impose sanctions on employers who hire unauthorized workers.

The decision upholding the validity of the 2007 law comes as the state is appealing a ruling that blocked key components of a second, more controversial Arizona immigration enforcement law. Thursday's decision applies only to business licenses and does not signal how the high court might rule if the other law comes before it.

Chief Justice John Roberts, writing for a majority made up of Republican-appointed justices, said the Arizona's employer sanctions law "falls well within the confines of the authority Congress chose to leave to the states."

Justices Stephen Breyer, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor, all Democratic appointees, dissented. The fourth Democratic appointee, Justice Elena Kagan, did not participate in the case because she worked on it while serving as President Barack Obama's solicitor general

Breyer said the Arizona law upsets a balance in federal law between dissuading employers from hiring illegal workers and ensuring that people are not discriminated against because they may speak with an accent or look like they might be immigrants.

Employers "will hesitate to hire those they fear will turn out to lack the right to work in the United States," he said.

.Business interests and civil liberties groups challenged the law, backed by the Obama administration.

The measure was signed into law in 2007 by Democrat Janet Napolitano, then the governor of Arizona and now the administration's Homeland Security secretary. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

The highly anticipated decision keeps intact the 2007 Legal Arizona Workers Act. Employers could have their business licenses suspended or revoked for hiring illegal immigrants, under the law. The ruling will make it easier for states to pass similar laws, even though immigration is traditionally a federal responsibility.

The decision in Chamber of Commerce v. Whiting didn't involve a more controversial Arizona measure that requires police to check the immigration status of individuals in certain circumstances. That law remains under separate legal challenge.

The law upheld Thursday also requires Arizona employers to use a federal program called E-Verify to check the immigration status of potential workers. Roberts called this state requirement “entirely consistent” with federal law. 

Butterfly Kisses --- 15 years ago -

Good for Arizona! 

justforfun --- 15 years ago -

At least one state is taking a stand. 

Butterfly Kisses --- 15 years ago -

They have a tough governor who won't back down. She fights for her state's rights! 

justforfun --- 15 years ago -

They have a tough governor who won't back down. She fights for her state's rights!



I like Jan Brewer. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

This will now swing through all states because illegals will move to other states if the don't. This is a huge step in controlling the illegal immigration problem. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

let's see if they bother to enforce it. lol 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

I don't think this was the controversial part of the bill. Good, fine and prosecute those business owners who hire illegals. DON'T ASK people who look "illegal" for special documentation while not asking for the same documentation from someone that looks caucasian. 

Evan Carroll --- 15 years ago -

Wait, isn't this government regulation that prevents business from operating efficiently? Now a business has to make sure the people it pays are citizens?! Damn expansive government. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

I don't necessarily think this law is a bad thing. But hasn't it always been illegal to hire workers without proper identification (I-9)? 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

Government intrusion. It's no coincidence that COnfederate politicians have avoided this mostly.

Now we will know who to blame when everything from fruits and veggies to lumber, housing and chicken prices skyrocket. Oh wait....only in Arizona LMAO. 

twisty --- 15 years ago -

Good for Arizona hopefully other states will follow. This is a first step in the right direction. It isn't just Mexicans that are here illegally look at how many came here with a visa for school etc and they just never left after it expired. Ask everyone if you are here legally it should not bother you to show your id. My daughter is traveling and she must carry a passport and she takes no offense when she has had to show it to get into other countries. 

james osterberg --- 15 years ago -

It's an important part of the three pillars that represent the problem.
Cutting the obvious reason as to why employers hire illegally,why people yearning to breathe free come here illegally, is a good start.
Will this law be enforced? Will corporations be willing to weigh the consequences of their illegal activity in the face of shareholder loss? That's my question.
As a progressive I have always had a problem with employers skirting the issue,profiting off cheap labor,labor that is disposable labor with no rights,whenever problems arise. I ask any progressives out there to tell me why I'm wrong in my thinking here. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

It isn't just Mexicans that are here illegally look at how many came here with a visa for school etc and they just never left after it expired.


yep 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

DON'T ASK people who look "illegal" for special documentation while not asking for the same documentation from someone that looks caucasian.

That was never part of 1070. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

DON'T ASK people who look "illegal" for special documentation while not asking for the same documentation from someone that looks caucasian.



What does someone who" looks illegal" look like? 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

I ask any progressives out there to tell me why I'm wrong in my thinking here.

Traditionally progressives have been against ALL immigration, even LEGAL for the simple reason that union membership and power radically declined as more immigrants landed. The great waves of immigration hurt the labor movement and it wasn't until the Depression that unions got going again. Of course, at that time FDR had banned ALL immigration for ordinary folks.

the famous Reagn amnesty only passed because the UNIONS insisted on employer sanctions for hiring illegals. That was the trade off for them giving support to the bill. The AFL-CIO has now recently CHANGED its position in the vain hope that more immigrants from the south will skew the voting population in the favor of Democrats. This is a stupid position to have since it flies in the face of common sense and facts.

The defeat of Rep. Ortiz D-TX in the last election should hopefully sober some of my fellow Democrats up. If a Democrat cannot win in a 70% Hispanic district against an Anglo with a harsh stand on illegals, it is time to rethink the strategy. The explanation is fairly straight forward since it is the Mexican American voters who are the ones getting screwed by more illegals. It is THEIR wages and schools, etc.. that are getting worse.

I cannot see how any so called progressive can be on the same side of an issue with the Chamber of Commerce. It is also quite clear why the GOP is simply spitting on their base since THEY are the ones who want the cheap labor. You will notice that NO E-verify bill even made it out of committee in Texas, much less got even close to a passing. The GOP leaders WANT illegald to stay and work here. They want them as cheap labor, and rail against illegals while they hire them. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

That was never part of 1070.

Actually that WAS the case in the first iteration of the bill which is why I was outraged against it. The legislature took another look at it, and changed it so that only those who are arrested have to produce documents. THAT is a bill I can and do support. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

the federal E-Verify system was the second part of this lawsuit. The state law makes it mandatory for Arizona employers to use the E-Verify system. The Chamber claimed this requirement was also preempted by IRCA because Congress made use of the E-Verify system voluntary. The Chamber relied on a provision in IRCA that prohibits the Secretary of Homeland Security from requiring any employer (outside the federal government) from using E-Verify absent a prior violation of federal law. However, the Court disagreed with the preemption claim since there is no language in IRCA preventing state action.

In fact, the federal government had agreed there was no preemption in 2008 during the Bush administration when it pointed to Arizona’s E-Verify mandate as an example of a permissible use of the system – although that did not prevent the Obama Justice Department from taking the exact opposite (and losing) position in this case. The Court concluded that Arizona’s requirement in no way interferes with the E-Verify system. In fact, the federal government has consistently expanded and encouraged the use of E-Verify by all 50 states.

Given the lack of political will exhibited in Washington for many years to enforce the federal sanctions against employers who knowingly hire illegal aliens, the implementation by Arizona and other states of these types of substantive state licensing laws is a crucial development. One of the keys to solving the problem we are experiencing with huge numbers of illegal immigrants is making it difficult for them to work. Enforcement of these types of prohibitions is essential to encouraging self-deportation by individuals who are not entitled to be here.


It is also quite clear why the GOP is simply spitting on their base since THEY are the ones who want the cheap labor.

So when conservatives do the right thing for the country they are "spitting on their base"? RJ are you saying that ONLY conservatives have businesses or only businesses that hire cheap labor? You do know that is a ridiculous claim right? Both parties have businesses and both have benefited by cheap labor to the detriment of the country. At least the AZ governor has taken a stand to do the right thing regardless of the political fallout. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

At least the AZ governor has taken a stand to do the right thing regardless of the political fallout.

It was NOT Brewer who signed the law, it was Napolitano, a DEMOCRAT who did.

So when conservatives do the right thing for the country they are "spitting on their base"? RJ are you saying that ONLY conservatives have businesses or only businesses that hire cheap labor?

What I was refering to was the FACT that the Texas GOP REFUSED to even let an E-Verify bill with sanctions on it to get out of committee. THAT is spitting on your base when you say one thing, and DO another. The Texas GOP knows its base is too stupid to realize that fact. So they will pass purely symbolic bills, and make damn sure that the illegals keep coming unhindered. You should have read all of my post about the Reagan amnesty. It was the unions who pushed for employer sanctions, NOT the GOP or businesses.

Just a little lesson in politics. Notice that the Chamber of Commerce was part of the suit against AZ. Also note that the C of C overwhelmingly supports the GOP! So WHO do you think will win in Congress or the legislature when crunch time comes, the base or the money people? The GOP fought tooth and nail to keep from having to make such a hard public choice and in this session they succeeded. The money people won because there is NO E-Verify bill, and better still, the GOP legislators did NOT have to make a public choice between money and their base supporters. As I said, the GOP base is too stupid to realize that they got sold down the river again by "their" side. 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

I have no problem with this bill at all. My only question is, how does Arizone enforce it? Who is going to check up on businesses. Who is going to fine them? I'm not aware of what state-wide agency is in effect to do this. If nothing is in place to investigate/raid a business, then it could end up being feel-good legislation. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

It was NOT Brewer who signed the law, it was Napolitano, a DEMOCRAT who did.


It may have been a Dem that started but Brewer got it done! Napolitano actually was fighting against AZ now that she works for Obama. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

This will now swing through all states because illegals will move to other states if the don't. This is a huge step in controlling the illegal immigration problem.


The swinging has begun.

Ala. governor signs tough illegal immigration law
By BOB JOHNSON Associated Press The Associated Press
Thursday, June 9, 2011 10:56 AM EDT

NewsMONTGOMERY, Ala. (AP) — Alabama's governor on Thursday signed a tough new illegal immigration crackdown that contains provisions requiring public schools to determine students' immigration status and making it a crime to knowingly give an illegal immigrant a ride.

The bill also allows police to arrest anyone suspected of being an illegal immigrant if they're stopped for any other reason. Alabama employers also are now required to use a federal system called E-Verify to determine if new workers are in the country legally.

Gov. Robert Bentley said the law is the nation's toughest, and groups including the American Civil Liberties Union and the Montgomery-based Southern Poverty Law Center agree. The groups say they plan to challenge it.

The legal director for the Southern Poverty Law Center, Mary Bauer, said Thursday that she expects a lawsuit to be filed before the provisions of law are scheduled to take effect on Sept. 1.

"It is clearly unconstitutional. It's mean-spirited, racist and we think a court will enjoin it," Bauer said.

Bentley, who campaigned on passing the toughest anti-illegal immigration bill possible, said he believes the measure can withstand legal challenges.

The House sponsor, Republican Rep. Micky Hammon of Decatur, said the bill was written so that if any part of it is determined to be unconstitutional or violate federal law, the rest will stand.

Alabama's measure was modeled on a similar law passed in Arizona. A federal judge blocked the most controversial parts of Arizona's law last year after the Justice Department sued. A federal appeals court judge upheld the decision, and Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer has said she plans to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Neighboring Georgia also passed a law cracking down on immigration this year, and civil liberties groups have filed a lawsuit trying to block it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground