Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Dr Berios being sued over the death of a patient

who's talking here?

~grandma again~ 4
2ndStarToTheRight 2
justforfun 1
SleightOfHand 18
Perfection 8
Rhea 4
Beach Girl 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
zapper007 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 5
Veto 1
Sufferbus 5
TexasOma 11
Banjos and Squealing Pigs 1
kwtraveler 2
BoxerMama 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 3
Mabs 1
HICK CHICK 9
horseymomma 26
Feeling Blue 1
gardeniagirl07 3
singpraydance 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

HICK CHICK --- 15 years ago -

DR. Berios being sued over the deadth of a patient.Doctors sued over death of woman
By Stefanie Thomas | Posted: Friday, July 22, 2011 12:00 am
The family of a woman who died after taking 11 prescription pills is suing the two physicians in Humble and Porter who allegedly prescribed the medications.
According to Harris County District Clerk’s documents, the family of Cynthia Turner, who died in 2008 at age 46, is bringing the suit against Dr. George A. Brooks, of Humble Pain Management, a clinic that has since stopped doing business in Humble, and Dr. Angelis Berios, who oversees the Porter Family Medical Center in East Montgomery County.
Both doctors have denied the allegations in their responses to the plaintiffs’ petition, filed in February, and a pathologist ruled Turner’s death an accident, according to court records.
The petition alleges that Turner had been seen by Berios, or a nurse practitioner under his supervision, since 2003, and although notations were placed in Turner’s chart that the patient was becoming increasingly addicted to the pills prescribed to her – specifically the pain medication Vicodin and the muscle relaxer Soma – Berios continued to prescribe the medications.
“In spite of this knowledge of her addiction, Dr. Berios continued to prescribe Vicodin and Soma, along with other medication such as Klonopin, Topomax, Cymbalta and Lunesta to manage her pain, anxiety and lack of sleep,” the petition states. “These medications were constantly refilled, refilled early or increased based on the request of Ms. Turner.”
The petition goes on to claim that Turner’s life began to unravel, that she experienced slurred speech, was unable to drive and was not presentable to the public. Her family reportedly attempted to convince Turner to stop taking her medication and Turner’s sister also voiced her concerns in a letter to Berios, to no avail.
“These medications continued to be refilled until approximately June 2008, when Ms. Turner was admitted (to the hospital) with complaints of slurred speech, aphasia, weakness and the inability to walk,” the petition states. “Dr. Berios, the admitting physician, initially suspected a stroke; but all diagnostic studies performed were normal ...
“Upon discharge by Dr. Berios, he had not ordered nor suggested any type of toxicology test for Ms. Turner and instructed her to continue all of her medications.”
About one month before her hospital admission, Turner reportedly had gone to Humble Pain Management, where she was seen by a physician’s assistant under Brooks’ supervision for vague complaints of pain.
Although Turner was asked for a list of medications already prescribed by Berios, Humble Pain Management allegedly never consulted with Berios or asked for the patient’s medical chart, the petition claims. Turner left the clinic with more prescriptions for Vicodin, Soma and Klonopin and continued to receive the medications through the offices of both Berios and Brooks.
“In October 2008, Ms. Turner had been arrested for possession of Xanax; and although the arrest was made known to Dr. Berios, he continued to prescribe the same basic regimen of pain medicine, muscle relaxers and sleeping pills that he had been doing for five years,” the petition states.
On Dec. 4, 2008, Turner reportedly once again visited Berios’ office and received additional prescriptions for Bentyl, most commonly prescribed for irritable bowel syndrome, and Xiratuss, a sinus medication. She also was prescribed refills for seven other medications.
According to the lawsuit, after leaving Berios’ office, Turner went to Humble Pain Management, where she was prescribed additional heavy doses of Vicodin and Soma. Turner then went home and took all 11 medications prescribed by Berios and Brooks.
Three days later, Turner’s father found her in an unresponsive state. She was transported to the hospital, where she was pronounced dead. An autopsy determined the primary cause of Turner’s death were the toxic combined effects of the medications she had ingested.
The autopsy also states that atherosclerotic heart disease was a contributing factor in Turner’s death, which pathologist Dr. Patricia Moore ruled an accident.
Berios filed an answer to the Turner family’s petition in court, saying the claims “resulted from a superseding and intervening cause, or a new and independent cause, not reasonably forseeable by (Berios),” and that “conditions existing before the occurrence in question caused, whole or in part, plaintiff’s damages.”
Brooks answered the allegations stating that the injuries and damages to the Turner family “were not caused by this defendant but were caused by an unavoidable accident or the acts of third parties over whom defendant has no rights or control.”
The lawsuit asks for compensation for pecuniary damages to Turner’s husband and children as well as the cost of the lawsuit and punitive damages, the amount of which is left to the court’s discretion. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Prime example of why I'm glad Texas has tort reform laws for physicians...it's a frivolous lawsuit.....

If the patient or family felt that she was addicted to meds or that the side effects were not acceptable, then they should have sought treatment appropriately.

It's not the physician's fault she refilled the prescriptions....unless the physician did not follow the law regarding controlled medications. 

HICK CHICK --- 15 years ago -

Her family reportedly attempted to convince Turner to stop taking her medication and Turner?s sister also voiced her concerns in a letter to Berios, to no avail. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

ohhhhhhhhhhhh she wrote a letter.

Well that is great. 

Rhea --- 15 years ago -

Was the letter sent certified? Who knows if the doctor ever got the letter in the first place not that it matters. He's not allowed to discuss her situation with anyone due to confidentiality. Did any family members go to her appointments with her and tell the doctors what she was doing and taking?

The patient concerned didn't tell the two doctor's what she was already prescribed and she didn't get them filled at the same pharmacy either. Now days pharmacies keep track of your prescriptions. She had to use different pharmacies as well as different doctors to even get those prescriptions filled. It's called doctor shopping and she is ultimately responsible for her own death due to addiction.

My condolences to her family and friends. Addiction destroys many lives. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

sadly an attorney will get a bunch of money for this waste. 

Rhea --- 15 years ago -

Unless the doctor's insurance company settles for cheaper than a trial will cost then they won't wind up with a dime.

Insurance companies have inhouse cousel so they can settle for pretty cheap. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

For the insurance company yes, but the attorney for the family will take most of that.

Then the two physicians will see their malpractice coverage price increase, they will then need to raise their prices to cover that. 

HICK CHICK --- 15 years ago -

From my understanding DR Berios referred her to the pain management Dr. so the Dr's were working together. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Not the physician's fault.

If she had concerns, she should have addressed them during an office visit, and had it recorded in her chart. If she still disagreed with the physician she could have not refilled the script and sought another opinion.

Addiction, slurred speech, change in mood, depression, somnolence, etc. are all WELL KNOWN side effects of those medications. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

A referral does not mean they were working together.

The clinic should have sent records but it appears they did not. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

And the family could have gone to the appointments, taken the pills away, etc.

They are just as culpable, they enabled her. 

kwtraveler --- 15 years ago -

So when a Dr notes his patient is getting addicted to the meds, its ok to just keep giving more.. nice logic 

Beach Girl --- 15 years ago -

That seems like a lot of personal information that is not appropriate to post in a public forum. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

How do we know that the physician suspected addiction or even had a reason to suspect addiction? 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Beach Girl, it is a news article in a local paper. No extra info on here. 

kwtraveler --- 15 years ago -

since 2003, and although notations were placed in Turner’s chart that the patient was becoming increasingly addicted to the pills prescribed to her –

Because its in her chart 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Who is responsible for a person?

Themselves or another?

Where is the family responsibility?

Where is the individual's? 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

many people who have chronic extreme pain are addicted to Vicodin. without it they would have unbearable pain if the problem can not be fixed surgically. i think it is the pain management doctors responsibility to control pain meds once a patient has been referred to them.

i would not take the snake that was on my back deck last night to dr barios for treatment! 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

We don't know that....we don't have access to the chart.

And he could have noted that and then switched meds appropriately.

I looked him on on the TMB website: Berios has held a Texas license for 19 years with no TMB actions taken against him.

You can't believe everything ya read in a newspaper. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

That it so many meds I can't even imagine. It's like a death cocktail. 

Rhea --- 15 years ago -

Charting addiction doesn't mean anything other than the doctor was paying attention.

Until the source of the pain is dealt with and resolved then addiction, expecially to opiates, can't be helped and is even expected. The doctor will either wean the patient off the meds or let them deal with withdrawal symptoms. 

Rhea --- 15 years ago -

No pharmacy would have prescribed all of those medications to one person. She was filling them at different places which automatically means she knew what she was doing was wrong.

There are safety measures in place to protect people from recieving the wrong or multiple medications from different doctors. The pharmacy would have called the doctor and told them about the other prescriptions.

Simple case of doctor shopping by a prescription drug addict. 

SleightOfHand --- 15 years ago -

Prime example of why I'm glad Texas has tort reform laws for physicians...it's a frivolous lawsuit.....

---------
How is this not frivolous?! Pain management clinics are nothing but high class drug dealers. As a doctor, he should have cut her off the medications. There is no reason to be taking the combination Klonopin, Soma and Vicodin. He should have had his license revoked! 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

i knew a man one time who would go to walmart and have his medicare prescription for vicodin filled then he would take a different dr prescription to walgreens and get the same thing but pay cash for it. he was very much addicted to vicodin. 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

Pain management clinics are nothing but high class drug dealers

absolutely not true. they do help many people who are in really bad pain in ways other than dishing out pain meds. 

Banjos and Squealing Pigs --- 15 years ago -

They're suing the wrong people.

The husband should be the one being sued and criminal charges should be filed against him for neglect. He was probably taking her drugs too. He was probably too stoned to know any better.

Throw in some child neglect while you're at it.

Loser family in every sense. No need to feel sorry for him.

Another simple example of lack of personal responsibility plain and simple. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

now now, let's not jump to conclusions 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Just as we cannot assume the Dr. here is responsible, we cannot assume that the family is responsible either.

There are legitimate reasons for being prescribed those meds; people are often good at hiding their problems, particularly if depression or another psychological problem (medication induced or otherwise) is involved.

Klonopin, although it has a bad rep as a benzo, it is very effective in reducing anxiety related to pain, and thus reduces severity to pain.

Vicodin is also a legitimate pain med.

Neither Cymbalta (SNRI) or Topamax (neuromodulator) are addictive, and are both commonly used for pain management. Although both have significant side effects including suicidal behavior, mood changes, somnolence, etc.

Should I continue? 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

I have severe migraines, and have held a script for all of these meds at one time or another.

I certainly didn't abuse them, and definitely would not hold the prescribing physician responsible for my decisions. 

singpraydance --- 15 years ago -

I can't figure out why she kept getting the refills. All of my meds, and my kids, and my husbands, run out of refills at 6 months. At that point, someone has to call the doctor's office to get it approved. The chart has all the medications listed, so why is the office approving all of them getting refilled?? I think that's the part that gets the doctor's office in trouble.
Yes, its quite possible she was pharmacy hopping and doctor hopping. However, at some point, the refills should have run out and could have been denied.
But who's fault is that? The doctor? The staff? Messy charts by the office manager? It's sad all the way around. 

SleightOfHand --- 15 years ago -

" The chart has all the medications listed, so why is the office approving all of them getting refilled?? I think that's the part that gets the doctor's office in trouble."
_____________
My point exactly!! 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Not exactly true either.....

Refills for non controlled substances in TX and schedules I and II are allowed to be refilled for up to 1 year from date of issuance.

Schedules III-V cannot be re-filled more than 5 times or after 6 months.

It's up to the filling pharmacy to maintain a current and valid prescription on file.


It's all in the Texas admin code here

For reference:
Vicodin = III
Klonopin = IV
Soma = IV
Lunesta = IV
Topamax and Cymbalta are not scheduled drugs. 

SleightOfHand --- 15 years ago -

Klonopin, although it has a bad rep as a benzo, it is very effective in reducing anxiety related to pain, and thus reduces severity to pain.

Vicodin is also a legitimate pain med.

Neither Cymbalta (SNRI) or Topamax (neuromodulator) are addictive, and are both commonly used for pain management. Although both have significant side effects including suicidal behavior, mood changes, somnolence, etc.

Should I continue?
____________________
The combination of Vicodin, Soma and any other Benzo, usually xanax, is called the "Holy Trinity" The effects are similar to heroine. Where is the medical necessity to be prescribing something similar to heroine? Why not prescribe her Dilaudid then? Im sorry, but I have a hard time believing that she was in need of the entire lot of drugs she was prescribed other than to deal with her DRUG ADDICTION. The doctor's chart stated that she appeared to have an addiction to the medication, he should have stopped the prescriptions right then, he was negligent thus at fault for her death 

SleightOfHand --- 15 years ago -

It's all in the Texas admin code here
____________
Thats fine and dandy, but the State board of Pharmacy controls PHARMACIES, not doctor's offices. The feds have laws requiring the Doctor to keep records as well on prescriptions issued to patients. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Read the link I posted regarding TX pharmcy codes.

How do we know she was prescribed those medications all at the same time?

It's common, especially in valid pain management cases, to switch meds if the medication is not working.

Based on TX pharmacy code, if she had a script, she could have filled it at any time up to 6 months after it was written....even if she has filled other medications prescribed for the same reason.

What I'm saying is you can't hold the physician or the family responsible based on the "evidence" stated in the article.

And, even if the physician suspected addiction, you do NOT stop them cold turkey. If he was not comfortable with dealing with addition, and he suspected addition, she was likely referred to a specialist who does...and likely did not go.

The physician cannot be held responsible for patient non-compliance. 

SleightOfHand --- 15 years ago -

I call BS 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

warweazl....not exactly true either....
Most refills are done via the pharmacy, and a Dr. cannot control when a patient actually picks up their meds, which is why it is regulated via the pharmacy codes.

Actually, once a Dr/patient relationship is established...which in TX can be as little as you saw your neighbor who is a Dr. watering his yard and asked him a question... he can then write you a prescription.

Only scheduled substances require a medical record.

And since we don't have these medical records, we cannot fault either the patient or the physician. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

You call BS cuz you're too lazy to read the TX code I made readily available? 

Feeling Blue --- 15 years ago -

The combination of Vicodin, Soma and any other Benzo, usually xanax, is called the "Holy Trinity"
There are these kinds of places all over Houston. They write presciptions that are filled at their personal pharmacy. Who in the world needs a 100 of all 3 of these medications at a time? I lived with a pill addict, its a horrible thing to deal with and its even worse to know that there are doctors out there writing these prescriptions to people for no good reason. First do no harm? Sure. 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground