Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

best guard dogs?

who's talking here?

lotsmore 1
dixie 1
Cajunmom 1
ladybeachbum 1
Rhea 1
Nickie 1
mc2imagescom 2
MeriZephyr 1
susie q 1
Quixote 1
K.T. 1
Photomomof2 2
Springfield 1
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
SailorTattoos 4
MandyPants 3
Kyobungee 3
Freckles00 7
Its Mygirl01 1
kol89 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

kol89 --- 15 years ago -

for protection of the home? I have not had much dealings with breeds of dogs so wonder if people could give advice from experience. 

ladybeachbum --- 15 years ago -

My golden retriever wouldn't let anyone near me at home or on the beach. He didn't believe anyone should be even in the next block. 

kol89 --- 15 years ago -

ha! wow sounds like a pretty awesome dog. 

dixie --- 15 years ago -

My mutt and English Mastiff wont let anyone even up the driveway if they are in the garage with us. If I even answer the door they try to open it to come "meet" you lol. They are the best! 

MandyPants --- 15 years ago -

Get a Pit Bull. Just Kidding!!!

My lab has a vicious growl and bark which scares the delivery people and door strangers, but she is the sweetest, most loving family pet. 

kol89 --- 15 years ago -

awww, where did you get her from? i like labs alot! 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

Go to MCAS and get a big mutt! It's not so much the attack it's the barking and the intimidation factor of the dog that freaks people out.

If you go to MCAS there are TONS of labs (and just about any other dog you can think of) there for adoption and it's only $75 and the dog is spayed or neutered, microchipped and has all it's shots. 

mc2imagescom --- 15 years ago -

If your main concern is gaurding be carefull what you ask for. Having a guard dog with no sense can cost you a hefty fine and be a liability with a ticking time bomb attached. I had to wonder about these things myself when I got our Sharpei. He was sweet as can be but the minute he felt threatened he was a bit of a rebel and had a feisty attitude. Heck even the vet brought attention too his feistiness. The nurse told me he was too little to have such an attitude and the vet told me to keep an eye on it. When others may have given up on him We stuck it out. Obedience has become an easy task and his sweetness is thru the roof. He is awesome and beautiful all in one. He is a great gaurd dog and a lovign family dog. He always let's me knw if something feels off and if there is anyone outside. He is indrs but loves to lounge on our back porch and never leaves the undenced property. I VOTE SHARPEI! 

MandyPants --- 15 years ago -

We got her from a breeder in baytown 8 years ago, but I will only get shelter dogs from here on out.

I agree, it's the size coupled with the bark. Our girl is 110 lbs! 

MandyPants --- 15 years ago -

I am a lab lover. I will never own another kind! I have had min pins, German shepherds, poodles, and St. Bernards (that's another intimidating, but super sweet breed.) 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

My dachshund will rip your throat out ;)... If you bend down a little.


Seriously though dachshunds are some of the best watch dogs (different from guard dogs). They bark like no body's business!

They are considered the most aggressive dog breed believe it or not. More aggressive than German shepherds, rotties, dobies, and pitties! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Big dogs have that aura of "I will kick your butt for fun and exercise" thing goin' on. It's obvious they have power. Little yippy dogs can be very protective and noisy as well. Noise is a great deterrent whether it be a throat rippin' weenie dog or a big German Shepherd. :) 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

a throat rippin' weenie dog or a big German Shepherd. :) 

Hahaha :) 

SailorTattoos --- 15 years ago -

If you truly want a guard dog that can back up his bark with bite if needed for your home I would pick a Mastiff. There are many different types. Mastiffs were bred to guard property whereas breeds like GSD, Doberman, and Rottweiler are more family oriented guardians. Mastiffs are serious dogs who call for serious owners. You need to do your research and make sure you know what you are getting into.

Links:
http://www.akc.org/breeds/mastiff/

Different types of mastiffs:

English
0

Dogue De Bordeaux(french mastiff)
0

Neapolitan Mastiff(italian)
0

Bull Mastiff
0

Fila Brasilerio(brazilian mastiff)
0

Tosa Inu(japanese mastiff)
0

Boerboel(south african mastiff)
0

Dogo Argentino(Argentinian mastiff)one of my fave breeds
0

Cane Corso(italian mastiff)
0

A guy I work with breeds Corsos, I love them. This is his:
0

and a corso he bred
0

Great Dane(german mastiff)
0

Tibetan Mastiff
0 

mc2imagescom --- 15 years ago -

OH I love the feedback. I had a dachsie for 15 years whoo was the best companion a girl could have and a male for 12, I don't know about the aggressive part neither nor any I have ever encountered have been close to the way you describe your ferocious lil guy. But it did take me several years to finally choose a different dog.
Mastifs well they are also wonderful, I had a large black Neopolitan one and he was great at scarring anyone away from my old home. My neighbor fell in love with him so much when I moved I let her keep him for the purpose of guarding her home. Be ready for a great big food bill though.

German Shephards are also WONDERFUL! I agree go to rescues and get your new guy there is no reason to pay breeder prices. Sharpeis have a rescue sight as well. Not sure the address but google is easy. I wish I could post a pic but I don't have a clue how. LOL 

K.T. --- 15 years ago -

Have an Australian shepherd who won't let anyone touch her Mamma LOL....sons have German shepherds and other son a lab...both very protective dogs also! Recently
we adopted a Gerottie ( half German shepherd and half Rottie)..still a pup but not protective at all!! Go figure!!! 

Rhea --- 15 years ago -

I've got a great dane and a lab. Great dane for sure. Really don't ever want any other kind of dog. As sweet as she is her size demands respect and when she barks everyone jumps. Perfect guard dog. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

Actually I was kidding he'll bark at strangers but he wouldn't bite lol

And I didn't make it up they are recorded as the most aggressive breed of dog lol 

SailorTattoos --- 15 years ago -

German Shephards are also WONDERFUL! I agree go to rescues and get your new guy there is no reason to pay breeder prices. Sharpeis have a rescue sight as well. Not sure the address but google is easy. I wish I could post a pic but I don't have a clue how. LOL

Just have to say that as someone who works with Doberman and German Shepherd rescue, we generally decline people who come to us looking for guard dogs. Our rescue dogs are family companions first and foremost and most have already been to hell and back and have come from "guard dog" type situations(living outdoors, no real family contact, etc) so I cringe when I see main purpose for wanting a GSD or Doberman: Guard Dog, on an application. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

I agree sailor... To me if you only want a dog to guard your property and not as a member of the family to live inside and be loved on then you should have a dog 

Quixote --- 15 years ago -

You can't go wrong with a GSD as a family member. 

Its Mygirl01 --- 15 years ago -

Rhodesian Ridgeback, best dog ever!! 

Springfield --- 15 years ago -

Stop right now. First, you do NOT want to buy a guard dog. That's like someone who has never fired a gun asking which handgun to buy. The wrong dog poorly trained is dangerous.

If you want a sweet housedog, which might bark at the door but never attack anyone (including your neighbor's toddler) do some research on breeds and your lifestyle (apartment vs. house, exercise requirements, etc...).

Really. Think about all the bad things untrained dogs do or that people do to their poorly behaved dogs and don't be that owner. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

Good advice Springfield. 100% correct.

I don't think OP is looking for an attack dog? But just one that is intimidating looking and barks... is that correct OP?

Since you don't have a dog now OP... have you really ever owned a dog before?

Many of the breeds being suggested (German Shepherds and the like) I wouldn't recommend for inexperienced dog owners... they are strong willed breeds and need a certain type of owner. They also need tons and tons of mental and physical exercise and will become destructive if they don't get it (as will any breed but GSDs and the others suggested are more intense).

I suggest if you are serious about a forever friend you should go take a look at the shelter and find a big, intimidating, cuddle bug that will scare anyone away with his bark! 

SailorTattoos --- 15 years ago -

Thank you Springfield and freckles. A big dog provides you with a better sense of security but one needs to take into consideration that dogs are a huge responsibility, period. On top of that the powerful breeds need a lot of training, structure, and strong leadership early on and continued throughout their life. A dog should be a family member as well and a dog can definitely get killed by an intruder. That is a big reason why keeping a "guard dog" in the yard is a bad idea because yeah they might bark behind a fence but all an intruder has to do is throw a poisoned piece of meat over your fence or shoot and kill the dog, and then you're back at square one. I cannot emphasize enough that you need to do a lot of research because it's not fair to a dog to get it and pitch it in a yard for the rest of its life. If you are seriously feared for your safety I would get a gun. My Doberman is intimidating to strangers but he is also very special to me and it is my job as his guardian to help keep him safe. Dogs can live up to 15 or so years so please be responsible with the choice you make. A popular GSD kennel that trains and sells protection dogs was recently in the news because one of their buyers bought a fully trained dog to protect his home/family due to a break in scare. The people had no idea how to control a dog of such power and the dog tried biting his wife and children and did not respect or listen to him. The kennel posted videos of them working/training the dog and it was totally obedient and in control. This is what can happen if you decide to get a "guard dog" on a whim, it can backfire ESP if you are a novice. 

Photomomof2 --- 15 years ago -

I have a pit bull, be he is one of our babies. Not just a guard dog. But he does a pretty dang good job. His bark alone keeps people away. He is very vocal, which I've taught him to be. :)

GSD is a great choice. Very loyal and protective.

Doberman, my mom is fostering a few now or can send you over to the rescue. Tons of great dobies and great gaurd dogs. Also very loyal.

Labs, need a lot of work and exercise. 

SailorTattoos --- 15 years ago -

Pit bulls are a poor choice for a guard dog and I hate to see them be used as such :(

This is from the pit bull terrier breed standard:

"The APBT is not the best choice for a guard dog since they are extremely friendly, even with strangers. Aggressive behavior toward humans is uncharacteristic of the breed and highly undesirable. This breed does very well in performance events because of its high level of intelligence and its willingness to work."

http://www.ukcdogs.com/WebSite.nsf/Breeds/AmericanPitBullTerrierRevisedNovember12008


Dobermans are a personal protection breed, they are useless for guarding property as they were bred to be right by their owner's side. They are unhappy as outside guard dogs, it is not an ideal life for such a Velcro breed as a dobie. We just rescued an 8 year old Doberman whose owner was keeping her outside bc the husband refused to let her stay inside. They dumped her because they couldn't stand her crying and pawing at Thr door all night because she wanted in to be by them. 

Photomomof2 --- 15 years ago -

Our put pull is not just a gaurd dog. He wouldn't ever bite anyone, but his bark would keep ppl away. He is our baby and a family member. We didn't get him to just gaurd. But if someone comes to the door, I've trained him to bark on command. I feel better protected when he is around.

Yes Dobermans are very loyal like I said, but my mom who foster them has 2 acres of land and the all love to be outside and chase squirrels. they spend most the time outside and at night come it. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

A friend has a big white dog, scary bark, good guard dog, but once accepted, really nice.
Doesn't slobber, she says he is great. Loves to go for walks, but doesn't need all that much room. Loving to her family including the little ones (3 & 6). Some kind of mountain dog I think, I'll ask her next time I see her. 

MeriZephyr --- 15 years ago -

"The APBT is not the best choice for a guard dog since they are extremely friendly, even with strangers. Aggressive behavior toward humans is uncharacteristic of the breed and highly undesirable. This breed does very well in performance events because of its high level of intelligence and its willingness to work."

This has been my experience:)

My dog is so loving and very eager to please!( However,I know she would be protective if my safety was ever threatened.)....

...and then there are my two mini~doxies,lol. 

susie q --- 15 years ago -

My JRT is very protective. 

lotsmore --- 15 years ago -

I have had all kinds of dogs. Rotts,dobies,labs,. I wanted a dog that would protect me and my family as well as not let someone just walk in my yard. I have had Blue Heelers for yrs now and as they are the best dogs I have ever had. The big dogs I can not handle by myself. These dogs are around 50 lbs. The only issue is they are a one person dog. They will listen to others when the master is not around but.They are ALPA dogs. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

My friend called out of the blue, how timely. She said her dog is a great watch dog, but that was what they were bred for.
She said here is a good place to adopt one.
Great Pyrenees Rescue Society

0 

Cajunmom --- 15 years ago -

Great Pyrenees are wonderful dogs! I have two of them. They are family dogs and they won't let anyone harm their family! Great Pyrenees Rescue Society is a wonderful and caring organization. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

Great Pyrenees

Kyo, I thought that was the breed of dog you were describing in your first post!

They are soooo fluffffffyyy! 

Nickie --- 15 years ago -

Rhodesian Ridgeback, best dog ever!!

Agreed :) 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Kyo, I thought that was the breed of dog you were describing in your first post!

I don't know dogs that much. I just know hers is always loud when you get to her house, but nice once he knows who I am.
Big, I think she said he is just over 100 pounds. But nice dog. Almost makes me want one, I said ALMOST.
Just can't see a dog in our family. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Go with a chihuahua or a chihuahua mix...we have a chiweenie and that dog barks if the wind blows! No one could get into this house without her going absolutely nuts!

Everyone in your neighborhood would know something was going on with the amount of barking those dog do...lol.


As far as large breeds go, I'd definitely research temperament first, then find a rescue group or shelter to adopt from.

Good luck! :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground