Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Any thoughts on this gun

who's talking here?

Gotcats 1
Tylers Journey 3
Rubicon 3
Nick 1
Laurabeth 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 5
Dr Aborto 4
idontplaynice 13
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
Defcon1 17
gunsnroses 1
kwgraniteguy 2
OL AG 89 1
DILLIGAFFAN 7
Friday 1
hard shell 1
Emperor of Kingwood 2
OneEyedManRedux 10

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

I think it would make for good always-with-type of gun (provided you have a CHL). S&W 317 revolver in .22LR. Holds 9-shots, small and lightweight. I like not using magazines because you don't have to worry about ammo reliability.

0 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

I think it's a neat little gun, but as far as defense purposes go I wouldn't choose a .22lr.

I am a lover of magazine-fed firearms, though. I enjoy revolvers for range time but I don't carry one.

You can't beat the reliability of a S&W revolver, though...that's for damn sure. 

gunsnroses --- 13 years ago -

Great gun for protection with hollow point bullets 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

Great gun for protection with hollow point bullets

.22lr really should not be used for defense purposes unless there is no other option. It's better than a stick, but definitely worse for defense than a .38, 9mm, .357, .40 or .45.

.22lr is possibly my favorite round of all time but I wouldn't kid anyone into thinking it would be sufficient for self-defense against an attacker. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

That looks kinda small...is it good for a woman? 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

is it good for a woman?


Sure, if your intent is plinking, target practice or shooting small game such as squirrels or birds. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Sure, if your intent is plinking, target practice or shooting small game such as squirrels or birds


Oh, no, i mean as protection...Why would they make a gun that's only good for shooting squirrels or birds?? 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

Why would they make a gun that's only good for shooting squirrels or birds?


All different rounds serve many different purposes.

.22lr is celebrated as the perfect round for shooting small game at relatively short distances and also as a fun plinking/target shooting gun because of its low cost.

Also great for young children and newcomers to firearms to learn proper firearm safety and operation. It has no recoil (kick) and you can shoot without hurting your ears.

Can a .22lr kill somebody? Absolutely.

Will it stop an angry attacker coming at you? I'm not willing to bet my life on it. 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

Just for scale reference, here is a .22lr round next to the most commonly chosen self-defense rounds:

0 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Oh, I see..makes more sense now. Thank you.

OMG, check out the .357 Mag! Now, that's gotta hurt! 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

Oh, I see..makes more sense now. Thank you.

:D Any time.


OMG, check out the .357 Mag


I REALLY want a Python .357 Magnum! It is definitely on the list of those I MUST OWN.

0


And of course, it's the handy sidearm of the one and only Rick Grimes:

0 

Nick --- 13 years ago -

I disagree with the argument of "the bigger the round the better for self defense" The 22 round round is known to be a ricochet round which means when it goes in it bounces around instead of passing through . Also that revolver hold 9 rounds and the 22 has very little kick , you could let all 9 rounds go as fast as you can pull the trigger and keep the group fairly small, try that with a .357 . I know with a .357 you only need to hit them once but what if you miss, to recover and re-aim would take much longer . You also need to be comfortable with whatever you shoot so if you hesitate on pulling the trigger on a .357 because it kicks like a mule that could be a fatal difference . Lastly who the hell looks down the business end of a barrel and says "oh its just a .22 I'll continue........" 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

I disagree with the argument of "the bigger the round the better for self defense"


As do I. I have chosen the .40 S&W as my defense round of choice. The entire round is smaller than a .45 or .357 and I can carry more rounds in a smaller package. It is, in my opinion, the perfect self-defense round.


The 22 round round is known to be a ricochet round which means when it goes in it bounces around instead of passing through


The whole "ricochets inside the body causing more damage" thing is actually a myth which holds no truth. Fact is a .22lr is about as weak of a round as you can possibly use and definitely the worst choice for self-defense.

As I said before..."Can a .22lr kill somebody? Absolutely.

Will it stop an angry attacker coming at you? I'm not willing to bet my life on it. "


You also need to be comfortable with whatever you shoot


100% true. You definitely do. That's why if you're not comfortable with a .357, don't carry a .357. There is a plethora of rounds besides a .357 to choose from...from a .380 Auto to a .50cal.

A .380 is going to be an infinitely wiser choice of a defense round than a .22lr.

As far as hesitating to pull the trigger, same is true with any gun. If you hesitate, you could be dead. Training, training, training. I can not stress that enough.


Lastly who the hell looks down the business end of a barrel and says "oh its just a .22 I'll continue.


I'm not willing to stake my life on what an attacker thinks of my defense weapon whether it be a .22lr or a .50. A lot of attackers would continue to come at you, whether they see you have a gun or not. You better not pull a gun unless your life is in danger and you're going to pull the trigger in order to stop a legitimate threat. It's not about looking intimidating by having a gun and hoping an attacker is scared off...it's about stopping a threat when you absolutely have to in order to stay alive. 

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

These days, it's better to have a .22LR you can afford ammo for (and can find), rather than a .45ACP or .357Mag you can't.

.22 LR, while not ideal, is way better than nothing.

Here is a Ruger Security Six .357 Mag. Its all steel construction will help dampen the recoil.

0undefined 

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

Another shot of the Smith.

0 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

.22 LR, while not ideal, is way better than nothing.

I do agree with that one.



These days, it's better to have a .22LR you can afford ammo for, rather than a .45ACP or .357Mag you can't.


I'm having a hard time even finding .22lr!

It's been easier for me to get a hold of .40s&w than .22lr! 

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

I REALLY want a Python .357 Magnum! It is definitely on the list of those I MUST OWN.

Those things are nice, but man, the price! 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

Those things are nice, but man, the price!


That is the only thing that has stopped me from getting one! Same with the Smith & Wesson 1911 Tactical I want! 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

The whole purpose of a self defense round is to STOP the attacker. The rounds pictured are all "ball" rounds (target), so if you are considering those as carry rounds, you should reconsider and look at hollow point or self defense rounds.
The .22lr is a very low mass round, and while it would inflict injury, it is NOT intended as a self defense round.
I carry the Springfield XDs in .45, while the DW has a H&K in .40.
The mere sound of the weapon (.45) is enough to deter others with the attacker. A .22 is a little pop, where the .40 or .45 is a head turner....
You also cannot take the CHL, with anything smaller than a .32 in Texas, so you will have to buy or rent something to test with if you decide to carry a .22lr. 

Gotcats --- 13 years ago -

I carried a Ruger 357 snub. It was a great shooting gun. My ex made our bullets and he used hollow point. I wouldn't like to be on the receiving end of that! I wish I still had it.. 

DILLIGAFFAN --- 13 years ago -

Colt 380 Auto for me.

Sorry got my guns mixed up, I just changed from the ruger p80 9mm 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

The rounds pictured are all "ball" rounds (target), so if you are considering those as carry rounds, you should reconsider and look at hollow point or self defense rounds.


Yea, I was only showing the difference in size of the different rounds and that was the best picture I could find.

I will admit, I am guilty of keeping my mags loaded with FMJs most the time. 

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

Colt 357 Auto for me.

Say what? 

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

I will admit, I am guilty of keeping my mags loaded with FMJs most the time.

FMJ to practice with, HP to carry. But FMJ is better than nothing. Just watch for the over-penetration. 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

Just watch for the over-penetration.



Definitely. My thought process is, if I need, for some reason, to get that round through an obstacle in order to hit my target, I will have a better chance of doing so.

It's a toss up...I never can decide what to keep loaded and have settled for awhile on FMJs...thinking about emptying them and loading them with defense rounds, though. 

DILLIGAFFAN --- 13 years ago -

Colt 357 Auto for me.

Say what? 


Colt 380 Auto for me.

Sorry got my guns mixed up, I just changed from the ruger p80 9mm 

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

Colt 380 Auto for me.


Colt hasn't made a .380 auto in years. Yours must be an old (and expensive) gun. Care to post a pic? 

DILLIGAFFAN --- 13 years ago -

I managed a Pawn Shop for 10 yrs so I got the cream of the crop. LOL
DH said I spent every penny I made on guns and jewelry. I would post a pic, but dh has already went to bed and it is in the bedroom. 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

I LOVE the Colt 380 auto! It's like a bad@ss mini 1911. I will post a pic of the one in our family's possession tomorrow if possible. I wish it was mine! 

DILLIGAFFAN --- 13 years ago -

It just fits my small hands much better than the Ruger P80 9MM 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

It is an EXCELLENT gun for small hands or simply for ease of concealed carry.

I NEED one of my own. 

DILLIGAFFAN --- 13 years ago -

You need to make friends with a Pawn Shop owner or mang. That way you will know when a good gun is coming out before it hits the floor. 

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

The Sig P238 is a modern Colt 380 Auto. 

DILLIGAFFAN --- 13 years ago -

The Sig P238 is a modern Colt 380 Auto. 

IMO! It is not near as smooth. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

does anyone know of a custom gunsmith? I'd like to buy an automatic with a scope, but I need something lightweight, that racks easily- 

Defcon1 --- 13 years ago -

The thing about optics on pistols is that you usually can't holster/conceal them well enough to be practical.

Optics are great on full frame pistols and large revolvers.

But to answer your question I really don't know who around here is a good gunsmith. Anything I run into with my guns I usually fix on my own. I will ask around though. 

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

What do you think is the perfect round for scenarios where things become hard to get, if you know what I mean? Me, I nominate .22LR 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

What do you think is the perfect round for scenarios where things become hard to get, if you know what I mean?

No I do not know what you mean.....

If things are hard to get, then are you defending what you have or foraging for something you do not?

In the first instance I believe you will be massivly outgunned, in the second, I believe you will be eating alot of small game and not much else. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Interesting discussion.... I hope you do not mind if I throw in my 2 cents....

The .22LR revolver is a back up gun at most, and even for that task, I would feel woefully inadequate.

Although the .22 LR is an excellent rifle round, we must remember that the pistol is a CLOSE quarters weapon. The .22LR does not have the bullet mass to disable or slow an attacker at 5 to 10 feet.

And if in a gun battle, you will be outgunned 99.999 % of the time.

The scenarios for success become narrowed to the point of irrelevancy.

Better than nothing??? Ya sure, but completely unsuited for success at the task one would ask of a concealed/ personal defense close quarters weapon. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground