Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Fruit smoothies just as bad as soda

who's talking here?

planemom 1
SleightOfHand 1
Perfection 2
Laurabeth 1
jtcitrus 2
Dendrobate 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Tootiefrog 1
Not KU 1
Beaner 5
Bubbletoes 1
Texashley 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

link title

That fruit smoothie you just bought from the local juice bar may not be nearly as healthy as you’d like to believe.

Two researchers responsible for highlighting the health risks behind consuming sugary soft drinks now say that fruit smoothies may be just as bad for you as soda since they contain the same amount of sugar.

“Smoothies and fruit juices are the new danger,” University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Professor Barry Popkin told the Guardian. “It's kind of the next step in the evolution of the battle.”

Popkin and his research partner George Bray say that since their 2004 soft drink study was released, Pepsi, Coke and other soda manufacturers have been buying fruit smoothie companies and marketing their products as healthier alternatives.

“It's a really big part of it because in every country they've been replacing soft drinks with fruit juice and smoothies as the new healthy beverage,” Popkin told the Guardian. “So you will find that Coke and Pepsi have bought dozens [of fruit juice companies] around the globe."

However, Popkin says these drinks are not in fact healthier and that they on average contain the same amount of sugar as a regular soda. Further, he says that smoothies do not actually provide the same health benefits as simply eating a whole fruit or vegetable.

“So pulped up smoothies do nothing good for us, but do give us the same amount of sugar as four to six oranges or a large coke. It is deceiving,” Popkin said.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says that about half of the U.S. population consumes at least one sugary drink per day on average. Those statistics are higher for lower income individuals, minors and minorities. The CDC also says the dramatic rise in soft drink consumption over the past 30 years has played a direct role in rising obesity rates and cases of diabetes.

A recent Harvard study found that a typical 20-ounce bottle of soda contains about 15-18 teaspoons of sugar. The same study says U.S. beverage manufacturers spend about $3.2 billion dollars each year marketing these drinks to children .

In fact, the near omnipresence of sugary drinks is so prevalent that a June 2013 study from the National Institutes of Health claims that removing soda machines from schools would not have a significant impact on the number of drinks consumed by kids.

However, at least one fruit smoothie manufacturer is standing by their claims. “Smoothies are made entirely from fruit and therefore contain the same amount of sugars that you would find in an equivalent amount of whole fruit,” reads a statement from fruit smoothie manufacturer Innocent, which is primarily owned by the Coca-Cola Company.

Despite his criticism of the fruit smoothie industry, Popkin has in the past praised companies like Coke for reducing the amount of sugar in the products offering lower sized portion options to the consumer. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Oh man!!

I love fruit smoothies and strawberry frappuccinos from Starbucks!

I love sugar, too. :) 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

while sugar is better than the artificial sweetners the "diet" drinks have, it needs to be monitored so it doesn't harm you later Dorothy Parker. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I'm not worried about it. I eat plenty of salt to balance it out....lol. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

How in the world can refined white sugar and junk in sodas be as bad for you as the sugar in fruit and natural food?? I realize they all affect insulin levels and such, and that calorie wise they all still have a count,but hell to the NO as far as fruit being as damaging as white sugar.

And do commercial smoothies have ADDED sugar?? Or is all the sweetness from fruit alone? 

Beaner --- 13 years ago -

I would say that most commercial smoothies have added sugar, but a smoothie made from organic juices and fruit, cannot be bad for you. It's the same as eating the fruit by itself. 

Dendrobate --- 13 years ago -

This so called study doesn't give much information does it? First of all the "testing" was done by a professor. Second, what kind of smoothies are they comparing to?

A lot of places will add ice cream to smoothies and other non healthy items so are not nearly as healthy as having a raw vegan smoothie. Plus sugars from fruit and veggies are different then ones added to soda.

I try and eat a raw vegan diet and have at least one green smoothie a day. I add fruit, kale, chia and flax seeds, coconut oil, and camu camu to it and I know it is 100% natural and wouldn't even compare to having a soda! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Yeah, I'd like to see what the ingredients were in said smoothies that were tested. You can make a good tasting healthy ones wIth no added sugars at all. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

but hell to the NO as far as fruit being as damaging as white sugar.

And do commercial smoothies have ADDED sugar?? Or is all the sweetness from fruit alone?


It's about quantity and delivery.

Commercial smoothies usually do have added sugar: Apple Juice (or fruit juice or some other juice concentrate) There's a ton of sweeteners they can add. AND if they add a little bit of a lot of different sweeteners: then none of those individual sweeteners makes it to the top of the ingredient list.

Here's some other perspective: a medium sized apple will produce maybe a quarter cup of juice. So, a kids Motts Apple juice box may have as much sugar as 3 whole apples, sans nutrients and fiber... and today's apples produce MUCH MORE sugar pound for pound than our Grand Parents Apples.


but a smoothie made from organic juices and fruit, cannot be bad for you.

NOT true.

The downside of the smoothie is that by busting up the structure of the fruit, the sugars absorb more readily. So in terms of glycemic index / glycemic load, they can be as bad as soda.


Also, by making more sugar absorb-able earlier in the gut, the share of sugar available to gut-bacteria "downstream" is lower... and there is a relationship (not really understood at all) between gut-microbe population characteristics and overall health.

Note: to the best of my knowledge there is no consensus on whether blending has any benefit over just consuming fruit and vegetables raw or cooked.

Yeah, I'd like to see what the ingredients were in said smoothies that were tested. You can make a good tasting healthy ones wIth no added sugars at all.

fer shizzle. Smoothie King is like a sugar factory. Their menu is awful. The last time I went there was only one thing I was willing to order for my daughter (convenience/situation), and I still thought it was too sweet. Jamba juice and other juice bars are better, but sugar still pays the bills. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

In my house Juice and Soda almost always have only one valid place: by the bar next to the liquor.

... adjacent to the cigars 

Bubbletoes --- 13 years ago -

It's just like everything else: everything in moderation. 

Beaner --- 13 years ago -

The downside of the smoothie is that by busting up the structure of the fruit, the sugars absorb more readily. So in terms of glycemic index / glycemic load, they can be as bad as soda.

The smoothies I make have about 3oz of fruit in them. The rest is juice (more sugar) of course, or milk/almond milk/soy milk. I think if people stay away from juices, the amount of sugar should be fine. 

Texashley --- 13 years ago -

I don't drink soda but I do love my sugar and coffee. I drink about 4 quarts of water a day now though. I love smoothie king .. but usually make my smoothies at home to save money. I also do not add any sugar to my smoothies. The natural sugar in the strawberries taste good alone. 

Tootiefrog --- 13 years ago -

Smoothie King uses Monin syrup...its the same stuff they use to flavor your tea at Macaroni Grill or Olive Garden. I have seen them use it...so disappointed, I thought they were using real fruit and not flavoring. 

Beaner --- 13 years ago -

Smoothie King adds sugar. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Most smoothie bar smoothies have added it concentrated sugars. 

Beaner --- 13 years ago -

Most, but not all. Life Time Fitness serves all organic, nothing added, smoothies. 

Texashley --- 13 years ago -

I like Lifetime Fitness's Strawberry Sunrise Smoothie yuuum 

Beaner --- 13 years ago -

Try the Tropical Breeze, very good. 

planemom --- 13 years ago -

DD1 eats a smoothie everyday for lunch. It's a combo of oatmeal, fruit, milk, Greek yogurt and sugar. For 4-5 servings I use 2 teaspoons of sugar. Cheap and easy to make. They freeze well. 

Laurabeth --- 13 years ago -

We use honey from the bee hives at my dad's house or organic coconut sugar for all of recipes that call for sugar at home. :)

Yesterday we had a smoothie with cantalope, greek yogurt and honey! So YUMMY! 

Not KU --- 13 years ago -

Does the study include "home-made" smoothies? 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

If its tasty, its bad for you, good rule of thumb 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Fruit juice is not the equivalent of fruit. There is a lot more sugar and a lot less fiber in the juice. Even if you are using fresh fruit and squeezing it yourself. 

Texashley --- 13 years ago -

Try the Tropical Breeze, very good.

Just tried it this morning! Pretty good! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground