Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

How do you feel about HFD cutbacks in Kingwood?

who's talking here?

marthas attic 4
ProudTXN 8
Tylers Journey 3
Donkey Hodie 1
ghostpost 1
SuperFantastic 2
Perfection 6
Laurabeth 13
Hiro Protagonist 1
Warren Peace 1
voice of reason 2
Annie's Mom 1
a2645039uu 2
CRM6146 6
kinz 1
GeorgiaPeach 1
Ogre13 3
Gigolo Bloodline 1
Prolix Raconteur 2
mrd16 1
JustPeachy27 1
Oregonian 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

marthas attic (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

From Humble, Kingwood, Atascocita FB Page link title

Mayor Parker sued the Houston Fire Department Pension Board in January ?to get them to the negotiating table? - NOW - Houston Fire Department is taking crews out of service and starting "rolling brownouts" in the first phase of cuts. Is Kingwood's Station 102 on West Lake Houston Parkway near Northpark scheduled to be shut in phase 2?

Lengthy show (video) about it on KPRC Newsmakers - "Houston tension over HFD pension and overtime" link title


Articles:

KHOU - "7 HFD ambulance crews will not be in service due to budget cuts" - link title

My Fox Houston - Mayor Parker Files Lawsuit on HBF over pension -
link title

KHOU - "Budget crunch forcing HFD to take vehicles off streets" - link title

Chronicle - "Budget woes could lead to idle firetrucks" - "HFD may begin 'rolling brownouts' of coverage to offset overtime costs" - link title

KTRK - "HFD budget issues could impact public safety" http://goo.gl/iYq3vS

KTRK - "HFD pulling six ambulances, medic unit out of service" link title 

Tylers Journey --- 12 years ago -

Being married to a fire fighter 70% of the calls that I have heard are falls. Most of them are over weight and can't get back up and most of the time they are not charged for helping them back to their feet or into bed. 2o% are cardiac and the rest are accidents or child lock in a vehicle. I think if people did a better job at taking care of the one and only body they have health care costs and city costs would go down. 

Tylers Journey --- 12 years ago -

If you go to the bottom of the page it will show you that fire call/accidents Last 12 Months:1644
2013 - 1759
2012 - 1284
EMT
Last 12 Months:3411
2014 - 338
2013 - 3348

Atascocita fire departments site http://www.avfd.com/ 

GeorgiaPeach --- 12 years ago -

Are they that busy in Kingwood? The only place that they seem to have to go to a lot is the old folks home behind Randall's. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Maybe they can pull the Volunteers back out. I grew up in Kingwood when her had the Volunteer Fire Department and EMS. Those were some great people. While I agree many runs are not needed I would hate to think that anyone would not get the help they need. I also do not understand why the fire truck has to go to every call.. When my dad passed away I had to call 911 to have the EMTS come to the their house even though we need he was gone. The EMT's arrived as well as the fire truck. Why is that? 

Tylers Journey --- 12 years ago -

Both come because most of the time they need help lifting the patient and the FF are CPR trained 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Both come because most of the time they need help lifting the patient and the FF are CPR trained

Thanks! 

a2645039uu --- 12 years ago -

[i]Maybe they can pull the Volunteers back out. I grew up in Kingwood when her had the Volunteer Fire Department and EMS. Those were some great people. While I agree many runs are not needed I would hate to think that anyone would not get the help they need. I also do not understand why the fire truck has to go to every call.. When my dad passed away I had to call 911 to have the EMTS come to the their house even though we need he was gone. The EMT's arrived as well as the fire truck. Why is that??[/]

Two things...you know the volunteers weren't volunteers....they got paid.

Second, most of the "volunteers" were HFD on their second job anyway. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Sounds like there really isn't a need for trained fire fighters much.

More like the need is for lower level medical assistants who can help in minor urgencies.

Seems like a good career choice for some adventureous person to investigate how to make money from it and save the city money. If they could offer the service cheaper than the fire department then the city could contract that part out, get rid of those pensions and costs and meet budget by keeping only the needed fire fighters on hand.

Win win 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

Perfection: Exactly why we need unions.

If you had an emergency wouldn't you be the first to complain if the FD or EMC were delayed.

All this really doesn't affect you since you are not a Houston resident. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

How would unions help?

Keeping jobs in place when they aren't needed isn't helping anyone.

There are limited tax revenues, while I think the Mayor is picking on the fire department for political reasons, she has chosen to target them for cuts and that, as your Mayor is her right.

Therefore cut the fire department must do. They have to look at where they spend money. There are contractual obligations they can't cut like the current pensions and insurance on equipment. So where do they cut? Cuts to administration will make a dent but not $8,000,000 which is what they need to save.

There really is only one line item in their budget that can save that money and that is current payroll with the subsequent expenses associated with them.

I'm sure they have done statistical analysis of response times, calls, and other probabilities in making these cuts, I would hope the fire department isn't playing the same political game as the Mayor but they may be. They may be choosing areas that will get the most publicity even if they make sense from a purely statistical perspective.


Have we become too reliant upon others to take care of us and less reliant upon ourselves?

If someone needs help that's one thing but if they are a frequent caller to the FD for really non-urgent issues shouldn't they be charged?

Cutbacks are never easy but they are sometimes needed. 

a2645039uu --- 12 years ago -

"Sounds like there really isn't a need for trained fire fighters much.?

More like the need is for lower level medical assistants"

Firefighters are BLS (basic life support) . Thats why they are sent because there are less ALS (advanced life support) as there should be. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Firefighters are BLS (basic life support) . Thats why they are sent because there are less ALS (advanced life support) as there should be.


They are BLS but they are paid at FF salary.

I'm thinking of a business that is strictly BLS, pays at that level and sends equipment that isn't a fire truck so less expensive.

There has to be a way to do this if we think outside the box. 

kinz --- 12 years ago -

A couple years ago, I had to wait more than 15 min for an ambulance as the ones we have here in Kingwood were all out on calls.

I was thankful the FF were here. It gave me great peace of mind. 

SuperFantastic --- 12 years ago -

Every ambulance in Kingwood is an ALS one. When one gets a call another ALS from Houston is dispatched to come cover the area. We never just have BLS in our area 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Well, sadly the budget crunch is apparently of their own doing since they're $8.5m over budget (a lot of it over time due to poorly scheduled vacation days apparently)

That money doesn't grow on trees.

Anyone got any suggestions? I think we should raise taxes in Houston. As I live in Atascocita, I don't really care and can say that with impunity (Bwahh ha ha ha ha ha!). 

ProudTXN --- 12 years ago -

HFD and HPD mismanaged. I'm for a nice comfy pension, but those pensions are ridiculous. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Anyone got any suggestions? I think we should raise taxes in Houston. As I live in Atascocita, I don't really care and can say that with impunity (Bwahh ha ha ha ha ha!).


LOL Ogre13, you note I did not say raise taxes. I am much more of the mindset of limiting taxes and being more efficient.



SuperFantastic, isn't that a greater level of care that what is needed here?

What % of the calls really need ALS vs BLS level services? 

Donkey Hodie --- 12 years ago -

All of these socialist people disgust me. They rely on others to help them out and save them. We should all pull ourselves up by our own bootstraps and save ourselves in whatever emergency comes to us. Relying on others, especially govt employees, makes us socialist sheeple. WAKE UP! 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 12 years ago -

All of these socialist people disgust me. They rely on others to help them out and save them. We should all pull ourselves up by our own bootstraps and save ourselves in whatever emergency comes to us. Relying on others, especially govt employees, makes us socialist sheeple. WAKE UP!

Beautiful. Sounds like a lot folks are socilaist when it hits their life.

I say cut the hell out of it. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

since they're $8.5m over budget (a lot of it over time due to poorly scheduled vacation days apparently)


From my understanding, a lot of that overtime was paid out since the city instituted a firing freeze. Qualified personnel doesn't grow on trees either! Hiring and training new recruit would have helped with a lot of those overtime issues.

I'm for a nice comfy pension, but those pensions are ridiculous.

Tell that to a firefighter's face that has made a career out of fire fighting. Long hours, difficult situations, facing death on a daily basis, time away from family, missed holidays, missed gatherings, sleep deprivation, the rigors of the physical standard that should be maintained, dealing with the dregs of humanity on a daily basis........it all takes it toll.

It a tough career, and yes they know it going in......and yes, they earn that pension. 

CRM6146 --- 12 years ago -

Oh where to start. The only units that will be effected in Kingwood will be Ladder 102, that crew will be sent out to fill in as needed and the truck will be out of service. Both medic units may only have 1 paramedic instead of 2. There could be 1 emt and 1 paramedic but they will both be in service.

As far as the budget issue, there is money there, the city is still giving out pay raises and going forward with non-essential projects (new dog parks, redoing community parks, etc), the problem we are in is the FD went over budget. Why did the FD go over budget: 1-hiring freeze from Whitmire many years ago, HFD never caught up, classes that would have brought in more members have been canceled causing an increase in overtime, someone has to staff the units! 2-After the Fire Chief turns in the budget for the year someone appointed by the city looks it over and makes changes, about $10 million was cut from HFD budget for the current fiscal year after the Fire Chief turned in his budget. Those are 2 of the big reasons, there are other reasons such as the new response policy causing the heavy apparatus to break down more frequently increasing repair cost.

As far as Sounds like there really isn't a need for trained fire fighters much.

More like the need is for lower level medical assistants who can help in minor urgencies.

Seems like a good career choice for some adventureous person to investigate how to make money from it and save the city money. If they could offer the service cheaper than the fire department then the city could contract that part out, get rid of those pensions and costs and meet budget by keeping only the needed fire fighters on hand.

Win win

All the FF's are at least EMT's, they be move between the fire trucks and ambulances. This is a fire based ems system, the fire dept runs the ems. You can not hire only emt's or paramedics to work for the city, they must be ff trained as well because of the hours we work. A emt or paramedic only gets paid overtime after 40 hours, a fire based ems system with dual trained personnel do not have to follow those rules, we work (average) 46.7 hours a week before any overtime. Also, having a private service take over EMS has been looked into, 911 EMS response will never be profitable, every private EMS wants guaranteed money from the city so in the end the city still has to pay.

Now what you have not heard, the pension has negotiated with the city, a couple of years ago the HFD pension agreed to reduce the city's contribution rate, no one on here has heard anything about that though. The mayor nor city council has ever admitted to it, the news media will not put out the full interviews with the pension board, out of a 30-45 min interview you guys see about 5-10 sec. The ff's and the pension have tried to work with the city without so much as an acknowledgment.I'm for a nice comfy pension, but those pensions are ridiculous.
If we got paid as much as private fire services or even close to other municipalities while we are working we would be able to put more money in some other type of pension, but the way it is set up is we get a lower pay during our time in a trade off for a higher pension contribution rate from the city. The FF's also do not put into social security, we will have no social security benefits when we retire. The reason the mayor is hammering our pension so hard is because it is successful. The FF's put in, the city puts in, the the pension invests and are very successful with the investments. The FF pension is over 90% funded, that is wildly successful. The HPD and city pension are 40-50% funded, run by the city. The mayor wants to get her hands on the HFD pension to have access to extra funds that are not hers or the city's. HFD took care and nurtured OUR pension so we could retire after 30+ years and live a comfortable life we did not have during our time working.

I encourage everyone reading this to go to the fire station and talk to the guys don't just get your info from the news. HFD members will continue to show up to work no matter what happens, we will continue to take care of the citizens of Houston. You need to know though, because the mayor and city council want to prove a point or are mad a dept they are willing to gamble with you and your family's life. Out of service units, cuts in personnel, increased response time means someone will die! 

CRM6146 --- 12 years ago -

Well, sadly the budget crunch is apparently of their own doing since they're $8.5m over budget (a lot of it over time due to poorly scheduled vacation days apparently)
This is completly not true. The last 2 contracts we entered into with the city have REDUCED the amount of time we are allowed to take off (vac) and punishes us for using unschedualed (sick) time. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

Well said CRM6146....and thank you for your service from the bottom of my heart! 

JustPeachy27 --- 12 years ago -

How do you feel about HFD cutbacks in Kingwood?

It's gay. No pun intended. 

Annie's Mom --- 12 years ago -

When we were forcibly annexed we were supposedly guaranteed the same amount of fire and police protection as we had before. That never happened then so cuts don't surprise me. 

ProudTXN --- 12 years ago -

It a tough career, and yes they know it going in......and yes, they earn that pension

Exactly, they sign up for it and know what they're getting into. I appreciate all their service. I have two military kiddos serving (one currently deployed) and they do all of the above and their pensions will not be nearly what these city employees are getting. Again, they deserve a descent pension but what they are retiring with now is a bit much, which isn't helping the city's financial problems. It includes many city workers actually. When one of my relatives retired as an Admin with 30 years of service - her retirement check is now way more than what she was getting paid on a regular basis. There is something wrong with that. 

ProudTXN --- 12 years ago -

we get a lower pay during our time in a trade off for a higher pension contribution rate from the city

I did not realized this CM, thanks for clarifying now I have a better understanding of why the pension is so generous. I don't like Parker and what she is trying to do and I can't, for the life of me, understand why she was re-elected. Will be happy to see her gone. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

HFD and HPD mismanaged. I'm for a nice comfy pension, but those pensions are ridiculous.

What percentage of their salary becomes guaranteed at retirement? 

ghostpost --- 12 years ago -

Two things...you know the volunteers weren't volunteers....they got paid.

Second, most of the "volunteers" were HFD on their second job anyway.


That would be news to my dh who proudly served on the VFD here in Kingwood for several years. I spent many late nights listening to the radio hoping he would be safe, as he went out on a volunteeer call after working all day at his regular job.

And no, he did not get paid, he was a volunteer. He was not a fireman, he was a business man in the oil industry that just wanted to help his community. He was trained and worked hard at his task and took it very seriously, as did his fellow VFFs. Yes, there were some volunteers that were also part of HFD, that also volunteered here in the neighborhood. One of those heros lost his life fighting a fire in Houston about 12 years ago.

BTW- Defcon's dad was Mike Fuhre, the former KVFD chief. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

REDUCED the amount of time we are allowed to take off (vac) and punishes us for using unschedualed (sick) time.

And the way I heard it, that time off was being mismanaged in such a way as to cause massive amounts of overtime. May not be the ONLY reason, but it is the only reason discussed on the radio show I was listening to.

HOWEVER, I should mention that as someone who fought fires in the Navy and have been involved in six major incidents including body recover from a boiler explosion onboard a Leahy class cruiser....

FIREFIGHTERS are NOT paid anywhere near enough. If they were paid $1,000,000 a year, it would not be enough.

I've been shot at, been sailing around in Iranian mine fields in the Persian Gulf, Been in a cat 4 hurricane AT SEA, I've NARROWLY avoided plowing into a gasoline truck on a motorcycle at 80+ mph. And I've never been more scared than when one of the main generators on the Hoel blew up and I had to go down into the hole and fight that fire. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 12 years ago -

there's a common theme in most large cities these days where bloated, unrealistic pensions are a big part of their inability to make a workable budget 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

Exactly, they sign up for it and know what they're getting into.


As well as the "promised pension"! If you think it's such an easy ride........sign up! I have two military kiddos serving (one currently deployed) and they do all of the above and their pensions will not be nearly what these city employees are getting.


Congrats, you raised some great kids then! Thank them for me. But it's not the fire fighters fault that they chose this profession with less pension....now is it? Would you want every job to pay out the exact same? Geez.....talk about socialism. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

I've been shot at, been sailing around in Iranian mine fields in the Persian Gulf, Been in a cat 4 hurricane AT SEA, I've NARROWLY avoided plowing into a gasoline truck on a motorcycle at 80+ mph.


Geez....remind me to never go anywhere with you :) 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

there's a common theme in most large cities these days where bloated, unrealistic pensions are a big part of their inability to make a workable budget


That's just it, HFD firefighters have being willing to compromise to a degree....the city.....not so much.

Taking the pensions away from the men and woman who have earned them....is wrong. Wrong. Wrong, wrong.......... 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

and I had to go down into the hole and fight that fire.


Freakin' awesome........ :) I was quite the adrenaline junkie in my younger years......I loved...loved getting into at a fire, conquering it......and come out smiling! 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Geez....remind me to never go anywhere with you :)

LOL... I'm quite boring these days.

And THAT fire was bloody scary...stuff was exploding in the engineroom and did I mention the 40,000 gallon waste oil tank that was OVER the burning generators??? 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

So the question becomes, we can see that in the past promises were made but never funded - previous administrations may have underfunded the pensions or made promises of future payments to get reductions on the budgets then and now all the bills are coming due.

So why are the taxpayers responsible for these misallocations of previous administrations?

Where is the real accountability?


CRM6146 that is a well written response and has a lot of great info in it but is one sided.

The other side is that of the citizens and taxpayers - how much is enough?

Shouldn't we have a say if we think the department or any government paid department is being mismanaged? 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

And THAT fire was bloody scary...stuff was exploding in the engineroom and did I mention the 40,000 gallon waste oil tank that was OVER the burning generators???


Wowser.......You rock Ogre! :) 

CRM6146 --- 12 years ago -

And the way I heard it, that time off was being mismanaged in such a way as to cause massive amounts of overtime. May not be the ONLY reason, but it is the only reason discussed on the radio show I was listening to.

If it was so mismanaged years ago then why was there not an "overtime crisis" then. The issue is not overtime, I am getting much less overtime now than I was 6 years ago. The problem is the city was given a budget for the year, the city cut that budget, the cuts created a deficit in the HFD budget that we are dealing with now. It actually cost the city less to pay some overtime out than to hire new guys for every position, but all they see is the large multi million dollar number attached to the overtime so that is what they will hammer with the media. Now let me explain that: FF A makes $20/hr plus benefits, on OT $30/hr no increase to the city for benefits. The city hires FF B to relieve FF A in the morning they pay FF B $20/hr plus benefits. It would be cheaper to pay the extra $10/hr to FF A and not have to train and provide insurance and other expenses to FF B. (This is only an example, not the real numbers)
That being said you can only have the members work so much before it is unsafe. The City of Houston Fire Dept is under manned by about 500 people last I heard, that averages out to 100-125 people per shift depending on staffing postions. That is why so much overtime is being paid out. The city created the problem by cutting budgets and classes while increasing non-essential projects and insane pay raises to certain people. So yes, mismanagement is the cause, but you have to know where to look for it. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground