Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Where the poor and rich really spend their money

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 1
Work in Progress 3
Joe Blow 1
Emperor of Kingwood 10
Judas 5
a889324uu 3
Not KU 4
Butterbean 4
Vivre Libre ou Mourir 1
thesweetness 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Judas --- 11 years ago -

I'm deleting all the graphs.
GO HERE FOR GRAPHS

Lawmakers in several states are urging limits on how welfare recipients use public benefits, suggesting that the poor are buying things like lobster, filet mignon, vacations aboard cruise ships and visits to psychics. It's an open question whether the problem these proposals aim to solve actually exists, but the Bureau of Labor Statistics just helpfully released new data on how the poor -- and the rich -- spend their money.

For the first time, the bureau released this data for ten equally sized classes of U.S. households, sorted by income. While the bureau doesn't have data on lobster and filet mignon, the survey does provide a fascinating level of detail.

As the chart above shows, the rich spend more in almost every category, because they can. As a percentage of their total incomes, which are larger, the rich generally spend less. The result is that the rich have relatively more to spare after covering essentials such as housing, despite their more extravagant budgets in these categories. The chart below reveals the differences.

GO HERE FOR GRAPHS

One exception was transportation. As a share of total spending, the middle class spent the most on getting around. Biking or walking to work is something that the wealthy and the destitute do. The middle class apparently commutes by car. The bureau's data show that people with moderate incomes spend the most on auto loans, gas, repairs and car insurance relative to overall spending. (The rich still spend more in these categories in absolute terms.)

Another way of examining the data is to compare spending in each category to the household budget for food at home. This comparison makes clear how much the rich or the poor are spending on something relative to the weekly grocery list.

GO HERE FOR GRAPHS

The survey provides no evidence that the poor are wasting their money on delicacies. Indeed, the results show that regardless of income, Americans make very similar choices at the grocery store. The wealthy spend more overall, of course, and less as a share of their total spending. Yet the rich, the poor and the middle class all spend about 19 percent their grocery budget on fruits and vegetables, about 22 percent on meats, and about 13 percent on breads and cereals.

Other categories of food also show no variation with income. What about that lobster? Fish and seafood account for between 3 percent and 4 percent of the grocery budget for all groups -- $80 per year for the poor, and $222 per year for the wealthiest group.

It's comforting that when it comes to their choices at the grocery store, Americans have so much in common, given the other factors dividing the country along economic lines.

Unsurprisingly, the rich spend relatively more of their money eating out and buying alcohol, compared to the grocery budget. The poor still smoke, while the affluent have largely given up the habit.

The rich have more to spend on other luxuries, too. The richest tenth spent $2,239 over the year on fees and admissions, likely to sporting events, museums and concerts, and $1,084 on their pets. The poorest group spent $162 and $220 in these categories, respectively.

The greatest difference by far between rich and poor is not in how they spend, but how they save. For every dollar they spend at the grocery store, the poorest households save 12 cents, while the wealthy sock away $3.07 in pensions and life insurance.

This image perfectly sums up inequality in America, according to the Internet.

This is one reason that some economists are concerned about rising levels of inequality. The rich save more than the poor, and the more they have, they more they'll save. Money that's being saved isn't being spent, which means less business for everyone from the dry cleaner on the corner to the owner of a five-star hotel. In turn, that means less work for everybody and a lethargic economy.

To be sure, banks can invest the money that the wealthy save, which can stimulate the economy as well. Yet many observers, including former Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, are worried that as a global society, we've accumulated too much in the way of savings already. 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

Well that's obnoxious. How do I shrink them? I removed them and linked them instead.

Very interesting survey! 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Seems like a very stilted view on spending. Did you notice that it said Pensions and Life insurance? Thats a very very limited choice of investment spending. There was no mention of other investments such as real estate, stocks, etc.

Also, there's no allowance for the fact that people with more money tend to dine out much more frequently than those that don't so comparing dining out with smoking is just silly.

Finally comparing spending as a percent of total income in these narrow categories is nonsense. 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

Seems like a very stilted view on spending. Did you notice that it said Pensions and Life insurance? Thats a very very limited choice of investment spending. There was no mention of other investments such as real estate, stocks, etc.



The answer is clear to me. The poor don't have any of that. My guess is that they have pensions and life insurance through their employment and very few have even that but it's better than nothing therefore worth showing.


Also, there's no allowance for the fact that people with more money tend to dine out much more frequently than those that don't so comparing dining out with smoking is just silly.

This wasn't done. Both were just mentioned in a paragraph. Inconsequential.


Finally comparing spending as a percent of total income in these narrow categories is nonsense.


Only in your narrow minded opinion. The first graph of total annual spending in relation to total annual income is quite relevant. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Only in your narrow minded opinion. The first graph of total annual spending in relation to total annual income is quite relevant.

Relevant to what in your narrow minded view? Its basic math, change the numerator or denominator and the quotient changes. So what. It means nothing. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

I would be willing to bet that the rich (whatever defintion that is) spend way more as a percenta of their income on vacation homes, vacations, cars (not transportation), furniture and quality thereof. All which means absolutely nothing. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Yes, here's another fact for you. Some people make more than others. There are many reasons for this, but its still a fact. 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

Food and shelter are our basic necessities. They threw in transportation which is biggie in today's world. These are basic categories that say so much. An analysis of how today's society addresses these financially should be of great interest. If you don't care that's because your needs are met and you couldn't give two craps about anyone else. We get that from reading your daily snob diatribes.

In other words if you're not interested, move on to another topic. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Not much doubt about the distribution of wealth among the populace over the last 50 years.

The rich have gotten richer and the poor have gotten poorer.

The distance between the richest and poorest has increased dramatically. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Poor has a more definate definition defined as the poverty level, but no one seems to be able to define rich. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

and you couldn't give two craps about anyone else. We get that from reading your daily snob diatribes.

Jealous? 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

I'm rich. You're rich.

A lot of people are poor. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

I'm rich. You're rich.

A lot of people are poor.


I'm by no means rich.

Thats the point. The bar for poor has risen but what has happened to the bar for rich? According to this administration, the bar for rich has decreased. Therefore, folks who formerly were upper middle class are now considered rich while folks who were lower middle class might be considered poor. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Thats the point. The bar for poor has risen but what has happened to the bar for rich? According to this administration, the bar for rich has decreased. Therefore, folks who formerly were upper middle class are now considered rich while folks who were lower middle class might be considered poor.

Tell it like it is, Emp. You're rich.

You resent having to pay taxes.

You resent any "welfare" programs that might use a part of the taxes that you personally paid.

The upper 5% that you post about makes you rich.

You have little, if any, compassion for anyone else. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Did I mention that you're rich? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Tell it like it is, Emp. You're rich.

No, I'm not. I don't consider myself rich by any means.

You resent having to pay taxes.

No, taxes are necessary. What I resent is waste and creating anothergeneration enslaved by government hand outs. I believe in a hand up, not hand outs.

You resent any "welfare" programs that might use a part of the taxes that you personally paid.

No, see above and add to it, I be;lieve in self responsibility.


The upper 5% that you post about makes you rich.

Thats an IRS defintion, not mine. Its how they breakdown their statistics.

You have little, if any, compassion for anyone else.

I have compassion for those that can not help themselves, not for those that WON'T help themselves. 

thesweetness --- 11 years ago -

The funny thing is welfare and food stamps for cheaters is probably the 100th most important item out of 100 total spending areas that are most important.
This is simply the lower middle class hating the lower class due to some perceived benefits advantage.
I feel for these KUers who have nothing but hate in their heart. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

nothing but hate in their heart.

I didn't read anywhere on here where anyone said they hated anyone else. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Where the poor and rich really spend their money

*Fast food joints.
*Wallmart
*Corporate grocery stores
*Used car lots 

Vivre Libre ou Mourir --- 11 years ago -

Butterbean --- 19 hours ago - quote - hide comments

You have little, if any, compassion for anyone else.


Kind of like you and the compassion you showed for the lady that was looking for her missing 18 yr. old daughter?

Hypocrite, thy name is Butterbean. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Jealous?



You sound like SoupFerBrains. Not everyone who points out your bragging is jealous or even poor for that matter. I, for example, live very well but the difference between you and I is that I don't have a need to come on KU daily and brag about it. I am concerned for those less fortunate, you most certainly are not.

Meanwhile RightWingNJMom....SU. 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

Let's get back on topic.

0 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Ignorant meme's for the ignorant. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Memes for Soup

0undefined 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Mark, would you still believe in raising the minimum wage if it led to more unemployment? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

come on KU daily and brag about it.

Show one place where I mentioned anything about my income OTHER than to say it was at least minimum wage. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

sweetness, you nailed it.
This is all about lower middle class feeling slighted.
They might be upper middle class if only that damn mom with 2 jobs worked a little harder. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Soup, RayofHope is the King of ignorant memes. I thought y'all were pals! 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Mark, would you still believe in raising the minimum wage if it led to more unemployment?

I'm not into hypothetical s. Fear mongering isn't my thing. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

If I can prove to you that it causes more unemployment, would you still advocate for it?

Think carefully, because I can back it up. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Think carefully, because I can back it up.

Thanks for the warning. Lets look at it this way. If raising the min wage causes UN-employment, then what was lost? A min wage job. What will that worker do? Get a better paying job.

I understand how a business with limited income could be jeopardized by having to pay more for the same level of output from the existing work force, and the fiscal outlook is a smaller profit margin for the entrepreneur. Or worse the closing of a business.

Some business would close. But was it the min wage, or bad management?

On the other hand if the workforce has more money in their pockets, wouldn't it seem spending would go up as well? I think it would. So, that entrepreneur would have to hire more help to meet the demand. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Mark, look at the countries with generous minimum wage laws--Greece, South Africa, Spain, they have unemployment rates of around 25%! Countries like Switzerland, with no minimum wage laws, have 2% unemployment.

The people who get hurt the worst with minimum wage laws are the young, and statistically, the minority young.

Mark, you aren't eliminating a bad job. You are eliminating opportunity. Statistics also show that people who enter into minimum wage jobs don't stay there after gaining work experience! The majority of minimum wagers are teens. You seem to think that you can increase the cost of having a worker without lowering the demand for the worker, but this isn't possible. You are actually creating a situation where businesses will higher less people than before and work their employees harder because they cannot afford to give more people entry level opportunity due to your "compassion."

It isn't compassion if it is hurting real people Mark. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Wrong again WIP, as usual.
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, 3/4 of those earning minimum wage are over the age of 20, NOT teens. Approximately 50% of those are women.

Do you need it shown to you in a pop up coloring book so it's easier for you to understand? 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground