Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Can States Ignore the Supreme Court on Gay Marriage?

who's talking here?

wayward1 1
SoupIsGoodFood 4
Red Heifer 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
steinhoister2016 2
Joe Blow 5
Sharticus 1
Emperor of Kingwood 4
Judas 2
Butterbean 4
mutton 3
alldayredux 2
Proud American 3
Detonator 1
Max01 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

The Atlantic
By David A. Graham
5 hours ago?
?

The Supreme Court?s decision last week did make gay marriage legal around the nation. Unfortunately for social conservatives, it did not, however, make nullification legal around the nation.

Nullification is the historical idea that states can ignore federal laws, or pass laws that supercede them. This concept has a long but not especially honorable pedigree in U.S. history. Its origins date back to antebellum America, where Southern states tried to nullify tariffs and Northern states tried to nullify fugitive-slave laws. In the 1950s, after Brown v. Board of Education, some Southern states tried to pass laws to avoid integrating schools. It didn?t work, because nullification is not constitutional.

Yet futile hope springs eternal. Since the ruling, a handful of officials have suggested that states need not issue licenses for same-sex marriages. The two most notable voices are two Republican candidates for president, Mike Huckabee and Ted Cruz.

Here?s Cruz, speaking to NPR:

Recommended: 100 Percent Is Overrated


They cannot ignore a direct judicial order. The parties to a case cannot ignore a direct judicial order. But it does not mean that those who are not parties to case are bound by a judicial order ....

The entire premise of the decision on marriage was that in 1868, when the people of the United States ratified the 14th Amendment, that we were somehow silently and unawares striking down every marriage law across the country. That's a preposterous notion. That is not law. That is not even dressed up as law.

This is a little slippery to interpret?Cruz?s words are opaque, so that it?s unclear whether he?s actually arguing that officials should refuse to issue marriage licenses, or simply making an intellectual argument that they could. (Or perhaps it?s a dogwhistle!)

Is he right? ?It?s ridiculous,? said David Vladeck, a professor of law at Georgetown. ?The Supreme Court says the Fourteenth Amendment requires states to issue licenses .? That is the law of the land. We have something in the Constitution called the Supremacy Clause,? which states that the Constitution is the ultimate authority in the U.S.

One argument here is that the ruling only applies to the Sixth Circuit, as that?s where the case the justices decided originated. That might hold true if it was a statutory, rather than constitutional ruling, Vladeck said?but it wasn?t. ?Ted Cruz ought to know that. I knew Ted Cruz before he became the new Ted Cruz, and he was an able lawyer,? Vladeck said. ?My guess is this is just political posturing of the worst kind.?

Recommended: Were All Those Rainbow Profile Photos Another Facebook Study?
?Ted Cruz ought to know that. My guess is this is just political posturing of the worst kind.?
Now, a state?say, Texas, where Attorney General Ken Paxton has told clerks they can refuse to issue same-sex marriage licenses?could try its luck: ?You don?t have to obey a red light,? Vladeck cracked. But it?s pretty easy to guess what would happen: A plaintiff would bring a civil-rights suit; courts would rule in their favor; and the state would probably have to pay for the plaintiffs? attorneys fees, under a federal law.

Mike Huckabee takes a slightly different approach: ?I'm not sure that every governor and every attorney general should just say, well, it's the law of the land because there's no enabling legislation.?

The former Arkansas governor has been trying this line for some time, but it hasn?t gotten any more correct since I wrote about it in January. Huckabee is claiming that there needs to be an affirmative law authorizing gay marriage, but that?s wrong. The justices ruled only that provisions banning same-sex marriage are illegal, not that all marriage laws have to be rewritten. By analogy, the Supreme Court?s decision overturning bans on mixed-race unions in Loving v. Virginia didn?t eliminate all marriage laws.

Recommended: A World Without Work

Really, the only way a state or jurisdiction could legally circumvent the Court?s ruling would be to stop issuing marriage licenses altogether. ?But that would be self-defeating, particularly among people who view marriage as the foundation of American society,? Vladeck noted.

There?s some precedent for that, though it?s not pretty. After Brown, some whites pulled their children out of public schools and opened all-white ?segregation academies??effectively reconstituting the public schools as private ones and avoiding integration orders. Virginia tried to close public schools that integrated. When that was ruled unconstitutional, Prince Edward County simply closed down its entire public-school system. Elsewhere in the South, the resistance was less elaborate?governors like Orval Faubus and George Wallace simply tried to block integration, sometimes by literally standing in the doorway. They were overruled by the federal government.

Unlike in the 1950s and 1960s, it seems unlikely that the government will send in troops to enforce the Court?s ruling on marriage. That?s because they won?t have to, which is a positive sign for the rule of law in the United States. But there may be a period of litigation as marriage-equality opponents exhaust every possible path (and possibly their states? coffers) fighting against the ruling.

Recommended: What ISIS Really Wants

To see how real the shift is, look to the example of Roy Moore, the chief judge of the Alabama Supreme Court. Moore became famous in an earlier term as chief judge, when he refused to remove a Ten Commandments monument and was removed from the bench. He later returned, and in February instructed Alabama probate clerks not to issue same-sex marriage licenses, despite a federal court striking down Alabama?s gay-marriage ban?a bid for state judiciaries to trump the federal one. This week, Moore issued a confusing order, but then clarified to say that he was not instructing probate clerks to disobey the Supreme Court.

Perhaps Moore doesn?t want to be remembered alongside Orval Faubus and George Wallace. Or maybe he?s just realized what some people were saying all along: There?s no such thing as nullification.

0 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

0 

Max01 --- 11 years ago -

Mississippi is may stop offering marriage licenses to all.

Maybe other states will file suit and get out of the marrying business.

link title 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Don't take the bait, Max. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Mississippi one of the few states more back asswards than Texas. LMAO

0undefined 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

Looks like it's basically down to the 2 dullard wing nuts of KU (soup of Bob) to carry the fight for 'Merica after this weeks trouncing.

2 guys with 5 alts and ZERO employment carrying the torch. Lick my boots please. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Except for the fact that I am employed, and have no alts.

The government has no right licensing any kind of relationship. 

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

I've said for years that the government shouldn't be in the marriage business. Everyone should be treated as individuals before the government. Of course, then we have to change Social Security benefits, Veterans benefits, tax filing rules, hospital privileges, etc etc etc, but I'd be ok with all of that. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Except for the fact that I am employed, and have no alts.



LMFAO When is it you get any work done? Same goes for your counterpart Soup Brain. MaxiLynch as well.


The government has no right licensing any kind of relationship.


Why weren't you crying the blues about hetero marriage licenses? Hypocrite. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Why weren't you crying the blues about hetero marriage licenses? Hypocrite

You really need to get caught up, I've been saying that for some time. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

LMFAO When is it you get any work done? Same goes for your counterpart Soup Brain. MaxiLynch as well.

Maybe I took today off, maybe I am screwing off in my office, at any rate, whats it to you? 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

Liar 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

2 guys with 5 alts and ZERO employment carrying the torch. Lick my boots please.

Awesome. Glad to see I get completely under you skin.

Also glad to see you taking a Nat Geo break today, allday. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

LMFAO When is it you get any work done? Same goes for your counterpart Soup Brain. MaxiLynch as well.

Don't be jealous, Joe. Just because you have to clock in and report to the man doesn't mean you have to hate on those of us who got smart and started our own businesses. I'm sure your boss would be happy to know you spend your entire day posting your hate on a local board. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Soup Fer Brains, the biggest hater here in a tie with the other two homophobes. LMFAO 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Soup Fer Brains, the biggest hater here in a tie with the other two homophobes. LMFAO

Not hardly. I already pointed out one of your unwarranted hate filled attacks today.

Keep trucking. 

Sharticus --- 11 years ago -

0 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Ok, that's just funny- lol! 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

lol 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Yes, that is funny. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

Now am hungry... 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Yep. Ice cream time here. Butter pecan tonight. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

No...CHEETOS! with a goose chaser! 

Detonator --- 11 years ago -

Sure they can. This garbage is WRONG. The liberals have run amok. I would refuse to comply. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

And then you get sued in federal court, held in contempt of court and jailed 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

I can see the news story now. "Boston harbor is full of broken crates of rainbow glitter from an apparent protest." 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

Do we really have to point out who's gay and who's straight? Can't we just love everyone and judge them by the car they drive? 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

Joe - you live here, right? What kind of bonehead continues to live in a state they think is backwards? What's stopping you from moving? 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

Change your name to Proud Texan and plaster a bumperstucker to your forehead. Choose one=
a. Native Texan
b. I wasn't born in Texas but got here as fast as I could 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Patience. Those that refuse to do their jobs in a governmental position won't have that position long.

They serve the public. All of the public, including far right wingers that are spoilin' for a fight 'cause "nobody's gonna tell them what to do." 

steinhoister2016 --- 11 years ago -

Mississippi one of the few states more back asswards than Texas. LMAO





That number is dwindling.... 

steinhoister2016 --- 11 years ago -

Change your name to Proud Texan and plaster a bumperstucker to your forehead. Choose one=
a. Native Texan
b. I wasn't born in Texas but got here as fast as I could




C. I fell for the low cost of living and moved to Texas, looked around, found next to nothing to do here, insufferable heat and humidity, and got out as fast as I could.



*Edited to add: I found out quickly why the cost of living is so low. 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

Patience. Those that refuse to do their jobs in a governmental position won't have that position long. They serve the public. All of the public, including far right wingers that are spoilin' for a fight 'cause "nobody's gonna tell them what to do."

those religious rights didn't last long! 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

Y'all should move! 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

I like it here. 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground