Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Do you know what Cap and Trade is?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
DrowningFish 1
JerseyGirl 3
Fallon 2
planemom 19
Sandyr9111 3
maverick 1
ukchristine 1
AuthorMan 1
NoNameNoLastName 14
Mabbers 1
wisherman 2
new_yorker_guy 2
USNA Mom 2
david 3
justforfun 6
JUNIPER 1
~sassy~ 1
Perfection 5
FANCY PANTS 10
PS 1
Agent of Change 1
summygood 1
believer 7
RCSKI 1
genxer 3
jtcitrus 6
NewNanna 1
Shenanigans 3
evolved 2
Darwin 3
*momof5* 10
Shaken-Not-Stirred 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

FANCY PANTS --- 17 years ago -

Cap and trade is the tax that dare not speak its name, and Democrats are hoping in particular that no one notices who would pay for their climate ambitions. With President Obama depending on vast new carbon revenues in his budget and Congress promising a bill by May, perhaps Americans would like to know the deeply unequal ways that climate costs would be distributed across regions and income groups. AP.Politicians love cap and trade because they can claim to be taxing "polluters," not workers. Hardly. Once the government creates a scarce new commodity -- in this case the right to emit carbon -- and then mandates that businesses buy it, the costs would inevitably be passed on to all consumers in the form of higher prices. Stating the obvious, Peter Orszag -- now Mr. Obama's budget director -- told Congress last year that "Those price increases are essential to the success of a cap-and-trade program." Hit hardest would be the "95% of working families" Mr. Obama keeps mentioning, usually omitting that his no-new-taxes pledge comes with the caveat "unless you use energy." Putting a price on carbon is regressive by definition because poor and middle-income households spend more of their paychecks on things like gas to drive to work, groceries or home heating. The Congressional Budget Office -- Mr. Orszag's former roost -- estimates that the price hikes from a 15% cut in emissions would cost the average household in the bottom-income quintile about 3.3% of its after-tax income every year. That's about $680, not including the costs of reduced employment and output. The three middle quintiles would see their paychecks cut between $880 and $1,500, or 2.9% to 2.7% of income. The rich would pay 1.7%. Cap and trade is the ideal policy for every Beltway analyst who thinks the tax code is too progressive (all five of them). But the greatest inequities are geographic and would be imposed on the parts of the U.S. that rely most on manufacturing or fossil fuels -- particularly coal, which generates most power in the Midwest, Southern and Plains states. It's no coincidence that the liberals most invested in cap and trade -- Barbara Boxer, Henry Waxman, Ed Markey -- come from California or the Northeast. Coal provides more than half of U.S. electricity, and 25 states get more than 50% of their electricity from conventional coal-fired generation. In Ohio, it totals 86%, according to the Energy Information Administration. Ratepayers in Indiana (94%), Missouri (85%), New Mexico (80%), Pennsylvania (56%), West Virginia (98%) and Wyoming (95%) are going to get soaked. Another way to think about it is in terms of per capita greenhouse-gas emissions. California is the No. 2 carbon emitter in the country but also has a large economy and population. So the average Californian only had a carbon footprint of about 12 tons of CO2-equivalent in 2005, according to the World Resource Institute's Climate Analysis Indicators, which integrates all government data. The situation is very different in Wyoming and North Dakota -- paging Senators Mike Enzi and Kent Conrad -- where every person was responsible for 154 and 95 tons, respectively. See the nearby chart for cap and trade's biggest state winners and losers. .Democrats say they'll allow some of this ocean of new cap-and-trade revenue to trickle back down to the public. In his budget, Mr. Obama wants to recycle $525 billion through the "making work pay" tax credit that goes to many people who don't pay income taxes. But $400 for individuals and $800 for families still doesn't offset carbon's income raid, especially in states with higher carbon use. All the more so because the Administration is lowballing its cap-and-trade tax estimates. Its stated goal is to reduce emissions 14% below 2005 levels by 2020, which assuming that four-fifths of emissions are covered (excluding agriculture, for instance), works out to about $13 or $14 per ton of CO2. When CBO scored a similar bill last year, it expected prices to start at $23 and rise to $44 by 2018. CBO also projected the total value of the allowances at $902 billion over the first decade, which is some $256 billion more than the Administration's estimate. We asked the White House budget office for the assumptions behind its revenue estimates, but a spokesman said the Administration doesn't have a formal proposal and will work with Congress and "stakeholders" to shape one. We were also pointed to recent comments by Mr. Orszag that he was "sure there will be enough there to finance the things that we have identified" and maybe "additional money" too. In other words, Mr. Obama expects a much larger tax increase than even he is willing to admit. Those "stakeholders" are going to need some very large bribes, starting with the regions that stand to lose the most. Led by Michigan's Debbie Stabenow, 15 Senate Democrats have already formed a "gang" demanding that "consumers and workers in all regions of the U.S. are protected from undue hardship." In practice, this would mean corporate welfare for carbon-heavy businesses. And of course Congress is its own "stakeholder." An economy-wide tax under the cover of saving the environment is the best political moneymaker since the income tax. Obama officials are already telling the press, sotto voce, that climate revenues might fund universal health care and other new social spending. No doubt they would, and when they did Mr. Obama's cap-and-trade rebates would become even smaller. Cap and trade, in other words, is a scheme to redistribute income and wealth -- but in a very curious way. It takes from the working class and gives to the affluent; takes from Miami, Ohio, and gives to Miami, Florida; and takes from an industrial America that is already struggling and gives to rich Silicon Valley and Wall Street "green tech" investors who know how to leverage the political class.  

FANCY PANTS --- 17 years ago -

We all need to call, email and hound our government to vote NO on Cap and Trade. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Just because some unnamed source doesn't like the idea? 

FANCY PANTS --- 17 years ago -

Just because some unnamed source doesn't like the idea? No...Just because we will all have to live like we live in a 3rd world country if this passes. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Wow, just wow. 

david --- 17 years ago -

So the dems think the tax will not be passed to consumers WOW did I mention wow 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

Thank you for posting this Fancy Pants. I've been frustrated for days b/c the news will not cover the rising utility costs that this bill will mean for the American public. I've seen two threads on utility bills today and nobody knows that the House just passed a bill that will make those utility bills go up no matter what they set their temps at or how often they water their yard. Hopefully it can be stopped in the Senate. We just need to get enough people aware of what is in the bill. Thanks again. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

So the dems think the tax will not be passed to consumers WOW did I mention wow It must be nice to live in their world. You know it will be passed onto us. 

USNA Mom --- 17 years ago -

The CBO (Congressional Budget Office) estimates our taxes will go up if this passes, plus our electic bills will sky rocket! 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

The CBO (Congressional Budget Office) estimates our taxes will go up if this passes, plus our electic bills will sky rocket! Someone post the phone numbers if you have them. We have to stop this. I don't want to pay more and more while getting less and less. 

USNA Mom --- 17 years ago -

Go to www.house.gov or www.senate.gov 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Well, the energy costs in Texas are one of the highest in the US because of deregulation. That whole "choose your provider" and "let the market regulate" backfired. If you want to pay less, ask for regulation to come back. CBO estimated $$175 a year increase for a typical family. I guess our concepts of "skyrocket" are a bit different. 

david --- 17 years ago -

So we can thank junk science for increasing our utility bills has anyone informed obama that were in a recession just a means to get uhc passed. I can hear the radio address now "americans can't pay there light bills, how can we expect them to worry about health insurance". 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

junk science Why? Because a guy in Australia financed by oil companies said so? 

JUNIPER --- 17 years ago -

CBO estimated $$175 a year increase for a typical family. I guess our concepts of "skyrocket" are a bit different. Houston has some of the worst air pollution in the country. Our family will actually save money if this bill passes. Asthma medication costs at least that per month. Plus several trips to the doctors' per year. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Well, the energy costs in Texas are one of the highest in the US because of deregulation. That whole "choose your provider" and "let the market regulate" backfired. If you want to pay less, ask for regulation to come back. I was just saying this to my friend yesterday!!!! Everywhere I have lived previous to Texas, had one provider for gas and one provider for electric. We NEVER had bills as expensive as we've had here...it's a HUGE difference. I realize the climate is different here with the humidity, but, my gas bills to heat my 2 story home in the dead of winter in Utah and Massachusetts are nowhere near as expensive as cooling your home here. It's ridiculous! Seriously, dead of winter, highest bill we ever had was $375 for one month. That was in New England, 100+ year old house with radiator heat and no insulation. We can't cool homes built in the last 30 years for less than that??? PUH-LEEZE! 

david --- 17 years ago -

No becuase everything they claim is global warming wait they had to change the name climate change has been debunked, the earth goes through cycles FACTUAL So juniper buying carbon credits is going to help the factories will buy the credits they need at the current rate there burning, then you get to see your gas bill increase, utility bill, groc bill, clothing etc.. 

FANCY PANTS --- 17 years ago -

A Costly Proposition These measures would set a limit, or cap, on carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuel use. The effect of such a cap would be to impose rationing of coal, oil, and natural gas on the American economy. Each covered utility, oil company, and manufacturing facility would be given allowances based on past emissions or some other formula. Those companies that emit less carbon dioxide than permitted by their allowances could sell the excess to those that do not; this is the trade part of cap and trade. Over time, the cap would be ratcheted down, requiring greater cuts in emissions. Each proposal differs from the others on specifics: the stringency of the cap, the number and type of companies covered, the ground rules for allocating and trading allowances, and other details. S. 2191 is, in several respects, more stringent than other cap and trade bills. Its requirement that emissions decline to 15 percent below 2005 levels by 2020--even in the face of a growing population and rising energy demand--sets a very difficult target.[1] Measures like S. 2191 that target carbon emissions aggressively will be costlier than those that give the economy more time to adjust to the energy constraints. For example, over the long term, energy companies may find ways to capture and store carbon dioxide emissions underground, rather than emit them into the air, or switch to lower-emitting alternative energy sources as they are developed. But most experts see these advances as taking decades--much longer than the initial targets in S. 2191 allow. In fact, these targets may actually complicate the development of longer-term innovations, as they will divert resources to near-term fixes. Carbon dioxide is the unavoidable byproduct of fossil fuel combustion, which currently provides 85 percent of America's energy. Thus, it will be very costly to move away from this preferred energy source, and especially doing so as expeditiously as S. 2191 requires. A study by Charles River Associates puts the cost (in terms of reduced household spending per year) of S. 2191 at $800 to $1,300 per household by 2015, rising to $1,500 to $2,500 by 2050.[2] Electricity prices could jump by 36 to 65 percent by 2015 and 80 to 125 percent by 2050.[3] No analysis has been done on the impact of S. 2191 on gasoline prices, but an Environmental Protection Agency study of a less stringent cap and trade bill estimates impacts of 26 cents per gallon by 2030 and 68 cents by 2050.[4] Even these cost projections may underestimate the true costs, because they assume no unpleasant surprises. But the world has already witnessed many unpleasant surprises with Europe's ongoing efforts to impose a cap and trade program under the Kyoto Protocol, the international climate treaty to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. In fact, European efforts have racked up significant costs while failing to reduce emissions.[5] Nearly every European country participating has higher emissions today than when the treaty was first signed in 1997. Further, despite ongoing criticism of the United States from Kyoto parties for failing to ratify the treaty, emissions in many of these nations are actually rising faster than in the United States. The European experience also shows the problem of cap and trade fraud.[6] None other than Enron's Ken Lay was a strong supporter of carbon cap and trade when the idea was first floated in the 1990s, saying that it could "do more to promote Enron's business than almost any other regulatory initiative." These carbon allowances that will be bought and sold have a value estimated at $50 billion to $300 billion annually, and the trade in them would be a huge new business.[7] Enron may be gone, but others ready to take advantage of cap and trade--often at public expense--are not. The actual cost of S. 2191 is difficult to estimate--as America has never had to deal with such severe energy constraints--but would likely be very high. A Regressive Tax By limiting the supply of fossil fuels, S. 2191 would raise the cost of energy. For consumers, cap and trade means more expensive gasoline and electricity as well as net job losses in energy-dependent sectors. Senator Lieberman himself concedes costs into the hundreds of billions of dollars. And as the Congressional Budget Office has noted, such energy cost increases act as a regressive tax on the poor.[8] Lost Jobs The net job losses from S. 2191 are estimated by Charles River Associates to be 1.2 million to 2.3 million by 2015.[9] Some of these jobs will be lost for good, due to the impact of higher energy costs on economic activity. Others, chiefly in the manufacturing sector, will be sent overseas. In the very likely event that S. 2191 significantly raises domestic manufacturing costs and that developing nations refuse to impose similar restrictions, the American economy could experience a substantial outsourcing of manufacturing jobs to those nations with lower energy costs. Little Environmental Gain While the costs of aggressive cap and trade proposals are substantial, the environmental benefits are suspect. This is true even if one fully accepts the claim of man-made global warming. The most ambitious measure to date is the Kyoto Protocol, but even if the U.S. were a party to this treaty and the European nations and other signatories were in full compliance (most are unlikely to meet their targets), the treaty would reduce the Earth's future temperature by an estimated 0.07 degrees Celsius by 2050--an amount too small even to verify.[10] S. 2191 would at best do only a little more. Indeed, a number of economists, including many who are far from global warming skeptics, warn of overly aggressive cap and trade measures imposing costs exceeding the benefits.[11] In other words, the costs of implementing such measures would be higher than the value of the global warming damage that they would prevent. The Slippery Slope It is a near certainty that the first climate bill enacted will not be the last one. In fact, most major environmental organizations have already criticized S. 2191 and other pending global warming bills as inadequate, or as at best "a good first step." The economic impacts of S. 2191, though substantial in their own right, could be a mere down payment toward costlier subsequent measures. Conclusion Cap and trade bills are nothing short of a government re-engineering of the American economy. And S. 2191, with its aggressive targets to reduce emissions from fossil fuel use, would put the nation on a path of serious economic harm not justified by any benefits. Ben Lieberman is Senior Policy Analyst for Energy and the Environment in the Thomas A. Roe Institute for Economic Policy Studies at The Heritage Foundation. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

I was just saying this to my friend yesterday!!!! Yes she was. I can't even visit the electricity thread because I'm very embarrassed by our bills. :( 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Untold thousands of jobs will be lost if this passes. Those jobs that remain, will be taxed so high that no one will bother working them. But hey, we will all love one another and that is really what it is all about. 

FANCY PANTS --- 17 years ago -

we will all love one another and that is really what it is all about. yes, the love is all that matters. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I love how Rep Pelosi was going to have former VP Gore fly to Washington DC in his private jet to give a pep talk on carbon problems and pollution. Does anyone else see anything wrong with this? In the age of teleconferencing and worry about the environment they hop on private jets. Hypocrits 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Untold thousands of jobs will be lost if this passes. Those jobs that remain, will be taxed so high that no one will bother working them. But hey, we will all love one another and that is really what it is all about. Sad, just sad. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Houston has some of the worst air pollution in the country. But God forbid we do something about it. It hurts businesses. The level of Sulfur in the air here is so high that sometimes you go outside for a feel minutes and come back reeking eggs. You and your family breathe that stuff, then you get sick and you wonder why. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Sky is falling! Run! Buy ammo! Buy canned food! Build a bunker! Brought to you by the GOP. 

Agent of Change --- 17 years ago -

Untold thousands of jobs will be lost if this passes. Just the opposite is true. A report by the Center for American Progress and the University of Massachusetts also found that the bill would create 1.7 million new jobs. Source 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

CBO estimated $$175 a year increase for a typical family I think that is just utilities and it is only for the year 2020. After 2020, when the standards increase more the costs will probably go up. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

the University of Massachusetts should have left that part out! They'll never believe it to be true now! Damn Yankees!! 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Why is there such a rush to pass all of this legislation? If it's good legislation it'll stand up to scrutiny. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

I think that is just utilities and it is only for the year 2020. After 2020, when the standards increase more the costs will probably go up. Right. You are saying that technology to reduce emissions will not improve in the next 10 years, and the costs will remain the same. Technology never improves, sure. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Why is there such a rush to pass all of this legislation? If it's good legislation it'll stand up to scrutiny. I guess people are not used to a president who actually has a plan and executes according to it. After 8 years of Bush, this is expected. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

A report by the Center for American Progress and the University of Massachusetts Yea, that's unbiased. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Why is there such a rush to pass all of this legislation? If it's good legislation it'll stand up to scrutiny. I guess you have answered your own question. They don't want people to read or question this bill. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I guess people are not used to a president who actually has a plan and executes according to it. After 8 years of Bush, this is expected. I guess it's too much to expect elected representatives to have time to read and understand what they are voting on. Or better yet, give the American people time to sort through all the hype. We're just the little people. The people in Washington D.C. know what's best for us so we should just sit down and be quiet. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

The people in Washington D.C. know what's best for us so we should just sit down and be quiet. That is what they keep telling us. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Right. You are saying that technology to reduce emissions will not improve in the next 10 years, and the costs will remain the same. I do expect technology to improve over time. However, how much will it cost? That is why the costs associated with this bill are all over the place. Nobody knows. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

From what I've read, it appears that utility companies are getting a better deal than petroleum companies. Does that mean our utilities won't go up that much but the price of gasoline will? 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Anything that uses energy will get taxed. I guess I will get money back. lol 

wisherman --- 17 years ago -

This is currently being debated in the House on C-span. Interesting to watch. Evasive, evasive, evasive. 

FANCY PANTS --- 17 years ago -

This is what U.S. Sen. John Cornyn of Texas has to say about Cap and Trade U.S. Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, today issued the following statement regarding President Obama's cap-and-trade proposal, which is scheduled to be voted on by the House of Representatives today: "President Obama this week sought to sell his cap-and-trade proposal to Texans by calling it a win-win-win-win-win proposition. As the number one energy producing state in the nation, Texans know firsthand that this is patently false, and his harmful cap-and-trade tax proposal would impose the largest tax increase in American history and result in major losses for Texans across the state. Texans will lose jobs, our economy will lose revenue, and families will pay for higher energy bills. The best way to achieve economic, environmental, and energy security is by encouraging more nuclear energy generation and domestic energy production. Yet, the President's cap-and-trade proposal would do the opposite by shackling domestic energy production with more red tape and restrictions. I call on all Texans to join me in opposing cap-and-trade and similar misguided policies that conceal the true cost to taxpayers and only further our dangerous dependence on foreign energy." Sen. Cornyn serves on the Finance, Judiciary and Budget Committees. He serves as the top Republican on the Judiciary Committee's Immigration, Refugees and Border Security subcommittee. He served previously as Texas Attorney General, Texas Supreme Court Justice, and Bexar County District Judge. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground