Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Opinions - Best Dogs for Security and Families

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
Saturn 2
LAXmom 3
sheltielover 2
Perfection 1
AngieKaye 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
tinman 5
MiaBella Farm 1
Work in Progress 2
BCSKW 1
In AbsentiaW 1
Dorothy Parker 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
SailorTattoos 13
gunsnroses 1
Its Mygirl01 3
FabFive 9
scipsekatattes 1
Semper 14
MoreToLife 2
JAMS 1
BiteMe 2
Smoochie and The Bean 5
dadof4 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Looking for opionions on what dogs are the best for home security BUT that are also good around children ...as young as toddler.

We currently have a spunky JRT but she doesn't really intimidate anyone and during a break in in 2009 she was left terrified in a corner.

My personal feeling is that I am interested in a German Shepherd but I'd like to get some more information. I'm not even sure if a male or female would be better. My JRT is a girl (yes, she's spayed ;). 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

This would probably scare off any intruders, but doesn't look smart enough to plot against you.


0 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

Grrr. . . .Try that again:

0 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Great Dane. Hands down. They are bred to be protective but not aggressive. They are awesome family dogs. Loyal and laid back. Until they sense danger. Then it is all business and they are not kidding around. They are the easiest puppies to train. I have had a JRT and these dogs are polar opposite. They have a slow metabolism. They do not eat as much as you think. We have 5 small children and have raised them with newborns. If you get ones with good bloodlines they love 11-12 years. If you want to meet mine, pm me. I can also answer any more questions you might have. I do not have pups right now but I know someone who has full siblings to one of mine. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Oh gosh...that would scare anybody! 

SailorTattoos --- 13 years ago -

I live with a GSD breeder that breeds Czech/German show lines for show/protection/work. She has some of the highest rated dogs in Germany. One litter was just born and another will arrive in about 12 days I believe. Her website is Rallhaus.com 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

What Fab Five Said.

We have two Danes and a German Shepherd.

The Danes sound mean but are not. However, they can get their hackles up if they think the family is in trouble.

These dogs are the absolute best around kids and we have never had to take more that a month, at the longest, to house train one. Even the ones we foster can be trained very quickly.

Plus, they will make you laugh out loud at least once a day.

They are the goofiest animals on four hooves. 

LAXmom --- 13 years ago -

I grew up with an awesome German Shepard - smart as all get out- great, great family dog - and the best protector ever. Just the sight of him scared people, he weighed about 100lbs, was absolutely gorgeous. 

LAXmom --- 13 years ago -

Rallhaus.com

Wow! Those are some nice looking GSD. 

SailorTattoos --- 13 years ago -

The litter that was just born yesterday is from these parents:

Male is highly titled in obedience, tracking, protection, and is a top rated show dog and does AKC rally
0

0

Him with my boyfriend
0

This is mom:
0

And this is me walking both of them on regular collars, they are heeling next to me with no direction and I've never walked or trained with them prior. I am 105 lbs. they are bred to be able to do what a proper built GSD should do..have strong nerves, stable temperament, highly obedient, good conformation, very courageous. She's a great breeder and really studies pedigrees to breed the best.
0 

SailorTattoos --- 13 years ago -

LAX, they are west German show line and czech. You won't find this type of quality in American line GSDs. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I think GSD and Dobies are the best watch dogs. They both have reps as being mean or aggressive and even tho that is not usually true to a dog that comes from a good loving home, it still permeates word of mouth out there. But I was raised around Shepherds and never saw an ounce of aggression towards us kids but let someone come to the gate and wow, what a show. lol

ANY dog who is loved and well adjusted will be protective, even the little yippers. IMO, JR's are not as good natured as a shepherd. Most of the ones I've been around are temperamental. Shepherds and Dobbies are very smart and obedient, I think the JR's lack in that area. They are stubborn and bossy lil things with other house pets.

I love Great Danes as well but they have relatively short life spans. 

SailorTattoos --- 13 years ago -

Btw semper, I volunteer with a GSD rescue and we have many dogs available for adoption. Ours are in foster homes so we can tell you exactly which ones are good with babies.

Secondchanceshepherds.org


If you choose a puppy from a breeder know that you will have to put a LOT of time and dedication into training and socializing. All puppies are land sharks that like to pee and poop and make a lot of noise.

This is a puppy we have at the house right now that I work with. She was 4 months here. We are clicker training her:
0 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

We have chihuahuas, they are awesome!!!

No one messes with Mr Grins!!! 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Those are beautiful dogs Sailor. I'd love to be able to right now afford a pet like that.

My JRT is generally even tempered. .She thinks she's bigger than she really is. She's a jumper and can easily clear fences.
After she's been outside for a while and she's let back in she runs circles through the house at warp speed, for 15 minutes.

Recently she's nipped my toddler a couple of times. Not even to leave a mark but enough that it startled my kid. Both times it happened when the dog was "sleeping" and my kid was trying to hug her. We've had her about five years and this is a new occurance. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Dane's do not have short life spans if you buy from someone with good lines. I have nothing against Dobermans but I would buy a GSD or a Dane first. I do not trust Dobies as much with kids. My in-laws will tell you all GSD's bite their family which is ridiculous, but they had bad experiences. The key is getting good bloodlines on whatever you buy. Use someone who knows their lines and ask them the high and low points of their lines. Any line does have faults. Just because they are show lines does not make them appropriate or good. Sometimes show dogs move in a direction that is not healthy for the dogs. My offer still stands if you want to be around a Dane first hand. 

SailorTattoos --- 13 years ago -

$1500. What you get is lifetime breeder support, a puppy that has been handled from birth, assurance of health testing and clearances for hip/elbow dysplasia and eyes for the parents before being bred, and a dog with a solid pedigree that the breeder knows like the back of her hand.

If health and temperament is your goal then that price tag is worth it for a well bred puppy with breeder support.

If you just want to save a life and find a cheaper dog, please adopt from rescue. Don't support a BYB. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Thanks FabFive. I have to give serious thought to owning such a large breed. As a responsible pet owner I need to know and respect my own limits. But my kids would get a kick out of owning a small pony! 

SailorTattoos --- 13 years ago -

Fabfive,

How many dobes have you been around? I think saying "most" dobies is a big exaggeration.


Most dobies are like this around kids(this is my certified therapy dog who meets kids regularly)
0 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I would never try to talk anyone out of getting a Dane. But, there are some things one needs to know prior to getting one.

While they are huge from birth and get bigger as time goes on, they really are not full grown until two years old. So, what you end up with is a full on, 100+ pound puppy and all that that entails.

We all know how energetic puppies can be. Dane puppies are no different....just bigger. So, you have to have a very firm hand with them and you have set boundaries and rules early on and get them obedience training.

Everything regular size puppies do, Danes do too.....just on a bigger scale.

Like my daughter says, if you can make it through the first 18 months or so of them being a**holes....then what you get after that is 10+ years of the best behaved, most loyal and loving dog breed that there is.

We will never own another breed. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Your Dobe is precious. I have been around two sets of breeders. I also had a pest control guy who had been in business forever tell me it was the only breed he would not go in the yard with. Both sets of breeders did not recommend them for kids under five. I am not trying to.start an issue but the OP asked for opinions. If I had this opinion about kids and dogs and didn't share it with her, I would be negligent. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Here is a picture of Big Doggie.

Her actual name is Lilly, but I call her Big Doggie and she answers to the name.

At her last check up she weighed 125 lbs.

Sweetest Dog On Earth.

0 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Mine are only butt heads between 15-20 months or so. Like a teenager phase. I think color plays into activity levels too. My mantels and blacks are the calmest. Harl's are my more active ones. Even still, it is 1/10 of a JRT and 1/2 that of a retriever. 

BiteMe --- 13 years ago -

Our mutts are great at protecting our home. Every dog is different, even those of the same breed. 

LAXmom --- 13 years ago -

We have chihuahuas, they are awesome!!!

No one messes with Mr Grins!!!


LOL!! 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Danes are beautifully goofy looking dogs.

Sailor...I am looking at GSD shelters and will not consider getting a dog from some random person in a neighborhood. Thanks for link. I had not seen that one yet. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

FabFive --- 11 min ago - quote - hide comments

Mine are only butt heads between 15-20 months or so. Like a teenager phase. I think color plays into activity levels too. My mantels and blacks are the calmest. Harl's are my more active ones. Even still, it is 1/10 of a JRT and 1/2 that of a retriever.




I agree about the coloring. We just finished fostering a Mantle and he was a spaz, but manageable.

The previous dane we fostered prior to the Mantle was a Harlequin and she was a rocket ship. She had the zoomies all the time.

Coincidentally, she was the funnest puppy I have ever had. She went to a fireman in Alvin. He named her Blaze which was a very appropriate name for her....both from a fireman point of view and from an activity point of view. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

I currently have a Harl, Mantle, and a Black. My new Harl was just born 1/9. Can't wait to get my mitts on her. Planning on another Harl late spring. 

Its Mygirl01 --- 13 years ago -

Rhodesian Ridgeback, BEST DOGS EVER!

Known as the "Navy Seal" of dog breeds, our is almost 10 and she is awesome!! 

Its Mygirl01 --- 13 years ago -

Rhodesian Ridgeback

Watch this video clip in Ridgebacks from Dogs 101 on Animal Planet! 

MoreToLife --- 13 years ago -

I have a black lab and a black mouth cur. It is not a good idea to get near my front door or approach my back yard. While they are the sweetest dogs in the world they don't want you in their space.

All our friends come to the side door and walk right in, it just isn't a good idea to come to the front door.

Both of mine are rescues. I didn't need to pay for a wonderful pet or protection. 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

I grew up with an awesome German Shepard - smart as all get out- great, great family dog - and the best protector ever. Just the sight of him scared people, he weighed about 100lbs, was absolutely gorgeous.


Ditto! Loyal to the end and never a threat to his own people! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

you aren't going to like this, but a well trained, calm Pit can't be beat-they're wonderful with kids-I got one of my dogs from Michelle, tinman's daughter,and he's all of 10 lbs- she has a Pittie, and when they played, all you could see was a wagging tail-the rest of him was in her Pittie's mouth!! 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Let the attacking commence! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

I'm expecting it- but what I said is true, and I stand by it- 

MoreToLife --- 13 years ago -

My daughter is fostering a 5 week old pit. Cutest thing ever. Sweet as can be. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I think dobermans are the most intimidating breed when it comes to home protection. Read up on each breed and see which best fits your family dynamic. Also, your home owners insurance could go up with certain breeds, that may be something to consider.

Personally, I would rather work with a rescue group and save a dog, than to pay big money to a breeder. But it's whatever your personal preference and budget allows. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

Dobie. Most loyal and obedient. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Personal preference would be a dog that's been bred.

My pocketbook's preference is otherwise.

I would prefer a puppy that could grow alongside the family.

But will consider an adult if it were the right fit.

Prefer a GSD but again, would consider other breeds if they were more suitable to the family dynamic. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

If you have a toddler at home, I think a puppy is the best way to go. Plus they're so cute! 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground