Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Police assault man with no id.

who's talking here?

JDB2 6
Fallon 1
randyjet 3
AuthorMan 1
Deltadawn 1
Going off air 1
Baroness 1
IslandHopper 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
SuperFantastic 1
rEVOLution 6
partsguy 2
Laurabeth 3
POTUS 13
TheBatsMeow 1
Hiro Protagonist 5
zapper007 1
Squareduck 2
LBHTX 2
TexasOma 1
MeriZephyr 1
OPFOR 11
MxMike. 10
Dr. Noinu 2
needrnr 7
It is I WhyWhyWhy 5
LiveFreeOrDie 5
april57 1
Puss In Boots 6
Superheroes In Disguise 1
a3000482uu 2
a1472326uu 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Dr. Noinu --- 16 years ago -

If you know anything about the police assault that happend last thursday at around 4pm outside of Alspaugh hardware and the learning center here in Kingwood, we would greatly appreciate any witnesses to what happened. I am the man who was assualted so if you have any questions please feel free to ask.

Thank you and Godspeed. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

A video camera is your most powerful weapon!

I heard all about it, brother. Best of luck. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

Good luck.


I'm the curious type. Were you in a vehicle and pulled over, or were you randomly asked for id? 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

Well I will tell you what I HEARD and Dr.No can correct any inaccurate info.

I believe his wife or fiancee was driving after they dropped books off at the library when they were pulled over by the "What 4th amendment?!" task force out here.

As far as how it escalated, I've no clue. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

"What 4th amendment?!" task force out here.


I hear you. That one seems ridiculous to me. As far as I know, legally the police have no right to search your vehicle if you get pulled over for a traffic violation. There is supposed to be some kind of probable cause. These guys just seem to bull their way in and arrest you if you say no, or try to stop them. Pretty f'd up. 

Superheroes In Disguise --- 16 years ago -

The victim is a friend of mine and a member of the church I attend. His face, elbows and knees are pretty messed up. Here is the Reader's Digest version:

He was the passenger in a car that was pulled over for literally nothing. They claim they were looking for a man driving a car drunk, but his fiance was driving and she has long hair. So, they should have let them go on their way. What happened next should have NEVER happened and it led to and overnight stay for both of them in the jail downtown.

The pair approached the vehicle on both the driver and passenger side. When asked for ID, he responded that he had none on him. He gave them his name and they asked for his Social Security number. When he replied he didn't have one, they made him get out of the car.

Mind you, there was no suspicion or reason to invade further because there was a female driving who had her license, registration and insurance and offered it to the officers when asked for them.

When he got out they told him to get in their car. When he asked if he was being detained or arrested and for what, they told him to just get in the car. When he refused, they tried to handcuff him. With no charges or reason to be arrested, he resisted and the beating commenced. Because you do as you say in this day and age, or ELSE! They believe we are their servants and we are to do as we are told.

These cops were the typical thugs who are increasingly becoming a part of the federalized police force in this country. They also searched the entire car and their persons in complete violation of the fourth amendment and with no probable cause. They also lied on the police report and stated that the male was driving the car as opposed to the female so their reason for pulling them over was justified.

Also, when he refused to be finger printed downtown because he hadn't been charged with anything or even read his Miranda rights, his face was slammed into the concrete wall and he was hog-tied by his wrists and ankles, connected together behind his back and thrown on a jail cell floor like an animal.

He is going to sue them personally for assault. NOT the city, department or state, because that is only penalizing the taxpayers who end up paying for their indiscretions. He is going to sue them personally criminally and civilly. It is the only way these thug cops who believe they are above the law will get the message that they are there to SERVE us and not to RULE us. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

When he refused, they tried to handcuff him. With no charges or reason to be arrested, he resisted and the beating commenced.

sounds like a dumb idea to me...why would you think you could refuse? What do you think should happen when people refuse to follow directions from our police officers?

Personally, I don't want people that feel no obligation to follow rules to be out running around. Can't speak to the so called beating, but we don't all just get to do whatever we want. Sounds like your friend should take a look at himself rather than the cops. 

TheBatsMeow --- 16 years ago -

Honestly, if you refuse for your SSN and you don't HAVE one, someone could assume you're an illegal immigrant. I thought if you weren't a citizen, you didn't get the same rights as if you were legal. He really should have never refused to get out of the car. If you have nothing to hide, you'd cooperate. I'm not about to say you should "bow down" to the cops, but this seems like the passenger was hessitant to talk to the police because he was illegal. Don't get me wrong I know a few, but it still doesn't make it right. Get legal the right way, and be a DI"K when you do get pulled over, and laugh your aS* out of there when you can prove your legal documents. just my opinion... 

zapper007 --- 16 years ago -

Sounds like a guy who got what he asked for. Don't mess with the law - or they will mess you up!!! 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

LOL @ Americans disregard for their own freedom.

The man did NOTHING wrong.

His WIFE was pulled over, not him. They had NO reason to I.D. him and he WILL win in court.

Your job is NOT to obey police, it's to obey the LAW...as is theirs to uphold it, not abuse it. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

I am so tired of people thinking they can challenge the police. Just do what you are ask, show your id, be polite and respectful and you go on your way if you haven't done anything wrong.

Don't blame the police if you fail to cooperate and then get beat down.

If the police stop a driver they have a right to question anyone in the car. Basic info, if you don't have id thats a red flag, if you don't have a SS card not just on you but you have never had a SS card thats another red flag, if you refuse to do what they tell you to do at that point it will not go well for you. Any questions?

If he is illegal they need to deport him, if he is here legally but not a citizen and was just being an azz they need to deport him. 

april57 --- 16 years ago -

Sounds like you were looking for trouble and all you had to do is give up a few answers to their questions. If they had reason to stop the car, everyone in the car is open to a line of questions. All you had to do is cooperate, if you had nothing to hide. Sounds like you were attempting to set up for a lawsuit and a free ride to the slammer for the night. I know you all had better things to do with your time than take a ride downtown in the police car. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

LOL @ Americans disregard for their own freedom.

The man did NOTHING wrong.


hopefully you've changed your mind about the military. You are too young and don't know how the world works yet. If you haven't changed your mind, better change your outlook. You won't make it otherwise. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

OL @ Americans disregard for their own freedom.

The man did NOTHING wrong.

hopefully you've changed your mind about the military. You are too young and don't know how the world works yet. If you haven't changed your mind, better change your outlook. You won't make it otherwise. 


lol jdb he will be in for an awakening if he doesn't realize this soon. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

LOL @ Americans disregard for their own freedom.
I think you missed something here young man, if the person in not a citizen, he is not entitled the to same rights. All visitors are required to carry their ID just like citizens are, whenever we are stopped by the police we are required to show ID. I think we are missing part of what happened that day. 

TexasOma --- 16 years ago -

This is who Dr. Noinu and Superheroes In Disguise are about. They are who formed Truth Tuesdays & were posting their message heavily on this board for a while. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

You know when an officer pulls you over just do what they ask.

It is easy and simple. If the officer is out of line, you KNOW you can call a lawyer and you are going to sue them. They know this too. There are some bad ones out there, but the majority are good decent people.

Kingwood has been annexed. We no longer have Barney Fife as our local lawman. These are Houston Police. Do they see things a bit different than a small town officer? I would imagine.

If you hate em so much, go join the force, and you work in some of these wards for a couple of years, and see what your take on the world is. Reality is far different than lofty ideas from a nice safe neighborhood. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

lol @ all the coward slaves... "just do what you're told!"

Sounds like this guy stood up for his rights, took a beat down, and will probably teach these thug cops to think twice before they power trip on a civilian again.

That's a win as far as I'm concerned. He might even win the lawsuit.... ahem, a well-placed article on a popular website could really give the city more of a headache than they need... 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Well, I heard a rumor he had a big jack-o-lantern painted on his behind, that would really be the cause of his arrest. 

OPFOR --- 16 years ago -

It is the law as an adult that you must carry identification on your person at all times while in public. Seems a simple solution if you didn't have an ID on you to provide the officer with your SSN to prove who you said you were. No harm done, no big deal. As for pulling the car over to begin with, there had to be a reason. You may not have thought so at the time, but there had to be one. Getting stupid and arrogant with an officer just trying to do his job won't win any law suit later. Your own most likely ridiculous actions and impeeding an investigation got your dumb rear end put in the back of a patrol car. But you didn't stop there. You kept it up down town too. After it was all said and done you now want to throw some of your money away too. I would pay a few bucks to see the dash cam video from the patrol car so that I could see and hear all the nonsense you had that day.
As said before, most officers are dang good people. Having to constantly deal with stupid stuff like this everyday and they come back to work the next day. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

It is the law as an adult that you must carry identification on your person at all times while in public.

False, didn't read the rest. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

I think the assumption that he was an illegal alien is incorrect. Sounds like another jacka$$ that thinks he can do whatever he wants. Anyone that actually thinks through how our country would function under the no rules theory knows they should just follow the rules. The rules make sense and I have never seen anyone get beat when following the rules.

Funny thing is that these boneheads don't realize that without the rules darwanism would kick in and these same anarchists would really have it handed to them. Mike is gonna learn this if he actually joins the military. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

When asked for ID, he responded that he had none on him.


Issue #1
You are required BY LAW to carry identification on your person in public.

When he replied he didn't have one, they made him get out of the car.

Issue #2

No ID, and NO SSN....hmmm... I would investigate further....


Mind you, there was no suspicion or reason to invade further

WRONG, they now have recognized that someone was not carrying proper identification. You do realize that when a vehicle is stopped that the officer can...and should obtain information of all occupants of the vehicle!

When he got out they told him to get in their car.


Because it's a way to secure an unsafe scene.

When he refused, they tried to handcuff him. With no charges or reason to be arrested, he resisted

Not complying with an officers request IS a reason to be handcuffed. DID you think that perhaps this was for the safety of the officer, your friend, and anyone else nearby.

Also, when he refused to be finger printed downtown
What an idiot.

even read his Miranda rights, his face was slammed into the concrete wall and he was hog-tied by his wrists and ankles, connected together behind his back and thrown on a jail cell floor like an animal.


So he says. It sounds like your friend was at fault, and had he had his ID as required, presented it to the officer and complied with the officers requests,,,,then everything would have been fine.

Sorry, but I would have to side with the officers on this one from your own account. If he was beaten or physically harmed after he was in custody (ie, handcuffed, or at the inmate procession center) then yes, he should speak out and the officer should be held accountable, but other than that possibility, I think your friend is a POS, and should realize that the police have a job to do, and he should follow the law. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

Guys, you DON'T have to carry around your slave papers if you're out in public. Driving a vehicle is a different story. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

POTUS - you sound intelligent often. What do you suppose would happen if nobody needed to identify themselves? Seriously. 

OPFOR --- 16 years ago -

Sounds like this guy stood up for his rights, took a beat down, and will probably teach these thug cops to think twice before they power trip on a civilian again.

Pipe dream, didn't read the rest. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

It is the law as an adult that you must carry identification on your person at all times while in public.

No, that is incorrect. If it were correct, we would be no better than a gestapo state, which we are not.

However, there may be a Texas state law on the books, which may clarify this.


First, what the United States Supreme Court said. What the United States Supreme Court held in Hiibel v. Sixth Judicial Dist. Court (2004) 542 U.S. 177, was that a state could make it a crime for a person to refuse to identify himself (i.e., tell the officer his name and address) when lawfully detained for criminal activity. Note that the Supreme Court did NOT say that any kind of identification papers could be required, nor did they say that police officers could ordinarily arrest someone for refusing to identify himself absent a state law permitting that arrest. There is no law in the United States requiring everybody to carry ID, at least not yet.  

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

POTUS - you sound intelligent often. What do you suppose would happen if nobody needed to identify themselves? Seriously.

Uhm, people would live their own lives and mind their own business? You don't need to show identification unless you're driving a vehicle or the officer has probable cause to ask you for it. The way this story was told, the cops never had it. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Come on folks, think about it. What if you're out jogging and get stopped by the police....and you don't have your identification with you. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

See the slave conditioning exemplified here? People actually believe that you have to carry slave papers on you ALL THE TIME or else the cops can beat you and throw you in a cage.

And they're raising their children to believe this nonsense, also. Raising them to be afraid of cops. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

Come on folks, think about it. What if you're out jogging and get stopped by the police....and you don't have your identification with you.

Well obviously you deserve to get beaten and tossed in jail, humiliated. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Issue #1
You are required BY LAW to carry identification on your person in public.


WRONG. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

I'm not afraid of cops, I do however respect them and the job that they do. 

OPFOR --- 16 years ago -

Like I said, I'm almost sure the dash cam video shows things a little different.
As far as carrying "slave papers," good luck with that one. You will probably find youself in a very simular situation someday, downtown. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

See the slave conditioning exemplified here? People actually believe that you have to carry slave papers on you ALL THE TIME or else the cops can beat you and throw you in a cage.

Simply amazing that people believe this. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

I've seen it and heard about it for months now. They're are 2 cops that pull cars over on little or no pretext, and then force a search.

1) They shouldn't be able to pull you over because they feel like it.

2) There is supposed to be probable cause to search a vehicle otherwise you have a right to refuse a search. If you refuse they need to obtain a warrant.


If this case on this thread had happened to me, nothing would've happened. I would've complied with his demands(while being snarky) and questioned why a car leaving the library was such a possible crime threat. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

You are required BY LAW to carry identification on your person in public.


I can't believe multiple people have said this. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

"What 4th amendment?!" task force
LOL @ Americans disregard for their own freedom.

The man did NOTHING wrong.


WOW, I mean really, WOW! I'm starting to see exactly what we are up against as freedom loving citizens in a nation that is being over run with fascism and Tyranny. I have seen more people in the few minutes it took me to read this to realize that people really think that since they have nothing to hide that it is their duty to sit down, shut up, and do as you are ordered.

What happened to all of you to make you think that you have no rights? What happened to America that made them think that they are guilty until proven innocent?

"Just do what you are told?" REALLY?

OMG, I even have friends in law enforcement that would disagree with that.

Now don't get me wrong, I agree that if you have done something wrong and the officer gives you a valid reason for stopping you that you should be as polite as possible to avoid any conflict and that you should cooperate as much as possible.

But being pulled over by random or even for a tail light out, you do not have to get out of your car. Specially on a highway where it is more dangerous to get out than stay in the car. And I'm sorry to say but "we are looking for a suspicious person" is not a good reason to randomly harass people.

Unfortunately Police are not required to tell you what you're being arrested for. Within 72 hours you have right to be brought before a judge or released. When brought before a judge, that's when the charges against you will be read. But the problem is, like in this case, this law was really abused. IMO it's absolutely ridiculous that if you don't "OBEY" then you can be legally kidnapped against your will and detained for up to 72 hours and be released without ever having committed a crime. Sounds to me like nothing more than a "legal" way to steal revenue from the citizens.

It is not a crime to not have ID as a passenger in a vehicle. They EASILY could have verified his ID by looking up his name and address. End of situation. And as for searching your vehicle, you DO NOT have to let them search your car. It's an extension of your property and if they want to search it they can get a warrant or their supervisor out there with a warrant.

This is the right way to prevent being searched and detained. It won't always work but it might help in this situation.



I hate that this happened to you man and it certainly shows the type of Tyranny we "FREE" Americans have allowed ourselves to be ruled under. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

ok, ok....I just looked up the law, I was wrong! Sorry, I really did believe that you always had to be able to identify yourself....and yes, I would carry my id while jogging just because of this. Sorry...I was wrong on that account! 

OPFOR --- 16 years ago -

Nobody said that if you don't have your identification on you that you will get beaten down. Proving who you say you are isn't that hard. Identification doesn't mean toting a birth certificate or state issued ID either. Having some means of indentifying yourself is a good thing. Most of us have earned it. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
charity
children
connecting


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground