Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Why Does the GOP Really Hate Obamacare?

who's talking here?

ToidBoid 1
whatchamacallit 1
smartypants 2
ladybeachbum 2
SoupIsGoodFood 16
Red Heifer 1
Perfection 5
FANCY PANTS 1
JohnLynch 2
Quixote 2
I_won't_tell 2
Dr Aborto 2
Aah Grasshoppa 1
Let Logic Prevail 3
IrvingShwartz 1
WatchOut 7
dogs 3
Emperor of Kingwood 2
OneEyedManRedux 1
Gigolo Bloodline 6
Snake Plissken 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Let Logic Prevail --- 13 years ago -

Meghan Foley 
October 15, 2013


The grounds for the Republican Party’s opposition to the Affordable Care Act are far from a single coherent argument. It is all the more confusing because one of the health care reform’s key provisions, the individual insurance mandate, has conservative origins. The requirement that individuals be required to purchase health insurance first emerged in Republican health care reform bills introduced in 1993 as alternatives to the Clinton administration’s plan.




That mandate was also a prominent feature of the Massachusetts plan passed under Gov. Mitt Romney in 2006. According to Romney, “we got the idea of an individual mandate from [Newt Gingrich], and [Newt] got it from the Heritage Foundation,” Forbes reports. Furthermore, as Bill Keller argued in an op-ed for The New York Times, the GOP should be “the people who ought to be most vigorously applauding this success story” because the reform of the United States’s “overpriced, underperforming health care system” was done almost entirely with market incentives instead of government decree.

The fact that the idea of the individual mandate developed out of GOP rhetoric proves that the party is not opposed to the thought of making insurance affordable to millions of Americans. “Many states now require passengers in automobiles to wear seat-belts for their own protection,” Stuart Butler, a health care expert for the conservative-leaning Heritage Foundation, wrote in a 1989 brief titled Assuring Affordable Health Care for All Americans. “Many others require anybody driving a car to have liability insurance. But neither the federal government nor any state requires all households to protect themselves from the potentially catastrophic costs of a serious accident or illness.”

So the argument goes that just as legally mandated insurance makes economic sense for automobiles, it makes sense for health care, as well.

Several theories as to why Republicans want to see Obamacare defunded and repealed have been tossed around.


Republicans have said that the health care reform will destroy the economy. “Well, if you don’t believe Obamacare is the biggest job killer in the country, look to the facts,” Republican Rep. Ted Cruz of Texas said during his 21-hour speech on the Senate floor earlier this month. “This year, report after report has rolled in about employers restricting work hours to less than 30 hours per week — the point where the mandate kicks in. The data also points to record-low workweeks in low-wage industries.”

But for most companies, the employer mandate is not a huge burden. The companies that do not provide insurance and will be required to probably employ around 1 percent of American workers.

“You’ve got 5.7 million firms in the U.S.,” Mark Duggan, who served as the top health economist at White House’s Council of Economic Advisers from 2009 to 2010, told the Washington Post. “Only 210,000 have more than 50 employees. So 96 percent of firms aren’t affected. Then if you look among those firms with 50 or more employees, something on the order of 95 percent offer health insurance. So it’s basically 10,000 or so employers who have more than 50 employees and don’t offer coverage.”

The unconstitutionality of the reform is another argument that has been made. Sen. Orrin Hatch wrote in The Hill’s “Congress Blog” in 2010 that that to come to “any other conclusion” than that the individual mandate is unconstitutional “requires treating the Constitution as the servant, rather than the master, of Congress.”

But given that in June 2012 the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act — with exception of the requirement that states expand Medicaid — that argument has lost its validity. The fiscal argument against Obamacare, that the reform would result in tax hikes and a bigger deficit, has also been recently dropped from party rhetoric.


The theory put forward by Keller in his op-ed and by Eduardo Porter in his New York Times piece entitled “Why the Health Care Law Scares the G.O.P.” is that Republicans are worried that Americans will like the benefits of the reform too much. “You have probably figured out that the real mission of the Republican extortionists and their big-money backers was to scuttle the law before most Americans recognized it as a godsend and rendered it politically untouchable,” Keller wrote.

That argument makes sense to some degree. Speaking to radio host Rush Limbaugh in late August, Cruz said that President Obama “wants to get as many Americans as possible addicted to the subsidies, addicted to the sugar, because he knows that in modern times, no major entitlement has ever been implemented and then unwound.”

But in Keller’s opinion, it is too late. Health care reform has already accomplished its first goal of enrolling millions of uninsured Americans, “many of whom have been living one medical emergency away from the poorhouse,” he wrote in the op-ed. The fact that the computer glitches that plagued the first week the exchanges were open for enrollment was evidence of demand for affordable coverage. This demand “is the 90 percent of the story that doesn’t make the headlines,” Sam Glick of the Oliver Wyman consulting firm told Keller.

Data also show demand for reform. Kaiser Family Foundation’s March 2013 health care tracking — the same survey that showed only 37 percent of respondents held a favorable view of the Affordable Care Act — found that a plurality of those surveyed actually support specific provisions of Obamacare.

Eighty-eight percent were in favor of tax credits for small businesses to buy insurance; 81 percent were in favor of closing the Medicare prescription coverage gap; 76 percent were in favor of extending coverage to dependents; 71 percent were in favor of expanding Medicaid; 66 percent were in favor of banning exclusions for preexisting conditions; and 57 percent were in favor of the employer mandate.

The only provision that regularly polled negatively was the individual mandate, but the requirement that all Americans purchase affordable insurance is necessary if excluding those with preexisting conditions is prohibited. To function as intended, the marketplaces need a broad, healthy risk pool to keep staggering rate increases from occurring. The premiums of healthy, cheap-to-insure people cover the big bills for the relatively small number of sick people.

Source: http://wallstcheatsheet.com/stocks/why-does-the-gop-really-hate-obamacare.html/ 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Republicans are worried that Americans will like the benefits of the reform too much.

Indeed... I don't deny that.....Happy little government slaves... 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Interesting that the issue is that the Republicans want the individual mandate postponed 1 year to make it equal to the business mandate that President Obama arbitrarily postponed outside the law earlier this year.

Seems the Republicans want individuals treated equally to business.

The second issue is the issue of the tax on medical equipment. The House wants to delay that as well as it is shown to be a deterrent to getting good quality care and supply availability.

Yup all bad stuff. 

Let Logic Prevail --- 13 years ago -

Seems the Republicans want individuals treated equally to business.


The republicans want it destroyed contrary to what real Americans want. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

The republicans want it destroyed contrary to what real Americans want.


Really?

How is delaying the implementation on individuals destroying it?

If you think that is destroying it, do you also feel the business exemption that President Obama arbitrarily implemented outside the law, also destroying it - since it was the business component that will be responsible for most of the income derived from the act.

Consistency......... try it. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Consistency......... try it.

Not likely with this liberal KU group.

They scream at any changes to Obamacare, but didn't seem to flinch a bit when Obama himself made changes. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Republicans are worried that Americans will like the benefits of the reform too much

i saw where a family of four on one of the plans would have a deductible of $12,250 before their plan would kick in...that's nothing i would want...and would never be happy with

it's not affordable... 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

The resistance to Obamacare was created due to the way it was created then passed. Unlike Mitt Romney, Obama didn't include all stakeholders in drafting the legislation. In 2010 the American people sent a clear "NO" but since the Democrats has both Houses and the Executive Branch, they passed it anyway (without reading it I might add).

Obama created this problem because he doesn't listen and doesn't work well with other. Frankly, I think he's one lazy m f. 

Let Logic Prevail --- 13 years ago -

i saw where a family of four on one of the plans would have a deductible of $12,250 before their plan would kick in...that's nothing I would want...and would never be happy withit's not affordable...



In reality the plans are very affordable and cheaper than much of the insurance options available prior.

By your presentation of the family deductible you don't seem to be able to grasp how the plans truly work.

The deductible is roughly $3k per person. That deductible is only applied for hospitalization and major testing. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

In reality the plans are very affordable and cheaper than much of the insurance options available prior.

not more affordable or as good as what i currently have...

That deductible is only applied for hospitalization and major testing.

maybe you should read again...that isn't the case 

Quixote --- 13 years ago -

It's a nice premise - if one removes the socialist realignment of wealth and repairs the effed up text, garbage jargon, conflicting requirements, laughable software/website, lack of consistent application, and enforcement by corrupt IRS leadership. It's a bureaucratic cesspool of special interests and cronyism. Apart from that, it's perfect! 

IrvingShwartz --- 13 years ago -

Health insurance is not health care. There lies the problem with Obumer care. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

That deductible is only applied for hospitalization and major testing.


Wrong, the deductible is on all care, other than kids well child visit (1 per year) or woman's screening mammo.

All other services such as a visit for a sore throat would be applied to the deductible and therefore the responsibility of the insured before the insurance paid anything.

What that comes out to is that the insured typically pays the first quarter or half the year before any insurance dollars are paid.

Oh that applies to medications too, you pick up all the cost on those too

I posted the actual dollars we are paying after subsidy the other day. Those are actual dollars, not made up data 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

That's a great question posed by the OP. I just can't put my finger on why something the GOP espoused aa a personal responsibility imperative became so evil all of a sudden.hmmmm

Maybe Obama? what is different about Obama? hmmm, can't put my finger on it. Laughing hard. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

So he is allowed to change a law arbitrarily?

You accept that he gives business a pass yet does not care about the individuals?

That's fair to you 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

I just can't put my finger on why something the GOP espoused aa a personal responsibility

How is subsidizing something with someone elses money "personal responsibility"? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Maybe Obama? what is different about Obama? hmmm, can't put my finger on it. Laughing hard.

Not as hard as we are at you.

Race card attempt is weak. 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

Soup even has a black friend. Don't scream too loud soup, we can see right through you. 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

Romneycare was the right idea that was expertly executed because the man had experience working with others be building a consensus. The people of Massachusetts loved Romneycare.

Romney made it look easy.

Romneycare is the iPhone. Obamacare is the Windows phone. On paper they do the same thing, but they ain't the same thing. 

I_won't_tell --- 13 years ago -

Two reason the GOP is against
Oh Ha Ha Care

0

0 

smartypants --- 13 years ago -

They hate social welfare bills period. GOP made the same ruckus over Social Security, claiming it was socialist. It was FDR's proposal. Your (mostly Republican) seniors say thanks. 

I_won't_tell --- 13 years ago -

Liberals love stuff ...

that others are forced to pay for. 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

Are you seriously planning to retire on social security alone? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Soup even has a black friend. Don't scream too loud soup, we can see right through you.

..... and it gets weaker. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

GOP made the same ruckus over Social Security

Is SS working EXACTLY as it was advertised and sold? 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

GOP made the same ruckus over Social Security

Is SS working EXACTLY as it was advertised and sold?




No! Why are there so many people receiving it that never even put in? 

ToidBoid --- 13 years ago -

The republicans want it destroyed contrary to what real Americans want.

Excuse me, I'm a REAL American - I want nothing to do with this cluster. 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

If citizens were allowed to invest just 10% of what goes into their social security, everyone would have a ton of money to retire on and pass to their heirs. Yes, this includes down markets but more importantly this includes the poor, minorities -- everyone. This is why the democrats hate the idea.

Keep comparing Obamacare to Social Security. 

smartypants --- 13 years ago -

If citizens were allowed to invest just 10% of what goes into their social security, everyone would have a ton of money to retire on and pass to their heirs.

Bring back Glass Steagall and that might actually not be a pipe dream. 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

As usual no one answers anything re the FACT that the GOP touted the individual mandate for years as their answer to reform. But now what's different?

Soup won't answer, can't answer.

What's the difference between the GOP presidential candidates signature accomplishment as governor and Obamacare.

The answer is EASY and I just won again. 

dogs --- 13 years ago -

Romney is NOT a Republican or a Conservative. He is a RINO.

Forcing me to buy something is unconstitutional. I don't know how John Roberts can sleep at night. 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 13 years ago -

Why don't we put all the uninsured in Medicare and Medicaid and beef it up? I'm for getting everyone on some type of insurance because paying for the uninsured anyway is out of control. But the reach into private insurance and making someone have to pay if they don't opt in just goes against what I believe the government should do for us. 

dogs --- 13 years ago -

Anyone thinking that putting the government in charge of anything, requiring them to hire people to implement it, will make something LESS expensive is a fool.

Paying taxes so the government can turn around and give it to people in the form of a debit card is a waste. Allow churches and nonprofit groups to supply those needs. 

dogs --- 13 years ago -

With government in charge of "helping" the poor, my husband works 80 hours a week for these people: Honest, right?. Look at the shelves, the healthy bananas are left, but the crap is loaded up. What other countries have fat poor people?

Now we also get to subsidize their healthcare. Yes, there are people with true needs but this government makes it TOO easy to sit around and do nothing and suck of the government's teat.

The ones who are hurt the most are those trying to work and get ahead. They make too much for government assistance, but not enough to live. It's sad when they are doing what is right, but those that aren't reap the benefits.

All obamacare is is yet another redistribution of wealth. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

The republicans want it destroyed contrary to what real Americans want.

Just ignorant. Typical of the left. 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

Redistribution of wealth?? Absolutely and thank goodness the redistribution to the wealthy continues selfishly speaking but contributes to the detriment of the middle class and casino economy we adore. 

Quixote --- 13 years ago -


Redistribution of wealth?? Absolutely and thank goodness the redistribution to the wealthy continues selfishly speaking but contributes to the detriment of the middle class and casino economy we adore.


See if you can break the 2nd sentence into some sort of a coherent thought. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

LOL 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

The answer is EASY and I just won again.

Don't break your arm patting yourself on the back, tommyboy.

Go buy yourself a cupcake. 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

The answer is EASY and I just won again.



It's easy to win when you're playing with yourself. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

health
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground