Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Bode Miller Custody Fight...

who's talking here?

LAXmom 2
SleightOfHand 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 3
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 8
SineadORebellion 1
snowprincess 3
Ender 6
JAMS 2
mutton 1
forevermt 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

"Msn-Here’s one I haven’t heard before: A woman gets pregnant in California by a famous athlete she is casually dating, decides to go to college in New York—tuition paid by the G.I. Bill—and after she moves there, before the baby is born, gets blasted by a New York judge for “her appropriation of the child while in utero,” which the judge calls “irresponsible”


I understand that fathers have rights, and I’m all for that. But this ruling took those rights way too far, to the point of dangerousness. It treated a fetus as a child, for purposes of a custody battle. And in doing so, it threatened to limit the rights of a pregnant woman to move and travel.

A New York appeals court has already overturned the ridiculous initial judicial order in this fight between Sara McKenna, 27, a former Marine and firefighter now attending Columbia University, and Bode Miller, 36, an Olympic skier. But the case isn’t over, and it’s the latest fascinating entry in a series of legal challenges by fathers to traditional assumptions about parental rights and child custody. The old legal problem for single mothers was deadbeat dads. The new one is fathers who are so eager to assert themselves that they run roughshod over women’s rights. As the adults clash, sometimes it even becomes hard to consider the child at the center.



McKenna and Miller met through an online dating service in April 2012, and she got pregnant in late May, before their brief relationship ended. In June, Miller told McKenna he wouldn’t come with her to an ultrasound because “U made this choice against my wish,” according to a text she released from him. She texted him in October, “Just a heads up, I met with an advisor from Columbia today and we will probably be moving there in the fall.”

That same month, Miller married someone else (Morgan Beck, a beach volleyball star and model, if you must know). And in November 2012, he filed a “Petition to Establish Parental Relationship” in California, checking the box on the form to say he was the father of “a child who is not yet born” and another box to begin a custody proceeding for a “child [who] resides or is found in this county.”

McKenna moved to New York in December, when she was seven months pregnant. Two days after her baby was born in February 2013, she went to New York Family Court to petition for custody—the legal basis for keeping the baby with her and making decisions about raising him. The first step of the Family Court’s job—deciding whether it had jurisdiction, or the authority to hear the case—should have been easy. New York law, which is based on a uniform code for all the states, says that New York courts have jurisdiction when New York is the child’s “home state.” This was obviously the case for McKenna and Miller’s baby (she calls the baby Sam; he calls him Nate), who was born in New York. But the New York family judge who heard the case (called a referee for some reason) seemed to have it in for McKenna when he sent the case back to the California courts, accusing her of moving to New York as an underhanded attempt at “forum shopping”—picking one court over another. The judge/referee also overlooked the fact that “child” in state custody law does not mean unborn child, as in fetus, which is what the “child” was when McKenna moved east."






Well , what say you? I don't like that she can do this to the father, just move away and take the kid from his dad. I know it's complicated. I know she's working on her career. But the hallmark of good parenting is to put your kids first regarding what's best for them. And what's best for them is to at least be near their father. And just bc you CAN move away, doesn't mean it's the best thing for the child.

This woman isn't a teenager, what happened to birth control? It seems this was a casual brief thang, and not sure why she allowed pregnancy to occur. But this IS Bode Miller and I can't help but be suspicious about her motives.

I think the judge was trying to chastise her for moving away from the father. I don't think a woman shouldn't be able to "travel" but moving away is a different thing when you have kids. Especially since you didn't use protection and have to know you may be procreating? Duh.

I know,woman's rights and all. And I get that but she took the risk and she should have known the father just might want to be near his child. I'm pretty sure she will win after the women's rights groups line up behind her.

I guess this is a very ethical question. And a legal one too. The problem is they can be very different things. Just because you CAN do something doesn't mean you should. I defer to what's best for the child. And unless the father is a douche, he should have easy access. I'm Leary of a Mother who doesn't think so. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

He may win because he filed first and before she was a legal resident of the state of NY. That usually requires a 6 month stay before you are considered as such. 

LAXmom --- 12 years ago -

He is also in another custody battle with the mother of his first child - who he also was never married too. Plus he wanted her to abort the baby. So he gets temp Custody of the baby and proceeds to travel the world with his new wife- and the baby's mother only sees the baby 10days in months. Personally, I think he sounds like a self-centered jerk. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I guess this is a very ethical question. And a legal one too. The problem is they can be very different things. Just because you CAN do something doesn't mean you should. I defer to what's best for the child. And unless the father is a douche, he should have easy access. I'm Leary of a Mother who doesn't think so.

Whew, this one is tough to wrap your mind around..

There is a lot of work that needs to be done in the definition of mother/father rights.

For example: If a father is responsible for child support for the 18 years after a child is born, shouldn't he also have a say when it comes to the decision to keep a baby? I am not talking about "forcing" a woman to have an abortion because he doesn't want to pay for it, rather the fact that a father should have to agree to an abortion. I have a friend who's wife decided to get an abortion without telling him, then divorcing him..

In my opinion we have to make it clear. If a woman has a choice to carry a pregnancy, doesn't that mean that she is choosing to have a child on her own, meaning that she can support it on her own?

I am mostly just playing devil's advocate here, but there are some serious double standards the way the law is set up currently. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I guess this is a very ethical question. And a legal one too. The problem is they can be very different things. Just because you CAN do something doesn't mean you should. I defer to what's best for the child. And unless the father is a douche, he should have easy access. I'm Leary of a Mother who doesn't think so.

Whew, this one is tough to wrap your mind around..

There is a lot of work that needs to be done in the definition of mother/father rights.

For example: If a father is responsible for child support for the 18 years after a child is born, shouldn't he also have a say when it comes to the decision to keep a baby? I am not talking about "forcing" a woman to have an abortion because he doesn't want to pay for it, rather the fact that a father should have to agree to an abortion. I have a friend who's wife decided to get an abortion without telling him, then divorcing him..

In my opinion we have to make it clear. If a woman has a choice to carry a pregnancy, doesn't that mean that she is choosing to have a child on her own, meaning that she can support it on her own?

I am mostly just playing devil's advocate here, but there are some serious double standards the way the law is set up currently.





It's really a mess. I'm on the fathers side with most of this stuff.

One of the hardest things is the whole issue of the mother being the carrier of the child so in possession of it makes/gives her greater authority. BUT if you stand back and try to be objective and say they both have equal rights, or should, regarding their child then her carrying it shouldn't give her greater authority.

I think it should be 50/50 . I do not think the father should be left out of anything, or have less authority. It would be very logical to dismiss all the arguments the parents have and err on the side of what's best for the kid. But the laws don't roll that way.

I didn't know Miller had another kid and custody issue. Just SMH at that. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I think that exploring this side of parenthood rights would help temper the out of control abortion debate.

If making a birth a "choice" for everyone, then we should make it a more difficult choice. Right now the "choices" are not even.

A woman gets pregnant from a consensual one night stand with someone she knows (can track down). Without any input from the man she can choose:

1. Take plan B and terminate the pregnancy, regardless of the religious convictions or wishes of the father.

2. Carry the child to term and give it up for adoption, regardless of the wishes of the father (by not telling him)

3. Keep the child and raise it with mandatory child support payments from the father, regardless of his financial situation.

*edit*

4. Get married


For men it is a lose-lose situation where they have no control 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

True Ender. It's not fair. Yet there would be no conception without either one. 

SineadORebellion --- 12 years ago -

So they both have different names for the kid?? Whaaaa?? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

SineadORebellion --- 29 min ago - quote - hide comments
So they both have different names for the kid?? Whaaaa??





I know! That's so odd.

Again, pull your head out of your butts and think of the kid!

You would think it was rocket science. Snicker. It's not about you! Lol 

snowprincess --- 12 years ago -

If you aren't married to the woman you knock up you are an idiot and deserve any hell she puts you through. JMO. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Snow princess, that's an emotional response. But ask yourself if that environment is healthy for the kid? Or anyone. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

If you aren't married to the woman you knock up you are an idiot and deserve any hell she puts you through. JMO.

Oh, I guess the term "mutual sex" means nothing to you.

Is she not equally responsible for opening her legs? Do not try to twist it around, I am not saying anything about rape.

The argument goes both ways: If women want to be a mans equal in every way then it has to count everywhere, regardless of it being an advantage or disadvantage 

snowprincess --- 12 years ago -

As a man, you know you aren't going to have control over what the woman does while she is pregnant. If you knock up someone you hardly know it shows how little you care about your offspring. She could have done drugs, drank, refused prenatal care or who knows what else. To claim that you care after the fact is just sad. The poor kid is stuck with idiots as parents. Irresponsible breeding is such a sad situation. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

If you knock up someone you hardly know it shows how little you care about your offspring. She could have done drugs, drank, refused prenatal care or who knows what else. To claim that you care after the fact is just sad


I am confused, how is this not BOTH of their faults?

Sex is a two way street last time I heard. It takes two to tango

It certainly hasn't changed since i got married...


As a man, you know you aren't going to have control over what the woman does while she is pregnant.

So a woman is not responsible for what she does while she is pregnant? 

snowprincess --- 12 years ago -

They are both responsible for creating a child with someone they didn't know.

Of course the woman is responsible. But, as a man, you should be smart enough to realize that while the woman is pregnant you have NO say it what she does. If a woman can terminate her child, she can easily move out of state while pregnant.

This is pretty easy to comprehend. 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Sounds like he makes bad choices when it comes to parking his ski pole. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

This is pretty easy to comprehend.

It is also clear that I do not agree with that being the current 'status quo'

It shouldn't work both ways. If a man has NO say over anything that happens to a child while it is in the womb, then why are we suddenly responsible for its financial well being once it breathes the good free air?

(Mind you, it doesn't look like this comes up in the OP's story)

It seems that women want to have their cake and eat it too when it comes to having a child.

I want absolute authority over this child while it is inside me, but i also want the father to be financially responsible for it once it is born (if i chose to have it)

I do not know what a good fix for this is, but I know BS when I see it. 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

"Sounds like he makes bad choices when it comes to parking his ski pole. "

Sounds like she made a bad choice for allowing the ski pole to be parked. Two way street there 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Yeah, they are both pretty dumb. How do people that age not use BC? It's not like ignorance or youth can be their excuse?

Miller is an athlete celeb, and a good looking one so he might be playing the field bc he can, but still. Stop making babies dude. Or pick women who won't try to play you and your financial future by having you for their baby daddy. Being the poster boy for casual hook ups is not that cool.

Maybe I'm naive, but wouldn't one think as a celeb you would be extra careful? I don't get it.

Everyone loses. Except maybe Momma who is gonna get your money for a long, long time. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Except maybe Momma who is gonna get your money for a long, long time. 

That is BS. She can decide to move to the other side of the country, but he is still liable for child support based on HIS income (that she had no hand in helping him gain) 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Who has more children, him or her? Who has been in this situation more, him or her?

Oh, him?

Again, perhaps he needs to make wiser decisions when it comes to spreading his snow.

No one is suggesting she doesn't have a responsibility. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

If he wanted her to have an abortion and she didn't, why does he get any say at all at this point?

And this is the SECOND TIME he's done this??

36 years old is WAAAAY too old to be such an asshat. 

LAXmom --- 12 years ago -


If he wanted her to have an abortion and she didn't, why does he get any say at all at this point?
And this is the SECOND TIME he's done this??
36 years old is WAAAAY too old to be such an asshat.


His little boy was born one month after his new wife had a miscarriage. So, basically 2 women were pregnant by him at the same time. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Except maybe Momma who is gonna get your money for a long, long time.

That is BS. She can decide to move to the other side of the country, but he is still liable for child support based on HIS income (that she had no hand in helping him gain)



What's BS about it? You said the same thing as I did. And I meant he was losing by giving his finances over to these women. They WILL get child support from him. He'll be broke if he keeps going at this rate. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Sounds like she made a bad choice for allowing the ski pole to be parked.


She made a lot better decision than he did. She's gonna have a big pay day every month for the next 18 years. One of them is a fool and it wasn't her. Maybe he needs to get better at his hit it and quit it method. 

forevermt --- 12 years ago -

This woman isn't a teenager, what happened to birth control? It seems this was a casual brief thang, and not sure why she allowed pregnancy to occur.



Why was it just HER responsibility for birth control? Why was he not acting responsibly? Another thing, have any of you thought that maybe her biological clock was ticking and he was just the sperm donor and this sort of back fired on her? And, did he pay for the pregnancy and birth? As far as I'm concerned, when people divorce, people should be able to go where they want. Some women choose to go back to where family lives for that support. I was a single mom for 10 years. It is not easy and being around what you know, is a good thing. This woman is not in prison, or on probation. She has the right to live where she wants. She went to get her degree, to further herself. I hardly call that irresponsible. I think many of you are being too hard on her. What counts at this point is that the baby is well taken care of and both parents get to raise him and hopefully it does not totally screw him up in the process. The child comes first and if either of these parents love him, they will keep that at the front of thought when making decisions. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

forevermt --- 36 sec ago - quote - hide comments
This woman isn't a teenager, what happened to birth control? It seems this was a casual brief thang, and not sure why she allowed pregnancy to occur.



Why was it just HER responsibility for birth control? Why was he not acting responsibly? Another thing, have any of you thought that maybe her biological clock was ticking and he was just the sperm donor and this sort of back fired on her? And, did he pay for the pregnancy and birth? As far as I'm concerned, when people divorce, people should be able to go where they want. Some women choose to go back to where family lives for that support. I was a single mom for 10 years. It is not easy and being around what you know, is a good thing. This woman is not in prison, or on probation. She has the right to live where she wants. She went to get her degree, to further herself. I hardly call that irresponsible. I think many of you are being too hard on her. What counts at this point is that the baby is well taken care of and both parents get to raise him and hopefully it does not totally screw him up in the process. The child comes first and if either of these parents love him, they will keep that at the front of thought when making decisions.







Oh, it's NOT just her responsibility. But if you're HIM, an athlete and celeb with money, you better be smarter than that.

Don't you think leaving it to literal hook ups to decide whether you become a father or not is stupid? Why would you trust these women??

It's good she's building a career but she's a mother now and she might as well start the sacrificing or at least realizing there will be some. Part of that is realizing the kid needs his Dad as much as he/she needs her.

They are both not very smart. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

That girl was singing "it all about the money, money"






 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

This woman isn't a teenager, what happened to birth control?

He isn't a teenager either, and apparently this isn't the first time he has had this happen so I am not sure what the question here is? He is a poopoo head... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground