Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: SHOULD US CITIZENS BE ALLOWED TO HOLD DUAL CITIZENSHIP?

who's talking here?

randyjet 6
SoupIsGoodFood 3
ghostpost 2
Warren Peace 2
Dr Aborto 3
Dorothy Parker 1
WatchOut 1
Emperor of Kingwood 1
Ogre13 3
Not KU 1
Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: SHOULD US CITIZENS BE ALLOWED TO HOLD DUAL CITIZENSHIP?

Given the fact that in this fluid world we can travel far more easily than when our Constitution was written, does it make sense to allow dual citizenship? Doing so establishes a privileged class of US citizens who have FAR more power and rights than native born US citizens since they can vote in US elections, and also vote in their native countries. The whole idea of demanding that a candidate for US President be natural born was to prevent divided loyalty in the most powerful office. Should this be allowed for President? Should this be allowed for simple US citizens?

Dual citizenship should be banned for all US citizens. Vote
 
 26.7% (8)
Dual citizenship should be banned for all Federal offices, elected and appointed Vote
 
 13.3% (4)
Dual citizenship should be banned only for President Vote
 
 10.0% (3)
Dual citizenship should be allowed for all US citizens as it is now. Vote
 
 50.0% (15)
randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Given the fact that in this fluid world we can travel far more easily than when our Constitution was written, does it make sense to allow dual citizenship? Doing so establishes a privileged class of US citizens who have FAR more power and rights than native born US citizens since they can vote in US elections, and also vote in their native countries. The whole idea of demanding that a candidate for US President be natural born was to prevent divided loyalty in the most powerful office. Should this be allowed for President? Should this be allowed for simple US citizens? 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

When I became a naturalized citizen, I had to relinquish my citizenship from my birth country. But I think it's a grey area. I still have paperwork and my birth certificate that is accepted as proof of citizenship somewhere else. So I do in a way I do have duel citizenship.

I don't really care either way. Even though my mother was a US citizen before I was born, I am not eligible to be president because I wasn't born on this land. Maybe if I were a senator, that would change. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

Why not? As long as said person with dual citizenship has no intentions of running for President of the United States. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

What does it matter?

duel citizenship
lol... You got the wrong type Aborto... with that one you're always having to fight! :-P

0
Aborto's Citizenship Test 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

You guys didn't know I had to sword fight a dude to be able to vote? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

You guys didn't know I had to sword fight a dude to be able to vote?

I assumed..... 

Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus --- 12 years ago -

Go take your meds, Randy. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Actually this is a rather serious problem in time of war or military operations. If you hold dual citizenship with a nation with which the US is engaged in military hostilities, you legally can be interned as an enemy alien. I do not know the Japanese law at the time of WWII, so I don't know if you were born in the US of both Japanese citizen parents that you would in fact be a Japanese citizen too. SO the internment of US born Japanese kids would have been perfectly legal even without the suspension of habeus corpus since you would legally be regarded as a Japanese citizen too.

Under the post war German Constitution they have a provision that a person must have been born within the borders of 1933 Germany to become Chancellor. That was to ensure no more wallpaper hanger Austrians would sneak across the border and cause the same kind of problems the last one did.

Then the problem of divided loyalty comes up when dealing with a foreign country for a Federal official. That was the main reason for our founders putting in the natural born requirement for the Presidency. Not surprisingly we have a large problem with many of the nations which have large immigrant populations in the US. During the run up to WWII, there was real concern about the loyalty of persons of Italian background and of course those of German as well. In fact, large numbers of those people were thrown into internment camps as were the Japanese, though not as many. China does not allow dual citizenship either.

Obama might have a problem if we made dual citizenship ineligible since he was at birth a British subject by virtue of his fathers nationality. The Brits don't allow one to repudiate their citizenship. Remember the War of 1812? One an Englishman always an Englishman since at birth you are property of the crown and a subject, not a citizen. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Aborto, was your mother physically present in the US for at least 5 years prior to your birth? 

WatchOut --- 12 years ago -

Doing so establishes a privileged class of US citizens who have FAR more power and rights than native born US citizens since they can vote in US elections, and also vote in their native countries.



Assumption that voting gives one far more power. LOL I voted yes for dual citizenship. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Aborto, was your mother physically present in the US for at least 5 years prior to your birth??

I don't know for sure. She came to the US for school, not sure how long she was here. Moved back, got married, kids, then we moved to the US. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Thanks. I was just wondering what the circumstances were where the child of a US citizen would not be granted citizenship by birth.

It may be that the only thing preventing you from running against Ted Cruz for Prez is that his mother got in her 10 years (I incorrectly referred to it as 5 years) of being physically present in the US before his birth. Other than that, I'm sure that's the only thing holding you back from being President. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

I'm sure that's the only thing holding you back from being President.

Well, maybe not the ONLY thing.... 

ghostpost --- 12 years ago -

I am also a duel citizen through my mother. I was born in the US. I didn't apply for either citizenship, it was automatic. In fact I wasn't even aware I was an Irish citizen until I was an adult. My children and dh also have duel citizenship through me. None of us are planning on running for president (that I am aware of).

Having an EU passport comes in very handy when I travel internationally. I am a proud American, but truthfully...who would mind being Irish? ;) 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

New Birthers UNITE!!!

Randy is leading the charge. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

You guys didn't know I had to sword fight a dude to be able to vote?

Prison style, Aborto? 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Randy is leading the charge.

Sorry, but I am NOT saying Cruz is definitely not an American citizen. I agree that he probably is given his mothers citizenship at the time of his birth. The FACT is that he IS and STILL IS A CANADIAN CITIZEN. Given the provision in the US Constitution that one must be a natural born US citizen to be US President one can only wonder what the founders would think of a person who had citizenship in another country. I would like to hear from our legal Constitutional scholars on this subject as to the reason for that provision that they inserted. How would they look on a dual citizen serving as POTUS? 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Given the results in this small poll, it would seem like there are lots of liberals voting to allow dual citizenship for President, or all the conservatives are going against their principles to keep Cruz eligible to run.

One of the more interesting facts about his family is that his father waited so many decades before he became a US citizen. He states that he was and is eager to fight communists, but he RAN away to Canada during the Vietnam war where he could have killed commies to his hearts content. The US government would have PAID him to do that and provided free training and ammo to use. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

who would mind being Irish? ;)

During WWII I would have been ashamed to have been Irish. They refused to join the UN, and were actively aiding Hitler, until Churchill told the Irish to STOP or the Irish would be forcibly joining the UK soon. De Valera took the hint and stopped being on Hitler's side so openly. They even returned some US pilots that they had captured when they got lost and landed in Ireland. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

American to tne exclusion of all other citizenships. 

ghostpost --- 12 years ago -

During WWII I would have been ashamed to have been Irish.

During World War II my mother, along with several girlfriends, voluntarily left Ireland to go to London to aid the cause. My mother worked as a volunteer nurse. During the London blitz my mother and her Irish flatmate were both injured. They had to live in the London Underground station along with everyone else who had their living quarters destroyed. Ashamed? Never.

BTW- She was also extremely beautiful and immediately caught the eye of the American lieutenant that became my father.

I am proud to be Irish and American. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

They had to live in the London Underground station along with everyone else who had their living quarters destroyed. Ashamed? Never.

Then they approved of Ireland supporting Hitler? I most certainly doubt that, and bravo for her good work. I wonder what they said about the Irish government at the time. Think that they were proud of it aiding the Nazis? I doubt it. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Randy. President of The New Birthers Club 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Only if they're from Krypton. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground