Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Women not treated equally to men when it comes to domestic violence

who's talking here?

Perfection 6
Warren Peace 10
Dorothy Parker 5
SagaciousSighFiGurl 6
sheddy 1
Emperor of Kingwood 13
DVaz 1
Not KU 1
MarthaStewart 1
mutton 7
You can call me Michelle 1
aragon 2
logic 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

interesting read

There were smiles all around Thursday night when Hope Solo extended her shutout record to 73 in the United States national women?s soccer team?s 4-0 victory over Mexico in Rochester.

Fans cheered, and the players, as they often do, posed for photos and signed autographs with the young girls who revere them. Ah, to be a strong and successful role model, especially for the next generation, and to have the honor to represent your country.

But look past the patina of glee and here?s what you will see: a team and a league ? not named the N.F.L. this time ? that are tone-deaf when it comes to domestic violence and how they handle players who have been accused of it.


It takes a lot to match the N.F.L. these days when it comes to missteps in the handling of players charged with assaulting family members and loved ones. But Thursday, at a time when domestic violence in sports is dominating the national conversation, U.S. Soccer did just that ? again ? by keeping Solo in goal when she shouldn?t have been anywhere near it.

Solo, one of the biggest and most marketable stars in women?s sports, is facing domestic violence charges from an episode over the summer in which she is accused of punching her sister and her 17-year-old nephew at a late-night party.

According to a police account of the episode, Solo was the primary aggressor and instigator of an assault at a family party that left her sister and nephew with noticeable injuries to their heads and faces. She has pleaded not guilty; her trial is set for November.

One can argue the differences between an N.F.L. player punching his soon-to-be wife and a soccer star brawling with her family, but it is indisputable that both qualify as domestic violence.

The glaring contrast in Solo?s case is that while several football players recently accused of assaults have been removed from the field, she has been held up for praise by the national team. On Thursday she was even given the honor of wearing the captain?s armband in celebration of her setting the team?s career record for shutouts in its previous game.

The question is why. Celebrating Solo?s achievement right now is like allowing running back Adrian Peterson, who has been accused of child abuse, to continue to play for the Minnesota Vikings ? and then awarding him the game ball for his next 100-yard game.

If that wouldn?t happen in the N.F.L., it shouldn?t happen in women?s sports, either.

Yet U.S. Soccer, showing that it has no sense regarding this issue, went ahead and gave Solo a very public pat on the back.

Every case involving domestic violence charges has its own circumstances, including the one in 2012 in which Solo?s boyfriend at the time was accused of assaulting her. (Those charges were later dropped.) When Ray Rice, Greg Hardy and Adrian Peterson were arrested, there were loud calls for those players to be suspended. The response to Solo?s case? The sound of crickets ? except on game days, when it changes to applause. And that?s inexcusable.

Maybe everyone is just too busy calling out the N.F.L. for its ineptitude, but a light needs to shine on Solo?s legal problems, too. It shows that domestic violence isn?t committed only by men, even if Solo is eventually cleared of the charges against her.

The court has ordered Solo to stay away from her sister and nephew and to refrain from drinking alcohol. At the same time, U.S. Soccer and the Seattle Reign, her team in the National Women?s Soccer League, have put on blinders. Solo played on as Seattle advanced to the league?s title game last month, and she played on this week as the national team continued preparations for next month?s qualifiers for the 2015 Women?s World Cup. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

It's WRONG and disgusting no matter who does it.

The reason women are treated differently is because it's fairly rare that they are the abuser and not the abused. Just like sexual assault. The vast majority of the time it's the men who commit the assault. So things evolve when it's so one sided like that, although the laws should be the same for both. I think juries are more sympathetic to the obvious that women are physically weaker than men therefor they are looked at as the proverbial underdog.

But, each case should be looked at on a one on one basis. Laws should apply equally to both.

In this case, it was two women so that probably will work in her favor as they will not see it as someone overpowering a weaker person. The nephew is different tho.

We have deeply engrained 'standards' in society that have to be brought out and talked about so we can change public opinions and myths about abuse and assault when the woman is the perpetrator. It takes time. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

The reason women are treated differently is because it's fairly rare that they are the abuser and not the abused.?

Maybe not. Men are not likely to report getting slapped by a woman but thats still assault. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

I think there is also stigma attached for the man to say a woman beat him up...I have known a few women who could very well do just that... 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Bob in Texas --- 10 min ago - quote - hide comments

The reason women are treated differently is because it's fairly rare that they are the abuser and not the abused.?

Maybe not. Men are not likely to report getting slapped by a woman but thats still assault.
mutton --- 7 min ago - quote - hide comments

I think there is also stigma attached for the man to say a woman beat him up...I have known a few women who could very well do just that...



I think both of you are right.

Men are viewed as weak if they report it and there are women who use that to their advantage 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I don't believe abuse at the hands of a woman against a man is as prevalent or as damaging as a man against a woman...that's why it isn't looked at in the same light.

How many women could punch a man in an elevator and knock him out cold?

Now, if some man is being beaten with a cast iron skillet while he sleeps...that is a different story. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Those skillets are effing heavy !! 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Most men I know were raised never to hit a woman, no matter what tne reason. However, I am seeing a change in that attitude to one of, "if she hits me she will get hit back". 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

I think girls in early grade school to Jr High should be taught martial arts as P.E. and self-defense and confidence building. Might even help w/childhood obesity. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

The circumstances of this are also different. Some people have used Ray Rice's actions to raise awareness to domestic abuse, but the reason it was a story was because an NFL player was caught on video nonchalantly dragging his unconscious wife out of an elevator. We know he hit her, but we didn't know much about her role in it until the 2nd video showed how unconscionable the brutality was.

If Ray Rice had smacked his brother and his nephew with no video footage, he would still be continuing his career decline, possibly getting something less than the brisk 3.1 yards per carry that he racked up last year.

In the Hope Solo case...yawn, cat fight. It's the type of thing that gins up ratings on reality TV. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Men are viewed as weak if they report it and there are women who use that to their advantage?

Exactly. So the slap, the shove, the object thrown never gets reported but its all still assault. 

aragon --- 12 years ago -

Men aren't allowed to defend themselves against physical or psychological abuse. If they do they will get labeled or worse, jailed. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Exactly. So the slap, the shove, the object thrown never gets reported but its all still assault.

Same thing when women sexually harass in the workplace. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Men aren't allowed to defend themselves against physical or psychological abuse. If they do they will get labeled or worse, jailed.

I disagree. Defend yourself but keep it proportional. I haven't read anything to indicate Ray Rice even had a need to defend himself, much less deliver the level of brutality he did. If you are an NFL player, you can't throw a punch at someone's face because they touched you or spit at you. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Among men, I think there's general agreement that we take much more off a woman than we ever would another man. 

aragon --- 12 years ago -

Defend yourself but keep it proportional.

Even if proportional or much less, men don't get the benefit of the doubt. All a woman has to do is cry or give a sob story (a lie) and the man is screwed.

Women get a pass when abusing men for the most part. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Men aren't allowed to defend themselves against physical or psychological abuse. If they do they will get labeled or worse, jailed.?

Agree in principle, but the response to psychological abuse can not be physical. The response to physical assault must be the force necessary to stop the assault and not retaliation.

The best response is divorce papers at the first sign of either. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -


In the Hope Solo case...yawn, cat fight. It's the type of thing that gins up ratings on reality TV.



Sad.

Facial injuries are not cat fights.

But your point is made, women fighting women is "cute" as cat fights, you don't see them as the brutality they are (as evidenced by the words you chose to use to describe it).

Physical abuse is physical abuse regardless of who is doing it. The fact that these are family members is no different than someone randomly walking up to someone and hitting them in the face.

And we aren't even discussing verbal abuse - my goodness the damage that does to children is just as real.

Family members who abuse other family members are trying to exert power over someone they profess to love - how messed up is that. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Among men, I think there's general agreement that we take much more off a woman than we ever would another man.

Well yeah, but that's the nature of chivalry. Chivalry still lives and I try to do my part. It's nice when women appreciate it. Most do. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

So the slap, the shove, the object thrown never gets reported but its all still assault.


So many dynamics. Have people lost the ability to reason and not be so reactionary? 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

But your point is made, women fighting women is "cute" as cat fights, you don't see them as the brutality they are (as evidenced by the words you chose to use to describe it).

My intention was to characterize it the way our culture sees it, not to promote that POV. By comparing it to what drives ratings on reality TV, I expected that intention to be obvious. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Well yeah, but that's the nature of chivalry. Chivalry still lives and I try to do my part. It's nice when women appreciate it. Most do.


It is nice to see someone hold the door open for another or let someone in line in front of them or hold an umbrella.

It doesn't take much to be considerate. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

So many dynamics. Have people lost the ability to reason and not be so reactionary??

Yes they have, its a severe lack of emotional control. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Perfection, abuse has been happening in every generation of human beings.

So, apparently, the art of reasoning and not reacting, has never existed. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

It is nice to see someone hold the door open for another or let someone in line in front of them or hold an umbrella.It doesn't take much to be considerate.?

Men past a certain age were mostly raised as gentlemen. I think the militant faction of the womens movement, along with society seeking 100% equality among the sexes might play a role in that change. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I think the militant faction of the womens movement, along with society seeking 100% equality among the sexes might play a role in that change.?



So, if women had just stayed in the home and known their place, domestic violence wouldn't exist and good manners would be shown all day, every day? Is that your assessment, Bob? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Go try and troll someone else. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

How am I trolling? You are saying women wanting equal treatment has played a role in domestic violence and bad manners.

You don't like your opinion being repeated back to you? Keep it to yourself. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

"Among men, I think there's general agreement that we take much more off a woman than we ever would another man. "





That's bc, IMO, they don't really feel threatened by the weaker sex, even if she does do something physical. Men see each other as physical equals. Plus there's the aspect of the opposite sex and all the so called behavioral expectations. When a woman acts like she shouldn't, as in hitting or throwing something, a man has been taught that hitting a woman is unsavory. So his instincts may be to purely deflect. Just like when a man does things he shouldn't, a woman's initial instinct is denial or evading a good portion of the time.

Abuse is a power/control issue. Women know they are the physically weaker sex the vast majority of the time. That sets up an imbalance of power issue even if there is only emotionally verbal abuse. When someone is mean/angry/controlling with words, the brain has no choice but to perceive that as a threat. Fear is born. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Abuse is a power/control issue. Women know they are the physically weaker sex the vast majority of the time. That sets up an imbalance of power issue even if there is only emotionally verbal abuse. When someone is mean/angry/controlling with words, the brain has no choice but to perceive that as a threat. Fear is born.


Which can explain for men, why they react physically.

It does NOT justify it but you raise a great point.

When women use their words as weapons, they are also being abusive. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

If someone doesn't want to get hit, they shouldn't hit, regardless of the sex. If I was hit by a man, I would call the police and if I couldn't he better blot the door when he goes to sleep. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

"When women use their words as weapons, they are also being abusive. "



Yes, that's true by definition. And it is. The caveat tho is that men are stronger physically and that means naturally they aren't going to experience the fear a 5"5 woman might when a 6"2 dude starts raging.

There are some things people feel deep down and subconsciously that are very natural. Just like when a kitten is wild and playful and running around being a badass, all a human has to do is bend over and pick it up. Badass is done. Lol. And all the kittens power is gone. Women can feel like that around a intimidating man who is angry and lacks control. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Abuse is a power/control issue. Women know they are the physically weaker sex the vast majority of the time. That sets up an imbalance of power issue even if there is only emotionally verbal abuse. When someone is mean/angry/controlling with words, the brain has no choice but to perceive that as a threat. Fear is born.?

I think you are right on track. Add to it, that women in the work place receive more protections than their male counter parts and that extends the perception of competition which in men breeds a win attitude. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Abuse is a power/control issue. Women know they are the physically weaker sex the vast majority of the time. That sets up an imbalance of power issue even if there is only emotionally verbal abuse. When someone is mean/angry/controlling with words, the brain has no choice but to perceive that as a threat. Fear is born.

I agree with everything except those last two sentences. I have no awareness of my brain perceiving mean/angry/controlling words as a threat. I perceive it as a communication issue that invites a need for clarity. When I hear those types of words, I ask follow-up questions. 

logic --- 12 years ago -

If someone doesn't want to get hit, they shouldn't hit, regardless of the sex.

Since men are more physical, I think it is hard for a man, especially a young man, to keep from physical retaliation when they are struck. It's probably even harder for a man whose career is physical in nature. I think for them to have any chance of being able to restrain themselves after having been struck, they have to be in full control of their mental faculties. Rice had been drinking and was drunk or close to being drunk, so I believe he reacted instinctively since he clearly didn't have full control of his mind and thoughts in his inebriated state. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

What protections do their male counterparts need, Bob?

Are men sexually harassed? Are they paid less? Are they overlooked for promotions due to women in the same positions?

Are you saying that this "win attitude" leads to women being punched in elevators, because men are being made to feel inferior by all of this "militant women's lib" nonsense?

Do clarify. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

?I perceive it as a communication issue that invites a need for clarity. When I hear those types of words, I ask follow-up questions.?

Thats because,

1. You are an educated man and as such have learned a level of emotional control and

2. Because of 1, you have adult level of discernment that allows you to step back emotionally and respond cerebrally. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

"I agree with everything except those last two sentences. I have no awareness of my brain perceiving mean/angry/controlling words as a threat. I perceive it as a communication issue that invites a need for clarity. When I hear those types of words, I ask follow-up "





Most likely bc you neither do that or haven't had someone bigger and meaner and threatening actually aim it at you. A dynamic develops where by the other person has a mind set they are walking on egg shells. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

When I grew up there was definite emotional and psychological abuse. When is a parent is kinda hard to get away from. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Most likely bc you neither do that or haven't had someone bigger and meaner and threatening actually aim it at you. A dynamic develops where by the other person has a mind set they are walking on egg shells.
I'm not a tall fellow. I'm average male height. So almost half of all males are bigger than me. But the career I chose has routinely put me in contact with "bigger and meaner" people that have threatened and taken aim at me. I still think there's some truth in what you're saying, but maybe the conclusion needs tweaking. Maybe since I have been exposed to it so much, it doesn't affect me the same way that it would people that have experienced it less frequently or from people who feel incapable of responding proportional to the threat.

I'm also aware of the feeling of walking on eggshells. For me, it's the feeling of having a conversation where word meanings are so precarious that a conversation is like walking through a minefield of trigger words. The other person typically has assigned motives to me and is only looking for evidence to support their righteous assignment of these motives. So there's some degree of anxiety about advancing the conversation and getting to the heart of whatever issue has caused conflict. But it is almost always a navigable conversation and doing it successfully has the effect of disarming or redirecting the other person. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground