Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Not sure we need that wall after all

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
Warren Peace 6
Dorothy Parker 1
Judas 2
a889324uu 1
mutton 3
AMDG 5
Zapper009 1
fuzz81 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

More people are migrating from the US to Mexico, than are migrating from Mexico to the US.

Houston Chron story

A few excerpts:

Pew found that slightly more than 1 million Mexicans and their families, including American-born children, left the U.S. for Mexico from 2009 to 2014. During the same time, 870,000 Mexicans came to the U.S., resulting in a net flow to Mexico of 140,000.

While the U.S. economic recovery is sluggish, Mexico has been free in recent years from the economic tailspins that drove earlier generations north in the 1980s and 1990s. The peso is relatively stable, inflation is manageable, and while many parts of Mexico suffer grinding poverty and violence, others -- especially in the more industrial northern half -- have become thriving manufacturing centers under the North American Free Trade Agreement, producing cars, airplanes and other heavy equipment. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

KU will never believe it!!! 

whatchamacallit --- 11 years ago -

So, we have a large influx of poor, unskilled, illiterate people destined to be a burden on the economy and an outflow of well off, tax paying, educated and skilled labor? What a great tradeoff!

How would they really know how many illegals come across, anyway?

MAYBE WE NEED A FENCE TO KEEP PEOPLE IN AND OUT! lol! 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

So, we have a large influx of poor, unskilled, illiterate people destined to be a burden on the economy and an outflow of well off, tax paying, educated and skilled labor? What a great tradeoff!




Typical that you would JUMP to that conclusion without any cold, hard facts to back yourself up. The definition for that is ignorance.

Here's the facts from the article:
A study published Thursday by the Pew Research Center said a desire to reunite families is the primary reason Mexicans go home. 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

How would they really know how many illegals come across, anyway?



If you feel that way why do you assume there are so many here when you have no idea who is legal and who is illegal? More ignorance. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

You know maybe Trump is just pure genius. By saying he will deport all illegal aliens, he gains favor with the far right, and at the same time gets the Latino vote, by providing free transportation where they really want to go anyway.

He may just be playing chess while the rest of us are playing checkers. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

The GOP is all about chess, and the dullards are all the pawns. Tell enough lies and eventually it becomes true. 

whatchamacallit --- 11 years ago -

AMDG --- 53 min ago - quote - hide comments
You know maybe Trump is just pure genius. By saying he will deport all illegal aliens, he gains favor with the far right, and at the same time gets the Latino vote, by providing free transportation where they really want to go anyway.



Sure! Lol 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

fuzz81 --- 1 days ago - quote - hide comments
The GOP is all about chess, and the dullards are all the pawns. Tell enough lies and eventually it becomes true.?


Careful with throwing around that dullard label fuzzy. If you actually read the article, it is not about illegal immigration. It's about all forms of migration to and from Mexico. It may be shocking to you and others, but this means it has absolutely nothing to do with the wall. We have a partial wall to address the illegal immigration at the southern border, regardless of migration trends. I have not read or seen anyone here or a member of the GOP taking objection to the legal migration of Mexican citizens. Have you? If so, please link. If not, be more careful - the dullard label may come back and bite you in the butt.

I'd say the true dullard is the author of the article who ignorantly writes, "The findings counter the narrative of an out-of-control border that has figured prominently in U.S. presidential campaigns, with Republican Donald Trump calling for Mexico pay for a fence to run the entire length of the 1,954-mile frontier." The author seems oblivious to the fact that the political issue is about how porous the border is. The political issue has absolutely nothing to do with net migration figures that include legal migration. The change in net migration has nothing to do with the border becoming less porous.

Non-dullards will recognize the data has nothing to do with an out of control border. In my opinion, the article was written to fool people into believing it does. I'd say the author was pretty successful at fooling people only capable of playing checkers. 

Zapper009 --- 11 years ago -

The GOP is all about chess, and the dullards are all the pawns. Tell enough lies and eventually it becomes true.?

DITTO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Non-dullards will recognize the data has nothing to do with an out of control border. In my opinion, the article was written to fool people into believing it does. I'd say the author was pretty successful at fooling people only capable of playing checkers.?

The paradox of dullards. Does it make ones self dull by calling someone else a dullard?

The irony of persuasion. Is the article really written to fool people into believing it?? Or is Donald trump's mouth?? I dunnnnnoooo 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Warren, not sure you are right that they are only talking about legal migration. At the risk of bring a dullard, I may have missed something.

By the way here is the pew article, that gives the methodology

http://www.pewhispanic.org/2015/11/19/more-mexicans-leaving-than-coming-to-the-u-s/ 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

Warren, not sure you are right that they are only talking about legal migration. At the risk of bring a dullard, I may have missed something.

I have a lot of respect for you AMDG. You're not only one of the classiest posters here, but you're also one of the most intelligent. I give you a pass on the angle you're taking with this. Fuzzy, not so much. He's been too much of a prick with too many people and his arrogance rivals only the Emp and possibly jams.

I reserve my disparaging remarks for those that earn it by relentlessly insulting others (jams, fuzzy, judy/joe and so on). I realize my remarks might have winged you with unintended collateral damage. I apologize.

But I did not say what you think I did. I did not say they are only talking about legal migration. If you believe I did, quote my remark.

You did miss something. But I'm 100% certain you are not a dullard. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

Amdg is definitely not a dullard Warren and yes, gives a very intelligent conversation/opinion piece all without the pokes others love to give... 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

I concur. He's a far better man than I. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

Is OK, there is always one better, lol. I likes you both! 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Fuzzy, not so much. He's been too much of a prick with too many people and his arrogance rivals only the Emp and possibly jams.

I reserve my disparaging remarks for those that earn it by relentlessly insulting others


So let me get this straight, you think I'm a prick because I disagree with you? Basically, you just listed everyone who disagrees with you.

Where did I call you a dullard? Show me where I've been a prick to you. I directed nothing at you.

So you're telling me the likes of soup, dread pirate Roberts or the slew of other people who relentlessly spew lies are NOT pricks? 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

LMAO

Oh, Warren...I'm not even part of this conversation, and you're sniveling about me being insulting while responding in kind.

But carry on with your crying, big boy. 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

^^^^^^
Textbook jams. Typical strawman arguments. No one said you needed to be a part of this conversation in order to be deserving of my spot-on remarks.

But fuzz, I did not say that you were a prick to me. I said you've been a prick. Past tense. And not to me. I'm optimistic that you just role play for the board and have it in you to be an occasional gentleman. We'd probably get along just fine outside message board political topics, despite your origins from a nation of no historical significance. I'm part Irish and at least we get to be noteworthy for potato famine (how is that even possible?), occasional rowdiness, and low corporate tax rates. But Canada? It only comes up in conversation when I debate others about where the worst possible whiskey is distilled. Canadian whiskey is basically for children. Texas whiskey is where it's at, and for what it's worth...the Irish have it going on as well.

As to the others you listed, I did say "and so on", which I intended as a reference to others. DPR at least has a sense of humor, which is a trait I admire in any part time prick.

Better? 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Of course I've been a prick, in a reciprocal manner. Kinda like what you're doing right now.. Why attack Canada? Lol.. No historical significance? Ok then. I guess you missed keystone pipeline, nafta, lumber, water, TPP, us burning down your White House, the Underground Railroad, New Orleans, that its part of the British commonwealth, the largest US trading partner, first to declare war after Pearl Harbor, etc etc etc but yeah we just live in igloos, club baby seals and make bad whisky :)

I agree that we produce horrible whisky and beer. I'll take scotch any day. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

I'm also Scottish and Irish. 15% of Canada is Irish. St Patty's day was always a riot in the city I grew up in. Entire market was green, green beer everywhere, good times. 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

Touche' and good point about New Orleans (that's as much ground that I'll cede). I'm part coonass (in fact, mostly coonass). I can face it, I'm a mutt from parts all over and parts unknown. I should know better than make playful banter about the nation my ancestors wisely fled, which we have all noticed...you did as well.

Is the US just your durty whore (not a direct reference to jams)? We will take just about anyone you know - see Syria.

I have a bottle of Lagavulin 16 I may have to share with you one day. Cheers. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Warren, this was the line I objected to.

If you actually read the article, it is not about illegal immigration. It's about all forms of migration to and from Mexico

I think there is an attempt to also count illegals in these numbers.

But, really neither here nor there, post wasn't a big political statement, just thought the article was interesting, and certainly a different take then the conventional wisdom out there.

And way more importantly thanks guys for the kind words, and back at ya. 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

Yes the count does include illegal aliens, but the conclusion of a change in net migration was not a direct reflection of only illegal aliens. I see where I could have written my remarks with more clarity. Perhaps if I had said, "The article is not about onlyillegal immigration. It's about all forms of migration (both legal and illegal) to and from Mexico, and is only about migration of Mexicans, not all persons who cross the Mexican border illegally."

The point I was trying to make is that the political issue is about the porous nature of our southern border. In order to make the case that a wall or an expanded wall is not needed, the author would need to not limit the query to only persons of Mexican origin and not blend legal immigration in with illegal. We have an estimated 230,000 Mexicans that get caught illegally crossing the southern border and around 90,000 persons from countries other than Mexico who get caught illegally crossing the same border. We can only speculate about the volume of persons from Mexico and other nations that do not get caught, but if we can agree that the figure is much higher, is the need for a wall lessened based on the fact that some of the persons of Mexican origin who came here legally return to Mexico? Of course not. That only clouds the issue.

We already have a wall. No one is proposing that we tear down the current wall. We have reason to believe that every administration of both parties supports the presence of a wall because every administration has funded its maintenance. The friction is over whether or not we should expand the wall to make our border more secure.

Even Bernie Sanders is aware of the border security issue, but he has such intense tunnel vision, he limits his conclusion to the statement that climate change is the biggest threat to our national security. It's related because the source of information he cites is the CIA. What he fails to publicly acknowledge is the reason the CIA has cited climate change as a long term security risk is because of the effect droughts and famine would have on border security. In other words, Bernie wants to limit his awareness to climate change at the expense of overlooking that the source he relies on is actually saying that border security is a significant long term issue.

All of us are intelligent enough to know that we are not going to prevent our climate from changing and we certainly will not be able to prevent drought or famine in other nations. But what we can do is better regulate the potential impact of drought or famine on the US, regardless of its cause by enhancing the physical structure that enables us to make the act of illegally crossing the border more difficult.

All of that are the reasons why I believe it is counter productive to suggest we do not need to improve our border security, particularly if we are relying only on net migration figures of only Mexican nationals and are including legal migration in the figures used to make that case. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Warren - the title of the post, was me just trying to be clever. That didn't work out so well. Think the pew article, and the chronicle story about the article, was just to point out there is a net outflow of Mexican migration.

No doubt soverin nations should control their borders. I have no real clue the best way to do that. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Vote for building a wall. I've invested in a company that specializes in 40' ladders, so please make sure the wall is no more than 42'. K thanks. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Ever hear the term "locks keep honest people out?" Same applies to a wall 

mutton --- 10 years ago -

Ok Fuzz, that was just funny! lol The ladder I speak of... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground