Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

GOPper's Healthcare Crash and Burn!

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 5
Joe Blow 5
Emperor of Kingwood 15
Judas 1
Not KU 5
AMDG 2
Karras 1
JustWatching 13
Tryingto 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Joe Blow --- 9 years ago -

20 reasons the GOP crashed and burned on health care

Republicans? inability to pass health-care legislation comes as no surprise to those who have watched the party descend into know-nothingism. They hope to get by on a mixture of brain-numbing catchphrases designed to dupe the masses and far-right ideology at odds with the views of Americans, even those within the GOP. Fortunately, that?s not a recipe for successful governance. Let?s recall 20 reasons the GOP?s health-care effort went down in flames.


1. Republicans saw polling show Obamacare was unpopular as a sign that people wanted less government. In fact, polls show that having seen what a post-Obamacare world would look like, they overwhelmingly want to keep it ? or make the benefits more generous. Each time Republicans argued that taking away health care was equivalent to ?freedom,? they lost another few percentage points of support.

2. No section of the electorate, not even Republicans, thinks Medicaid cuts are a good idea. Using this as an opportunity to whack Medicaid ? starving it of resources ? was misguided. GOP promises that they were improving Medicaid were hollow and unbelievable.

3. Taking benefits away from people to give tax cuts to the rich is a dream target for Democrats.

4. President Trump?s campaign rhetoric made it sound as though the GOP was going to give more and take away nothing in health-care reform. When Republicans did the opposite, they made Trump into a liar and alienated his base.

5. The White House assumption that it could delegate health-care reform to the GOP leaders who do not share Trump?s populist outlook was dumb.

6. The notion that you can run a White House without experienced insiders reflected a fundamental lack of understanding about what the president does.

7. Trump seemed to believe that bucking up his base has been productive (by attacking the media, for example). It did nothing to win votes in Congress or to keep independents on his side. His ego compels him to do things unrelated to or damaging to governing.

8. Ironically, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), the lover of Senate tradition, should have known that you cannot order senators around like House members. Threaten them or put them on deadline ? and they will revolt.

9. Many Republican lawmakers ? I know this is cringe-worthy ? likely didn?t realize that Medicaid serves lots of people other than unemployed, poor people. They grossly misjudged the damage that Medicaid cuts would do.

10. The entire notion of creating a ?free market? for health care is off-base. Government ? via Medicaid, Medicare and requirements to treat all urgent-care patients ? has already big-footed the market. Reforms around the edges are possible, but there is no free market for health care and there hasn?t been for 50 years or so. (Even at the state level, strict insurance regulations do not allow insurance companies to operate like other private businesses.)

11. Republicans seemed to forget that people fear change, especially when it comes to health care.

12. Republicans on Capitol Hill never enlisted GOP governors who are far more influential and popular than they are. Governors are not going to stand idly by while Congress wrecks their states? finances.

13. They should have done infrastructure first.

14. Rolling out a half-baked tax plan with supersize cuts for the rich only intensified the perception that the GOP cares only about tax cuts for the rich.

15. The idea that taking people off Medicaid wouldn?t cause suffering because they could buy insurance was economically questionable and politically untenable. If your income is so low as to qualify for Medicaid, you cannot afford the premiums and/or the big deductibles (if you choose a plan with lower premiums).

16. Plotting in secret never works, especially when the people in the room have a poor grasp of health-care economics.

17. Republicans intentionally exaggerated the problems with the exchanges, assuming that alone would make anything they proposed acceptable.

18. Claiming Democrats only wanted single-payer health care didn?t match reality. They are fighting to keep Obamacare, which isn?t single-payer health care. (A segment of the Democratic Party certainly wants single-payer health care, but for now that is not what they are advocating.)

19. Standing up for ?hardworking taxpayers? could not disguise the fact that the overwhelming amount of tax relief was going to the richest Americans.

20. You cannot pass major legislation with a policy-illiterate president who cannot explain what?s in it and therefore cannot persuade voters and lawmakers of its merits.

Am I surprised the GOP crashed and burned? Not in the least. I?m surprised that so many are surprised the party failed.



FAIL FAIL FAIL
65 attempts to repeal Obamacare
FAIL FAIL FAIL
House attempt at TrumptyCare
FAIL FAIL FAIL
Senate attemt at DumpCare
FAIL FAIL FAIL
GOP Pubies in general
FAIL FAIL FAIL

LMFAO 

Joe Blow --- 9 years ago -

Pubie Logic

0 

Karras --- 9 years ago -

Let's see, didn't it take 14 months for the dems to shove Obamacare down our throats?

The problem with republicans is that they too think government should be in the health care business.

They just need to repeal obamcare and let the free market take care of the rest. 

Joe Blow --- 9 years ago -

It's so weird when the Pubies can't agree on how to screw the country over.

LMFAO 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

But the Dimocrats are all lock step on how to screw over the country. 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

Tell you what...let's let Obamacare implode as it will next year. The democrats own it and if it's so good then let it be. The democrat party will die when Obamacare dies. 2018 will probably be the last year for Obamacare as all the insurance companies pull out of it. 

Joe Blow --- 9 years ago -

Obamacare is imploding because the Pub heads have refused to fix it for the good of the country. Party over country is their motto. Morons that they are. But let the mindless pubies keep being the black sheeple that they are for the good of party and screw the country.

The pubies healthcare bill is political kryptonite!!! That's crystal clear!

LMFAO 

Joe Blow --- 9 years ago -

The news just keeps getting worse and worse for the pubies:

A new NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll shows the Senate health-care bill is deeply unpopular ? and not just among Democrats.
 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

Obamacare is imploding because the Pub heads have refused to fix it for the good of the country.

If Obamacare is so good why do we have to fix it. The democrats own it. It's dying and won't be around long. Next year there will be counties that have no choice of insurance companies. You democrats don't blame the Republicans because we didn't vote for it. This is all on the democrats. 

Not KU --- 9 years ago -

Un believable.
For the last 8 years the GOP has been​ looking to repeal and replace the ACA..
Now that the GOP has the house senate & Whitehouse why is it that the GOP isn't able to do get anything done? 

Not KU --- 9 years ago -

GOP 0
ACA 2 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

Watch and see what happens before you start making predictions. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

Obamacare is imploding because the Pub heads have refused to fix it for the good of the country.

Fix it? So you're admitting the Dems screwed up and passed a flawed law?

Nice to see you're coming around. 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

All the democrats admit Obamacare has to be fixed and they want the Republicans to do it. I say let them fix their own mess. 

Tryingto --- 9 years ago -

All the democrats admit Obamacare has to be fixed and they want the Republicans to do it. I say let them fix their own mess.

Yes, healthcare is messy. Will you be using your Medicare at 65, or will you tell the government to keep it, you're good? How are old people supposed to get affordable insurance without pre-existing condition exceptions?

I cared for an aging parent. It is expensive to die. There were multiple ambulance trips, lengthy hospital stays, rehabilitation. He worked until he couldn't, at about 75. What if you have no family? Who cares for the elderly?

My dad worked hard and saved just enough...but without social security and Medicare, he wouldn't have made it.
And we all contributed to assist. 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

Actually, I pay for Medicare but have never used it. I am entitled to other healthcare for life but was so afraid Obama would take that from me, I signed up for Medicare, just in case. 

Tryingto --- 9 years ago -

So, I'm guessing you had another government job that entitles you to benefits?

My dad worked hard, planned and saved but didn't die with much. The cost of care was extremely expensive. When he was at the last nursing home, and we went over the admitting papers, my heart broke for the people who had no one--the nursing home became their legal caretaker.

He had his family checking up and making sure things got done.

Sadly, it should be different, but it's not. The face of the needy isn't lazy, do nothings'. 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

Tryingto --- 8 hours ago - quote - hide comments
So, I'm guessing you had another government job that entitles you to benefits?


Yes, I'm a combat veteran who was in the Army for 6 years. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Good luck getting VA health care. I too am a combat veteran and can't get VA health care. 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

Emperor of Kingwood --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments
Good luck getting VA health care. I too am a combat veteran and can't get VA health care.


I've never had a problem. My care is great. They've operated on me twice. I've heard of the complaints but have had none myself. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

My complaint is that I can't get access. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Emp - I have never tried to use it, but I think vietnam vets ( served prior to 75) get some kind of priority. I got some explanation of it a while back - don't remember all of it sorry 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Its more about means testing 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

Emperor of Kingwood --- 4 min ago - quote - hide comments
My complaint is that I can't get access.?


All you have to do is sign up and they will assign you a doctor. You must show them your DD214 to prove you were in the service first. You can sign up at any location. I went to the hospital. It took about 20 minutes. 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

Emperor of Kingwood --- 2 min ago - quote - hide comments
Its more about means testing?


That only determines what your copay is. As long as you served in combat (you must have done that because Obama changed the rules) then you will be covered. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

That only determines what your copay is. As long as you served in combat (you must have done that because Obama changed the rules) then you will be covered.

When did this change. I got a letter saying I was in Priority Group 8 and therefore not covered. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Just got off the phone with the VA and its means tested. 

Tryingto --- 9 years ago -

Thanks for your service. I think it is wrong to cut VA healthcare and benefits. Just like I think it's wrong to cut the elderly or needy.

I have enough to share. I'm not rich, but I would certainly give part of my paycheck to make sure everyone gets healthcare.

If hospitals and doctors feel a moral obligation to treat people, regardless of payment, shouldn't that be an example to all?


Personally, I thought Obama Care wasn't drastic enough. I would have liked to see employers out of healthcare, and the ability to really use the marketplace for competitive rates. Rates are still crappy, and basically catastrophe care. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Emp - never really looked into it - was lucky to retire with lifetime medical - I always thought the VA stuff was kind of a last resort thing.

Am i right - do veterans in some real financial need get coverage from the VA ?? 

Not KU --- 9 years ago -

Good luck getting VA health care. I too am a combat veteran and can't get VA health care.

All you need is your DD214
It worked for me 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Am i right - do veterans in some real financial need get coverage from the VA ??

Yes, but you don't get it if your above their income threshold. 

Judas --- 9 years ago -

Mitch McConnell is stunned that taking health insurance away from 22 million Americans wasn't enough to make Repugnants love the bill. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

LOL..... responding to your own posted meme.

Priceless. 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

When did this change. I got a letter saying I was in Priority Group 8 and therefore not covered.?

You need to read the letter again. 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

Judas --- 7 min ago - quote - hide comments
Mitch McConnell is stunned that taking health insurance away from 22 million Americans wasn't enough to make Repugnants love the bill.?


The people who give the estimates are real good at budget numbers but not so good at anything else. They gave an estimate for how many people would sign up for Obamacare and less than half of what the CBO said would sign up did. I don't believe any of the estimates they give other than the budget numbers. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

health insurance away from 22 million Americans

Lets be clear about it. 63% of that 22 million is medicaid expansion, not insurance. 

Tryingto --- 9 years ago -

Lets be clear about it. 63% of that 22 million is medicaid expansion, not insurance.


In Texas, you can only make $16,000 to get Medicaid. Jeez. Here's $15.00 from my paycheck, go to the doctor. Whatever happened to, "For those whom much is given, much is expected." Did I really deserve all the good things in my life, or am I lucky?

I think sometimes people overestimate the role they had in getting what they have. Or, what can happen, in spite of good planning.

A lot of Medicaid is used to pay for the elderly in long term care. If you're in a an Alzheimer's unit, that can run $5000.00 a month. So, sell your house, and the $100,000 equity should keep you alive for around two years. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

"For those whom much is given, much is expected."

That's a paraphrase of Luke 12:48 and used totally out of context with the parables of Jesus in Luke Chapter 40. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

A lot of Medicaid is used to pay for the elderly

Not really. Medicaid provides health coverage to more than 4.6 million low-income seniors, nearly all of whom are also enrolled in Medicare. Medicaid also provides coverage to 3.7 million people with disabilities who are enrolled in Medicare. In total, 8.3 million people are "dually eligible" and enrolled in both Medicaid and Medicare, composing more than 17% of all Medicaid enrollees. 

Tryingto --- 9 years ago -

In total, 8.3 million people are "dually eligible" and enrolled in both Medicaid and Medicare, composing more than 17% of all Medicaid enrollees.


That is 20% who are both old and poor, and the number is expected to rise. Who gets cut out when you cut back?

The other 80% are living high and mighty on their annual $16,000 salary? So, I should cut out the disabled? Or, the kids transitioning from foster care. Again, here, is some of my paycheck. I'm okay. My kids are healthy. I am employed and relatively healthy. I eat daily. My house is okay. I put some away for a rainy day. I've got disability insurance and long term care. Thanks mom. Thanks dad. Thanks God.

But, take $100.00 out of my paycheck, not $15.00. That's probably more accurate.

"For those whom much is given, much is expected."

It doesn't change the meaning of the paraphrase...regardless of the original source, correct? If you get a lot, expect to do a lot.

And maybe we underestimate what a lot is.... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground