Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I have a religious question

who's talking here?

Carla 11
smartypants 2
Rubicon 1
ghostpost 2
JUNIPER 2
3monkeysmomma 1
ExLady In Blue 4
Atasca Mom 1
Lillabeth 1
justcat 1
POTUS 6
Hiro Protagonist 1
zapper007 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 16
JohnLynch 38
mommie21g1b 3
james osterberg 2
OH SNAP 13
Frio 2
RedMulch 5
Pollys Crackers 1
Gigix4 3
Dr Aborto 1
Aah Grasshoppa 1
20yrtexan 6
hebrcb 1
RushJunkie 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 6
Devil in a Blue Dress 1
horseymomma 5
JoyceD 1
Joe Blow 3
ChrisC2011 3
Kara 10
Feeling Blue 1
honeymustard 1
gardeniagirl07 5
Kyobungee 4
IrvingShwartz 1
Iman 2
The Lake Houston Bridge Troll 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Kara --- 15 years ago -

Why don't some Christians recognize infant baptisms?

Why are only adults/teens baptized?

Why don't they attend infant baptisms?

Why don't you recognize infants being baptized and only as being blessed?

I am Catholic and I am accepting of every faith. I don't force my views upon others, people can make their own decisions. I respect others views and rituals. I attend other religion's services when I am invited.

I know for a fact that some Christians will not attend infant baptisms (happened to my family.) The potential Godfather even declined because his new wife would not allow it.

Confused Catholic and concerned neighbor of an impressionable teen that is being coerced into being baptized again when she has already been baptized as an infant.

The church told her that she was not baptized and only blessed. Therefore, she has to be baptized. And if she does it, she even will talk more from it! She doesn't talk much, she is a listener. I told her that it is nothing to be ashamed of.

She also told me that she felt ackward each time they brought it up to her and finally she caved in.

She invited me to the baptism tomorrow. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

Some churches believe only "their" type of baptism is correct. I grew up in a church that believed if a baby died before baptism it went to hell (I am serious).

I would be very concerned about peer pressure and the teen you mentioned. 

POTUS --- 15 years ago -

Great thread! I have a few questions of my own, actually, before my own baptism this weekend.

1. I understand from the numerous bible study threads from JohnLynch that God doesn't give kids cancer or make them retarded at birth-- those are the results of man's bad choices and decisions, etc. So my question is, why does God sometimes let lightning strike and kill young innocent children? It happens several times a year. Please help me understand.

2. If the universe is only a few thousand years old, then why can we see stars that are millions of light years away? How is that light reaching us if it hasn't even had enough time to travel this far? lol, I'm sure the Bible tells us but I'm just so perplexed.

I'm sure I'll have more. 

Kara --- 15 years ago -

I am concerned. We talked about it for awhile.

I told her exactly what you said. I even told her if she brought her baptismal certificate, they would still tell her that she wasn't baptized.

After our long discussion, she left my house and was going to make a phone call to tell them that she has changed her mind.

Her mother was upset at the church and the teen opened up to me. I told her that her mother had a right to be. I would be upset if my son came home one day telling me that he was not baptised and that special day (in my eyes) did not mean a thing.

I told her to explore different religions, read, take a class and then decide on her own. I also told her to never do anything unless she was 100% sure that it was the right thing to do. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

There are two very different and separate views on this.

Catholics belive in infant baptism and in that a kind of holy condition in the vein of faith or accepting Christ. Many Protestants believe baptism is for those who are old enough to knowingly and willingly accept Christ as their redeemer/Savior. They don't believe an infant can do that. So Protestants have baby dedications or a blessing/prayer ceremony and have baptism after someone accepts Christ. 

Kara --- 15 years ago -

I get that but to say her baptism was not truly a baptism is WRONG.

Why can't they attend infant baptisms? I happily attend Bar/Bat Mitzvahs. I support the people in my life, regardless if I don't believe in what they believe.

Christians should be accepting and not hypocrites. 

Kara --- 15 years ago -

Great thread! I have a few questions of my own, actually, before my own baptism this weekend.

1. I understand from the numerous bible study threads from JohnLynch that God doesn't give kids cancer or make them retarded at birth-- those are the results of man's bad choices and decisions, etc. So my question is, why does God sometimes let lightning strike and kill young innocent children? It happens several times a year. Please help me understand.

2. If the universe is only a few thousand years old, then why can we see stars that are millions of light years away? How is that light reaching us if it hasn't even had enough time to travel this far? lol, I'm sure the Bible tells us but I'm just so perplexed.

I'm sure I'll have more.


Are you being facetious? If so, I don't appreciate it. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I see no reason not to go either. Seems silly but I'm guessing they feel if they go, they are validating the families' beliefs on baptism.

Catholics believe there is a forgiveness/cleansing of sin at baptism. The protestant believe that comes at salvation or acceptance of Christ.

If you asked 10 Christians, you'd probably get 10 different answers, but it is a doctrinal issue. But not going because your beliefs are different seems rude. 

Kara --- 15 years ago -

But not going because your beliefs are different seems rude.

Agree, they are not my friends any longer. Everyone talks of my husband's ex best friend as being brainwashed by his new wife.

It took him 2 weeks to get back to my husband after he had asked his mate to become his twin's Godfather. He told everyone in his office and called my DH two weeks later saying that his wife has a problem with the Catholic church and declined. WHAT???

A problem? The problem is her. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Why don't some Christians recognize infant baptisms?

because water baptism is an outward sign of a person's acceptance of Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior and it is something you choose to do...babies can't make that choice for themselves

infant baptism isn't Scriptural 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

The Baptism thing is a sticky subject even among protestants. Most denominations have an infant christening, but it's considered the parents' promise to raise their child in a Christian home and not so much a baptism. For protestants, the baptism has to be a choice made by someone who is old enough and capable enough to decide for themselves. BUT, there are some denominations (Methodists, for instance) that feel that sprinkling water over someone's head is enough of a baptism while others (Baptist, for example) believe the body has to be completely submerged to count.

In other words, I wouldn't sweat it. It's what's in the heart that counts. =) 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Oh, Kara....I know and have seen this scenario before. And it amazes me how people who are commanded to love one another part ways as believers.

I would say this. Try not to get into the "fray." Be nice, be mature and try at all costs not to be offended. People get uber sensitive with personal religious issues. Obey God, and His commandments and try to set yourself above it. I guess that's called turning your cheek... 

ChrisC2011 --- 15 years ago -

My religion goes along with what.SighFi said. I do go to infant baptisms and believe they are Holy. I don't think anyone can say that her infant baptism is wrong and if she feels uncomfortable then she should not do it. 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

Baptist, for example) believe the body has to be completely submerged to count.

That would totally mess up my hair. 

Carla --- 15 years ago -

John & Snap have already explained it.

BUT, there are some denominations (Methodists, for instance) that feel that sprinkling water over someone's head is enough of a baptism while others (Baptist, for example) believe the body has to be completely submerged to count.

I don't think it is necessarily that Baptists believe that other forms of baptism don't "count," it's just that is the way Jesus was baptized and how the apostles did it. It's not the water that counts, it's the Holy Spirit.

There are only two things that Jesus instructed Christians to do: observance of the Lord's Supper and baptism of believers.

Baptism isn't a condition of salvation, it's a sign of obedience. It's a public profession of a private decision.

Infants are not capable of making a decision for Christ, so that is why Protestants don't believe in infant baptism.

I'm not totally clear on the Catholic theology for infant baptism, but my impression is that they believe it somehow "sanctifies" or "seals" the infant, which is not Biblical at all. 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

Does the church charge any fees for the baptisms? 

james osterberg --- 15 years ago -

The problem here is,as John Lynch and Rick Perry's friends will attest to, Catholics are not Christian, it is a Evil cult of Satin according to the above mentioned. Of course, John could prove me wrong by publicly attesting to Catholicism as being a TRUE Christian faith, but he won't. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

In other words, I wouldn't sweat it. It's what's in the heart that counts. =) 

or doesn't count 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

Infants are not capable of making a decision for Christ, so that is why Protestants don't believe in infant baptism.

Yes they do. Many infant baptisms are held in Protestant churches during Sunday services. 

POTUS --- 15 years ago -

Anyone else laughing about how utterly preposterous the idea of a baptism is?

There are actually intelligent people debating the topic of splashing water on infants in order for them to be blessed by a Magic Man in the sky.

Are you being facetious? If so, I don't appreciate it.

I'm the only person being real in here. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

Are you being facetious? If so, I don't appreciate it.


That's life.




it is a Evil cult of Satin

I thought that was a 70's themed cover band. 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

... and we're off ...
Remember Kara, you started this. 

Carla --- 15 years ago -

Yes they do. Many infant baptisms are held in Protestant churches during Sunday services.

Baptisms or infant dedications? I've been to a lot of different Protestant churches and I've never seen an "infant baptism."

At a dedication, the parents are committing to raise their child according to Christian principles and are asking for the support of the congregation.

Potus,

I've become inured to your babblings, but I have to say that what *I* find amusing and almost touchingly naive that you can say that there isn't a God and actually believe it.

But back to baptisms. It has nothing to do with salvation.

It is standing up and showing where you stand. Making a choice about who's team you're on. That's the point. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Yes they do. Many infant baptisms are held in Protestant churches during Sunday services. 

which churches would those be?...infants are christened in protestant churches...that's not a baptism 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

Infants are not capable of making a decision for Christ, so that is why Protestants don't believe in infant baptism.

So if Lutherans aren't protestant, what are they? 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

infants are christened in protestant churches...that's not a baptism

Maybe you should talk to a lutheran or methodist before making a blanket statement like that. 

POTUS --- 15 years ago -


Potus,

I've become inured to your babblings, but I have to say that what *I* find amusing and almost touchingly naive that you can say that there isn't a God and actually believe it.


In my many babblings I've often stated that I *do* indeed believe a god is possible. But it's just not the selfish, ignorant "God" from the Bible.

Off topic, sorry, but I wanted to stress the point... again.

But back to baptisms. It has nothing to do with salvation.

It is standing up and showing where you stand. Making a choice about who's team you're on. That's the point.


Why do you do need to "show" where you stand? Why prove or explain yourself to anybody? Doesn't the Bible itself recommend praying in secret, being humble about it?

And if it's supposed to be showing GOD what team you're on, why the ritual? Doesn't he already know what's in your heart?


It's just silly. 

ExLady In Blue --- 15 years ago -

It is like others have said; unless you can consciously make that decision on your own, most protestant churches do not recognize child baptism. No, it's not that the church doesn't believe they were baptized as a child; they just don't believe that a child who is still in diapers can make that decision. In the case of a child baptism, the PARENTS are making that decision, not the child.

To be baptized at a later date just signifies that YOU are willing to accept Christ as your savior and it's not anyone else's decision but yours. I have seen churches recognize other church's baptisms IF the person was baptized at an age where the new church believes they were old enough to make the decision for themselves. Likewise, I have seen people baptized as a teen in say a Methodist church (example only), be baptized again at a Baptist church (again, example only), and they do this because THEY want to be baptized again, not because the new church tells them they have to do so.

The ultimate decision should be between the one being baptized and God, and no one else, but of course many churches weigh in on the decision as well. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

But back to baptisms. It has nothing to do with salvation.


Yes it does. Baptism is a public profession of faith in God. Salvation is trusting God. Baptism doesn't save your soul if that's what you mean. But baptism has no meaning without salvation first. 

Carla --- 15 years ago -

So if Lutherans aren't protestant, what are they?

I've always kind of thought of them as "Catholic-Lite," but it's been a long time since my classes on church history.

I don't really remember what differentiates them when the church started splitting.

But one of the things that I think that is really cool is that I've been meeting spirit filled people that are in all different denominations.

Yes it does. Baptism is a public profession of faith in God. Salvation is trusting God. Baptism doesn't save your soul if that's what you mean. But baptism has no meaning without salvation first.

That's what I meant. But it's an act of obedience, your salvation isn't conditional upon it. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

So if Lutherans aren't protestant, what are they? 

they are sorta half protestant and half catholic 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Maybe you should talk to a lutheran or methodist before making a blanket statement like that. 

don't need to...i don't believe that lutherans are really protestant...and i've been to methodist christenings 

Carla --- 15 years ago -

In my many babblings I've often stated that I *do* indeed believe a god is possible. But it's just not the selfish, ignorant "God" from the Bible.

I have a quote for you Potus.

Written by C.S. Lewis. One of the greatest apologists of the 20st century. Former atheist, turned theist, and then became a Christian. He taught at Oxford, one of the members of the "Inklings," and was friends with J.R.R. Tolkien. He attended the Anglican church.

" Either the day must come when joy prevails and all the makers of misery are no longer able to infect it: or else for ever and ever the makers of misery can destroy in others the happiness they reject for themselves. I know it has a grand sound to say ye'll accept no salvation which leaves even one creature in the dark outside. But watch that sophistry or ye'll make a Dog in a Manger the tyrant of the universe."

From the Great Divorce. 

Carla --- 15 years ago -

To answer the rest of your question.

And if it's supposed to be showing GOD what team you're on, why the ritual? Doesn't he already know what's in your heart?

Because it's not a ritual. It is a real decision with long term consequences.

It's for you to look back on and say, "This day I chose to follow Him." It is a physical act so that on the days when you feel apart from Him, you can remember it.

It's saying, "Yes, I mean it."

Christians aren't meant to make their decision in secret and hide their faith. They are supposed to go out and stand for Christ. They are meant to bring His Kingdom on earth.

The baptism is supposed to be the start of the journey.

You think it's silly because you don't believe it's real.

I think *you're* silly because you obstinately ignore how real it is. 

20yrtexan --- 15 years ago -

I am Catholic and I am accepting of every faith. I don't force my views upon others, people can make their own decisions. I respect others views and rituals. I attend other religion's services when I am invited. I am catholic as well. This is also what I was taught. It seems very unfortunate that these truths are not universally accepted. 

ChrisC2011 --- 15 years ago -

Well said Texan! I agree. 

Rubicon --- 15 years ago -

AMEN 20yrtexan! 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

I am Catholic and I am accepting of every faith.

every faith?...there is only one true faith, and that is faith in God...different denominations or churches aren't faiths...

It seems very unfortunate that these truths are not universally accepted.

the problem with that statement is...they aren't all truths...man's "rituals" aren't truths...only God ordained "rituals" are truths

men make void the word of God by their traditions...Mark 7:13 

ChrisC2011 --- 15 years ago -

This thread is a perfect example of the way people behave when they can hide behind a computer. Kara asked a question which many people answered appropriately except for a few who just come on the message board to insult people. 

20yrtexan --- 15 years ago -

I respect others views and rituals. Sorry John, it's not up to me to judge 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground