Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Organic Foods Not Much Better

who's talking here?

planemom 1
txwareagle 4
Farmer Bill 1
ExLady In Blue 6
Perfection 1
Mommyto3kiddos 1
genxer 1
Dr Aborto 1
LiveFreeOrDie 1
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 4
TinktheSprite 1
MissValarie 1
snowprincess 4
SmoochieAndTheBean 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Interesting, not what I would expect in the differences b/t organic and non organic foods. In the case of pesticide exposure I'm especially surprised that the difference wasn't very pronounced...Maybe the body processess pesticides better than I thought. All good...



"WASHINGTON • Patient after patient asked: Is eating organic food, which costs more, really better for me?

Unsure, Stanford University doctors dug through reams of research to find out — and concluded there's little evidence that going organic is much healthier, citing only a few differences involving pesticides and antibiotics.

Eating organic fruits and vegetables can lower exposure to pesticides, including for children — but the amount measured from conventionally grown produce was within safety limits, the researchers reported Monday.

Nor did the organic foods prove more nutritious.

"I was absolutely surprised," said Dr. Dena Bravata, a senior research affiliate at Stanford and longtime internist who began the analysis because so many of her patients asked if they should switch.

"There are many reasons why someone might choose organic foods over conventional foods," from environmental concerns to taste preferences, Bravata stressed. But when it comes to individual health, "there isn't much difference."

Her team did find a notable difference with antibiotic-resistant germs, a public health concern because they are harder to treat if they cause food poisoning.

Specialists long have said that organic or not, the chances of bacterial contamination of food are the same, and the analysis released Monday agreed. But when bacteria did lurk in chicken or pork, germs in the nonorganic meats had a 33 percent higher risk of being resistant to multiple antibiotics, the researchers reported in the journal Annals of Internal Medicine.

That finding comes amid debate over feeding animals antibiotics, not because they're sick but to fatten them up. Farmers say it's necessary to meet demand for cheap meat. Public health advocates say it's one contributor to the nation's growing problem with increasingly hard-to-treat germs. Caroline Smith DeWaal, food safety director at the Center for Science in the Public Interest, counted 24 outbreaks linked to multidrug-resistant germs in food between 2000 and 2010.

The government has begun steps to curb the nonmedical use of antibiotics on the farm.

Organic foods account for 4.2 percent of retail food sales, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. It certifies products as organic if they meet certain requirements including being produced without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers, or routine use of antibiotics or growth hormones.

Consumers can pay much more for some organic products, but demand is rising: Organic foods accounted for $31.4 billion in sales last year, according to a recent federal report. That's up from $3.6 billion in 1997.

The Stanford team combed through thousands of studies to analyze the 237 that most rigorously compared organic and conventional foods. Bravata was dismayed that just 17 compared how people fared eating either diet while the rest investigated properties of the foods themselves.

Organic produce had a 30 percent lower risk of containing detectable pesticide levels. In two studies of children, urine testing showed lower pesticide levels in those on organic diets. But Bravata cautioned that both groups harbored very small amounts — and said one study suggested that insecticide use in their homes may be more to blame than their food.

Still, some studies have suggested that even small pesticide exposures might be risky for some children, and the Organic Trade Association said the Stanford work confirmed that organics could help consumers lower their exposure.

DeWaal noted that difference, but added that the issue was more complicated. Some fruits and vegetables can harbor more pesticide residue than others — she listed peaches from Chile as topping a recent testing list. Overall levels have dropped in North American produce over the last decade as farms implemented new standards addressing child concerns, she said.

"Parents with young children should consider where their produce is coming from," DeWaal said, calling types grown in the U.S. or Canada "a safer bet" for lower pesticide levels.

As for antibiotics, some farms that aren't certified organic have begun selling antibiotic-free meat or hormone-free milk, to address specific consumer demands, noted Bravata. Her own preference is to buy from local farmers in hopes of getting the ripest produce with the least handling.

That kind of mixed approach was evident in a market in the nation's capital Thursday, where Liz Pardue of Washington said she buys organic "partially for environmental reasons." Pardue said she doesn't go out of her way to shop organic, but if she does, it's to buy mostly things that are hard to wash such as berries and lettuce.

Michelle Dent of Oxon Hill, Md., said she bought most of her groceries from regular chain stores but got her fruit from organic markets: "It's fresh; you can really taste it."

Anna Hamadyk of Washington said she bought only organic milk because she had a young son.

"I would love to buy everything organic, but it's just too much money," said Hamadyk, who also shops at local farmers markets." 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

Most people I know buy organic because of pesticides not nutrition. It wasn't an issue for me until I bought some apples that tasted like bug spray. Washing them didn't help the taste. In some produce there is a huge difference in taste between organic and non-organic. Some organic produce just tastes fresher. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Most people I know buy organic because of pesticides not nutrition


So true. It's why I prefer it, but I haven't noticed much difference in taste in some items. I eat a lot of apples, or at least I used to, and the price difference in apples vs. taste had me going back to regular..

What's funny, is they have said pesticides penetrate the skin as well, as in potatoes and apples, and yet according to this study, apparantly the penetration isn't what they thought or I suspect there would have been more residue in the urine tests? 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

This does not make any allowance for organic foods tainted by GMO crops. Also, in the case of milk and meat, it is a matter of whether or not the animal is fed its "natural" diet, and how much. In the instance of chickens, a company can sell their chickens as "free range", but there might only be one exit for hundreds of chickens and the "free range" might only be the size of a postage stamp. Furthermore, their diet might still be corn (not their natural diet). In the case of milk, just because the cows are not being fed steroids, does not mean they are not being over milked, or are being grass fed, vs. grain fed. Grain is NOT their natural diet. 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

Who funded the study? That explains it all!

Wake up people! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

I took this another way.

Even organic is laced with chemicals because no place is truly chemical free. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

snowprincess --- 11 min ago - quote - hide comments

Who funded the study? That explains it all!

Wake up people!


Exactly!

Stanford University doctors dug through reams of research to find out — and concluded there's little evidence that going organic is much healthier, citing only a few differences involving pesticides and antibiotics.

And these would be the same doctors who want to shove a pill down your throat, instead of finding the underlying issue as to why you're sick or what you can do to correct the problem through lifestyle changes. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Stanford University doctors dug through reams of research


Ok, what did I miss? How/what is the slant Stanford has?? 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Stanford University is a very well respected, top tier school. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

Organic produce had a 30 percent lower risk of containing detectable pesticide levels.

That is why I buy organic.

As for taste, it varies. I buy organic apples but I think regular apples taste better. Organic Green Beans, Refried Beans, Milk and Eggs taste better than their regular counterparts. 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

Stanford University is a very well respected, top tier school

Who do you think funds the research labs in top tier schools? Do some research on monsanto. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

Stanford University doctors dug through reams of research

Hence, it was not a specific study, but a compilation of many studies; meaning there was no control group.

As an example, you cannot compare what Coke finds out in a study, vs. what Pepsi and Dr. Pepper finds out in a study, because there are going to be various differences of the control group used in each study. To compile/form an absolute, you have to be able to provide documentation as to the control group of that study.

Try to come up with a story using the stories of Goldilocks, Alice in Wonderland, Winnie the Pooh, Little Red Riding Hood, and any of the Dr. Seuss books and then get back to me with your complete evaluation on a typical American's childhood. 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

Ok, what did I miss? How/what is the slant Stanford has??

They are going to favor the corporations that fund their research so they still have jobs. 

genxer --- 14 years ago -

As the first lady wants to preach about obesity it is the modified foods we eat that is more the cause. Her husband and his administration has helped companies like monsanto continue to poison the food supply.

Walking back to organic, without hormones, without nasty chemical derivatives and without pesticides does improve the quality of life and does help you to lose weight.

There is some underlying information in this article even though the slant of the article was say there wasn't enough nutritional differences. This is nothing about nutrition and all to do with toxicity.

Read on Type II diabetes. The amount of modified corn in our diets that you aren't even aware of would scare the heck out of any of you if you really took the time to learn about it. 

txwareagle --- 14 years ago -

Click me

The researchers did not use any outside financing for their research. “I really wanted us to have no perception of bias,” Dr. Bravata said.

To incriminate an institution like Stanford as not being independent, shows a lack of respect for the scientific process at institutions of higher learning.

I would expect further research to counter these findings. This will in-turn move us closer to "fact" vs "opinion". Isnt that what we all want? 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

And, txwareagle, did you read what genxer said, or what I said? It is a COMPILATION of several research studies. How can you come to a valuable conclusion? What is the control group used? 

SmoochieAndTheBean --- 14 years ago -

The FDA doesn't regulate labeling very well, so if you are concerned, you basically have to check out the ingredients and go further by researching the companies directly.

I buy organically as much as possible if and when it is available. I always, ALWAYS buy milk and meat organic, no exceptions. There are far too many steroids, hormones, and antibiotics our regular farm animals. But, one brand of "organic" milk can be very different than another brand's "organic" milk. Some milk brands only use pure milk from all-natural grass fed, free roaming cows, other brands just avoid growth hormone injections, and yet sell them both as "organic" and there is no way to know the difference other than researching the individual companies.

Most produce with a thick peel, like bananas, will not absorb the pesticides all the way through to the actual fruit, but then you may have GMO fruit and that is another concern.

Organic or not, you should always wash produce thoroughly because just think of how many people handle the fruit and veggies you are about to stick in your mouth. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

I think the biggest risk of pesticides is the unintended consequences to the beneficial bug population such as bees.

Our bodies are more than capable of filtering out the trace amounts of chemicals in the pesticides. But the bugs may not be so lucky. That is the study that needs to be done when considering the affects of a pesticide. 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

Our bodies are more than capable of filtering out the trace amounts of chemicals in the pesticides.

Even if you (foolishly) believe that it is safe to consume these chemicals at every meal why are you not concerned for the safety of the farm workers? Do you not care that they are much more likely to end up with cancer (as are their children when they are exposed to their clothing)? Or do you believe migrant farm workers are just "throw away people" who deserve to die? 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

Have any of you ever seen the chemical suits that are needed by those that apply chemicals to our produce? It's crazy! It's like they're going into the middle of a nuclear reactor or something. That right there ought to tell you everything you need to know! 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 14 years ago -

I still will be driving to whole foods once a week. 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

Have any of you ever seen the chemical suits that are needed by those that apply chemicals to our produce? It's crazy! It's like they're going into the middle of a nuclear reactor or something. That right there ought to tell you everything you need to know!
That is simply for the safety of the workers. The amount of chemical exposure the workers are subject to is much, much, MUCH higher than we are exposed to. Same goes for extermination. You don't have to wear a mask around your home after being treated for bugs, but for safety, the exterminator often wears a mask. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Can anyone provide a link showing which corporations did fund the Stanford study?

I'd be interested to see if it was a biased, bought study, or legitimately done without bias. 

txwareagle --- 14 years ago -

DP: my link from the NYT above has a quote from the lead Doctor claiming no outside funding was used. 

txwareagle --- 14 years ago -

In the study — known as a meta-analysis, in which previous findings are aggregated but no new laboratory work is conducted — researchers combined data from 237 studies, examining a wide variety of fruits, vegetables and meats. For four years, they performed statistical analyses looking for signs of health benefits from adding organic foods to the diet.


This is an absolute acceptable way to combine numerous studies, to find trends, based on statistics.

Click me

From a brief reading of wiki, it seems this is a valid approach so long as the sample size is large. 

txwareagle --- 14 years ago -

but of course, if you think the research is biased, what could they do to proove themselves wrong if you know the answer before the study?

:) 

MissValarie --- 14 years ago -

When one tastes chemicals in the food, be they fresh or processed, its time for an organic and more natural alternative. Had a sammich yesterday that tasted like a chemical crap storm in my mouth and it was thrown away.

Even if you (foolishly) believe that it is safe to consume these chemicals at every meal why are you not concerned for the safety of the farm workers? Do you not care that they are much more likely to end up with cancer (as are their children when they are exposed to their clothing)? Or do you believe migrant farm workers are just "throw away people" who deserve to die?

Thank you for the new perspective, that is one that hasn't occurred to me. Duly noted. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

DP: my link from the NYT above has a quote from the lead Doctor claiming no outside funding was used.


Thanks TXW. One does have to watch out for these studies and who funds or profits from them in any way.



why are you not concerned for the safety of the farm workers? Do you not care that they are much more likely to end up with cancer (as are their children when they are exposed to their clothing)? Or do you believe migrant farm workers are just "throw away people" who deserve to die?


Woah, that's a bit off topic, not that I care, but no one was dissing on farm workers and that's a whole different topic. 

Farmer Bill --- 14 years ago -

I am a believer in this....when it comes to veggies....do not believe you are getting something better this day and timeby falling for the totally organic thing. I am in the business ...and I am not somebody that would lie to you.
I know growers,I know sellers, all over the country.There is a lot of decieving going on.
Organic, is a wonderful idea but an even better selling point for a growing number of folks.
I m telling you....there is no such thing as a vegetable or fruit grown in this country that has not been touched by something chemical in some way.
Try growing yourself a small garden...see what happens if you just water it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground