Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Obama wants to kill 529 college savings plans -- the "rich" benefit too much from them

who's talking here?

randyjet 2
ladybeachbum 1
d:-] 1
SoupIsGoodFood 10
Red Heifer 1
FANCY PANTS 1
voice of reason 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
Work in Progress 5
Dorothy Parker 5
Miss Understanding 1
sheddy 1
UncleT 1
Emperor of Kingwood 19
Identity Crisis 1
a889324uu 1
Not KU 2
Prolix Raconteur 3
mutton 1
jacobson 5
AMDG 27
FNHO 3
satsuma 2
them 5
aragon 1
alldayredux 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

them --- 11 years ago -

During the most recent State of the Union address, the President?s proposal includes removing one of the current key tax advantages for 529 college savings plans.

Didn't know that I was rich.

The anti-jobs president is now the anti-education president? WTF? 

sheddy --- 11 years ago -

He's trying really hard to give you the first two years free. Gosh, kick a man when he's down! lol 

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

The idea behind the tax break was to help the middle class save for college. Apparently, these accounts are used disproportionately by people with higher incomes, so there's less reason to offer the tax break, just like the phaseout of deductions at higher incomes. 

FANCY PANTS --- 11 years ago -

During the most recent State of the Union address, the President?s proposal includes removing one of the current key tax advantages for 529 college savings plans.

Didn't know that I was rich.

The anti-jobs president is now the anti-education president? WTF??


It's called redistribution. How could you think you should be able to save for your kids education when others can't? Socialists think it's not fair. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

The anti-jobs president is now the anti-education president? WTF??

It's called redistribution. How could you think you should be able to save for your kids education when others can't? Socialists think it's not fair.


People making min wage cant save. But here is a quote from the SOTU:
0

Snark is my friend: 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Sorry about the size. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

I don't think that is a shocker to anyone that those who pay more in taxes will receive more benefit in a tax break. That's what you guys are whining about as being a disproportionate benefit to the rich? Do you even hear yourselves?

And Mark, I truly believe that your heart is in the right place. I see your passion for people, and your desire to help others. I admire that about you, a lot. And I'm not trying to be at all patronizing, if it comes across that way, please forgive me. I just recognize that you are genuine and kind, so I have more respect for you than I do for some others.

But I don't think that it is reasonable to expect higher quality education when the students do not invest in their own education. The incentives are not sufficient to do well in that environment.

What will happen, is that the standards will be lowered and an AA will cease to mean anything at all. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

What I've been saying all along- his idea of rich became the income of the upper middle- now the middle and the upper class has the entire burden. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

And the only people to be fit from his insurance, either can't afford the deduction, or can't find A doctor will take it- thanks for nothing, Obama- 

Prolix Raconteur --- 11 years ago -

#FreeCommunityCollege

Hashtag activism..pffft...how noble. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

You can't just "lower the cost" of college. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Anyway you slice it. Mark is looking for a free ride. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

But I don't think that it is reasonable to expect higher quality education when the students do not invest in their own education. The incentives are not sufficient to do well in that environment.

I think that is a generalization painted with a very very wide brush.

Expectations of failure are poor reasons not to try.

I know, there are currently lots of ways for deserving and motivated students to fund their college education. (thank you Uncle Sam for my BS, and my former employer for my MBA) I just don't think that is the target audience of this program.

There is little doubt that that best way to move people from dependence and poverty to self reliance is by education. To me these dollars seem to be more investment than spending, and with a possible rate of return well over government's cost of capital.

It looks like good business to me to borrow at 2 percent with kind of possible returns this investment can bring.

Not even talking about the ancillary benefits of maybe more jobs for teaches, admin, and staff. Maybe even some construction jobs if we need to build some more schools. Heck - this could create more jobs than Keystone without the environmental risk.

In general, with one big caveat (that it is implemented and executed well) additional investment in education is our best bet in breaking the cycles of institutional poverty and the related entitlements that so many on here whine about.

Complaining about poverty on the one side, and accepting poverty from the other side, is a losing strategy. At some point somebody has to do something - and IMO this does not seem like a bad something to do. 

aragon --- 11 years ago -

The 529 is a great program. Really hope they don't get rid of that. I doubt they will, wouldn't congress have to go along with that??? 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

It will dumb down the colleges as much as we have dumbed down high school. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Agreed, Fisher. I started 529's years ago for my kids. One of the better investments I've ever made. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

It will dumb down the colleges as much as we have dumbed down high school.

Exactly. The value of free is nothing to those receiving it. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

It will dumb down the colleges as much as we have dumbed down high school.

I think it may focus some Community colleges to focus more on pure job training, than more classical educations. IMO that is not a bad thing.

My guess is it won't have too much effect on the quality of education at well accredited 4 year universities. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

by the way - agree on the 529's - weren't a big thing when I was in the college paying/saving market. But I am in favor of anything that improves the opportunities for education. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

It will if they have to accept the AAs. The students will not be adequately prepared for the rigor of a four year. If they fail too many, they lose money. They won't do that. So they will lower the standards to the lowest common denominator. We've already seen this in public schools. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

The value of free is nothing to those receiving it.


I think level one values almost anything, including education, has more to due with their character than their wallet. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

It will if they have to accept the AAs. The students will not be adequately prepared for the rigor of a four year. If they fail too many, they lose money. They won't do that. So they will lower the standards to the lowest common denominator. We've already seen this in public schools.

Again, that is a generalization, and by no means an absolute. There are thousands of examples of well run public schools that are doing amazing work in educating disadvantaged students.

Just hate expectations of failure to be reasons to prevent action. 

voice of reason --- 11 years ago -

During the most recent State of the Union address, the President?s proposal includes removing one of the current key tax advantages for 529 college savings plans.Didn't know that I was rich. The anti-jobs president is now the anti-education president? WTF?



twist twist

spin spin

dizzy yet? 

FNHO --- 11 years ago -

Such garbage from the underemployed right because they are not degreed is likely. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 11 years ago -

Such garbage from the underemployed right because they are not degreed is likely.

With the syntax used in that sentence, I think we can assume who is not degreed. 

FNHO --- 11 years ago -

That's your retort Racoon?

So weak 

Prolix Raconteur --- 11 years ago -

What retort? I'm just pointing out the obvious hypocrisy in your post. 

voice of reason --- 11 years ago -

Such garbage from the underemployed right because they are not degreed is likely.



i was just thinking the same thing! bahahahahahahahaaa

fret not pubies as soon you can have 2 years of free community college. bahahahahahahaaaa 'o' is all for and all about educating you dullards 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

I can absolutely justify not taking "action"
at the expense of one when it will most likely lead to waste and failure of the other.

People must have proper incentives for behavior. Some people consider their character enough incentive, but that is not human nature. The community colleges will be flooded by those without proper incentives to meet the requirements, because they have no skin in the game, and no penalty if they fail.

They won't care if it is your money being wasted. And neither will the college, or the government. It will be another failed welfare experiment that leaves everyone worse off than when it was first dreamed up by an ideologue. 

FNHO --- 11 years ago -

God you're weak Racoon. 

satsuma --- 11 years ago -

It will dumb down the colleges as much as we have dumbed down high school.?

It's extended highschool... kind of like the first two years of most public university curriculum now: spend two years learning all the stuff you failed to learn in Highschool. 

satsuma --- 11 years ago -

The 529 is awesome... now if only we ALL could have HSA's. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

God you're weak Racoon.

Looks like he got to you. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

People must have proper incentives for behavior. Some people consider their character enough incentive, but that is not human nature. The community colleges will be flooded by those without proper incentives to meet the requirements, because they have no skin in the game, and no penalty if they fail.

I haven't heard anything in the proposal that said the CC's were not going to grade, and that failing, unmotivated students were required to be kept on.

The students you describe above should just be failed and flunk out. From your posts, you make it seem this is not an option. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

People must have proper incentives for behavior.

How about a decent paying job if they graduate ?

Some people consider their character enough incentive, but that is not human nature.


Disagree - don't let the noise of the media get to you. Most people out there, rich and poor are good solid people with a good moral compass. We all focus too much on the small minority of bad apples. In general and in the vast majority people are good.

The community colleges will be flooded by those without proper incentives to meet the requirements

Well I hope they are flooded. And again, a well paying job if they graduate seems a proper incentive. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

It will become as much of an option as it is in high school. As in "not at all." Many or even most public schools no longer allow teachers to fail a student who does not meet the standards. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

you seem to have some predisposed belief that education is wasted on the poor. They are doomed to fail, they won't appreciate it, they are incapable of succeeding. My goodness that is cynical. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

The students you describe above should just be failed and flunk out.

At a monetary waste of taxpayers money.

Your positions on this subject exemplify your liberal/socialist beliefs.


It has been proven over and over again that most people don't appreciate what they receive for free. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Your positions on this subject exemplify your liberal/socialist beliefs.

I was unaware that believing in education as the key to decreasing generational poverty was liberal or socialist. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

I was unaware that is how it works. Didn't know we have to tag every idea and principal as either liberal or conservative, democrat or republican, us or them. Force them all into some box, with the biggest criteria being who proposed it.

Here all along I just kept trying to decide if I thought they were good or bad, and debate and discuss on the issues and the merits. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground