Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Auto insurance accident dispute! What would you do? (Small update)

who's talking here?

ToidBoid 1
Jen 10
napoleon 1
random 1
d:-] 1
SleightOfHand 1
Dotti 1
RedMulch 2
Gigix4 1
*LOL* 2
Davi 1
SoccerMomX3 1
sheddy 1
snowprincess 1
FabFive 2
kwgraniteguy 1
witchywoman 2
Not KU 2
mutton 2
aragon 1
ScarletWitch 1
Barnstormer 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Jen --- 11 years ago -

January 9th, my husband and I were in his truck in downtown Houston. We were on a one way street and approaching the light to take a left on to a one way street. A lady in the car to our right, was on her phone and rammed right in to us. It was AS IF, she realized that is where she was supposed to turn, but realized it almost to late. (I assume-because she was cursing foul words on her cell, as soon as she jumped out of the car and clearly she wasn't speaking to 911 that way!)

The police officer gives her the ticket of unsafe lane change and the police report states where car is located and still partially in her lane. She is clearly at fault and she is only one that got a ticket.

So her insurance is only willing to pay 70% of the claim, stating my husband "should have slowed down to let her in". We are in rush hour traffic and if he never saw her, how could he slow down in time? Are they asking us to cause another accident? We have full coverage on his truck but he has a $1,000.00 deductible. If we let our insurance go after them for the other 30%, we have to pay the $1K and HOPE we get it back. We are almost better off taking the 70%,because we don't think our 30% will be $1K, will be more $450-$500.00. But if we pay our deductible, our insurance could even file a legal judgement against her!

Our insurance even says that they do not understand why the other insurance won't pay 100%!

I have filed a complaint with the Texas Dept of Insurance, but they are behind from the holidays still. I also filed a complaint with the Illinois Dept of Ins, where the other insurance company is based out of. Friday they told me, the 70% offer still stands. I had already told them that I filed complaints with the insurance boards, but it does not matter to them.

We also need a rental car, when his truck gets fixed, which they only offer 70% of, as well.

This is causing so much stress to us. We feel we should not pay any cash out of our pocket and that they should pay 100%!

I am coming here for your thoughts. Should we give up and take the 70% offer? Can you think of anyone else I can complain to?

Any advice is appreciated! 

napoleon --- 11 years ago -

Doesn't seem fair. Dealing with insurance companies is such a hassle. I'd take the 70%. 

ScarletWitch --- 11 years ago -

I'd take the 70%.?

NO, get a lawyer. 

*LOL* --- 11 years ago -

I would fight it with your insurance company. That really sound crummy. I wonder if you should consult with an attorney? 

Jen --- 11 years ago -

I spoke to friends that are Lawyers and they say it is really not worth taking legal action against, since its a small amount of money. Boo hoo! Its not a small amount in my pocketbook! 

FabFive --- 11 years ago -

Who is your insurance company and who is theirs? I would never take 70%. 

*LOL* --- 11 years ago -

Your insurance isn't going to want to pay out if they don't have to. I would definitely fight it.

From what you described, it sounds just like an accident my sister was in, it was downtown and a one way street too.

The guy stopped at the stop sign before entering the intersection but didn't see her car and thought it was clear because a bus blocked the view, hit my sister and in turn, she hit another car.

My sister was not found at fault even though I guess technically she could have avoided him, if she knew he was coming (Isn't that true of most accidents?) but the guy got the ticket and paid 100% of the rental car and the damages. 

Jen --- 11 years ago -

Mine is thru Safeco and the ladies is called AAINS. I imagine she only had liability, by the looks of the car she drove, which was a jalopy! I might add that the HPD officer also had to tell her to shut and go back to her car! She kept mouthing off to us, outside of her car, while we stayed in the truck. She was yelling that we were rednecks! Because were in a truck? None of that matters, by the way... 

Jen --- 11 years ago -

"My sister was not found at fault even though I guess technically she could have avoided him, if she knew he was coming (Isn't that true of most accidents?) but the guy got the ticket and paid 100% of the rental car and the damages. "
Exactly! How could he stop when he never saw her? I saw her and started yelling! (She was on my side). He is driving looking ahead, as he should be. Especially in evening rush hour traffic because everyone drives crazy downtown! 

Gigix4 --- 11 years ago -

If I were you, I'd tell my insurance company to handle it and you want 100% for repairs and the rental. You dearly pay your premiums so let them handle it and it should not cost you a thing. 

Jen --- 11 years ago -

GIGI- we have to pay our insurance company the $1,000.00 deductible that we have on the truck, for them to go after the 30%. Then we "hope" to get it back, is what we understand on how it works. It just does not seem we should have to pay anything, when he is clearly not at fault. But we may have to :( 

Jen --- 11 years ago -

I will look in to small claims court, as well, if they don't agree to 100%.

Does have anyone have any other suggestions how to take this higher? 

FabFive --- 11 years ago -

There's an appeal process with every insurance company. They are doing this to bully you and so far it's working because you're going to be out your deductible and the other people are telling you it's not worth it to hire an attorney. Imagine cutting costs 30% on each wreck. Big savings to them. 

Barnstormer --- 11 years ago -

The first thing an adjuster asks is how you are doing. You never say your'e ok, because you might have spine problems that show up days later. If you sue them, the adjuster will say you said you felt ok. Probably on a recorded line too. I wonder if once they determine from you there's no injury, that they can call the shots. At some point an adjuster determined you are 30% at fault, maybe due to something you said. Who's the big firm that handles this? Like 1-800- the dogs? or something like that. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

What if..
Everyone dropped their insurance?

My truck was hit and the other driver's insurance declared they weren't going to pay because of the age of my truck. The damage was cosmetic. 

snowprincess --- 11 years ago -

Sue the other driver. You can bet once they get the paperwork they will be on the phone with the insurance company. 

Davi --- 11 years ago -

1- Inform the insurance company that there was no signal of intent for their client to change lanes, so there was no opportunity for you to allow their client to change lanes.

2- Under Texas law, there is no duty for a driver to anticipate another driver making an illegal left turn.

3- Call them back and say you are having neck and back pain, you are going to see a doctor, so please keep the claim open... 

sheddy --- 11 years ago -

Your insurance should deal with this. You should not even have to deal with the other company or driver. If she got the ticket she was at fault. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

 

RedMulch --- 11 years ago -

"should have slowed down to let her in"????? is their no such thing as "right of way" anymore? I know that "do not block the intersection" is a dying thought.

Why the (stuff I can't say) does HOUSTON not get REAL mass transit like Atlanta?????????? Only back up there is when it snows. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

FIGHT! 

RedMulch --- 11 years ago -

RedMulch for mayor. I'll fix it, dammit 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

Yay!!! 

d:-] --- 11 years ago -

Well her insurance company is going to say anything to get out of paying, that's what they do. Don't agree with their opinion and don't give in. Sue her for the deductible. 

kwgraniteguy --- 11 years ago -

I feel your pain. I am fighting with State Farm, wife was broadsided in a parking lot on Christmas eve and we still don't have our Jeep back. Trans failed right after and they are playing the coincidence card. The advice here has given me some hope, thanks all. 

witchywoman --- 11 years ago -

I would fight it with your insurance company.


Your insurance will never bother to fight it because it's too expensive to do that.

This whole thing boils my blood. The whole insurance industry sucks and needs major regulation. We pay high premiums and are so at their mercy.

It's just not fair.

Be sure to go after the other insurance company for devaluation of your vehicle or whatever it's called because you will now have an accident on your carfax. They won't pay much but they should give you something.

AAINS??? Huh? When it comes to a payout, your insurance company matters not just the cheap rates you pay.


GIGI- we have to pay our insurance company the $1,000.00 deductible that we have on the truck, for them to go after the 30%.

This doesn't make sense. You already stated your 30% isn't even $1,000. You never write your insurance company a check when you have a claim. Never. You'd be paying the 30% to the body shop too, not your company. I think you're misunderstanding something. Does your company realize your 30% won't even be $1,000? It doesn't sound like it. 

witchywoman --- 11 years ago -

KPRC just did a spot on people who force you into an accident then claim injuries. It's usually where you rear end someone. Maybe check their website for those interested. 

SleightOfHand --- 11 years ago -

"KPRC just did a spot on people who force you into an accident then claim injuries. It's usually where you rear end someone. Maybe check their website for those interested. "

Insurance companies keep a detailed list of individuals who make claims to prevent reoccurring fraud 

SoccerMomX3 --- 11 years ago -

It's not expensive for the carriers to resolve. Most reputable insurance carriers are members of Arbitration Forums which handles disputes when the two sides disagree as to liability. Members subscribe so there is no fee to file arbitration and facts are evaluated by a three person panel. Safeco is a member but I'm not sure about the other one. You can search with their full name at this link.

https://www.arbfile.org/webapp/execute/memberDirectory?actionCommand=init&menu=memberdirectory

Good luck! 

random --- 11 years ago -

sorry you are having this problem. 

Jen --- 11 years ago -

I will check in to this Arbritation site!

Texas Dept of Ins called today and said that yesterday they sent this other ins company a notice of complaint and that they had 15 days to respond. He said to ask them in the mean time, for evidence in writing, as how they came to the 70% offer. What proof do they have that my husband would have had time to "slow down, to let her in"?

I had mentioned that the $1K deductible, would probably more than we would spend out of pocket, but I will double check that.

Its all so frustrating! :( 

aragon --- 11 years ago -

A lawyer may still be the way to go.

Even though the damage may be limited, you are having to waste a lot of time dealing with this.

If these jokers force you to sue them, I'm sure that a good lawyer can determine additional expenses for them to pay.

Couldn't hurt to get a free consult. 

Jen --- 11 years ago -

A little update but still not settled...yesterday the Texas Dept of insurance told me that this other Insurance company hadn't responded to my complaint within the 15 days they were given. This lady at TDI even suggested that I also file a complaint with Govenor Greg Abbotts office and gave me the number. So I faced everything over to Govenor Abbotts office and will notify the other insurance company today, what my latest step was. I've not caved in yet! 

ToidBoid --- 11 years ago -

Remember these words - "good faith" - insurance companies go insane when you start throwing those words around. Her ins. co. is not negotiating with you in "good faith". . . 

Jen --- 11 years ago -

Thank you Toldbold! I will
Add that in! 

Dotti --- 11 years ago -

Whoever said something about Carfax is 100% correct. My brand new car still had the temp tag on it and an idiot on 1314 ran into the back of me at a traffic light. He was going about 40 and never slowed down or anything. He did over $5K in damage.

He was driving his girlfriends car and had Fred Loya insurance. I called my insurance and they weren't much help. I didn't know the thing about the Carfax until I went to trade in my car and they were taking $3k off because of the accident on my Carfax. They said the next person doesn't care they don't want to pay as much for a car that was in an accident. I ended up keeping the car. Good luck with the insurance. They are blood suckers. 

Jen --- 11 years ago -

Yes, not to mention the value depreciates! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground