Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What's next

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 16
FANCY PANTS 1
Warren Peace 2
steinhoister2016 1
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 8
Emperor of Kingwood 2
mutton 3
AMDG 13
FNHO 1
CartmanUK34 1
fuzz81 29
Behold the pale horse 6
whatelse 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

whatelse --- 10 years ago -

 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

Poster OB. Odd. I wonder why someone would do this. I guess only they know. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

God can be funny. Lol. So can Harry Potter 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

I think you missed the point Fuzzy. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

No. I got the point. The message assumes that God is real, which of course is just a human construct and is not real. Like Harry Potter. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

So Fizzy you have proof there's no God?? You sound very sure of yourself so let's see it! 

Behold the pale horse --- 10 years ago -

I have proof there is a God. The proof is that you are here. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

So Fizzy you have proof there's no God?? You sound very sure of yourself so let's see it!

You don't prove a negative. Burden of proof is on the believer (Google burden of proof).

It's like asking you to prove to me that unicorns don't exist. Or prove to me that Harry Potter doesn't exist. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

Fizzy, lol at that. :)

Why is God a negative, let's start there! 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Asserting that something doesn't exist is a negative. If I make an assertion that "unicorns don't exist", that is a negative. You wouldn't ask someone to prove that a unicorn doesn't exist.

If someone asserts "unicorns do exist", that is a positive assertion. Surely you would ask for someone to prove that a unicorn exists.

You don't prove a negative (except in some mathematical contexts). 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

Oh come on, Christ existed. History acknowledged that. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Fuzzy needs peer reviewed material. Or it didn't happen. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

That doesn't prove anything. So did Mohammed, do you believe the Quran?

There are plenty of things the bible is wrong about. Like the exodus. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Fuzz - just for old times sake -

There are 3 kinds of true things,

1. Facts - thinks that can be proved by observation to be true, or correct.

2. Reason - things you believe to be true by use of reason.

3. Faith - things you believe to be true purely by faith.


I can not prove by fact that God is. But there are many things you believe to be true that you can not prove by fact.

I can prove by reason, that it is a reasonable belief to believe in an un-created creator.

I can not prove by reason, the Christian God of the bible exists, that takes faith.

You don't prove a negative.

We, or at least I am not discussing God as fact, We are both IMO discussing what we believe to be true. And the burden for the reasonableness of that belief lies with each of us. It is just as valid to ask you to support your belief that God does exist, as it is mine that he does.

It is not proving a negative, your belief exists, now do you have a reasonable basis for it. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

So, you'll agree Mohammed existed but you question whether or not Christ did? Why?
You have a fear that God is real sounds like to me. Interesting..

I didn't say the bible was perfect, I said prove that God/Christ didn't exist.

The only thing in question, fairly, is the diety of Christ. And he rose from the dead and appeared to hundreds of people. So, don't feel bad. Even some of those people chose to deny him even.
See, people don't want to answer to authority so I get it. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

I will even help you fuzz - in a philosophic discussion that has been going on for hundreds of years, there are really 2 major well accepted arguments against the existence of God.

The first is that all things attributed to God, can be explained by nature, without divine intervention. The big loophole in it is they simply state all the stuff we cant explain by nature (science) yet, we will be at some time.

The problem with this argument is it just substitutes faith in science for faith in God. It just elevates science to religion.

The second in the problem of evil. This is by far the best argument against the existence of God. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

But there are many things you believe to be true that you can not prove by fact.

Such as? 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

So, you'll agree Mohammed existed but you question whether or not Christ did? Why?
You have a fear that God is real sounds like to me. Interesting..


Jesus could have existed as a man. That doesn't make him special, other than a book told you so. Also, people can't agree if he was "god", or the son of "god". Consensus by scholars is that he was the son.

Why would I be afraid of something I don't believe in? Lol. Are you afraid of unicorns? 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Sounds more like you're afraid that it's all a made up story. Interesting... 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

You believe that nature operates by certain rules - that nature is not random - that it can be understood by logic. - This is an un-provable assumption at the core of all science.

You believe the scientific method is the best method to find factual truths, yet you can not use the scientific method to prove that.

You believe in love, in justice, in right and wrong. They are not facts.

I could go on and on - 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

No, I don't "believe" in those things. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Biology and science tell us about the rules of nature that we understand. We can test, and repeat them. The rest are just things we don't know or don't understand. We do not "believe" anything about nature. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

No, I don't "believe" in those things.

Ok - cool - nevermind then 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

We do not "believe" anything about nature.

So you don't believe in persons being "transgendered"? 

Behold the pale horse --- 10 years ago -

Rules of nature

Who or what put those rules of nature in play other than God? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

http://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/basic_assumptions

basic assumptions

Take a quick look fuzz 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Who or what put those rules of nature in play other than God??

That's the weakest argument possible, since you can't answer "who put God into play?" 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

AMDG, what does that have to do with belief? In the following, you will note the language like "elusive". In other words, we acknowledge we don't know exactly what it is (actually area of research at super collider), we don't claim a belief to explain it.

There are natural causes for things that happen in the world around us. For example, if a ball falls to the ground, science assumes that there must be a natural explanation for why the ball moves downward once released. Right now, scientists can describe gravity in great detail, but exactly what gravity is remains elusive. Still, science assumes that there is an explanation for gravity that relies on natural causes, just as there is for everything in nature. 

Behold the pale horse --- 10 years ago -

That's the weakest argument possible

Because you can't answer it. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

LOL. The Big Bang is as far back as we know. What was there before it? Who knows.

Now, who created God? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

AMDG, what does that have to do with belief? In the following, you will note the language like "elusive". In other words, we acknowledge we don't know exactly what it is (actually area of research at super collider), we don't claim a belief to explain it.

There are natural causes for things that happen in the world around us. For example, if a ball falls to the ground, science assumes that there must be a natural explanation for why the ball moves downward once released. Right now, scientists can describe gravity in great detail, but exactly what gravity is remains elusive. Still, science assumes that there is an explanation for gravity that relies on natural causes, just as there is for everything in nature.


Never mind fuzz - I don't have the time or energy for this today.

I gave you the basic un-proven assumptions of science, and then I showed you that I didn't make that up.

If it is beyond your level of abstract thought to understand the meaning of that, which by your post you obviously don't, I can't help you. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

For all we know we're just a microscopic piece of matter in a sub space of a larger world, where we perceive time at a much slower rate and a giant ant like creature is about to squash us with his toe. Everything is relative. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -





Get your own valid XHTML YouTube embed code 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -


If it is beyond your level of abstract thought to understand the meaning of that, which by your post you obviously don't, I can't help you.?


Honestly, read that again. I could say the same thing back to you. If you want to have a discussion, you can't just default to assuming you have all the answers, and dismiss a response because it's not in line with what you want to hear.

"I can't help you".

Trust me AMDG, I don't need help ;) I will never change to a believer. Assumptions are not beliefs. 

Behold the pale horse --- 10 years ago -

God has always been, God in some form, transcends any known measure of time created by man. God has no physical presence, no home, no residence. God is some form of entity beyond the complete comprehension of man. 

Behold the pale horse --- 10 years ago -

I will never change to a believer.

At some point everyone does. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

No, they don't. In fact far more people are doing the opposite. Religion is on a massive decline, and will continue at an exponential rate. 

Behold the pale horse --- 10 years ago -

I said nothing about religion. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Ok Fuzz - here is the discussion as I understand it -

1 - I say there are things that are not facts that you believe to be true.

2 - you say no there are not - like what

3 - I say there are underlying assumptions that all (or at least most) science it based on - that are not facts, but must be believed to be true for science to work.

4. you say you don't believe them either, with 3 or 4 sentences that at least to me made no sense at all against the point I was making .

You can not believe science to be true, which you do, without believing those unproven assumptions to be true. It is impossible, or at least completely irrational, to believe the science and not believe the assumptions.

therefore - I contest that you do actually believe to be true things you, or anyone else, can not prove to be fact. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

say there are underlying assumptions that all (or at least most) science it based on - that are not facts, but must be believed to be true for science to work.


But they are facts. Using the example from your link, which uses gravity as an example. The effects of gravity are factual. The only assumption is that there is a force we can't describe. However, we can factually prove that it exists. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground