Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Rethinking the treatment of alcoholism

who's talking here?

SleightOfHand 2
Laurabeth 1
zapper007 1
Warren Peace 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 4
JohnLynch 20
Gigix4 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 8
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
WatchOut 1
sheddy 1
PokerFace 1
Olivejuice 1
Ender 2
JakeBob 1
Sharticus 2
Emperor of Kingwood 2
Plain Bellied Sneetch 1
publicserviceA 1
Butterbean 4
Kayry 1
Commoner Sense 5
AMDG 13
Oregonian 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Sorry for the long read, but since there's some discussion about drunks, there's some interesting conversation starters in this article:

After 75 Years of Alcoholics Anonymous, It?s Time to Admit We Have a Problem

For much of the past 50 years or so, voicing any serious skepticism toward Alcoholics Anonymous or any other 12-step program was sacrilege?the equivalent, in polite company, of questioning the virtue of American mothers or the patriotism of our troops. If your problem was drink, AA was the answer; if drugs, Narcotics Anonymous. And if those programs didn?t work, it was your fault: You weren?t ?working the steps.? The only alternative, as the 12-step slogan has it, was ?jails, institutions, or death.? By 2000, 90 percent of American addiction treatment programs employed the 12-step approach.

In any other area of medicine, if your doctor told you that the cure for your disease involved surrendering to a ?higher power,? praying to have your ?defects of character? lifted, and accepting your ?powerlessness,? as outlined in the original 12 steps, you?d probably seek a second opinion. But, even today, if you balk at these elements of the 12-step gospel, you?ll often get accused of being ?in denial.? And if you should succeed in quitting drinking without 12-step support, you might get dismissed as a ?dry drunk.?

...

Dodes doesn?t pull his punches. ?Alcoholics Anonymous was proclaimed the correct treatment for alcoholism over seventy-five years ago despite the absence of any scientific evidence of the approach?s efficacy,? he writes in his introduction, ?and we have been on the wrong path ever since.?

Dodes shows that much of the research that undergirds AA is a conflicted mess that confuses correlation with causation. It?s true that people with alcoholism who choose to attend AA regularly drink less than those who do not?but it?s not proven that making people attend works better than other options, including doing nothing.

In fact, some studies find that people mandated into AA do worse than those who are simply left alone. (If true, that would be no small problem. AA?s own surveys suggest that some 165,000 Americans and Canadians annually are court-mandated into the program?despite the fact that every court ruling on the issue has rejected such coercion as unconstitutional, given AA?s religious nature.)

Contrary to popular belief, most people recover from their addictions without any treatment?professional or self-help?regardless of whether the drug involved is alcohol, crack, methamphetamine, heroin, or cigarettes. One of the largest studies of recovery ever conducted found that, of those who had qualified for a diagnosis of alcoholism in the past year, only 25 percent still met the criteria for the disorder a year later. Despite this 75 percent recovery rate, only a quarter had gotten any type of help, including AA, and as many were now drinking in a low-risk manner as were abstinent.

Unfortunately, compared to the rehab narrative, the stories of people who get better without treatment are rarely as compelling. They tend to consist of people leaving college and realizing they can?t binge drink or take drugs and hold a job and care for a family. And since most people who straighten out on their own never show up in treatment, the worst cases congregate in rehab and make addiction recovery seem quite rare.

This is not to say that there is no benefit at all to 12-step programs: It?s clear from studies of recovery, with or without treatment, that some of the most important factors in success are having social support and a sense of meaning and purpose. Both of those can be provided by AA?at least to those who find its approach amenable. Rather than treating AA as one potentially excellent resource out of many, though, all too many people still regard 12-step programs as the only true way.

One effect of this 12-step dominance is that addiction continues to be seen by many people as a moral failing rather than a disease. This is somewhat ironic, because many 12-step advocates firmly consider addiction to be a disease, as do government agencies like the National Institute on Drug Abuse. But it is awkward to posit addiction as a disease while simultaneously promoting AA?s non-medical and moralistic course of treatment. For what other medical condition does 90 percent of the treatment consist of meetings and prayer?

Dodes is eloquent on what drives addiction, and his argument that much of it results from an attempt to counter a sense of helplessness is convincing. In his view, addiction is a compulsive disorder, an attempt to cope with anguish by engaging in ritualistic behavior that is soothing and predictable, despite ongoing negative consequences.

...

Dodes advocates traditional treatment, such as talk therapy and medication, for what he labels ?chemical? compulsive disorders (including most of what the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders calls OCD). For instance, someone who can?t stop washing his hands might receive Prozac and a specialized type of talk therapy. But Dodes recommends individual therapy for what he labels ?psychological? disorders?including what we commonly think of as addiction. Specifically, he prefers psychodynamic therapy, which involves looking deeply into a patient?s past and often takes years to bear fruit.

Unfortunately, psychodynamic therapy has not been found to be any more effective than the 12-step programs Dodes so ably eviscerates. Although he admits he has his own bias in advocating psychodynamic therapy, Dodes thinks it?s an approach that hasn?t yet been studied well enough for its true effectiveness to be reflected in data. This is an unsatisfying answer. In a major review of the literature featured in The Handbook of Alcoholism Treatment Approaches, psychodynamic therapy ranked 46th out of 48 in effectiveness for treatments of alcoholism, even lower than Alcoholics Anonymous, which ranked 38th. It seems unlikely that additional study will cause a complete inversion of those numbers. (The review was notorious for finding an inverse correlation between what is most practiced in treatment and what is most effective in helping people.)

Dodes also fails to mention the success of certain approved medications for addictions?like buprenorphine and methadone for opioid problems, which have been shown to be more effective than any type of talk therapy or self-help in terms of saving lives and reducing the spread of blood-borne disease, according to the Institute of Medicine and the World Health Organization.

Still, Dodes has a deeply humane understanding of the ailments he studies, and has made an excellent case for why we need to overhaul our treatment system and provide more evidence-based options. If his book has weaknesses, they only underscore how much we still need to learn if we want to cure the multifactorial disorder we call addiction. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

alcoholism isn't a disease... 

JakeBob --- 12 years ago -

I think what he is saying is that if the mental health industry could profit from AA they would find it way more effective. Since AA is generally free, it can not be as effective as paying a doctor. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

"Contrary to popular belief, most people recover from their addictions without any treatment?professional or self-help?regardless of whether the drug involved is alcohol, crack, methamphetamine, heroin, or cigarettes. One of the largest studies of recovery ever conducted found that, of those who had qualified for a diagnosis of alcoholism in the past year, only 25 percent still met the criteria for the disorder a year later. Despite this 75 percent recovery rate, only a quarter had gotten any type of help, including AA, and as many were now drinking in a low-risk manner as were abstinent."





That seems very high. I think of the people who struggled with the cigarette smoking, and the success rate doesn't see nearly that good. Of Anyone who I've ever known who had a drinking problem, almost no one ever quit and stayed sober. And yet this study shows 75% self heal? Wow. Maybe the key is they just don't die from their addictions. But that doesn't mean they aren't addicted. Lol 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Of Anyone who I've ever known who had a drinking problem, almost no one ever quit and stayed sober.

maybe if you'd go to a real Christian church...you'd meet some people who overcame their alcohol addiction through Jesus Christ 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

.you'd meet some people who overcame their alcohol addiction through Jesus Christ

I know some people who overcame their addiction through the slammer. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Alcoholism like any other addiction is a mental disorder. Until we deal with mental illness we will continue to have these issues.

maybe if you'd go to a real Christian church...you'd meet some maybe if you'd go to a real Christian church...you'd meet some people who overcame their alcohol addiction through Jesus Christ



Another mental disorder. Self medicating with god. Church is their AA. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Of Anyone who I've ever known who had a drinking problem, almost no one ever quit and stayed sober. And yet this study shows 75% self heal?

That probably does seem strange if the basis for your observation is those you have known to have problems with alcohol. The author uses a different basis - "those who had qualified for a diagnosis of alcoholism"

It seems likely to me that we know many more people who qualify for a clinical diagnosis of alcoholism (it's probably a very low threshold) but we never know it because the magnitude of their problem is not as visible.

I think the author is spot on with his view that, "addiction is a compulsive disorder, an attempt to cope with anguish by engaging in ritualistic behavior that is soothing and predictable, despite ongoing negative consequences". Hardcore addicts seem to substitute addictions or add addictions (including addictions to therapy), while those with a lesser degree of compulsive disorder can simply commit themselves to behavior change. 

Sharticus --- 12 years ago -

It boils down to this. Half of the people on this Earth NEED someone to tell them what to do (sheeple). They need marriage counselors, psychiatrists, religious "experts," whatever. The people that get sucked into cults, for instance, are the most extreme of this type of person. Their entire life is controlled by someone who seems to knows better.

The other half are people that don't like for anyone to tell them what to do. They know what's best for them and attempt to fix whatever problem they are presented with. They usually don't care for other people telling them how they should live their lives regardless of the person's field of "expertise." Agnostic people are the most extreme of this group of people. A "God" can't exist because they would be forced to follow his rules.

The article above is probably true for the latter group. Life experts are mostly for people that don't trust their own decisions and need someone to take control of their lives. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

The true alcoholic and/or substance abuser will loose everything they have and still won't recognize the problem. They continue to blame someone else for their plight. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Another mental disorder

yep...not believing in God is a mental disorder... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

That probably does seem strange if the basis for your observation is those you have known to have problems with alcohol. The author uses a different basis - "those who had qualified for a diagnosis of alcoholism"

It seems likely to me that we know many more people who qualify for a clinical diagnosis of alcoholism (it's probably a very low threshold) but we never know it because the magnitude of their problem is not as visible.

I think the author is spot on with his view that, "addiction is a compulsive disorder, an attempt to cope with anguish by engaging in ritualistic behavior that is soothing and predictable, despite ongoing negative consequences". Hardcore addicts seem to substitute addictions or add addictions (including addictions to therapy), while those with a lesser degree of compulsive disorder can simply commit themselves to behavior change.





Totally agree with what you're saying.

The drunks I've known were life long drinkers whose issue escalated with longevity. That seems more common in my experience. As does the observation that none of them self heal or seek treatment. And as with many addictions, use escalates without intervention. It's astounding that one can abuse their bodies continually and not even kill themselves, they may get sick, develop cirrhosis of the liver, but they live on.


There are many levels of over use that may not actually qualify as addiction. I think maybe the low threshold you mentioned is why there may be a 75% success rate, the "light weight" alcoholics may be able to get a grip and alter their behavior on their own perhaps? We could really get complicated and delve I to their measuring stick they used for an addiction diagnosis.

I also agree addiction is compulsive and I've always thought related to underlying depression issues. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

JohnLynch --- 5 hours ago - quote - hide comments
Another mental disorder

yep...not believing in God is a mental disorder...


Wrong cult boy. 

WatchOut --- 12 years ago -

alcoholism isn't a disease...


You're just another [edited, iced] for thinking that. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

Knew a woman who begged her children to never drink. She saw in it her family her entire life and was sure it was hereditary. One night she was upset and her ex-husband said have a wine cooler it will help you calm down. That is all it took. This woman was a devout christian, taught Sunday school class for years, if the church door was open, she was there. She lost everything. Ended up in the drunk tank several times. She said it is horrible to be in a situation you are so ashamed to be in, that there is no one you can call to come get you. I had moved several years before this and while she was telling me this, I kept thinking it was joke. She had to hit rock bottom, but she doesn't drink anymore. I know another family where one is a drug addict and two others are gamblers. Families play a big part in enabling them. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

If anybody had a solution for addiction, we would not be reading this thread. 

Kayry --- 12 years ago -

^^^so true Butterbean^^^ 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I agree with most posts, but I have ambivalent feelings about the ability to quit- people who are really motivated have the best chance of staying sober- some people need support groups like AA- and yes, it's trading one addiction for another- I'm also convinced it's an inherited disease- in Italy, people drink wine with everything, and as a rule aren't alcoholics- in France, they are- the bottom line, IMO, is taking responsibility for yourself- if you're motivated to stop drinking/drugs, there are ways to do it- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

You're just another asssshole for thinking that.

nope...i'm just knowledgeable enough to know...

Wrong cult boy.

LOL...you're the one who belongs to a cult... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Somebody push Lynch down a trap door in the floor. Please tell me there is one.

You need meds, JL. I wonder if Lipitor would help you. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

You need meds, JL.

you need the TRUTH...

and most of all you need to quit pushing your false "truth"...

satan doesn't need your help... 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -


Somebody push Lynch down a trap door in the floor. Please tell me there is one.


I'm sure he's already down one. Unfortunately it has wifi. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

anyone who thinks SiFi isn't a Christian has no concept of what makes up a true Christian- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

anyone who thinks SiFi isn't a Christian has no concept of what makes up a true Christian-

anyone who thinks that all of the stuff she espouses is Scriptural...doesn't know Scripture...and therefore doesn't understand what it means to have Jesus as Lord and Savior...which means they have no concept of being a Christian 

Gigix4 --- 12 years ago -

I'm so glad we are all entitled to our OWN OPINION! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

isn't that the truth, Gigi girl- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

I'm so glad we are all entitled to our OWN OPINION!

you are...but when it contradicts God...your own opinion is worthless... 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

JL.

How can you be ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN that you speak for God?

Did he appoint you as his only rep on earth?

Is that approved by JC - and God? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

How can you be ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN you speak for God?

how about you being truthful for once?...i NEVER said i speak for God...

i CAN be certain that i KNOW what He says about a topic...i read what He has said...

His Word is clear...and ANYONE can know it IF they WANT to...

fyi...Jesus IS God... 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

yi...Jesus IS God

Nonsense 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

he nonsense is you thinking you know anything... 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

As recoverng alcoholic JL probably does have first hand knowledge. There is nothing like a recovering alcoholic who has found God. 

PokerFace --- 12 years ago -

I'm sure he's already down one. Unfortunately it has wifi.

Hahahaha- that there is comedy gold! 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

not believing in God is a mental disorder...
Undoubtedly the stupidest post on the thread. 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

[i]JohnLynch --- 17 hours ago - quote - hide comments

You're just another asssshole for thinking that.

Why was WatchOut iced for using the ***hole word when John L. used the
above in his post?

Ah yes, he intentionally mispelled the forbidend word. He should be iced too.
Everyone knows what he meant, don't we?. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Why was WatchOut iced for using the ***hole word when John L. used the
above in his post?



Sometimes going to the icebox is totally worth it and even planned. Happy Easter WatchOut you rock! 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

There is nothing like a recovering alcoholic who has found God.

how can you make that claim about yourself?...wouldn't you have to find God first?

Undoubtedly the stupidest post on the thread.

nope...your next post easily accomplished that... 

publicserviceA --- 12 years ago -

alcoholism is a choice not a disease. Lupus is a disease. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Jl - have a blessed Easter, I wish for you the grace to see that love and mercy are the foundation of a Christian life.

May I suggest some time in contemplation on Mathew 5 : 23

Again enjoy the most holy of days with joy 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Mistyped. I ment 5 : 22 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground