Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What Caitlyn Jenner Can Teach Our Daughters

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
smartypants 1
ukchristine 2
SoupIsGoodFood 3
BalletMom 1
FANCY PANTS 2
Work in Progress 9
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Ava 1
Dorothy Parker 4
Defcon1 1
Joe Blow 1
PokerFace 11
Emperor of Kingwood 3
a889324uu 3
Prolix Raconteur 1
Fresh Meat 1
FNHO 2
alldayredux 1
ugly yapper dog 1
Proud American 1
Max01 1
ants r marching 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Magazine covers can often start conversations with children what with their lurid headlines and provocative imagery. I frequently find them hard to explain: There is no really comprehensible answer, for an 8-year-old, to the question of why the girl on the cover of Sports Illustrated is taking off her swimsuit bottom. (And there?s really no comprehensible answer for me about why our general store stacked those up next to the brownie mix).

So I?m grateful to the editors of Vanity Fair for providing not just a cover I can explain easily, but one that offers a sort of antidote to all the other airbrushed, hair-tossing images looking out at the checkout line: Caitlyn Jenner, formerly known as Bruce Jenner, glamorous, glorious, triumphant ? and looking as little like her day-to-day self as any of us would look if we were styled by Vanity Fair and photographed by Annie Leibovitz.

I?ve suggested before that we let our children, especially our teenagers, lead the conversation about Ms. Jenner?s identity transition. As I wrote in that earlier post, for all the expectations that fill our toy aisles, our children are still growing up in a world in which gender identity is less constrained than it once was, and they view this through different eyes. My oldest son (13) saw Ms. Jenner?s public transformation as something that no one of his generation would have to go through, because, he said, it might not be easy, but ?they probably wouldn?t feel like they had to hide it for so long.? My younger children clearly filed the whole thing away under ?things grown-ups do,? perhaps unexpected, but no more disturbing than taking off a swimsuit in public.

But when it comes to the various tricks and cheats the advertising and fashion industries use to gloss over any imperfections in their models and other images, I?m ready to talk, and I?m grateful to Ms. Jenner and the Vanity Fair crew for creating the perfect opportunity to remind my children, and especially my daughters, that what you see in those pictures is emphatically, and designedly, not what you get.

Magazine photos are a game, I tell them, like Minecraft, in which photographers and editors and models take their favorite elements and graft them onto another while consigning their rejects to the digital trash bin. The goal isn?t beauty or ?looking good.? We?re beautiful when we?re happy and relaxed and doing something we love. Instead, the object is to create an image that?s unattainable: a portrait of someone looking the way no person in real life could possibly look, often in the hope of selling you products that you will use to strive toward that standard.

We can look at Ms. Jenner and see the standard applied, presumably with her enthusiastic consent. We can speculate not only about the smoothing over of what?s there but also about the decision to remove what is not. Is that a narrower jaw I see before me? Where is her Adam?s apple? Why is she hiding her hands? From there, I can click over to the retouched and unaltered images Jezebel featured from Lena Dunham?s Vogue shoot, and point out that Ms. Dunham looks great in both, but the magazine chose to erase the kinds of lumps and bulges we all have in some shots ? and changed entire elements of the background in others. We can talk about Seventeen magazine?s promise (after a petition from 14-year-old Julia Bluhm) not to alter images ? and how they can get around that with lighting and angles and the pinning of clothing and other tricks of the trade.

Will all these conversations keep my children from measuring themselves and others against media images? Probably not, but Caitlyn Jenner and Vanity Fair have given us a gift by wrapping her so thoroughly in the glossy mantle of unattainable feminine perfection, hands hidden and lines erased, even while she is so frequently photographed and interviewed living her life, not posing for it. Ms. Jenner looks as if she enjoyed the process of having the image gamers recreate her in their idealized likeness ? and as if she is ready to drop the pose and grab life with both hands.



0 

ants r marching --- 11 years ago -

Ugh, "Ms. Jenner?!?!"


Where is her Adam?s apple? Why is she hiding her hands?

HIS Adam's apple was shaved off. And HE is not showing HIS hands because HE has MAN hands.

And this whole hot mess is NOT a gift. This is not something wrapped up in a box with a pretty bow. It is just more proof this world is headed to hell in a hand basket quicker and quicker each day.

Notice HE had to tuck his private parts to look more like a woman? Or did they have to digitally remove and smooth down that part. Don't want his little pecker out there to explain to your daughters. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

The article had some good points. I don't agree with most of it, but the author was spot on about how magazine covers (and celebrities with their hours of makeup and hair) are not reality, and we need to let our children understand that. 

ukchristine --- 11 years ago -

Neither of those three pictures look like a 65 year old man. And the one on the right doesn't look like a65 year old woman either. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Someone is really trying to get a full troll out of this one. 

whatchamacallit --- 11 years ago -

Jenner can offer nothing to anyone other than proof that psychiatric treatment doesn't always fix everything that is wrong with a persons mind. I wouldn't want anything he did or said or even thought about to have any effect on my child, no matter their sex. I feel sorry for Jenner because of his illness but at this point, the only the he can offer to anyone is to serve as an example of how pitiful a human can be and advice on what not to do to your body if you want to be considered even anything close to normal. He is a prefect example of mental illness and it's often present presentation of self mutilation. 

ukchristine --- 11 years ago -

There's a LOT we don't know about the Human mind especially in this regard. The lauding of this HERO (apparently agreed by many) makes it's politically incorrect to research it. The more it's mainstreamed the less likely we will encourage research. 

Max01 --- 11 years ago -

You speak to any child (that has yet to be corrupted by the media, pop culture government schools) and tell them what Bruce did, what do you think they ould say?

I would bet 99 out of 100 would say Gross! 

Prolix Raconteur --- 11 years ago -

The former Chief Psychiatrist for Johns Hopkins Hospital says that changing sex is biologically impossible and that "transgender" is simply a misnomer for a mental disorder. 

ants r marching --- 11 years ago -

Nail on the head to Max and Prolix! 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Hate and bigotry is taught.
Kids think their parents kissing is "gross."

Kids today are far more tolerant and understanding than their parents.

And it's beautiful! 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

How much do you really respect our military?

Transgender in US Army.

Is your support conditional towards the men and women who serve this country? 

PokerFace --- 11 years ago -

The former Chief Psychiatrist for Johns Hopkins Hospital says that changing sex is biologically impossible and that "transgender" is simply a misnomer for a mental disorder.

He also claims homosexuality is a choice. He selectively reads literature to support his own agenda. 

ants r marching --- 11 years ago -

Kids today are far more tolerant and understanding than their parents.

And it's beautiful!



Nah, not so. Kids feel the same way kids did 2,3 even 4 generations ago its just that others are teaching them to accept more. If you don't accept more of what society is feeding us then we are called bigots etc. I'm not a bigot for not accepting the homosexual and/or trans whatever lifestyle. I don't have to like everything you're shoving down my throat. Just like in every comment you make is against conservative people or christians. Believe me everyone on here knows how you feel. You have made yourself and your beliefs very known on here. Why repeat yourself over and over. 

PokerFace --- 11 years ago -

Ugh, "Ms. Jenner?!?!"

do you go around ridiculing the disabled, disfigured, and handicapped too? Lol. your comments are fun to read. 

ants r marching --- 11 years ago -

Well, "Ms Jenner" is disfigured now by multulating himself and he is mentally handicapped by thinking the way he does so I guess that's a, yup. 

PokerFace --- 11 years ago -

Well, "Ms Jenner" is disfigured now by multulating himself and he is mentally handicapped by thinking the way he does so I guess that's a, yup.

Such an outstanding model of Christianity! Jesus is proud of you. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

For the same reason you repeat yourself over and over again.

You hate anyone who doesn't subscribe to your brand of hatred and bigotry. We get it. 

ants r marching --- 11 years ago -

I'm not a model of or for christianity and I don't hate anyone. Well, not everyone. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

You hate anyone who doesn't subscribe to your brand of hatred and bigotry. We get it.

Same can be said about liberals. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

I love when liberals, who are themselves completely hostile to Christianity, tell actual Christians that they aren't "Christian" enough.

I don't think that either of you are in a position to discern true Christianity from fake Christianity, especially when you have a great deal of difficulty telling the difference between male and female, real marriage and the mockery of marriage, whether or not life is life or even human in the womb, or even what constitutes racism or bigotry. 

PokerFace --- 11 years ago -

And I love it when fundies who say they are Bible literalists pick and choose which parts of the Bible they want to adhere to and ignore the rest. 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

This REALLY upsets the bigoted and homophobic...in other words, the self described, Christians. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

So much anger over something that hurts no one.

Put that energy into fixing our foster care system. Actually make a difference. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

You wouldn't know, Poker, hence my post. You don't know what is taught, none of you do, but then you attempt to judge our adherence to your own ignorance. It's weird. Why do you do that? 

BalletMom --- 11 years ago -

Amen, Dorothy.. 

FANCY PANTS --- 11 years ago -

She is a he and can not teach my daughters anything. He is mentally ill. He is not something to be looked up to by any child. He should have had many many years of psychiatric treatment befor being allowed to mutalate his body. I wonder how happy he will be with his surgery in 5 years. 

Ava --- 11 years ago -

Jenner is Caitlyn now and he is making a fortune off of this. In 5 years, he may decide to be a man again...just to make another fortune off of his big story. 

FANCY PANTS --- 11 years ago -

In 5 years, he may decide to be a man

But if they put it back it will not work like it did before. Will he be happy with that? All the money in the world can not make you happy. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

He still has his penis. He just takes hormones and got implants. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

He also claims homosexuality is a choice

It is. 

Defcon1 --- 11 years ago -

If you have a wang and have to get prostate exams...you're a man. 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

Pap smears and mammograms...oh, not necessary...a man cannot become a woman 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

0 

PokerFace --- 11 years ago -


You wouldn't know, Poker, hence my post. You don't know what is taught, none of you do, but then you attempt to judge our adherence to your own ignorance. It's weird. Why do you do that?


You don't have to be a member of a cult to understand its dangers, do you?

I'm judging you on your adherence to silly rules in a book written by ignorant men to keep the Israelites in line and your willingness to cherry pick the parts that you want to. Do you go banish yourself to a hut until your menstrual cycle is over? Do you wear mixed fabrics? Do you cut your hair? The Old Testament says it's ok to stone your child to death for misbehavior. God forbid if someone wants an abortion right after a rape, but once the child is born, stone it! 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

That's how I know that you don't know what you are talking about, Poker. Have I ever intimated that I am a Old Testament Jew living in Israel or Judah? Pretty sure I haven't. Then what does any of that have to do with me? You don't understand the difference, but you seek to judge others by your own ignorance. 

ugly yapper dog --- 11 years ago -

My younger children clearly filed the whole thing away under ?things grown-ups do,?

It's a sad day when any child "matures" to the point where they start paying attention to anything celeb-gossip related. 

ants r marching --- 11 years ago -

I'm judging you on your adherence to silly rules in a book written by ignorant men to keep the Israelites in line and your willingness to cherry pick the parts that you want to. Do you go banish yourself to a hut until your menstrual cycle is over? Do you wear mixed fabrics? Do you cut your hair? The Old Testament says it's ok to stone your child to death for misbehavior. God forbid if someone wants an abortion right after a rape, but once the child is born, stone it!




It really gets on my last nerve when people use the old testament to try to make a invalid point. If you have read the whole bible then you would know that Jesus came to fulfill the law and by believing in Him we don't have to do these things that the old testament talks about. Read the letters written by Paul in the new testament and you will get a clear understanding of how we are to behave today. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

I put wings on my dog today.

Does that make him a bird? 

ants r marching --- 11 years ago -

I'm going to sit in the garage today.

Does that make me a car?

No more than sitting in a church makes someone a Christian. Or getting boobies and taking off your pecker and balls make someone a woman. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground