Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

* VOTE NO! TO PROP 3 / Red light cameras

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
randyjet 10
wayward1 1
kwmomx2 1
~sassy~ 3
NoCitySlicker 2
rEVOLution 16
fishlady 10
Betty 2
Lillabeth 1
Nightstorm 1
MsTLP 1
Laurabeth 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
zapper007 2
voice of reason 1
TooMuch 1
curtis 6
Whoop Dee Doo 1
james osterberg 1
CouchPotato 1
AlphabetSoup 1
~Scotch~ 1
Dr Aborto 3
Tipsyhic 3
Aah Grasshoppa 1
A Simple Equation 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
Puss In Boots 9
poolgal 1
gambit 1
Clock 1
DuckHunt 8
DriveSafe 3
Queenwood789 1
duckyboo 1
nomessanwithmytexan 1
yellowsubmarine 1
nolanfan16 1
teensey 1
yelloweye 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

“In every city where the public had a right to vote on red-light cameras, the cameras have been removed,” said Kubosh, who believes Houston voters will deliver the same outcome on Nov. 2.



Proposition 3 – Red Light Cameras
Monday, October 11, 2010
By Felicia Cravens

Proposition 3 reads:

An Amendment to the City Charter Relating to the Use of
Photographic Traffic Signal Enforcement Systems (Red Light
Cameras).
Shall the City of Houston continue to use red light cameras to enforce
state or local laws relating to traffic safety?

HTPS recommends a vote AGAINST Proposition 3.

Reason #1 – The Lawsuit – Proponents of Proposition 3, the team known as Keep Houston Safe, have spent much of the summer filing a lawsuit to keep Prop 3 off the ballot. What group thinks it’s a smart move to tell voters they should not be allowed to vote on an issue such as this? Apparently “Keep Houston SILENT”, as they’ve become known. And be aware, Matress Mac supports this anti-safety, cash-grabbing group. We’re just sayin’.

Reason #2 – The Lawsuit Part 2 – It bears repeating, and some further explanation. The company behind the Red Light Cameras, American Traffic Solutions, used this argument against allowing citizens to vote on the cameras in West Palm Beach:

“The city has created a scenario whereby voters who oppose the safety cameras program – a group that historically tends to vote in a conservative manner – will vote in greater numbers than would otherwise have turned out for a November 2, 2010 election.”

So if the city lets voters get their say on red light cameras, it’s racist. We would wager that the exact same language has been filed in Houston and Baytown as well.

(Side Note: In Baytown, the proposition is reversed. A vote to limit red light cameras in BAYTOWN is a vote FOR Prop 1 on that ballot.)

Reason #3 – Safety - You can find studies that say anything you want them to say. However, Citizens Against Red Light Cameras has long list of resources for you to peruse, including studies on safety. Included in the allegations of bogus safety claims are shortening yellow light times and increases in rear-end collisions.

Reason #4 – Safety Part 2 – Claims made by Keep Houston Safe are showing up on television screens, stating that law enforcement and emergency personnel support the red light cameras in vast numbers. However, the current policy does not allow insurance companies access to the data, eliminating one potential means of stopping red light runners by raising their insurance rates. In addition, one can not lose one’s license or suffer criminal penalties for habitual citations. If red light cameras are about safety, they sure have a funny way of showing it.

Reason #5 – Follow the Money – Keep Houston Silent has stressed safety as an overarching reason to keep the cameras. But red light cameras are a huge business in the US and elsewhere. American Traffic Solutions and their “partners in crime” had spent almost a quarter of a million dollars fighting Houston area attempts to overturn the cameras. The reason is simple: traffic camera schemes make lot of money for installers who maintain them, but not so much for cities. As we mentioned with out post on Proposition 1 with ReNew Houston, it’s about corruption, and we have to weed it out at ALL levels.

To view what else is on the ballot in language that makes sense go here: http://houstontps.org/ 

Nightstorm --- 16 years ago -

Why install thousands of cameras first (at what cost?) and have us vote on it afterwards?

Who's paying for this crap? 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Houston made over $5 million in red light camera revenue last year off the backs of their citizens. $75.00 at a time. 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

Why install thousands of cameras first (at what cost?) and have us vote on it afterwards?

Who's paying for this crap? 


The RLC companies pay to install, monitor and maintain the cameras. The proceeds (in most cases) are split 50/50 between the company and the municipality. The cost is nothing for the government, so it's not at all about "safety" but just another way to fleece the public out of more money. It is a scam and has been found to be un-constitutional as well. I learned this all when researched this a few years ago after getting a ticket in Chicago. Cost me $180 for missing a light by 1/10th of a second. No harm, no foul. And the video showed that had I slammed on my brakes, I most likely would have caused an accident because the car behind me was so close. The city didn't care. They got their money.

I came across a Senate study that concluded that increasing the amber (yellow) light by just 1 second reduced the number of red light runs by 97%. But that's too simple of a solution for Big Government. And it doesn't make them any money. Even though it actually INCREASES the safety of the public...

We're just slaves to be fed on by the parasite government. It's a simple equation. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

Bottom line -no due process

The 10,000 little cuts will be the death of our Constitutional Rights.

$70.00 is meaningless compared to my loss of basic rights awarded to me as a natural born citizen. 

Tipsyhic --- 16 years ago -

I feel that I should have the freedom to run as many red lights As I wish and The freedom to T bone as many people possible while holding a glass of Vadka in one hand and my cell phone in the other. 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 16 years ago -

I'm voting for the red light cameras. I understand the negatives but if it can get people to slow down instead hauling like gangbusters through busy intersections, then it has my vote. 

Tipsyhic --- 16 years ago -

but if it can get people to slow down

See thats it. It is just all about controlling people. I have the right to smash and kill as many people as possible thank you!!!!! HIC

Damm the red lights FULL STEAM AHEAD MATEY 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

I'm for the red light cameras. People run red lights all the time so why not catch them? City makes money and reduces people who speed past the yellow lights. I know the 3 camera lights on my way to work and you better believe that I don't try to run the yellow. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

2. The majority of the money collected goes to a for profit third party that maintains them and administers them. 

Unless the city wants to get in the business of making red light cameras then they have a 3rd party doing it. The way it is now, no matter what % cut they get, it's 100% profit for the city. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

Oh I understand but once purchased they could be maintained by existing city staff in the public works dept just like the traffic lights. 

Makes sense but the company making the cameras wouldn't do that. They might own the patent on them so they would rather lease them out than just sell them. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

Houston made over $5 million in red light camera revenue last year off the backs of their citizens. $75.00 at a time.


Off the backs of the folks that can't seem to STOP at red lights. I'm totally ok with that. :) 

NoCitySlicker --- 16 years ago -

If folks would obey the laws, which we have to have, then they would not be needed. I wish they were on every corner that has a stop sign! 

gambit --- 16 years ago -

mr white said to vote yes for them so i am. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

or how about you all just follow the rules of the road! quite a concept eh?! 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Brian1 --- 2 hours ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments
I'm voting for the red light cameras. I understand the negatives but if it can get people to slow down instead hauling like gangbusters through busy intersections, then it has my vote.


Exactly!!

I wish we had these in Kingwood. I hate people who run lights. That being said.... some of the lights in Kingwood take FOREVER to change. 

wayward1 --- 16 years ago -

These cameras are the closest thing we've got to Robo-cop and Robo-cop is cool. I want to keep them. Oh, and taxing only the people that are both dangerous and stupid so that the rest of us get taxed less - priceless. Keep running the lights so that the our property taxes don't go up. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Some y'all crack me up with this stuff.

People that Tbone other cars and cause wrecks by running a red light are NOT going to be stopped by a red light camera. Red light cameras catch you if you are too slow getting through the yellow light, it catches you way before the other lights turn green and way before any other cars enter the intersection.

It's the same ignorant mentality that because walmart has 40 surveillance cameras on the outside of their roof that no one will commit crimes. Or that cameras on ATM machines stops people from robbing them, which still happens quite often.

Cameras are to create revenue and a FALSE sense of safety. And they are exactly that, a FALSE sense of safety. The facts have been proven over and over again.

VOTE no people, stop buying into all the idiocy that dictates this new world our governments have created. It's all lies. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

“In every city where the public had a right to vote on red-light cameras, the cameras have been removed,” said Kubosh, who believes Houston voters will deliver the same outcome on Nov. 2. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

It's been shown in some instances red light cameras can increase accident rates due to people slamming on their brakes to avoid going thru the yellow. Not to mention the vast differences light to light of the time a light remains yellow. These cameras are designed entirely as a money generator, they do absolutely nothing for public safety. 

AlphabetSoup --- 16 years ago -

Oh I understand but once purchased they could be maintained by existing city staff in the public works dept just like the traffic lights.

It might actually cost the city more to monitor the lights themselves than pay a 3rd party. Existing city staff already have a job so the time they would spend maintaing them would take time off other things they already did so either more people would still be needed or more OT paid.

As for due process - there is due process, they still have to prove you ran the red light. 

Whoop Dee Doo --- 16 years ago -

My husband works in EMS and we are voting YES. I believe him when he tells me how it has cut down on accidents. He has no reason to lie, he doesn't get any of the money. 

DuckHunt --- 16 years ago -

New Study Says Traffic-Light Cameras Cause Accidents
By Marty Jerome March 12, 2008 | 12:00 pm | Categories: Uncategorized
Their legality is still questioned in some states. A case was argued before Iowa’s Supreme Court only yesterday. But how about their efficacy?

Researchers at the University of South Florida Public Health have released a study that shows a significant spike in accidents at intersections that use cameras to catch light runners. Why? Drivers are more likely to slam on their brakes when the signal turns yellow, causing tailgaters to ram into them.

The spike is not insignificant. The USF study focused on Florida, and found that traffic fatalities caused by red-light running were not increasing. In fact, they account for less than 4% of the state’s yearly traffic deaths. From the study:

"The injury rate from red-light running crashes has dropped by a third in less than a decade, indicating red-light running crashes have been continually declining in Florida without the use of cameras."

Is this study applicable only to Florida–with its high number of elderly drivers? No, similar studies in Virginia, North Carolina and Ontario found similar increases in crashes at intersections where cameras were installed. As for studies that show a decrease in accidents, many were funded by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, a trade group for the insurance industry. Insurers tend to profit from red light cameras, because revenues go up with increased citations and accidents.

Cities profit from them, too. And this explains why they are proliferating throughout the U.S. Is your city risking your life just to kick up a little scratch from traffic violations?

Sources: Scientific American, USF, Billings Gazette, Des Moines Register



Read More http://www.wired.com/autopia/2008/03/new-study-says/#ixzz12SoioHXc 

fishlady --- 16 years ago -

What about the people who stop and turn on red...I personally know THREE people that have went to court for the Townsend camera bc they were turning right on red and got a ticket....proof showed they were right, BUT wasted four hours of their day to go fight it...how many people are just paying the 75.00 to keep from spending a day in court and missing work????

this is what I think is not fair, I don't agree with them because they are not right all the time UNLESS they clearly POST IN SIGHT that there is a red light camera IN USE, so everyone can know it is there, otherwise the excuse that they are doing it to "save lives" and make people slow down and not run red lights is a load of crap, if that was the goal, POST A SIGN, don't be SNEAKY about it...I have no idea what lights have cameras and not...but if they do it should be posted if the goal is to stop people from running them and not just to collect revenue...IMO 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

I'm for red light cameras. Obeying the traffic laws is just something everyone should do. If you don't run a red light (or turn right on red without stopping) then you don't have a problem. As far as due process is concerned....you do have the opportunity to review the video.

Fines for illegal parking and running through the EZ tag lanes without a sticker are other revenue generating streams....and no one complains about due process with those.

I also find it interesting that the person who is fighting this whole thing is a LAWYER who stands to lose big money over the whole due process argument. 

DuckHunt --- 16 years ago -

I'm for red light cameras. Obeying the traffic laws is just something everyone should do. If you don't run a red light (or turn right on red without stopping) then you don't have a problem. As far as due process is concerned....you do have the opportunity to review the video.

The problem with that theory is some bonehead slams on his brakes just as the light turns yellow and you slam into the back of him... Oh happy days!!!

But hey at least no one ran a red light!! 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Well Duck, I am sorry if that happens. But seems to me that if you slam into the back of him, you (in general)were going to run a red light, especially if the driver in front of you encountered a yellow. And you were traveling too fast to stop in time. We all know what a "stale green" is....and speeding up to get to the yellow is not a safe way to drive. 

DuckHunt --- 16 years ago -

The main issue I see with them is, every study out their show they don't do what they were intended to do. (cut down on accidents) In fact most show the opposite. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Yes, definitely some controvesy with the data. I wish people would quit using the data to slant towards their view point....we have horrible drivers in Houston. IMO, the behind-the-wheel texters are even more dangerous than those running red lights. 

DuckHunt --- 16 years ago -

Houston Police Department has been accused of trying to influence the outcome of a city-commissioned study into traffic-light cameras by changing how crashes at intersections with red-light cameras were counted, according to documents included in a lawsuit.

The police department’s request was refused by the study’s authors, however, who concluded the number of accidents at 50 intersections with the cameras had increased, not decreased as city officials expected, documents say.

Attorneys fighting to end Houston’s two-year-old red-light camera program seized on the documents as evidence the study was tainted by a purposefully skewed methodology.

Lawyer Randall Kallinen said: “As in other cities, the red-light camera system in Houston is increasing accidents. This is very dangerous for the public, and we must end the red-light camera experiment.”

City officials and Rice University political science Professor Robert Stein, one of the study’s main authors, contend the Houston Police Department’s requests were part of an ordinary back-and-forth about how best to examine the efficacy of red-light cameras and not a conspiracy to deliver false data.

Stein acknowledged that the cameras are not working in Houston as well as he believes they have been shown to work in other cities and said the city and critics should be more concerned about why.

“Why are these crashes going up at these intersections?” Stein said. “Nobody really cares to get at the truth here. Cars are being damaged, people are being injured and a handful of people are dying.”

Red-light cameras have been controversial in Houston since they were installed in September 2006. Critics say the primary purpose of the cameras is generating revenue, not reducing accidents.

link title 

DuckHunt --- 16 years ago -

the behind-the-wheel texters are even more dangerous than those running red lights. 

ABSOLUTELY!!! 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

It's been shown in some instances red light cameras can increase accident rates due to people slamming on their brakes to avoid going thru the yellow. Not to mention the vast differences light to light of the time a light remains yellow. These cameras are designed entirely as a money generator, they do absolutely nothing for public safety.

Finally sir, something we agree on. LOL 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

What about the people who stop and turn on red...I personally know THREE people that have went to court for the Townsend camera bc they were turning right on red and got a ticket....proof showed they were right, BUT wasted four hours of their day to go fight it...how many people are just paying the 75.00 to keep from spending a day in court and missing work????

Several more reasons to vote NO on Prop 3 next month.

I say give cops their jobs back of writing tickets for people who run red lights. It's all about job creation right???? 

DriveSafe --- 16 years ago -

First of all, I think that the elected officials should decide on traffic laws and enforcement methods. That is one of the things they are elected to do. Imagine what a mess it would be if every time the US congress passed a law it would have to voted on in a national election. If the public is unhappy with the positions taken by an elected official, they can vote that official out at the time of the next election.

There have been several articles recently in the news about the fact that traffic fatalities nationally are the lowest in decades even with higher traffic flow amounts. But these articles cite increased traffic law enforcement as one of the reasons for this decline, camera enforcement being one of the methods used in increasing enforcement. Red-light camera enforcement reduces red light running and intersection collisions and should be utilized in an effort to increase safety. 

DriveSafe --- 16 years ago -

First of all, I think that the elected officials should decide on traffic laws and enforcement methods. That is one of the things they are elected to do. Imagine what a mess it would be if every time the US congress passed a law it would have to voted on in a national election. If the public is unhappy with the positions taken by an elected official, they can vote that official out at the time of the next election.

There have been several articles recently in the news about the fact that traffic fatalities nationally are the lowest in decades even with higher traffic flow amounts. But these articles cite increased traffic law enforcement as one of the reasons for this decline, camera enforcement being one of the methods used in increasing enforcement. Red-light camera enforcement reduces red light running and intersection collisions and should be utilized in an effort to increase safety. 

DriveSafe --- 16 years ago -

First of all, I think that the elected officials should decide on traffic laws and enforcement methods. That is one of the things they are elected to do. Imagine what a mess it would be if every time the US congress passed a law it would have to voted on in a national election. If the public is unhappy with the positions taken by an elected official, they can vote that official out at the time of the next election.

There have been several articles recently in the news about the fact that traffic fatalities nationally are the lowest in decades even with higher traffic flow amounts. But these articles cite increased traffic law enforcement as one of the reasons for this decline, camera enforcement being one of the methods used in increasing enforcement. Red-light camera enforcement reduces red light running and intersection collisions and should be utilized in an effort to increase safety. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

First of all, I think that the elected officials should decide on traffic laws and enforcement methods. That is one of the things they are elected to do. Imagine what a mess it would be if every time the US congress passed a law it would have to voted on in a national election. If the public is unhappy with the positions taken by an elected official, they can vote that official out at the time of the next election.


That all sounds great in a world without liars, thieves, buyouts, payoffs, manipulation, all generated by those "elected representatives" and the media.

When click2houston tells all of it's viewers that red light cameras save lives, what else are they to believe? The research has shown that in most if not all intersections they have increased car wrecks, not minimized them. Meanwhile the city of Houston steals $5 million in revenue from it's citizens.

The fact is that if you really want to minimize wrecks, you increase the time the lights stay red. What causes most intersection wrecks is when one side turns red the opposite side of the intersection turns green at the same time with little or no delay. The other major cause is people not paying attention, it's been said many times that you can't fix stupid and camera lights won't do it either. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

There have been several articles recently in the news about the fact that traffic fatalities nationally are the lowest in decades even with higher traffic flow amounts.

That's mainly due to safer vehicles, not safer drivers and certainly not due to traffic cameras catching people running a yellow light. 

duckyboo --- 16 years ago -

Although annoying these systems do work!I think the would really help out at some busy intersections. 

Queenwood789 --- 16 years ago -

Houston made over $5 million in red light camera revenue last year off the backs of their citizens. $75.00 at a time. 

And those citizens, if they have a drivers license, should know that it's against the law to speed and run red lights. Very easy way to avoid giving money to the city? Obey the laws. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground