Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Noah's Ark was round

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 8
wayward1 4
Donkey Hodie 1
RiteWingKing 4
zapper007 1
Warren Peace 1
jtcitrus 1
JohnLynch 19
Quicksilver Messenger Service 2
RedMulch 3
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
In AbsentiaW 1
Dorothy Parker 3
Defcon1 1
WatchOut 3
KingOfSomewhereHot 1
Four Pinocchios 1
JAMS 1
witchywoman 2
Ogre13 8
Jepperd 3
Sangria 1
Dutchess 10
JustPeachy27 5
Ryanno 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

LONDON (AP) — It was a vast boat that saved two of each animal and a handful of humans from a catastrophic flood.

But forget all those images of a long vessel with a pointy bow — the original Noah's Ark, new research suggests, was round.

A recently deciphered 4,000-year-old tablet from ancient Mesopotamia — modern-day Iraq — reveals striking new details about the roots of the Old Testament tale of Noah. It tells a similar story, complete with detailed instructions for building a giant round vessel known as a coracle — as well as the key instruction that animals should enter "two by two."

The tablet went on display at the British Museum on Friday, and soon engineers will follow the ancient instructions to see whether the vessel could actually have sailed.

It's also the subject of a new book, "The Ark Before Noah," by Irving Finkel, the museum's assistant keeper of the Middle East and the man who translated the tablet.

Finkel got hold of it a few years ago, when a man brought in a damaged tablet his father had acquired in the Middle East after World War II. It was light brown, about the size of a mobile phone and covered in the jagged cuneiform script of the ancient Mesopotamians.

It turned out, Finkel said Friday, to be "one of the most important human documents ever discovered."

"It was really a heart-stopping moment — the discovery that the boat was to be a round boat," said Finkel, who sports a long gray beard, a ponytail and boundless enthusiasm for his subject. "That was a real surprise."

And yet, Finkel said, a round boat makes sense. Coracles were widely used as river taxis in ancient Iraq and are perfectly designed to bob along on raging floodwaters.

"It's a perfect thing," Finkel said. "It never sinks, it's light to carry."

Elizabeth Stone, an expert on the antiquities of ancient Mesopotamia at New York's Stony Brook University, said it made sense that ancient Mesopotamians would depict their mythological ark in that shape.

"People are going to envision the boat however people envision boats where they are," she said. "Coracles are not unusual things to have had in Mesopotamia."

The tablet records a Mesopotamian god's instructions for building a giant vessel — two-thirds the size of a soccer field in area — made of rope, reinforced with wooden ribs and coated in bitumen.

Finkel said that on paper (or stone) the boat-building orders appear sound, but he doesn't yet know whether it would have floated. A television documentary due to be broadcast later this year will follow attempts to build the ark according to the ancient manual.

The flood story recurs in later Mesopotamian writings including the "Epic of Gilgamesh." These versions lack the technical instructions — cut out, Finkel believes, because they got in the way of the storytelling.

"It would be like a Bond movie where instead of having this great sexy red car that comes on, somebody starts to tell you about how many horsepower it's got and the pressure of the tires and the capacity of the boot (trunk)," he said. "No one cares about that. They want the car chase."

Finkel is aware his discovery may cause consternation among believers in the Biblical story. When 19th-century British Museum scholars first learned from cuneiform tablets that the Babylonians had a flood myth, they were disturbed by its striking similarities to the story of Noah.

"Already in 1872 people were writing about it in a worried way — What does it mean that Holy Writ appears on this piece of Weetabix?" he joked, referring to a cereal similar in shape to the tablet.

Finkel has no doubts.

"I'm sure the story of the flood and a boat to rescue life is a Babylonian invention," he said.

He believes the tale was likely passed on to the Jews during their exile in Babylon in the 6th century B.C. And he doesn't think the tablet provides evidence the ark described in the Bible existed. He said it's more likely that a devastating real flood made its way into folk memory, and has remained there ever since.

"I don't think the ark existed — but a lot of people do," he said. "It doesn't really matter. The Biblical version is a thing of itself and it has a vitality forever.

"The idea that floods are caused by sin is happily still alive among us," he added, pointing out a local councilor in England who made headlines recently for saying Britain's recent storms were caused by the legalization of gay marriage.

"Had I known it, it would have gone in the preface of the book," Finkel said. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

LOL...apparently you just love posting absolute nonsense 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

How am I supposed to keep track of my flood stories now.

Two of them! 

Quicksilver Messenger Service --- 12 years ago -

I thought it was flat... 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 12 years ago -


LOL...apparently you just love posting absolute nonsense


Instead of posting about the poster, talk about the topic. If you think it is nonsense, explain why. It's a much nicer board if we just stick to the topics and not the people. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Great flood stories were around well before the Torah. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

There's a flood story in nearly every culture. So it probably did happen. 

WatchOut --- 12 years ago -

Lynch as usual you always make about as much sense as the person I overheard yesterday who was blaming someone she sat next to an hour earlier for the massive cold that just came upon her. 

WatchOut --- 12 years ago -


There's a flood story in nearly every culture. So it probably did happen.




If its not Lynch's story, its false. 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

There's a great flood story for the cultures in an isolated region of the middle east. That would be my guess where the flood was. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Instead of posting about the poster, talk about the topic.

are you purposely trying to start something?...I did talk about the subject...I said it was nonsense 

WatchOut --- 12 years ago -

Lynch logic:
0 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

You said the poster liked posting nonsense.

I'm not trying to start anything, but as a mod it is well within my rights to try and steer a convo away from the OP and toward the topic. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

WatchOut, the same goes for you. This thread is not discussing John, but the ark. 

JustPeachy27 --- 12 years ago -

are you purposely trying to start something?...I did talk about the subject...I said it was nonsense 

I know, right!? lol ..and I agree JL, it's nonsense. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

You said the poster liked posting nonsense.

I'm not trying to start anything, but as a mod it is well within my rights to try and steer a convo away from the OP and toward the topic.


which means it's about the topic... 

Dutchess --- 12 years ago -

The Mod asked you JL to explain why it is nonsense....not just posting that YOU THINK it ia nonsense....there is a difference. 

JustPeachy27 --- 12 years ago -

Why is everyone attacking JL? 

Dutchess --- 12 years ago -

AshleyLanette --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments

Why is everyone attacking JL?


You have only been on here 3 days....you will figure it out as time goes on if you stick around. 

JustPeachy27 --- 12 years ago -

I have been here for 3 years. Everyone attacks JL. Now let's stick to the topic. 

Dutchess --- 12 years ago -

Then why does your profile say 3 days. If you have been here 3 years then you would already know. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I'm not attacking JL. I'm attacking this habit we've all gotten into of not addressing the topics but rather the posters. It needs to stop. Everyone is tired of it, even those doing it. Unfortunately we've become so used to it that it becomes modus operandi anytime we comment. It needs to stop. 

Four Pinocchios --- 12 years ago -

Dutchess --- 37 sec ago - quote - hide comments
Then why does your profile say 3 days. If you have been here 3 years then you would already know.



Dutchess, meet Ashley, aka
TexasAshley
Frashley
Ashley87
jellygirl
nikegirl
coffeee
jelly87

oh good gracious, I cannot remember the others.

She creates ID's, gets mad, and obliterates, only to return later. 

RedMulch --- 12 years ago -

Why is everyone attacking JL?
We are Peachtree people...it's what we do.......lol

Just block him, your life will be more reasonable. I consider myself a Christian above all else......but i would never treat people that way. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Why is everyone attacking JL?

Because simply posting; "That's nonsense" is a juvenile response to a complex topic.

What's Nonsense? The fact that a document was translated? Was it the translation? Was it nonsense because it doesn't jibe with the "traditional" view?

What?

If you cant' hold an intelligent conversation about a topic, then you don't have the right to an opinion as far as I'm concerned.

As to the idea of the Ark story originating NOT in the Bible, but in ancient Mesopotamia. I'm sorry, but there are TROVES of evidence to support that theory. This is just the latest. The most well known outside scholarly circles is on Tablet XI of the Gilgamesh Epic, which is believed to be cribbed from an even older story, the Epic of Atrahasis. Gilgamesh predates Christianity by at least 7 centuries, and Atrahasis by about 18.

In the Atrahasis story, the god Enki warns the hero Atrahasis to dismantle his house and build a boat to escape the flood planned by the god Enlil to destroy humankind.

And that is NOT nonsense. 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

Please people, enough with the fighting. Didn't we learn anything from the lessons here of Atram-Hasis and the construction of his giant round ark to escape God's wrathful flood. 

JustPeachy27 --- 12 years ago -

Thank You 4 Ps :) 

Dutchess --- 12 years ago -

Thanks 4pin. good ro know.

@mod....things have been great on here since Tinman left. Hardly any iceing, edit comments. We have all been getting along. Things have been great....now this...come on... 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Didn't we learn anything from the lessons here of Atram-Hasis and the construction of his giant round ark to escape God's wrathful flood.

Boats are cool? But I bet his wife rolled her eyes when he said he was going to build one.

"Sure, sure, you haven't even fixed the leaky roof on the goat shed yet, Atram." 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

"Sure, sure, you haven't even fixed the leaky roof on the goat shed yet, Atram." 

"That boat will sit in the shed like that classic yoke you were going to restore." Bronze age wives, am I right... 

Dutchess --- 12 years ago -

To stay on topic. I believe the Bible on this one. It wasnt round. But look the Titantic sank, the Ark didnt. What does that say. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Bronze age wives, am I right...

Can't live with em, can't stone em to death unless you catch them en flagrante..... 

KingOfSomewhereHot --- 12 years ago -

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) ---
There's a flood story in nearly every culture. So it probably did happen.


Had you been alive, and living in northern Japan 2000 years ago, and experienced a tsunami like the one that occurred in 2011, you would likely have told people about it ... and as the story moved on and was embellished, it could easily have become a "global flood". That is a rather plausible example of how these myths can come about. So it's not surprising that many cultures have flood myths, since tsunamis and typhoon storm-surges are not uncommon events (over historical time-scales.)

And since there is no evidence (other than story-telling) of any type of global flood (or anything even close to that) it would stand to reason that the myths are nothing more than exaggerated stories of what were local events. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

What does that say.

not a lot of icebergs in the Middle East?

The problem,I think, Dutchess in simply "believing the Bible" is that it ignores Real evidence that the story predates the Noah story by several hundred years.

In fact, Andrew R. George (widely recognized as the foremost expert on Babylonia and prof. at the U. of London) submits that the flood story in Genesis 6–8 matches the Gilgamesh flood myth so closely, "few doubt" that it derives from a Mesopotamian account.

It is something that SHOULD be thought about when considering the story. 

Donkey Hodie --- 12 years ago -

There's a flood story in nearly every culture. So it probably did happen.

Or, it's an archetype fear that is so primal that it expresses itself in every culture as part of their cultural myth.

I think the story in the bible probably has something to do with when the Black Sea flooded in 5600 BC or 7400 BC. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

it's an archetype fear that is so primal that it expresses itself in every culture

That's always been my thought. Like vampires (and the undead in general) and dragons (of some shape or form). 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Which one was it that "Noah" (can't remember the other names) and his wife walked the land after the flood, gathering the bones of the dead and throwing them over their shoulders where they became living beings, thus creating a new human race? 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Maybe this flood was Glacial like the one in North America:

About 12,000 years ago, the valleys of western Montana lay beneath a lake nearly 2,000 feet deep. Glacial Lake Missoula formed as the Cordilleran Ice Sheet dammed the Clark Fork River just as it entered Idaho. The rising water behind the glacial dam weakened it until water burst through in a catastrophic flood that raced across Idaho, Oregon, and Washington toward the Pacific Ocean. Thundering waves and chunks of ice tore away soils and mountainsides, deposited giant ripple marks, created the scablands of eastern Washington and carved the Columbia River Gorge. Over the course of centuries, Glacial Lake Missoula filled and emptied in repeated cycles, leaving its story embedded in the land. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

The Mod asked you JL to explain why it is nonsense....not just posting that YOU THINK it ia nonsense....there is a difference.

which rule says that i'm REQUIRED to explain why it is nonsense

Because simply posting; "That's nonsense" is a juvenile response to a complex topic.

actually...it's much more accurate and mature than the initial post

I'm not attacking JL. I'm attacking this habit we've all gotten into of not addressing the topics but rather the posters.

you are attacking me...since i did address the topic

fyi...anytime you (the general you) respond to someone's post...you (the general you) ARE addressing the poster


And that is NOT nonsense.

yep...it sure is... 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

About 12,000 years ago, the valleys of western Montana lay beneath a lake nearly 2,000 feet deep. Glacial Lake Missoula formed as the Cordilleran Ice Sheet dammed the Clark Fork River just as it entered Idaho. The rising water behind the glacial dam weakened it until water burst through in a catastrophic flood that raced across Idaho, Oregon, and Washington toward the Pacific Ocean. Thundering waves and chunks of ice tore away soils and mountainsides, deposited giant ripple marks, created the scablands of eastern Washington and carved the Columbia River Gorge. Over the course of centuries, Glacial Lake Missoula filled and emptied in repeated cycles, leaving its story embedded in the land.


LOL...even though none of that could have happened 12,000 years ago...who was there to make a record of that happening at all? 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground